Debates about children's mental health problems have raised questions about the reliability and validity of diagnosis and treatment. However, little research has focused on social reactions to children with mental health problems. This gap in research raises questions about competing theories of stigma, as well as specific factors shaping prejudice and discrimination toward those children. Here, we organize a general model of stigma that synthesizes previous research. We apply a reduced version of this model to data from a nationally representative sample responding to vignettes depicting several stigmatizing scenarios, including attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), depression, asthma, or “normal troubles.” Results from the National Stigma Study—Children suggest a gradient of rejection from highest to lowest, as follows: ADHD, depression, “normal troubles,” and physical illness. Stigmatizing reactions are highest toward adolescents. Importantly, respondents who label the vignette child's situation as a mental illness compared to those who label the problem as a physical illness or a “normal” situation report greater preferences for social distance, a pattern that appears to result from perceptions that the child is dangerous.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsStephen M.ParteeD. Jenkins1998.
“Integrating Psychosocial Rehabilitation in a Community-Based Faculty Nursing Practice.”Journal of Psychosocial Nursing and Mental Health Services36:
24–28
2.
AllportGordon E.1954.
The Nature of Prejudice.Garden City, NY:
Doubleday
3.
AngermeyerMatthias C.HerbertMatchinger1995.
“The Effect of Violent Attacks by Schizophrenic Persons on the Attitude of the Public Towards the Mentally Ill.”Social Science and Medicine43:
1721–28
4.
BhugraDinesh1989.
“Attitudes toward Mental Illness: A Review of the Literature.”Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica80:
1–12
5.
BiernatMonicaDovidioJohn F.2000.
“Stigma and Stereotypes.”
Pp. 88–125 in
The Social Psychology of Stigma,
edited by HeathertonTodd F.KleckRobert E.HeblMichelle R.HullJay G.New York, NY:
The Guilford Press
6.
BruntonKeith1997.
“Stigma.”Journal of Advanced Nursing26:
891–98
7.
BurnsBarbara J.CostelloE. JaneAdrianAngoldTweedDan L.StanglDalene K.FarmerElizabeth M. Z.AlaattinErkanli1995.
“Children's Mental Health Service Use across Service Sectors.”Health Affairs14:
147–59
8.
CallaghanPatrickShanCheung SinYiLan SukChingLo WaiKwanTsin Lai1997.
“Attitudes towards Mental Illness: Testing the Contact Hypothesis among Chinese Student Nurses in Hong Kong.”Journal of Advanced Nursing26:
33–40
9.
CaplowTheodore1964.
Principles of Organization.New York:
Harcourt, Brace, and World
10.
ChouKee LeeKi-YanMak1998.
“Attitudes to Mental Patients among Hong Kong Chinese: A Trend Study over Two Years.”International Journal of Social Psychiatry44:
215–24
11.
ClausenJohn A.1981.
“Stigma and Mental Disorder: Phenomena and Terminology.”Psychiatry44:
287–96
12.
ConradPeter2000.
“Medicalization, Genetics and Human Problems.”
Pp. 322–33 in
Handbook of Medical Sociology,
edited by BirdChloe E.PeterConradFremontAllen M.Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice Hall
13.
CostelloE. JaneAdrianAngoldBurnsBarbara J.AlaattinErkanliStanglDalene K.TweedDan L.1996.
“The Great Smoky Mountains Study of Youth: Functional Impairment and Serious Emotional Disturbance.”Archives of General Psychiatry53:
1137–43
14.
CrispArthur H.GelderMichael G.SusannahRixMeltzerHoward I.RowlandsOlwen J.2000.
“Stigmatization of People with Mental Illness.”British Journal of Psychiatry177:
4–7
15.
CrockerJennifer1981.
“Judgment of Covariation by Social Perceivers.”Psychological Bulletin90:
272–92
16.
DavisJames A.SmithTom W.1992.
The NORC General Social Survey: A User's Guide.Newbury Park, CA:
Sage Publications
17.
DavisJames A.SmithTom W.2002.
General Social Survey 1998: Culture Model [United States].Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press
18.
DesforgesDonna M.LordCharles G.RamseyShauna L.MasonJulie A.Van-LeeuwenMarilyn D.WestSylvia C.LepperMark P.1991.
“Effects of Structured Cooperative Contact on Changing Negative Attitudes toward Stigmatized Social Groups.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology60:
531–44
19.
DohrenwendBruce P.EdwinChin-Song1967.
“Social Status and Attitudes toward Psychological Disorder: The Problem of Tolerance and Deviance.”American Sociological Review32:
417–33
20.
DovidioJohn F.BrendaMajorJenniferCrocker2000.
The Social Psychology of Stigma.New York:
The Guilford Press
21.
EstroffSue E.1981.
Making it Crazy: An Ethnography of Psychiatric Clients in an American Community.Berkeley, CA:
University of California Press
22.
FosuGabriel B.1995.
“Women's Orientation toward Help-Seeking for Mental Disorders.”Social Science and Medicine40:
1029–40
23.
GathererA.ReidJ.J.A.1963.
“Public Attitudes and Mental Health Education: Northamptonshire Mental Health Project 1963.”
Northampton, UK:
Northamptonshire County Council
24.
GoffmanErving1963.
Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall
25.
GoveWalter R.1970.
“Societal Reaction as an Explanation of Mental Illness: An Evaluation.”American Sociological Review35:
873–84
26.
HomansGeorge1951.
The Human Group.London:
Routledge and K. Paul
27.
JackmanMary R.MarieCrane1986.
“Some of My Best Friends are Black…: Interracial Friendship and Whites' Racial Attitudes.”Public Opinion Quarterly50:
459–86
28.
KolodziejMonika E.JohnsonBlair T.1996.
“Interpersonal Contact and Acceptance of Persons with Psychiatric Disorders: A Research Synthesis.”Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology64:
1387–96
29.
LinkBruce G.CullenFrancis T.JamesFrankWozniakJohn F.1987.
“The Social Rejection of Former Mental Patients: Understanding Why Labels Matter.”American Journal of Sociology92:
1461–1500
30.
LinkBruce G.PhelanJo C.2001.
“Conceptualizing Stigma.”Annual Review of Sociology27:
363–85
31.
LinkBruce G.PhelanJo C.MichaelineBresnahanAnnStuevePescosolidoBernice A.1999.
“Public Conceptions of Mental Illness: Labels, Causes, Dangerousness and Social Distance.”American Journal of Public Health89:
1328–33
MarkowitzFred E.2001.
“Modeling Processes in Recovery from Mental Illness: Relationships between Symptoms, Life Satisfaction, and Self-Concept.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior42:
64–79
34.
MartinJack K.PescosolidoBernice A.TuchSteven A.2000.
“Of Fear and Loathing: The Role of Disturbing Behavior, Labels and Causal Attributions in Shaping Public Attitudes toward Persons with Mental Illness.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior41:
208–33
35.
MartinJack K.TuchSteven A.1997.
Racial Attitudes in the 1990s: Continuity and Change.Westport, CT:
Praeger
36.
McGovernDermotPatriciaHemmingsCopeR.LowersonA.1994.
“Long-Term Follow-Up of Young Afro-Caribbean Britons and White Britons with a First Admission Diagnosis of Schizophrenia.”Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology29:
8–19
37.
McLeodJane D.PescosolidoBernice A.TakeuchiDavid T.WhiteTerry Falkenberg2004.
“Public Attitudes toward the Use of Psychiatric Medications for Children.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior45:
53–67
38.
MechanicDavidDonnaMcAlpineSarahRosenfieldDianeDavis1994.
“Effects of Illness Attribution and Depression on the Quality of Life among Persons with Serious Mental Illness.”Social Science and Medicine39:
155–64
39.
NangleDouglas W.ErdleyCynthia A.CarpenterErika M.NewmanJulie E.2002.
“Social Skills Training As a Treatment for Aggressive Children and Adolescents: A Developmental-Clinical Integration.”Aggression and Violent Behavior7:
169–99
40.
National Institute of Mental Health.2002.
Breaking Ground, Breaking Through: The Strategic Plan for Mood Disorders Research of the National Institute of Mental Health.Bethesda, MD:
National Institute of Mental Health
41.
OkazakiSumie2000.
“Treatment Delay among Asian-American Patients with Severe Mental Illness.”American Journal of Orthopsychiatry70:
58–64
42.
OlfsonMarkMarcGameroffJensenP.StevenMarcus2004.
“National Trends in the Treatment of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: Reply.”American Journal of Psychiatry161:
932
43.
PagelMark D.ErdlyWilliam W.JosephBecker1987.
“Social Networks: We Get By With (and In Spite of) a Little Help from Our Friends.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology53:
793–804
44.
PagerDevahLincolnQuillian2005.
“Walking the Talk: What Employers Say Versus What They Do.”American Sociological Review70:
355–80
45.
PellmarTerry C.LeonEisenberg2000.
Bridging Disciplines in the Brain, Behavioral, and Clinical Sciences: A Report of the Board on Neuroscience and Behavioral Health, Institute of Medicine.Washington, DC:
National Academy Press
46.
PennDavid L.AmyDrummond2001.
“Politically Correct Labels and Severe Mental Illness: A Rose by Any Other Name?”Schizophrenia Bulletin27:
197–203
47.
PennDavid L.KimGuynanTamaraDailySpauldingWilliam D.MarkSullivan1994.
“Dispelling the Stigma of Schizophrenia: What Sort of Information is Best?”Schizophrenia Bulletin20:
567–77
48.
PescosolidoBernice A.MartinJack K.LinkBruce G.SaekoKikuzawaGiovanniBurgosRalphSwindle2000.
“Americans' Views of Mental Illness and Health at Century's End: Continuity and Change.”
Bloomington, IN:
Indiana Consortium for Mental Health Services Research
49.
PescosolidoBernice A.JohnMonahanLinkBruce G.AnnStueveSaekoKikuzawa1999.
“The Public's View of the Competence, Dangerousness, and Need for Legal Coercion of Persons with Mental Health Problems.”American Journal of Public Health89:
1339–45
50.
PhelanJo C.2005.
“Geneticization of Deviant Behavior and Consequences for Stigma: The Case of Mental Illness.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior46:
307–22
51.
PhelanJo C.LinkBruce G.AnnStuevePescosolidoBernice A.2000.
“Public Conceptions of Mental Illness in 1950 and 1996: What is Mental Illness and Is It to be Feared?”Journal of Health and Social Behavior41:
188–207
52.
RogersAnneDavidPilgrim2001.
Mental Health Policy in Britain.Basingstoke, England:
Palgrave
53.
RookKaren1984.
“The Negative Side of Social Interaction: Impact of Psychological Well-Being.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology46:
1097–1108
54.
RostKathryn G.RichardSmithTaylorJ. Lynn1993.
“Rural-Urban Differences in Stigma and the Use of Care for Depressive Disorders.”Journal of Rural Health9:
57–62
55.
SartoriusNorman1998.
“Stigma: What Can Psychiatrists Do About It?”The Lancet352:
1058–59
56.
ScheffThomas J.1966.
Being Mentally Ill: A Sociological Theory.Chicago, IL:
Aldine
57.
SchnittkerJason2000.
“Gender and Reactions to Psychological Problems: An Examination of Social Tolerance and Perceived Dangerousness.”Journal of Health & Social Behavior41:
224–40
58.
SchumanHoward S.CharlotteSteehLawrenceBoboMariaKrysan1997.
Racial Attitudes in America: Trends and Interpretations.Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press
59.
StarS. A.1955.
“The Public's Ideas about Mental Illness.”
Chicago:
National Opinion Research Center
60.
StiffmanArlene R.PescosolidoBernice A.CabassaLeopoldo J.2004.
“Building a Model to Understand Youth Service Access: The Gateway Provider Model.”Mental Health Services Research6:
189–98
61.
StuartHeatherJulioArboleda-Florez2000.
“Community Attitudes toward Persons with Schizophrenia.”Canadian Journal of Psychiatry46:
245–52
62.
ThoitsPeggy A.2005.
“Differential Labeling of Mental Illness by Social Status: A New Look at an Old Problem.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior46:
102–19
63.
TuchSteven A.1987.
“Urbanism, Region, and Tolerance Revisited: The Case of Racial Prejudice.”American Sociological Review52:
504–10
64.
TuchSteven A.MartinJack K.1997.
“Regional Differences in Whites' Racial Policy Attitudes.”
Pp. 165–76 in
Racial Attitudes in the 1990s: Continuity and Change,
edited by TuchSteven A.MartinJack K.Westport, CT:
Praeger
65.
U.S. Department of Health & Human Services.1999.
Mental Health: A Report of the Surgeon General.Bethesda, MD:
U.S. Department of Health & Human Services
66.
U.S. Department of Health & Human Services.2003.
Achieving the Promise: Transforming Mental Health Care in America. The President's New Freedom Commission on Mental Health Report.Bethesda, MD:
U.S. Department of Health & Human Services
67.
WahlOtto F.1999.
“Mental Health Consumers' Experience of Stigma.”Schizophrenia Bulletin25:
467–78
68.
WeinerBernard1995.
Judgments of Responsibility: A Foundation for a Theory of Social Conduct.New York:
Guilford
69.
WellerLeonardShoshanaGrunes1988.
“Does Contact with the Mentally Ill Affect Nurses' Attitudes to Mental Illness?”British Journal of Medical Psychology61:
277–84
70.
WhaleyArthur L.1997.
“Ethnic and Racial Differences in Perceptions of Dangerousness of Persons with Mental Illness.”Psychiatric Services48:
1328–30
71.
WilliamsRobin M.1947.
The Reduction of Intergroup Tensions.New York:
Social Science Research Council
72.
ZitoJulie MagnoDanielSaferMarkRiddleRichardJohnsonStuartSpeedieMichaelFox1998.
“Prevalence Variations in Psychotropic Treatment of Children.”Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology8:
99–105
