Through a phone-based field experiment, I investigated the effect of mental help seekers’ race, class, and gender on the accessibility of psychotherapists. Three hundred and twenty psychotherapists each received voicemail messages from one black middle-class and one white middle-class help seeker, or from one black working-class and one white working-class help seeker, requesting an appointment. The results revealed an otherwise invisible form of discrimination. Middle-class help seekers had appointment offer rates almost three times higher than their working-class counterparts. Race differences emerged only among middle-class help-seekers, with blacks considerably less likely than whites to be offered an appointment. Average appointment offer rates were equivalent across gender, but women were favored over men for appointment offers in their preferred time range.
AbreuJosé M.1999. “Conscious and Nonconscious African American Stereotypes: Impact on First Impression and Diagnostic Ratings by Therapists.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology67(3):387–93.
2.
American Psychological Association. 2009. 2008 APA Survey of Psychology Health Service Providers. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association Center for Workforce Studies.
3.
ArberSaraMcKinlayJohnAdamsAnnMarceauLisa D.LinkCarolO’DonnellAmy. 2006. “Patient Characteristics and Inequalities in Doctors’ Diagnostic and Management Strategies Relating to CHD: A Video-simulation Experiment.” Social Science & Medicine62(1):103–15.
4.
BisgaierJoannaRhodesKarin V.2011. “Auditing Access to Specialty Care for Children with Public Insurance.” New England Journal of Medicine364(24):2324–33.
5.
BlowFrederic C.ZeberJohn E.McCarthyJohn F.ValensteinMarcia. 2004. “Ethnicity and Diagnostic Patterns in Veterans with Psychoses.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology39(10):841–51.
6.
BromanClifford L.2012. “Race Differences in the Receipt of Mental Health Services among Young Adults.” Psychological Services9(1):38–48.
7.
ChiarelloElizabeth. 2013. “How Organizational Context Affects Bioethical Decision-making: Pharmacists’ Management of Gatekeeping Processes in Retail and Hospital Settings.” Social Science & Medicine98:319–29.
8.
DossRichard C.GrossAlan M.1994. “The Effects of Black English and Code-switching on Intraracial Perceptions.” Journal of Black Psychology20(3):282–93.
9.
DovidioJohn F.PennerbLouis A.AlbrechtbTerrance L.NortoncWynne E.GaertnerdSamuel L.SheltonJ. Nicole. 2008. “Disparities and Distrust: The Implications of Psychological Processes for Understanding Racial Disparities in Health and Health Care.” Social Science & Medicine67(3):478–86.
10.
FeaginJoe R.1994. “A House Is Not a Home: White Racism and U.S. Housing Practices.” Pp. 17-48 in Residential Apartheid: The American Legacy, edited by BullardR. D.GrigsbyJ. E.LeeC.Los Angeles, CA: CAAS.
11.
FennellMary L.2005. “Racial Disparities in Care: Looking Beyond the Clinical Encounter.” Health Services Research40(6):1713–21.
12.
FiscellaKevinFranksPeterGoldMarthe R.ClancyCarolyn M.2000. “Inequality in Quality: Addressing Socioeconomic, Racial, and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care.” JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association283(19):2579–84.
13.
FischerMary J.MasseyDouglas S.2004. “The Ecology of Racial Discrimination.” City & Community3(3):221–41.
14.
GellerJ. D.1988. “Racial Bias in the Evaluation of Patients for Psychotherapy.” Pp. 112–34 in Clinical Guidelines in Cross-cultural Mental Health, edited by Comas-DiazL. D.GriffithE. E. H.New York: Wiley.
15.
GreenAlexander R.CarneyDana R.PallinDaniel J.NgoLong H.RaymondKristal L.IezzoniLisa I.BanajiMahzarin R.2007. “Implicit Bias among Physicians and Its Prediction of Thrombolysis Decisions for Black and White Patients.” Journal of General Internal Medicine22(9):1231–38.
16.
GreenwaldAnthony G.PettigrewThomas F.2014. “With Malice toward None and Charity for Some: Ingroup Favoritism Enables Discrimination.” American Psychologist69(7):669–84.
17.
HaiderAdil H.SextonJanelSriramN.CooperLisa A.EfronDavid T.SwobodaSandraVillegasCassandra V.HautElliott R.BondsMorganPronovostPeter J.LipsettPamela A.FreischlagJulie A.CornwellEdward E.2011. “Association of Unconscious Race and Social Class Bias with Vignette-based Clinical Assessments by Medical Students.” JAMA: : The Journal of the American Medical Association306(9):942–51.
KikanoGeorge E.SchiaffinoMaria A.ZyzanskiStephen J.1996. “Medical Decision Making and Perceived Socioeconomic Class.” Archives of Family Medicine5(5):267–70.
20.
KossinetsGueorgiWattsDuncan J.2009. “Origins of Homophily in an Evolving Social Network.” American Journal of Sociology115(2):405–50.
21.
KriegerNancyCarneyDanaLancasterKatieWatermanPamela D.2010. “Combining Explicit and Implicit Measures of Racial Discrimination in Health Research.” American Journal of Public Health100(8):1485–92.
22.
LeeStephen D.TemerlinMaurice K.1970. “Social Class, Diagnosis, and Prognosis for Psychotherapy.” Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice7(3):181–85.
23.
LoringMartiPowellBrian. 1988. “Gender, Race, and DSM-III: A Study of the Objectivity of Psychiatric Diagnostic Behavior.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior29(1):1–22.
24.
LorionRaymond P.1974. “Patient and Therapist Variables in the Treatment of Low-income Patients.” Psychological Bulletin81(6):344–54.
25.
LutfeyKaren E.CampbellStephen M.RenfrewMegan R.MarceauLisa D.RolandMartinMcKinlayJohn B.2008. “How Are Patient Characteristics Relevant for Physicians’ Clinical Decision Making in Diabetes? An Analysis of Qualitative Results from a Cross-national Factorial Experiment.” Social Science & Medicine67(9):1391–99.
26.
LutfeyKaren E.EvaKevin W.GerstenbergerEricLinkCarol L.McKinlayJohn B.2010. “Physician Cognitive Processing as a Source of Diagnostic and Treatment Disparities in Coronary Heart Disease: Results of a Factorial Priming Experiment.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(1):16–29.
27.
LutfeyKaren E.LinkCarol L.GrantRichard W.MarceauLisa D.McKinlayJohn B.2009. “Is Certainty More Important Than Diagnosis for Understanding Race and Gender Disparities? An Experiment Using Coronary Heart Disease and Depression Case Vignettes.” Health Policy89(3):279–87.
28.
MartinTodd W.1993. “White Therapists’ Differing Perceptions of Black and White Adolescents.” Adolescence28(110):281–89.
29.
MasseyDouglas S.LundyGarvey. 2001. “Use of Black English and Racial Discrimination in Urban Housing Markets: New Methods and Findings.” Urban Affairs Review36(4):452–69.
30.
McKinlayJohn B.BurnsRisa B.DuranteRichardFeldmanHenry A.FreundKaren M.HarrowBrooke S.IrishJulie T.KastenLinda E.MoskowitzMark A.1997. “Patient, Physician and Presentational Influences on Clinical Decision Making for Breast Cancer: Results from a Factorial Experiment.” Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice3(1):23–57.
31.
McKinlayJohn B.PotterDeborah A.FeldmanHenry A.1996. “Non-medical Influences on Medical Decision-making.” Social Science & Medicine42(5):769–76.
32.
MichalskiDanielMulveyTanyaKohoutJessica. 2010. Report on 2008 APA Survey of Psychology Health Service Providers. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association Center for Workforce Studies.
33.
OlahMichelle E.GaisanoGregoryHwangStephen W.2013. “The Effect of Socioeconomic Status on Access to Primary Care: An Audit Study.” Canadian Medical Association Journal185(6):E263–69.
34.
PadgettDeborah K.PatrickCathleenBurnsBarbara J.SchlesingerHerbert J.1994. “Ethnicity and the Use of Outpatient Mental Health Services in a National Insured Population.” American Journal of Public Health84(2):222–26.
35.
PagerDevah. 2007. “The Use of Field Experiments for Studies of Employment Discrimination: Contributions, Critiques, and Directions for the Future.” ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science609(1):104–33.
36.
PagerDevahShepherdHana. 2008. “The Sociology of Discrimination: Racial Discrimination in Employment, Housing, Credit, and Consumer Markets.” Annual Review of Sociology34:181–209.
37.
PennerLouis A.DovidioJohn F.WestTessa V.GaertnerSamuel L.AlbrechtTerrance L.DaileyRhonda K.MarkovaTsveti. 2010. “Aversive Racism and Medical Interactions with Black Patients: A Field Study.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology46(2):436–40.
38.
PurnellThomasIdsardiWilliamBaughJohn. 1999. “Perceptual and Phonetic Experiments on American English Dialect Identification.” Journal of Language and Social Psychology18(1):10–30.
39.
QuillianLincoln. 2006. “New Approaches to Understanding Racial Prejudice and Discrimination.” Annual Review of Sociology32:299–328.
40.
RahmanJacqueline. 2008. “Middle-class African Americans: Reactions and Attitudes toward African American English.” American Speech83(2):141–76.
41.
RossStephen L.TurnerMargery Austin. 2005. “Housing Discrimination in Metropolitan America: Explaining Changes between 1989 and 2000.” Social Problems52(2):152–80.
42.
Roy-ByrnePeter P.JoeschJutta M.WangPhilip S.KesslerRonald C.2009. “Low Socioeconomic Status and Mental Health Care Use among Respondents with Anxiety and Depression in the NCS-R.” Psychiatric Services60(9):1190–97.
43.
SabinJanice A.NosekBrian A.GreenwaldAnthony G.RivaraFrederick P.2009. “Physicians’ Implicit and Explicit Attitudes about Race by MD Race, Ethnicity, and Gender.” Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved20(3):896–913.
44.
SabinJanice A.RivaraFrederick P.GreenwaldAnthony G.2008. “Physician Implicit Attitudes and Stereotypes about Race and Quality of Medical Care.” Medical Care46(7):678–85.
45.
SalonerBrendanPolskyDanielFriedmanAriRhodesKarin. 2015. “Primary Care Appointment Availability and Preventive Care Utilization: Evidence from an Audit Study.” Medical Care Research and Review72(2):149–67.
46.
SchnittkerJasonPescosolidoBerniceCroghanThomas W.2005. “Are African Americans Really Less Willing to Use Health Care?” Social Problems52(2):255–71.
47.
ShaversVickie L.FaganPebblesJonesDionneKleinWilliam M. P.BoyingtonJosephineMotenCarmenRorieEdward. 2012. “The State of Research on Racial/ethnic Discrimination in the Receipt of Health Care.” American Journal of Public Health102(5):953–66.
48.
ShimRuthComptonMichaelRustGeorgeDrussBenjaminKaslowNadine. 2009. “Race-ethnicity as a Predictor of Attitudes toward Mental Health Treatment Seeking.” Psychiatric Services60(10):1336–41.
49.
SmithLauraMaoSusanPerkinsSethAmpueroMarilyn. 2011. “The Relationship of Clients’ Social Class to Early Therapeutic Impressions.” Counselling Psychology Quarterly24(1):15–27.
50.
SnowdenLonnie R.YamadaAnnMarie. 2005. “Cultural Differences in Access to Care.” Annual Review of Clinical Psychology1:143–66.
51.
StepanikovaIrena. 2012. “Racial-ethnic Biases, Time Pressure, and Medical Decisions.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior53(3):329–43.
52.
TeasdaleAnthony C.HillClara E.2006. “Preferences of Therapists-in-training for Client Characteristics.” Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training43(1):111–18.
53.
TryonGeorgiana Shick. 1986. “Client and Counselor Characteristics and Engagement in Counseling.” Journal of Counseling Psychology33(4):471–74.
54.
van RynMichelleBurkeJane. 2000. “The Effect of Patient Race and Socio-economic Status on Physicians’ Perceptions of Patients.” Social Science & Medicine50(6):813–28.
55.
van RynMichelleFuSteven S.2003. “Paved with Good Intentions: Do Public Health and Human Service Providers Contribute to Racial/ethnic Disparities in Health?” American Journal of Public Health93(2):248–55.
56.
WangPhilip S.BerglundPatriciaOlfsonMarkPincusHarold AlanWellsKenneth B.KesslerRonald B.2005. “Failure and Delay in Initial Treatment Contact after First Onset of Mental Disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication.” Archives of General Psychiatry62(6):603–13.
57.
WangPhilip S.LaneMichaelOlfsonMarkPincusHarold AlanWellsKenneth B.KesslerRonald B.2005. “Twelve-month Use of Mental Health Services in the United States: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication.” Archives of General Psychiatry62(6):629–40.
58.
YoungLaura M.PowellBrian. 1985. “The Effects of Obesity on the Clinical Judgments of Mental Health Professionals.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior26(3):233–46.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
