Does psychological distress increase mortality risk? If it does, are women more vulnerable than men to the effect of distress on mortality? Drawing from cumulative disadvantage theory, these questions are addressed with data from a 20-year follow-up of a national sample of adults ages 25–74. Event history analyses were performed to examine mortality from general and specific causes for men and women. Findings reveal that the effect of psychological distress on all-cause mortality was nonlinear for men. Moderate amounts of distress were associated with lower mortality risk, but high levels of distress raised men's mortality risk. Moreover, the curvilinear relationship between distress and mortality varied by cause of death for men and women. Men with high levels of psychological distress were more vulnerable to ischemic heart disease mortality. Women with high levels of distress were more vulnerable to cancer mortality.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AffleckGlennHowardTennen1996.
“Construing Benefits from Adversity: Adaptational Significance and Dispositional Underpinnings.”Journal of Personality64:
899–922
2.
AndersonRobert N.SmithBetty L.2003.
Deaths: Leading Causes for 2001.
National Vital Statistics Reports 52(9).
Hyattsville, MD:
National Center for Health Statistics
3.
AneshenselCarol S.EstradaAntonio L.HansellMary JoClarkVirginia A.1987.
“Social Psychological Aspects of Reporting Behavior—Lifetime Depressive Episode Reports.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior28:
232–46
4.
BoothAlanJohnsonDavid R.GrangerDouglas A.1999.
“Testosterone and Men's Depression: The Role of Social Behavior.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:
130–40
5.
BruceMartha LivingstonLeafPhilip J.1989.
“Psychiatric Disorders and 15-Month Mortality in a Community Sample of Older Adults.”American Journal of Public Health79:
727–30
6.
CoateDouglas1993.
“Moderate Drinking and Coronary Heart Disease Mortality: Evidence from NHANES I and the NHANES I Follow-up.”American Journal of Public Health83:
888–90
7.
CoxChristine S.MussolinoMichael E.RothwellSandra T.LaneMadelyn A.GoldenCordell D.MadansJennifer H.FeldmanJacob J.1997.
Plan and Operation of the NHANES I Epidemiologic Followup Study, 1992.Vital and Health Statistics, Series 1, No. 35.
Hyattsville, MD:
National Center for Health Statistics
8.
DanneferDale1987.
“Aging as Intracohort Differentiation: Accentuation, the Matthew Effect, and the Life Course.”Sociological Forum2:
211–36
9.
DanneferDale2003.
“Cumulative Advantage/Disadvantage and the Life Course: Cross-Fertilizing Age and the Social Science Theory.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences58B:
S327–S337
10.
ElderGlen H.Jr.LikerJeffrey K.1982.
“Hard Times in Women's Lives: Historical Influences across Forty Years.”American Journal of Sociology88:
241–69
11.
Everson-RoseSusan A.HouseJames S.MeroRichard P.2004.
“Depressive Symptoms and Mortality Risk in a National Sample: Confounding Effects of Health Status.”Psychosomatic Medicine66:
823–30
12.
FarmerMelissa M.FerraroKenneth F.1997.
“Distress and Perceived Health: Mechanisms of Health Decline.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior38:
298–311
13.
FerraroKenneth F.FarmerMelissa M.1999.
“Utility of Health Data from Social Surveys: Is There a Gold Standard for Measuring Morbidity?”American Sociological Review64:
303–15
14.
FerraroKenneth F.Kelley-MooreJessica A.2003.
“Cumulative Disadvantage and Health: Long-Term Consequences of Obesity?”American Sociological Review68:
707–29
15.
FredmanLisaSchoenbachVictor J.KaplanBerton H.BlazerDan G.JamesSherman A.KleinbaumDavid G.BonnieYankaskas1989.
“The Association between Depressive Symptoms and Mortality among Older Participants in the Epidemiologic Catchment Area-Piedmont Health Survey.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences44:
S149–S156
16.
FuhrerR.DufouilC.AntonucciT. C.ShipleyM. J.HelmerC.DartiguesJ. F.1999.
“Psychological Disorder and Mortality in French Older Adults: Do Social Relations Modify the Association?”American Journal of Epidemiology149:
116–26
17.
GeorgeLinda K.2003.
“What Life-Course Perspectives Offer the Study of Aging, and Health.”
Pp. 16188
in Invitation to the Life Course: Toward New Understandings of Later Life,
edited by RichardSetterstenJrAmityville, NY:
Baywood Publishing
18.
HondaKeikoGoodwinRenee D.NeugutAlfred I.2005.
“The Associations between Psychological Distress and Cancer Prevention Practices.”Cancer Detection and Prevention29:
25–36
19.
HorwitzAllan V.2002.
“Outcomes in the Sociology of Mental Health and Illness: Where Have We Been and Where Are We Going?”Journal of Health and Social Behavior43:
143–51
20.
HorwitzAllan V.WhiteHelene RaskinSandraHowell-White1996.
“The Use of Multiple Outcomes in Stress Research: A Case Study of Gender Differences in Responses to Marital Dissolution.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior37:
278–91
21.
IdlerEllen L.YaelBenyamini1997.
“Self-Rated Health and Mortality: A Review of Twenty-Seven Community Studies.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior38:
21–37
22.
KesslerRonald C.1979.
“Stress, Social Status, and Psychological Distress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior20:
259–72
23.
KesslerRonald C.McCraeJames A.Jr1981.
“Trends in the Relationship between Sex and Psychological Distress: 1957–1976.”American Sociological Review46:
443–52
24.
KettererMark W.JohanDenolletJeanineChappSteveKeteyianFarhaA. J.VivianClarkMichaelHudsonArifHakimAdamGreenbaumJohnSchairerCaoJ. Jane2004.
“Familial Transmissibility of Early Age at Initial Diagnosis in Coronary Heart Disease (CHD): Males Only, and Mediated by Psychosocial/Emotional Distress?”Journal of Behavioral Medicine27:
1–10
25.
MacLeodJ.SmithG. Davey2003.
“Psychosocial Factors and Public Health: A Suitable Case for Treatment?”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health57:
565–70
26.
MacLeodJohnSmithGeorge DaveyPaulineHeslopChrisMetcalfeDouglasCarrollCaroleHart2001.
“Are the Effects of Psychosocial Exposures Attributable to Confounding? Evidence from a Prospective Observational Study on Psychological Stress and Mortality.”Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health55:
878–84
27.
MechanicDavid1989.
Mental Health and Social Policy.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall
28.
Mendes de LeonCarlos F.KrumholzHarlan M.SeemanTeresa S.ViolaVaccarinoWilliamsChristianna S.KaslStanislav V.BerkmanLisa F.1998.
“Depression and Risk of Coronary Heart Disease in Elderly Men and Women.”Archives of Internal Medicine158:
2341–48
29.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.1989.
Social Causes of Psychological Distress.New York:
Aldine de Gruyter
30.
National Center for Health Statistics.1977.
Plan and Operation of the Health and Nutrition Examination Survey: United States, 1971–1973.Vital and Health Statistics, Series 1, No.10b.
Washington, DC:
U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare; Publication PHS 79–1310
31.
National Center for Health Statistics.2005.
‘National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey.’
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Retrieved July 12, 2005 (http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes.htm)
32.
National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute.1998.
Clinical Guidelines on the Identification, Evaluation, and Treatment of Overweight and Obesity in Adults.National Institutes of Health Publication 98–4083.
Bethesda, MD:
National Institutes of Health
33.
O'RandAngela M.1996.
“The Precious and the Precocious: Understanding Cumulative Disadvantage and Cumulative Advantage over the Life Course.”The Gerontologist36:
230–38
34.
PearlinLeonard I.1999.
“Stress and Mental Health: A Conceptual Overview.”
Pp. 16175
in A Handbook for the Study of Mental Health: Social Contexts, Theories, and Systems,
edited by HorwitzAllan V.ScheidTeresa L.Cambridge, England:
Cambridge University Press
35.
PhillipsAndrew N.SmithGeorge Davey1991.
“How Independent are the ‘Independent’ Effects? Relative Risk Estimation When Correlated Exposures are Measured Imprecisely.”Journal of Clinical Epidemiology44:
1223–31
36.
PrestonSamuel H.HillMark E.DrevenstedtGreg L.1998.
“Childhood Conditions that Predict Survival to Advanced Ages among African-Americans.”Social Science and Medicine47:
1231–46
37.
RasulFarhatStansfeldStephen A.HartCarole L.GillisCharles R.SmithGeorge Davey2004.
“Psychological Distress, Physical Illness and Mortality Risk.”Journal of Psychosomatic Research57:
231–36
38.
ReicheEdna Maria VissociVarSandra Odebrechtgas NunesMorimotoHelena Kaminami2004.
“Stress, Depression, the Immune System, and Cancer.”Lancet Oncology5:
617–25
39.
ReskinBarbara F.ShelleyCoverman1985.
“Sex and Race in the Determinants of Psychophysical Distress: A Reappraisal of the Sex-Role Hypothesis.”Social Forces63:
1038–59
40.
RitcheyFerris J.MarkLaGoryJeffreyMullis1991.
“Gender Differences in Health Risks and Physical Symptoms among the Homeless.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior32:
33–48
41.
RitcheyFerris J.1993.
“A Response to the Comments of Walter R. Gove on Gender Differences in Health Risks and Physical Symptoms among the Homeless.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior34:
182–85
42.
RobertsRobert E.KaplanGeorge A.CamachoTerry C.1990.
“Psychological Distress and Mortality: Evidence from Alameda County.”Social Science Medicine31:
527–36
43.
RossCatherine E.JoanHuber1985.
“Hardship and Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior26:
312–27
44.
RossiAlice S.1984.
“Gender and Parenthood.”American Sociological Review49:
1–19
45.
SapolskyRobert M.1994.
Why Zebras Don't Get Ulcers: A Guide to Stress, Stress-Related Diseases, and Coping.New York:
W.H. Freeman
46.
SeemanMary V.1997.
“Psychopathology in Women and Men: Focus on Female Hormones.”American Journal of Psychiatry154:
1641–47
47.
SelyeHans1974.
Stress without Distress.Philadelphia, PA:
J. B. Lippincott Company
48.
ShekelleRichard B.RaynorWilliam J.Jr.OstfeldAdrian M.GarronDavid C.BieliauskasLinas A.LiuShuguey C.CarolMalizaPaulOglesby1981.
“Psychological Depression and 17-year Risk of Death from Cancer.”Psychosomatic Medicine43:
117–25
49.
SingerEleanorRobinGarfinkelCohenSteven M.LeoSrole1976.
“Mortality and Mental Health: Evidence from the Midtown Manhattan Restudy.”Social Science and Medicine10:
517–25
50.
SomervellPhilip D.KaplanBerton H.GerardoHeissTyrolerHerman A.KleinbaumDavid G.ObristPaul A.1989.
“Psychologic Distress as a Predictor of Mortality.”American Journal of Epidemiology130:
1013–23
51.
StansfeldStephen A.RebeccaFuhrerShipleyMartin J.MarmotMichael G.2002.
“Psychological Distress as a Risk Factor for Coronary Heart Disease in the Whitehall II Study.”International Journal of Epidemiology31:
248–55
52.
ThoitsPeggy A.1986.
“Multiple Identities: Examining Gender and Marital Status Differences in Distress.”American Sociological Review51:
259–72
53.
ThoitsPeggy A.1995.
“Stress, Coping, and Social Support Processes: Where are We? What Next?”Journal of Health and Social Behavior35
(extra issue):
53–79
54.
ThomasCynthiaKelmanHoward R.KennedyGary J.ChulAhnChun-yongYang1992.
“Depressive Symptoms and Mortality in Elderly Persons.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences47:
S80–S87
55.
TurnerR. JayBlairWheatonLloydDonald A.1995.
“The Epidemiology of Social Stress.”American Sociological Review60:
104–25
56.
VerbruggeLois M.1989.
“The Twain Meet: Empirical Explanations of Sex Differences in Health and Mortality.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior30:
282–304
57.
WheatonBlair1999.
“The Nature of Stressors.”
Pp. 17697
in A Handbook for the Study of Mental Health: Social Contexts, Theories, and Systems,
edited by HorwitzAllan V.ScheidTeresa L.Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge University Press
58.
WulsinLawson R.VaillantGeorge E.WellsVictoria E.1999.
“A Systematic Review of the Mortality of Depression.”Psychosomatic Medicine61:
6–17
