Previous research has shown that involuntary job loss may have negative health consequences, but existing analyses have not adequately adjusted for health selection or other confounding factors that could reveal the association to be spurious. Using two large, population-based longitudinal samples of U.S. workers from the Americans' Changing Lives Study and the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study, this analysis goes further by using respondents' self-reports of the reasons for job loss and information about the timing of job losses and acute negative health shocks to distinguish health-related job losses from other involuntary job losses. Results suggest that even after adjustment for numerous social background characteristics and baseline health, involuntary job loss is associated with significantly poorer overall self-rated health and more depressive symptoms. More nuanced analyses reveal that among involuntary job losers, those who lose their jobs for health-related reasons have, not surprisingly, the most precipitous declines in health. Job losses for other reasons have substantive and statistically significant effects on depressive symptoms, while effects on self-rated poor health are relatively small.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BrandJennie E.2004.
“Enduring Effects of Job Displacement on Career Outcomes.”
Unpublished manuscript. Department of Sociology. University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin
2.
BrandJennie E.2006.
“The Effects of Job Displacement on Job Quality: Findings from the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study.”Research in Social Stratification and Mobility24:
275–98
3.
DooleyDavidRalphCatalanoWilsonand G.1994.
“Depression and Unemployment: Panel Findings from the Epidemiologic Catchment 0 Area Study.”American Journal of Community Psychology22:
745–65
4.
DooleyDavidJonathanFieldingLennartLevi1996.
“Health and Unemployment.”Annual Review of Public Health17:
449–65
5.
FarberHenry S.2003.
“Job Loss in the United States, 1981–2001.“
National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 9707. Cambridge, MA
6.
FerrieJane E.ShipleyM. J.MarmotMichael GideonStansfieldS. A.SmithG. D.1998.
“An Uncertain Future: The Health Effects of Threats in Employment Security in White-Collar Men and Women.”American Journal of Public Health88:
1030–36
7.
GalloWilliam T.BradleyElizabeth H.MicheleSiegelKaslStanislav V.2000.
“Health Effects of Involuntary Job Loss among Older Workers: Findings from the Health and Retirement Study.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences55B:
S131–S140
8.
HamiltonV. K.BromanC. L.HoffmanW. S.RennerD. S.1990.
“Hard Times and Vulnerable People: Initial Effects of Plant Closings on Autoworkers' Mental Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior31:
123–40
9.
HamermeshDaniel1989.
“What Do We Know about Worker Displacement in the United States?”Industrial Relations28:
51–59
10.
HayesJohnPeterNutman1981.
Understanding the Unemployed: The Psychological Effects of Unemployment.London:
Tavistock
11.
HouseJames S.1987.
“Chronic Stress and Chronic Disease in Life and Work: Conceptual and Methodological Issues.”Work and Stress1:
129–34
12.
HouseJames S.LantzPaula M.PamelaHerd2005.
“Continuity and Change in the Social Stratification of Aging and Health Over the Life Course: Evidence from a Nationally Representative Longitudinal Study from 1986 to 2001/2 (The Americans' Changing Lives Study).”
Journal of Gerontology: Series B60 B:
15–26
13.
IdlerEllen L.RussellLouise B.DianeDavis2000.
“Survival, Functional Limitations, and Self-Rated Health in the NHANES I Epidemiologic Follow-up Study, 1992.”American Journal of Epidemiology152:
874–83
JahodaM.1982.
Employment and Unemployment: A Social-Psychological Analysis.Cambridge, England:
Cambridge University Press
16.
KaslS. V.GoreS.CobbS.1975.
“The Experience of Losing a Job: Reported Changes in Health, Symptoms and Illness Behavior.”Psychosomatic Medicine37:
106–22
17.
KaslS. V.JonesBeth A.2000.
“The Impact of Job Loss and Retirement on Health.”
Pp. 118–37 in
Social Epidemiology,
edited by BerkmanLisa F.IchiroKawachiNew York:
Oxford University Press
18.
KeefeVeraPapaarangiReidClintOrmsbyBridgetRobsonGordonPurdieJoanneBaxterIncorporatedNgati Kahunguni Iwi2002.
“Serious Health Events Following Involuntary Job Loss in New Zealand Meat Processing Workers.”International Journal of Epidemiology31:
1155–61
19.
KeltzerLori1998.
“Job Displacement.”Journal of Economic Perspectives12:
115–36
20.
KesslerRonald C.HouseJames S.TurnerJ. Blake1987.
“Unemployment and Health in a Community Sample.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior28:
51–59
21.
KohoutF.BerkmanL.EvansD.Coroni-HuntleyJ.1993.
“Two Shorter Forms of the CES-D (Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression) Depression Symptoms Index.”Journal of Aging and Health5:
179–93
22.
KorpiTomas2001.
“Accumulating Disadvantage: Longitudinal Analyses of Unemployment and Physical Health in Representative Samples of the Swedish Population.”European Sociological Review17:
255–73
23.
MastekaasaA.1996.
“Unemployment and Health: Selection Effects.”Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology6:
189–205
24.
McDonoughPeggyAmickBenjamin C.III2001.
“The Social Context of Health Selection: A Longitudinal Study of Health and Employment.”Social Science & Medicine53:
135–45
25.
NewmanKatherine S.1988.
Falling From Grace: The Experience of Downward Mobility in the American Middle Class.New York:
Free Press
26.
PearlinLeonard I.LiebermanMorton A.MenaghanElizabeth A.MullenJoseph T.1981.
“The Stress Process.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior22:
337–56
27.
PodgurskyMichaelPaulSwaim1987.
“Job Displacement and Earnings Loss: Evidence from the Displaced Worker Survey.”Industrial and Labor Relations Review41:
17–29
28.
RadloffLenore S.1977.
“The CES-D Scale: A Self-Report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population.”Applied Psychological Measurement1:
385–401
29.
SchnittkerJason2005.
“When Mental Health Becomes Health: Age and the Shifting Meaning of Self-Evaluations of General Health.”The Milbank Quarterly83:
397–423
30.
SewellWilliam H.HauserRobert M.KristenSpringerHauserTaissa S.2001.
“As We Age: A Review of the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study, 1957–2001.”
Center for Demography and Ecology Working Papers, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin
31.
SmithVicki1997.
“New Forms of Work Organization.”Annual Review of Sociology23:
315–39
32.
TheorellTores G. T.1982.
“Review of Research on Life Events and Cardiovascular Illness.”Advance Cardiology29:
140–47
33.
TurnerJ. Blake1995.
“Economic Context and the Health Effects of Unemployment.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36:
213–29
34.
TurnerR. JayBlairWheatonLloydDonald A.1995.
“The Epidemiology of Social Stress.”American Sociological Review60:
104–25
35.
WaldronIngrid1980.
“Employment and Women's Health: An Analysis of Causal Relationships.”International Journal of Health Services10:
435–54
36.
WestinSteinar1990.
“The Structure of a Factory Closure: Individual Responses to Job-Loss and Unemployment in a 10-year Controlled Follow-Up Study.”Social Science and Medicine31:
1301–11
