After struggling as a surgical specialty, obstetrics and gynecology initiated its “women's physician” program in the 1970s. This program officially defined the mostly male obstetricians and gynecologists at that time as women's primary care physicians. Using archival data, this article explains this development as a response to the specialty's dishonored position within the medical division of labor. Whatever else it was intended to be, the women's physician program, in its most developed form, aimed to galvanize the various interests within obstetrics and gynecology behind a strategy to restructure the medical division of labor serving women so that obstetricians and gynecologists controlled both the upstream positions responsible for their own case referrals and the downstream positions to which they referred their difficult cases. The article illustrates the importance of integrating insights from both macro-institutional and intra-occupational explanatory frameworks in accounting for significant developments in medicine.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbbottAndrew D.1988.
The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
2.
American Medical Association, Council on Long Range Planning and Development.1987.
“The Future of Obstetrics and Gynecology.”Journal of the American Medical Association258:
3547–53
3.
BarnesAllan G.1971.
“Quality and Quantity in the Specialty of Obstetrics and Gynecology.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology109:
203–205
4.
BarterRobert H.1975.
“Discussion.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology121:
814
5.
BeechamClayton T.1969.
“Self-Purification: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology103:
605–608
6.
BermanElizabeth Popp2006.
“Before the Professional Project: Success and Failure at Creating an Organizational Representative for English Doctors.”Theory and Society35:
157–91
7.
BermanElizabeth Popp2006.
Forthcoming.
“Why Did Universities Start Patenting? Institution-Building and the Road to the Bayh-Dole Act.”Social Studies of Science38
8.
BlossJames R.1950.
“Presidential Address: The Ideals, Responsibilities, and Reward of the Obstetrician.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology59:
1183–88
9.
BrewerJohn I.1953.
“From Little Acorns: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology65:
465–71
10.
BrunschwigAlexander1968.
“Whither Gynecology?”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology100:
122–27
11.
BucherRue[1962] 1972.
“Pathology: A Study of Social Movements within a Profession.”
Pp. 113–27 in
Medical Men and Their Work,
edited by EliotFreidsonJudithLorberChicago, IL:
Aldine-Atherton
12.
1988.
“On the Natural History of Health Care Occupations.”Work and Occupations15:
131–47
13.
BucherRueStraussAnselm L.1961.
“Professions in Process.”American Journal of Sociology66:
325–34
14.
BurkonsDavid M.WillsonJ. Robert1975.
“Is the Obstetrician-Gynecologist a Specialist or Primary Physician to Women?”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology121:
808–16
15.
BurmanRichard G.1968.
“The Gynecologist—The Woman's Physician.”Southern Medical Journal61:
391–94
16.
CraigR. Glenn, 1959.
“Presidential Address: Our Opportunities.”Obstetrics and Gynecology14:
811–14
17.
De SantisGrace1980.
“Realms of Expertise: A View from within the Medical Profession.”Research in the Sociology of Health Care1:
179–236
18.
DunnLeo J.1993.
“Not to Decide is to Decide: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology168:
1053–62
19.
EllisonEugene T.ThorntonW. D.1955.
“Late Results of Pelvic Surgery.”Southern Medical Journal47:
913–18
20.
FeinRashiWeberGerald I.1971.
Financing Medical Education: An Analysis of Alternative Policies and Mechanisms.New York:
McGraw-Hill
21.
FligsteinNeil2001.
“Social Skill and the Theory of Fields.”Sociological Theory19:
105–25
22.
FreidsonEliot[1970] 1988.
Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of Applied Knowledge.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
23.
FreidsonEliot2001.
Professionalism: The Third Logic.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
24.
GardnerHerman L.1966.
“The Gynecologist and the Periodic Checkup: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology95:
1–4
25.
GinzbergEli, ed. 1986.
From Physician Shortage to Patient Shortage: The Uncertain Future of Medical Practice.Boulder, CO:
Westview Press
26.
GinzbergEliEdwardBrannDaleHiestandMiriamOstow1981.
“The Expanding Physician Supply and Health Policy: The Clouded Outlook.”Milbank Quarterly59:
508–41
27.
GritzerGlenn1982.
“Occupational Specialization in Medicine: Knowledge and Market Explanations.”Research in the Sociology of Health Care2:
251–83
28.
HaffertyFrederic W.LightDonald W.1995.
“Professional Dynamics and the Changing Nature of Medical Work.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior35:
132–53
29.
HalpernSydney A.1990.
“Medicalization as Professional Process: Postwar Trends in Pediatrics.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior31:
28–42
30.
HalpernSydney A.1992.
“Dynamics of Professional Control: Internal Coalitions and Crossprofessional Boundaries.”American Journal of Sociology97:
994–1021
31.
HayashiT. TerryKathleenMcIntyre-Seltman1987.
“The Role of Gender in an Obstetrics and Gynecology Residency Program: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology156:
769–77
32.
HesterLawrence L.1975.
“Discussion.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology121:
812–13
33.
HicksonD.HiningsJ. C. R.LeeC. A.SchneckR. E.PenningsJ. M.1971.
“A Strategic Contingencies' Theory of Intraorganizational Power.”Administrative Science Quarterly16:
216–29
34.
HiestandDale L.1984.
“Medical Residencies in a Period of Expanding Physician Supply.”
Pp. 69–82 in
The Coming Physician Surplus: In Search of a Policy,
edited by EliGinzbergMiriamOstowTotawa, NJ:
Rowman and Allanheld
35.
HodgkinsonC. Paul1961.
“Continuing Education in Gynecology-Obstetrics.”Obstetrics and Gynecology18:
243–50
36.
HodgkinsonC. Paul1968.
“Challenge and Response: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology101:
1–7
37.
HughesEverett C.1971.
The Sociological Eye: Selected Papers.Chicago, IL:
Aldine-Atherton
38.
LarsonMagali Sarfatti1977.
The Rise of Professionalism: A Sociological Analysis.Berkeley:
University of California Press
39.
LeRoyLaurenLeePhilip R., eds. 1977.
Deliberations and Compromise: The Health Professions Education Assistance Act of 1976.Cambridge, MA:
Ballinger
40.
LightDonald W.1995.
“Countervailing Powers: A Framework for Professions in Transition.”
Pp. 25–41 in
Health Professions and the State in Europe,
edited by TerryJohnsonGerryLarkinMikeSaksLondon:
Routledge
41.
LightDonald W.2004.
“Introduction: Ironies of Success: A New History of the American Health Care ‘System.’”Journal of Health and Social Behavior45:
1–24
42.
LundCurtis J.1971.
“Their Shadows Are Cast: Coming Events in the Education of the Obstetrician-Gynecologist.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology111:
463–68
43.
McCarthyEugene G.FinkelMadelon Lubin1980.
“Second Consultant Opinion for Elective Gynecologic Surgery.”Obstetrics and Gynecology56:
403–10
44.
McElinThomas W.1977.
“Discussion.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology128:
306–307
45.
MechanicDavid2004.
“The Rise and Fall of Managed Care.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior45:
76–86
46.
MengertWilliam F.1949.
“President's Address: The Organization and Relationship of a Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology58:
207–14
47.
MengertWilliam F.1959.
“Obstetrics and Gynecology Today: President's Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology77:
697–705
48.
OstergardDonald R.GunningJohn E.MarshallJohn R.1975.
“Training and Function of a Women's Health-Care Specialist, a Physician's Assistant, or Nurse Practitioner in Obstetrics and Gynecology.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology121:
1029–37
49.
PearseWarren H.1980.
“Closing.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology137:
326
50.
PearseWarren H.TrabinJay R.1977.
“Subspecialization in Obstetrics and Gynecology.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology128:
303–307
51.
PearsonJack W.1975.
“The Obstetrician and Gynecologist: Primary Physician for Women.”Journal of the American Medical Association231:
815–16
52.
PerdueJ. Randolph1952.
“The Future in Gynecology.”Southern Medical Journal45:
77–79
53.
RanneyBrooks1976.
“Shadows or Light?: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology125:
283–89
54.
RanneyBrooksDavidHolzwarthRichardThorntonMarjorieMacNeil1976.
“The Practice of Gynecology and Obstetrics: An Analysis.”Obstetrics and Gynecology47:
725–29
55.
ReidDuncan E.1961.
“The Obstetric and Gynecologic Discipline: Potentials and Responsibilities.”Obstetrics and Gynecology17:
263–68
56.
RiskaElianne2001.
Medical Careers and Feminist Agendas: American, Scandinavian, and Russian Women Physicians.New York:
Aldine de Gruyter
57.
RivaH. L.1965.
“Hysterectomy: Indications and Technics.”Postgraduate Medicine39:
645–49
58.
ScottW. RichardMartinRuefMendelPeter J.CaronnaCarol A.2000.
Institutional Change and Healthcare Organizations: From Professional Dominance to Managed Care.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
59.
SimardJ. A. René1957.
“Considerations on Obstetrics and Obstetricians: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology73:
1163–68
60.
StarrPaul1982.
The Social Transformation of American Medicine: The Rise of a Sovereign Profession and the Making of a Vast Industry.New York:
Basic Books
61.
StevensRosemary1971.
American Medicine and the Public Interest: A History of Specialization.New Haven, CT:
Yale University Press
62.
SturgisSomers H.1957.
“The Challenge of Comprehensive Gynecology.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology73:
180–89
63.
SymmondsRichard E.1976.
“Ureteral Injuries Associated with Gynecologic Surgery: Prevention and Management.”Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology19:
623–44
64.
TaylorHoward C.Jr1958.
“Competition and Cooperation: Presidential Address.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology76:
931–38
65.
TaylorHoward C.Jr1965.
“Objectives and Principles in the Training of the Obstetrician-Gynecologist: Training for Surgical Virtuosity and Versatility or for Public Service.”American Journal of Surgery110:
35–42
66.
TysonJohn E.1971.
“A Contemporary Approach to Recruitment in Obstetrics and Gynecology.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology111:
711–17
67.
TysonJohn E.1973.
“The Attractiveness of Obstetrics and Gynecology as a Professional Career.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology117:
130–35
68.
WallaceMichaelGriffinLarry J.RubinBeth A.1989.
“The Positional Power of American Labor, 1963–1977.”American Sociological Review54:
197–214
69.
WechslerHenryDorseyJoseph L.BoveyJoanne D.1978.
“A Follow-Up Study of Residents in Internal-Medicine, Pediatrics and Obstetrics-Gynecology Training Programs in Massachusetts: Implications for the Supply of Primary-Care Physicians.”New England Journal of Medicine298:
15–21
70.
WillsonJ. Robert1962.
“Undergraduate Education in Obstetrics and Gynecology.”Obstetrics and Gynecology20:
929–36
71.
WillsonJ. Robert1972.
“Recruitment into Obstetrics-Gynecology.”Obstetrics and Gynecology40:
432–37
72.
WillsonJ. RobertBurkonsDavid M.1976a.
“Obstetrician-Gynecologists Are Primary Physicians to Women. I. Practice Patterns of Michigan Obstetrician-Gynecologists.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology126:
627–32
73.
WillsonJ. RobertBurkonsDavid M.1976b.
“Obstetrician-Gynecologists Are Primary Physicians to Women: II. Education for a New Role.”American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology126:
744–54
74.
YankauerAlfredJanSchneiderJonesSally H.HellmanLouis M.FeldmanJacob J.1971.
“Practice of Obstetrics and Gynecology in the United States.”Obstetrics and Gynecology38:
800–808.”
75.
ZetkaJames R.Jr2001.
“Occupational Divisions of Labor and Their Technology Politics: The Case of Surgical Scopes and Gastrointestinal Medicine.”Social Forces79:
1495–1520
76.
ZetkaJames R.Jr2003.
Surgeons and the Scope.Ithaca, NY:
Industrial and Labor Relations Press
77.
ZetkaJames R.Jr2008.
“Radical Logics and Their Carriers in Medicine: The Case of Psychopathology and American Obstetricians and Gynecologists.”Social Problems55:
95–116
78.
ZetkaJames R.Jr.WalshJohn P.1994.
“A Qualitative Protocol for Studying Technological Change in the Labor Process.”Bulletin de Methodologie Sociologique45:
37–73
79.
ZolaIrving K.MillerStephen J.1971.
“The Erosion of Medicine from Within.”
Pp. 153–172 in
Professions, and their Prospects,
edited by EliotFreidsonChicago, IL:
Aldine Atherton
