Past research has consistently documented the positive relationship between a transition to marriage and psychological well-being. In this study, we separate the depressed from the nondepressed to assess whether the benefits marriage has for psychological well-being depend on premarital depression. We also examine whether the effect of marital quality in moderating the psychological consequences of marriage differs for the depressed and the nondepressed. Results indicate that, on average, those who were depressed prior to marrying report larger psychological gains from marriage than those who were not depressed. The role of marital quality in moderating the effect of marriage on psychological well-being is similar for previously depressed and previously nondepressed respondents. These findings call into question the assumption that marriage is always a good choice for all individuals. What appear to be strong average benefits of marriage are actually highly dependent on a range of individual, interpersonal, and structural characteristics.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American Psychiatric Association.2000.
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders DSM-IV-TR.Washington, DC:
Donnelly and Sons.
2.
BirdChloe E.1997.
“Gender Differences in Social and Economic Burdens of Parenting and Psychological Distress.”Journal of Marriage and Family59:
809–23.
3.
BoothAlanAmatoPaul1991.
“Divorce and Psychological Stress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior32:
396–407.
4.
BradburyThomas N.FinchamFrank D.BeachSteven R.2000.
“Research on the Nature and Determinants of Marital Satisfaction: A Decade in Review.”Journal of Marriage and Family62:
964–80.
5.
BrownSusan L.BoothAlan1996.
“Cohabitation versus Marriage: A Comparison of Relationship Quality.”Journal of Marriage and Family58:
668–78.
6.
ClearyPaul D.MechanicDavid1983.
“Sex Differences in Psychological Distress among Married People.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior24:
111–21.
7.
EnselWalter1986.
“Measuring Depression: The CES-D Scale.”
Pp. 51–70 in
Social Support, Life Events, and Depression,
edited by LinN.DeanA.EnselW.New York:
Academic Press.
8.
ForthoferMelinda S.KesslerRonald C.StoryAmber L.GotlibIan H.1996.
“The Effects of Psychiatric Disorders on the Probability and Timing of First Marriage.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior37:
121–32.
9.
GoveWalter R.HughesMichaelStyleCarolyn B.1983.
“Does Marriage Have Positive Effects on the Psychological Well-Being of the Individual?”Journal of Health and Social Behavior24:
122–31.
10.
HatfieldElaineCacioppoJohn T.RapsonRichard L.1993.
“Emotional Contagion.”Current Directions in Psychological Science2:
96–99.
11.
HorwitzAllan V.McLaughlinJulieWhiteHelene R.1997.
“How the Negative and Positive Aspects of Partner Relationships Affect the Mental Health of Young Married People.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior39:
124–36.
12.
HorwitzAllan V.WhiteHelene R.1991.
“Becoming Married, Depression, and Alcohol Problems among Young Adults.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior32:
221–37.
13.
HorwitzAllan V.WhiteHelene R.Howell-WhiteSandra1996.
“Becoming Married and Mental Health: A Longitudinal Study of a Cohort of Young Adults.”Journal of Marriage and Family58:
895–907.
14.
JacksonPaul R.1985.
“Differential Vulnerability and Psychological Health in Unemployment.”Statistician34:
83–91.
15.
JohnsonSheri L.JacobTheodore1997.
“Marital Interactions of Depressed Men and Women.”Journal of Counseling and Clinical Psychology65:
15–23.
16.
JoinerThomas E.Jr.1994.
“Contagious Depression: Existence, Specificity to Depressed Symptoms, and the Role of Reassurance-Seeking.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology67
(2):
287–96.
17.
KatzJenniferH. BeachSteven R.1997.
“Self-Verification and Depressive Symptoms in Marriage and Courtship: A Multiple Pathway Model.”Journal of Marriage and Family59:
903–14.
18.
KawachiIchiroBerkmanLisa F.2001.
“Social Ties and Mental Health.”Journal of Urban Health78:
458–67.
19.
KesslerRonald. C.1982.
“A Disaggregation of the Relationship between Socioeconomic Status and Psychological Distress.”American Sociological Review47:
752–64.
20.
Koropeckyj-CoxTanya1998.
“Loneliness and Depression in Middle and Old Age: Are the Childless More Vulnerable?”Journals of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences53:
S303–S312.
21.
LinNanEnselWalter M.1984.
“Depression-Mobility and Its Social Etiology: The Role of Life Events and Social Support.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior25:
176–88.
22.
MarksNadine F.LambertJames D.1998.
“Marital Status Continuity and Change among Young and Mid-Life Adults: Longitudinal Effects on Psychological Well-Being.”Journal of Family Issues19:
652–86.
23.
MastekaasaArne1992.
“Marriage and Psychological Well-Being: Some Evidence on Selection into Marriage.”Journal of Marriage and Family54:
901–11.
24.
McLeodJane D.EckbergDeborah A.1993.
“Concordance for Depressive Disorders and Marital Quality.”Journal of Marriage and Family55:
733–46.
25.
MirowskyJohn1996.
“Age and the Gender Gap in Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior37:
362–80.
26.
MirowskyJohn1999.
“Mental Health and Social Circumstances.”
Pp. 105–23 in
Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health,
edited by AneshenselCarol S.PhelanJo C.New York:
Plenum Publishing Corporation.
27.
MoffitPaulSpenceNeilGoldneyRobert1986.
“Mental Health in Marriage: The Roles of Need for Affiliation, Sensitivity to Rejection, and Other Factors.”Journal of Clinical Psychology42:
68–76.
28.
RadloffLenore S.1977.
“The CES-D Scale: A Self-Report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population.”Applied Psychological Measurement1:
385–401.
29.
RobertsR. E.VernonS. W.1983.
“The Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale: Its Use in a Community Sample.”American Journal of Psychiatry140:
41–46.
30.
RossCatherine E.MirowskyJohnGoldsteenKatherine1990.
“The Impact of the Family on Mental Health: The Decade in Review.”Journal of Marriage and Family52:
1059–78.
31.
SegrinChrisPowellHeather L.GivertzMichelleBrackinAnne2003.
“Symptoms of Depression, Relational Quality, and Loneliness in Dating Relationships.”Personal Relationships10:
25–36.
32.
SimonRobin W.2002.
“Revisiting the Relationships among Gender, Marital Status, and Mental Health.”American Journal of Sociology107:
1065–96.
33.
SimonRobin W.MarcussenKristen1999.
“Marital Transitions, Marital Beliefs, and Mental Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:
111–25.
34.
SkinnerKevin B.BahrStephen J.CraneD. RussellA. CallVaughn R.2002.
“Cohabitation, Marriage, and Remarriage: A Comparison of Relationship Quality over Time.”Journal of Family Issues23:
74–90.
35.
SteinhausenHans-ChristophHaslimeierClaudiaMetzkeChrista Winkler2006.
“The Outcome of Episodic versus Persistent Adolescent Depression in Young Adulthood.”Journal of Affective Disorders96:
49–57.
36.
SweetJames A.BumpassLarry L.1996.
“The National Survey of Families and Households— Waves 1 and 2: Data Description and Documentation.”Center for Demography and Ecology, University of Wisconsin,
Madison.
Retrieved October 30, 2005 (http://www.ssc.wisc.edu/nsfh/home.htm).
37.
SweetJames A.1990.
“National Survey of Families and Households—A Sampling Report.”Center for Demography and Ecology, University of Wisconsin,
Madison.
Retrieved October 30, 2005 (http://www.pop.psu.edu/dataarchive/codebooks/nsfh/wave_1/appendices/c1app_l.001).
38.
TaylorJohnTurnerR. Jay2001.
“A Longitudinal Study of the Role and Significance of Mattering to Others for Depressive Symptoms.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior42:
310–25.
39.
TowerRoni BethKaslStanislav V.1995.
“Depressive Symptoms across Older Spouses and the Moderating Effect of Marital Closeness.”Psychology and Aging10:
625–38.
40.
TurnerHeather A.TurnerR. Jay1999.
“Gender, Social Status, and Emotional Reliance.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:
360–73.
41.
TurnerJohn B.1995.
“Economic Context and the Health Effects of Unemployment.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36:
213–29.
42.
UmbersonDeborahWilliamsKristi1999.
“Family Status and Mental Health.”
Pp. 225–53 in
Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health,
edited by AneshenselCarol S.PhelanJo C.New York:
Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
43.
VanFossenBeth E.1981.
“Sex Differences in the Mental Health Effects of Spousal Support and Equity.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior22:
130–43.
44.
WaiteLinda J.1995.
“Does Marriage Matter?”Demography32:
483–507.
45.
WaiteLinda J.GallagherMaggie2000.
The Case for Marriage: Why Married People Are Happier, Healthier, and Better off Financially.New York:
Doubleday.
46.
WalenHeather R.LachmanMargie E.2000.
“Social Support and Strain from Partner, Family, and Friends: Costs and Benefits for Men and Women in Adulthood.”Journal of Social and Personal Relationships17:
5–30.
47.
WilliamsDavid R.TakeuchiD. T.AdairR. K.1992a.
“Marital Status and Psychiatric Disorders among Blacks and Whites.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior33:
140–57.
48.
WilliamsDavid R.1992b.
“Socioeconomic Status and Psychiatric Disorder among Blacks and Whites.”Social Forces71:
179–94.
49.
WilliamsKristi2003.
“Has the Future of Marriage Arrived? A Contemporary Examination of Gender, Marriage, and Psychological Well-Being.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior44:
470–87.
