We use an empirically grounded simulation model to examine how initial smoking prevalence moderates the effectiveness of potential interventions designed to change adolescent smoking behavior. Our model investigates the differences that result when manipulating peer influence and smoker popularity as intervention levers. We demonstrate how a simulation-based approach allows us to estimate outcomes that arise (1) when intervention effects could plausibly alter peer influence and/or smoker popularity effects and (2) across a sample of schools that match the range of initial conditions of smoking prevalence in U.S. schools. We show how these different initial conditions combined with the exact same intervention effects can produce substantially different outcomes—for example, effects that produce smoking declines in some settings can actually increase smoking in others. We explore the form and magnitude of these differences. Our model also provides a template to evaluate the potential effects of alternative intervention scenarios.
AlexanderCherylPiazzaMarinaMekosDebraValenteThomas W.2001. “Peers, Schools, and Adolescent Cigarette Smoking.” Journal of Adolescent Health29(1):22–30.
2.
BearmanPeter S.JonesJoUdryJ. Richard. 1997. “The National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health: Research Design.”
3.
BoardmanJason D.Saint OngeJarron M.HaberstickBrett C.TimberlakeDavid S.HewittJohn K.2008. “Do Schools Moderate the Genetic Determinants of Smoking?” Behavioral Genetics38(3):234–46.
4.
BrechwaldWhitney A.PrinsteinMitchell J. 2011. “Beyond Homophily: A Decade of Advances in Understanding Peer Influence Processes.” Journal of Research on Adolescence21(1):166–79.
5.
BruchElizabethAtwellJon. Forthcoming. “Agent-based Models in Empirical Social Research.” Sociological Methods & Research. doi:10.1177/0049124113506405
6.
CampbellRonaStarkeyF.HollidayJ.AudreyS.BloorM.Parry-LangdonN.HughesR.MooreL.2008. “An Informal School-based Peer-led Intervention for Smoking Prevention in Adolescence (Assist): A Cluster Randomised Trial.” Lancet371(9624):1595–602.
7.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2008. “Smoking-attributable Mortality, Years of Potential Life Lost, and Productivity Losses—United States, 2000–2004.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report57(45):1226–28.
8.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2010. “Cigarette Use among High School Students—United States, 1991–2009.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report59(26):797–801.
9.
ChristakisNicholas A.FowlerJames H.2008. “The Collective Dynamics of Smoking in a Large Social Network.” New England Journal of Medicine358:2249–58.
10.
de la HayeKaylaGreenHarold D.KennedyDavid R.PollardMichaelTuckerJoan S.2013. “Selection and Influence Mechanisms Associated with Marijuana Initiation and Use in Adolescent Friendship Networks.” Journal of Research on Adolescence23(3):474–86.
11.
EisenbergMarla E.ForsterJean L.2003. “Adolescent Smoking Behavior: Measures of Social Norms.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine25(2):122–28.
12.
El-SayedAbdulrahmanScarboroughPeterSeemannLarsGaleaSandro. 2012. “Social Network Analysis and Agent-based Modeling in Social Epidemiology.” Epidemiologic Perspectives & Innovations9(1):1.
13.
El-SayedAbdulrahman M.SeemannLarsScarboroughPeterGaleaSandro. 2013. “Are Network-based Interventions a Useful Antiobesity Strategy? An Application of Simulation Models for Causal Inference in Epidemiology.” American Journal of Epidemiology178(3):287–95.
14.
EnnettSusan T.BaumanKarl E.HussongAndreaFarisRobertFosheeVangie A.CaiLiDuRantRobert H.2006. “The Peer Context of Adolescent Substance Use: Findings from Social Network Analysis.” Journal of Research on Adolescence16(2):159–86.
15.
GestScott D.OsgoodD. WayneFeinbergMark E.BiermanKaren L.MoodyJames. 2011. “Strengthening Prevention Program Theories and Evaluations: Contributions from Social Network Analysis.” Prevention Science12(4):349–60.
16.
GreenHarold D.HortaMarianade la HayeKaylaTuckerJoan S.KennedyDavid R.PollardMichael. 2013. “Peer Influence and Selection Processes in Adolescent Smoking Behavior: A Comparative Study.” Nicotine & Tobacco Research15(2):534–41.
17.
HaasSteven A.SchaeferDavid R.2014. “With a Little Help from My Friends: Asymmetrical Social Influence on Adolescent Smoking Initiation and Cessation.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior55(2):126–43.
18.
HaasSteven A.SchaeferDavid R.KornienkoOlga. 2010. “Health and the Structure of Adolescent Social Networks.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(4):424–39.
19.
HallJeffrey A.ValenteThomas W.2007. “Adolescent Smoking Networks: The Effects of Influence and Selection on Future Smoking.” Addictive Behaviors32(12):3054–59.
20.
HoffmanBeth R.SussmanSteveUngerJennifer B.ValenteThomas W.2006. “Peer Influences on Adolescent Cigarette Smoking: A Theoretical Review of the Literature.” Substance Use & Misuse41(1):103–55.
21.
HomerJack B.HirschGary B.2006. “System Dynamics Modeling for Public Health: Background and Opportunities.” American Journal of Public Health96(3):452–58.
22.
HouseJames S.LandisKarl R.UmbersonDebra. 1988. “Social Relationships and Health.” Science241(4865):540–45.
23.
HwangMyunghee SongYeagleyKathleen LuxPetosaRick. 2004. “A Meta-analysis of Adolescent Psychosocial Smoking Prevention Programs Published between 1978 and 1997 in the United States.” Health Education & Behavior31(6):702–19.
24.
IpEdward H.RahmandadHazhirShohamDavid A.HammondRossHuangTerry T.-K.WangYoufaMabryPatricia L. 2013. “Reconciling Statistical and Systems Science Approaches to Public Health.” Health Education & Behavior40(1 Suppl.):s123–s131.
25.
KesslerDavid A.NatanblutSharon L.WilkenfeldJudith P.LorraineCatherine C.MaylSharon LindanBernsteinIlisa B.G.ThompsonLarry. 1997. “Nicotine Addiction: A Pediatric Disease.” Journal of Pediatrics130(4):518–24.
26.
KiuruNoonaBurkWilliam J.LaursenBrettSalmela-AroKatariinaNurmiJari-Erik. 2010. “Pressure to Drink but Not to Smoke: Disentangling Selection and Socialization in Adolescent Peer Networks and Peer Groups.” Journal of Adolescence33(6):801–12.
27.
KobusKimberly. 2003. “Peers and Adolescent Smoking.” Addiction98(Suppl. 1):37–55.
28.
KoopmanJim. 2004. “Modeling Infection Transmission.” Annual Review of Public Health25:303–26.
29.
LakonCynthia M.HippJohn R.TimberlakeDavid S.2010. “The Social Context of Adolescent Smoking: A Systems Perspective.” American Journal of Public Health100(7):1218–28.
30.
LantzPaula M.JacobsonPeter D.WarnerKenneth E.WassermanJeffreyPollackHarold A.BersonJulieAhlstromAlexis. 2000. “Investing in Youth Tobacco Control: A Review of Smoking Prevention and Control Strategies.” Tobacco Control9(1):47–63.
31.
LarsonReedRichardsMaryse H.1991. “Daily Companionship in Late Childhood and Early Adolescence: Changing Developmental Contexts.” Child Development62(2):284–300.
32.
LevyDavid T.MabryPatricia L.GrahamAmanda L.OrleansC. TracyAbramsDavid B. 2010. “Exploring Scenarios to Dramatically Reduce Smoking Prevalence: A Simulation Model of the Three-part Cessation Process.” American Journal of Public Health100(7):1253–59.
33.
LynamDonald R.MilichRichardZimmermanRickNovakScott P.LoganT. K.MartinCatherineLeukefeldCarlClaytonRichard. 1999. “Project Dare: No Effects at 10-year Follow-up.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology67(4):590–93.
34.
MabryPatricia L.MarcusStephen E.ClarkPamela I.LeischowScott J.MéndezDavid. 2010. “Systems Science: A Revolution in Public Health Policy Research.” American Journal of Public Health100(7):1161–63.
35.
MaglioPaul P.SepulvedaMartin-J.MabryPatricia L.2014. “Mainstreaming Modeling and Simulation to Accelerate Public Health Innovation.” American Journal of Public Health104(7):1181–86.
36.
ManskiCharles F.1993. “Identification of Endogenous Social Effects: The Reflection Problem.” Review of Economic Studies60(3):531–42.
37.
MarsdenPeter V.2011. “Survey Methods for Network Data.” Pp. 370–388 in The Sage Handbook of Social Network Analysis, edited by ScottJ.CarringtonP. J.Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
38.
MayhewKathryn P.FlayBrian R.MottJoshua A.2000. “Stages in the Development of Adolescent Smoking.” Drug and Alcohol Dependence59(Suppl. 1): 61–81.
39.
McPhersonMillerSmith-LovinLynnCookJames M.2001. “Birds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks.” Annual Review of Sociology27:415–44.
40.
MerckenLiesbethSnijdersTom A. B.SteglichChristian E. G.VartiainenE.de VriesH.2010. “Dynamics of Adolescent Friendship Networks and Smoking Behavior.” Social Networks32(1):72–81.
41.
MollbornStefanieDomingueBenjamin W.BoardmanJason D.2014. “Norms as Group-level Constructs: Investigating School-level Teen Pregnancy Norms and Behaviors.” Social Forces93(1):241–67.
42.
MoodyJamesBrynildsenWendy D.OsgoodD. WayneFeinbergMark E.GestScott. 2011. “Popularity Trajectories and Substance Use in Early Adolescence.” Social Networks33(2):101–12.
43.
PearsonMichaelSteglichChristianSnijdersTom. 2006. “Homophily and Assilimation among Sport-active Adolescent Substance Users.” Connections27(1):51–68.
44.
PetersonArthur V.KealeyKathleen A.MannSue L.MarekPatrick M.SarasonIrwin G.2000. “Hutchinson Smoking Prevention Project: Long-term Randomized Trial in School-based Tobacco Use Prevention. Results on Smoking.” Journal of the National Cancer Institute92(24):1979–91.
45.
RipleyRuth M.SnijdersTom A. B.BodaZsofiaVorosAndrasPreciadoPaulina. 2014. “Manual for RSiena.” Department of Statistics, Nuffield College, University of Oxford.
46.
RobinsGarryPattisonPhilippaKalishYuvalLusherDean. 2007. “An Introduction to Exponential Random Graph (p*) Models for Social Networks.” Social Networks29(2):173–91.
47.
RogersEverett M.1995. Diffusion of Innovations. New York: Free Press.
48.
RossmanGabriel. 2012. Climbing the Charts: What Radio Airplay Tells Us about the Diffusion of Innovations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
49.
SalatheMarcelJonesJames H.2010. “Dynamics and Control of Diseases in Networks with Community Structure.” PLoS Computational Biology6(4):e1000736.
50.
SambranoSoledadSpringerJ. FredSaleElizabethKasimRafaHermannJack. 2005. “Understanding Prevention Effectiveness in Real-world Settings: The National Cross-site Evaluation of High Risk Youth Programs.” American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse31:491–513.
51.
SchaeferDavid R.adamsjimiHaasSteven A.2013. “Social Networks and Smoking: Exploring the Effects of Peer Influence and Smoker Popularity through Smoking Simulations.” Health Education & Behavior40(S1):24–32.
52.
SchaeferDavid R.HaasSteven A.BishopNicholas J.2012. “A Dynamic Model of US Adolescents’ Smoking and Friendship Networks.” American Journal of Public Health102(6):e12–e18.
53.
ShaliziCosma RohillaThomasAndrew C.2011. “Homophily and Contagion Are Generically Confounded in Observational Social Network Studies.” Sociological Methods & Research40(2):211–39.
54.
SmithKirsten P.ChristakisNicholas A.2008. “Social Networks and Health.” Annual Review of Sociology34:405–29.
55.
SnijdersTom A. B.2011. “Statistical Models for Social Networks.” Annual Review of Sociology37:129–51.
56.
SnijdersTom A. B.SteglichChristian E. G.2015. “Representing Micro-macro Linkages by Actor-based Dynamic Network Models.” Sociological Methods & Research44(2):222–71.
57.
SnijdersTom A. B.van de BuntGerhardSteglichChristian E. G.2010. “Introduction to Stochastic Actor-based Models for Network Dynamics.” Social Networks32(1):44–60.
58.
SteglichChristianSnijdersTom A. B.PearsonMichael. 2010. “Dynamic Networks and Behavior: Separating Selection from Influence.” Sociological Methodology40(1):329–93.
59.
ToblerNancy S.RooniaMichael R.OchshornPeterMarshallDiana G.StrekeAndrei V.StackpoleKimberly M.2000. “School-based Adolescent Drug Prevention Programs: 1998 Meta-analysis.” Journal of Primary Prevention20(4):275–336.
60.
ValenteThomas W.1995. Network Models of the Diffusion of Innovations. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
61.
ValenteThomas W.1996. “Social Network Thresholds in the Diffusion of Innovations.” Social Networks18(1):69–89.
62.
ValenteThomas W.2010. Social Networks and Health: Models, Methods, and Applications. New York: Oxford University Press.
ValenteThomas W.DavisRebecca L.1999. “Accelerating the Diffusion of Innovations Using Opinion Leaders.” Annals of the American Academy of the Political and Social Sciences566(1):55–67.
65.
ValenteThomas W.PumpuangPatchareeya. 2007. “Identifying Opinion Leaders to Promote Behavior Change.” Health Education & Behavior34(6):881-96.
66.
ValenteThomas W.Ritt-OlsonAnamaraStacyAlanUngerJennifer B.OkamotoJanetSussmanSteve. 2007. “Peer Acceleration: Effects of a Social Network Tailored Substance Abuse Prevention Program among High-risk Adolescents.” Addiction102(11):1804–15.
67.
ValenteThomas W.UngerJennifer B.JohnsonC. Anderson. 2005. “Do Popular Students Smoke? The Association between Popularity and Smoking among Middle School Students.” Journal of Adolescent Health37(4):323–29.
68.
WieheSarah E.GarrisonMichelle M.ChristakisDimitri A.EbelBeth E.RivaraFrederick P.2005. “A Systematic Review of School-based Smoking Prevention Trials with Long-term Follow-up.” Journal of Adolescent Health36(3):162–69.
69.
ZhangJ.TongL.LambersonP. J., et al2015. “Leveraging Social Influence to Address Overweight and Obesity Using Agent-based Models: The Role of Adolescent Social Networks.” Social Science & Medicine125(1): 203–213.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
