Disability carries negative social meaning, and little is known about when (or if), in the process of health decline, persons identify themselves as “disabled.” We examine the social and health criteria that older adults use to subjectively rate their own disability status. Using a panel study of older adults (ages 72+), we estimate ordered probit and growth curve models of perceived disability over time. Total prevalent morbidity, functional limitations, and cognitive impairment are predictors of perceived disability. Cessation of driving and receipt of home health care also influence older adults' perceptions of their own disability. A dense social network slowed the rate of labeling oneself disabled, while health anxiety accelerated the process over time, independent of health status. When considering perceived disability, the oldest old use multidimensional criteria capturing function, recent changes in health status and social networks, and anxiety about their health.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlbrechtGary L.WalkerVivian G.LevyJudith A.1982.
“Social Distance from the Stigmatized: A Test of Two Theories.”Social Science & Medicine16:
1319–27
2.
BenyaminiYaelLeventhalElaine A.HowardLeventhal2003.
“Elderly People's Ratings of the Importance of Health-Related Factors to their Self-Assessments of Health.”Social Science and Medicine56:
1661–67
3.
BerkRichard A.1983.
“An Introduction to Sample Selection Bias in Sociological Data.”American Sociological Review48:
386–98
4.
BollenKenneth A.PatrickCurran2001.
‘Latent Growth Curve Analysis.’Department of Sociology, University of North Carolina,
Chapel Hill, NC.
Unpublished manuscript
5.
BorawskiElaine A.KinneyJennifer M.EvaKahana1996.
“The Meaning of Older Adults' Health Appraisals: Congruence with Health Status and Determinant of Mortality.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences51B:
S157–S170
6.
BreitenbachNancy2001.
“Ageing with Intellectual Disabilities; Discovering Disability with Old Age: Same or Different?”
Pp. 23139
in Disability, and the Life Course: Global Perspectives,
edited by MarkPriestleyCambridge, MA:
Cambridge University Press
7.
BrenesGretchenGuralnikJack M.WilliamsonJeff D.FriedLinda P.CrystalSimpsonSimonsikEleanor M.PennnixBrenda W. J. H.2005.
“The Influence of Anxiety on the Progression of Disability.”Journal of the American Geriatrics Society53:
34–39
8.
BryantLucinda L.CorbettKitty K.KutnerJean S.2001.
“In Their Own Words: A Model of Healthy Aging.”Social Science and Medicine53:
927–41
9.
de BeursE.AartjanBeekmanvan BalkomA. J.DorlyDeegDyckRichard vanTilburgWillem van1999.
“Consequences of Anxiety in Older Persons: Its Effect on Disability, Well-Being and Use of Health Services.”Psychological Medicine29:
583–93
10.
DentonMargaretVivienneWalters1999.
“Gender Differences in Structural and Behavioral Determinants of Health: An Analysis of the Social Production of Health.”Social Science and Medicine48:
1221–35
11.
FerraroKenneth F.1980.
“Self-Ratings of Health among the Old and the Old-Old.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior21:
377–83
12.
FerraroKenneth F.Kelley-MooreJessica A.2001.
“Self-Rated Health and Mortality among Black and White Adults: Examining the Dynamic Evaluation Thesis.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences56B:
S195–S205
13.
FerrucciLuigiGuralnikJack M.EleanorSimonsickSaliveMarcel E.ChiaraCortiJeanLanglois1996.
“Progressive versus Catastrophic Disability: A Longitudinal View of the Disablement Process.”Journal of Gerontology: Medical Sciences51A:
M123–M130
14.
FreedmanVicki A.MartinLinda G.SchoeniRobert F.2002.
“Recent Trends in Disability and Functioning among Older Adults in the United States.”Journal of the American Medical Association288:
3137–46
15.
FriedLinda P.KarenBandeen-RocheChavesPaulo H. M.JohnsonBrent A.2000.
“Preclinical Mobility Disability Predicts Incident Mobility Disability in Older Women.”Journal of Gerontology: Medical Sciences55A:
M43–M52
16.
GignacMonique A. M.CherylCott1998.
“A Conceptual Model of Independence and Dependence for Adults with Chronic Physical Illness and Disability.”Social Science and Medicine47:
739–53
17.
GoffmanEving1963.
Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice Hall
18.
HeckmanJames J.1979.
“Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error.”Econometrica47:
153–61
19.
HoeymansN.FeskensE. J. M.KromhoutD.Van Den BosG. A. M.1997.
“Ageing and the Relationship between Functional Status and Self-Rated Health in Elderly Men.”Social Science and Medicine45:
1527–36
20.
HongTantina B.ZaritSteven H.BoMalmberg2004.
“The Role of Health Congruence in Functional Status and Depression.”Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences59B:
P151–P157
21.
IdlerEllen L.1993.
“Perceptions of Pain and Perceptions of Health.”Motivation and Emotion17:
205–24
22.
IdlerEllen L.YaelBenyamini1997.
“Self-Rated Health and Mortality: A Review of Twenty-Seven Community Studies.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior38:
21–37
23.
IezzoniLisa I.2003.
When Walking Fails: Mobility Problems of Adults with Chronic Conditions.Berkeley:
University of California Press
24.
IezzoniLisa I.McCarthyEllen P.DavisRoger B.HiliarySiebens2000.
“Mobility Problems and Perceptions of Disability by Self-Respondents and Proxy Respondents.”Medical Care38:
1051–57
25.
KahanaEvaBoazKahana1996.
“Conceptual and Empirical Advances in Understanding Aging Well Through Proactive Adaptation.”
Pages 1840
in Adulthood and Aging: Research on Continuities, and Discontinuities,
edited by BengtsonVern L.New York:
Springer Publishing Company
26.
KahanaEvaBoazKahana2003.
“Contextualizing Successful Aging: New Directions in an Age-Old Search.”
Pp. 22555
in Invitation to the Life Course: A New Look at Old Age,
edited by RichardSetterstenJrAmityville, NY:
Baywood Publishing
27.
KahanaEvaBoazKahanaKyleKercher2003.
“Emerging Lifestyles and Proactive Options for Successful Ageing.”Ageing International28:
155–80
28.
KahnRobert L.AntonucciToni C.1980.
“Convoys over the Life Course: Attachment, Roles, and Social Support.”
Pp. 25386
in Life-Span Development and Behavior,
edited by BaltesP. B.BrimO. G.New York:
Academic Press
29.
KaplanGioraOrnaBaron-Epel2003.
“What Lies behind the Subjective Evaluation of Health Status?”Social Science and Medicine56:
1669–76
30.
KatzSidneyFordAmassa B.MoskowitzRoland W.JacksonBeverly A.JaffeeMarjorie W.1963.
“Studies of Illness in the Aged: The Index of ADL, a Standardized Measure of Biological and Psychological Function.”Journal of the American Medical Association185:
914–19
31.
KellowayE. Kevin1998.
Using LISREL for Structural Equation Modeling.Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage Publications
32.
LangloisJean A.StefaniaMaggiTamaraHarrisSimonsickEleanor M.LuigiFerrucciMaraPavanLeonardoSartoriGiulianoEnzi1996.
“Self-Report of Difficulty in Performing Functional Activities Identifies a Broad Range of Disability in Old Age.”Journal of the American Geriatrics Society44:
1421–28
33.
LawtonM. P.BrodyE. M.1969.
“Assessment of Older People: Self-Maintaining and Instrumental Activities of Daily Living.”Gerontologist9:
179–86
34.
LeinonenRaijaEinoHeikkinenMarjaJylhä.2001.
“Predictors of Decline in Self-Assessments of Health among Older People—a 5-Year Longitudinal Study.”Social Science and Medicine52:
1329–41
MurtaghKirsten NaumannHubertHelen B.2004.
“Gender Differences in Disability Among an Elderly Cohort.”American Journal of Public Health94:
1406–11
37.
OliverMichael1996.
Understanding Disability: From Theory to Practice.New York:
St. Martin's Press
38.
PalmoreErdman2001.
“The Ageism Survey: First Findings.”Gerontologist41:
572–80
39.
ParsonsTalcott1958.
“Definitions of Health and Illness in the Light of Americans' Values and Social Structure.”
Pp. 165187
in Patients, Physicians and Illness: A Sourcebook in Behavioral Science, and Health,
edited by JacoE. GartlyGlencoe, IL:
Free Press
40.
PearlinLeonard I.1999.
“The Stress Process Revisited: Reflections on Concepts and Their Inter-Relationships.”
Pp. 395415
in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health,
edited by AneshenselC. S.PhelanJ. C.New York:
Plenum
41.
PfeifferE.1975.
“A Short Portable Mental Status Questionnaire.”Journal of the American Geriatric Society23:
433–41
42.
RadloffL. S.1977.
“The CES-D Scale: A Self-Report Depressive Scale for Research in the General Population.”Journal of Applied Psychological Measurement1:
385–401
43.
RennemarkM.HagbergB.1999.
“Gender Specific Associations between Social Network and Health Behavior in Old Age.”Aging and Mental Health4:
320–27
44.
Reyes-GibbyCielito C.LuAnnAdayCharlesCleeland2002.
“Impact of Pain on Self-Rated Health in Community-Dwelling Older Adults.”Pain95:
75–82
45.
RossCatherineJohnMirowsky2002.
“Family Relationships, Social Support, and Subjective Life Expectancy.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior43:
469–89
SchneiderGudrunGeorgDrieschAndreasKruseMichaelWachterHans-GeorgNehenGereonHeuft2004.
“What Influences Self-Perception of Health in the Elderly? The Role of Objective Health Condition, Subjective Well-Being and Sense of Coherence.”Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics39:
227–37
48.
SmithAnthony M. A.ShelleyJulia M.LorraineDennerstein1994.
“Self-Rated Health: Biological Continuum or Social Discontinuity?”Social Science and Medicine39:
77–83
49.
SusmanJoan1994.
“Disability, Stigma, and Deviance.”Social Science and Medicine38:
15–22
50.
TurnbullH. RutherfordTurnbullAnn P.1999.
“Family Support: Retrospective and Prospective.”
Pp. 41330
in Mental Retardation in the Year 2000 and Beyond,
edited by WehmeyerM.PattonJ.Austin, TX:
ProEd
51.
TwaddleAndrew C.1974.
“The Concept of Health Status.”Social Science and Medicine8:
29–38
52.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.2000.
“Disability and Secondary Conditions.”
Pp. 6–16–28
in Healthy People 2010: Understanding and Improving Health,
2nd ed.Washington, DC:
U.S. Government Printing Office
53.
VerbruggeLois M.JetteAlan M.1994.
“The Disablement Process.”Social Science and Medicine38:
1–14
54.
WillettJ.B.SayerA.G.1994.
“Using Covariance Structure Analysis to Detect Correlates and Predictors of Individual Change over Time.”Psychological Bulletin116:
363–81
55.
WilliamsonJeff D.FriedLinda P.1996.
“Characterization of Older Adults who Attribute Functional Decrements to ‘Old Age.’ ”Journal of the American Geriatrics Society44:
1429–34
56.
WoodP. H. N.1980.
International Classification of Impairments, Disabilities, and Handicaps: A Manual of Classification Relating to the Consequences of Disease.Geneva, Switzerland:
World Health Organization
57.
ZinkJean1992.
“Adjusting to Early- and Late-Onset Disability.”Generations16:
59–60
58.
ZolaIrving K.1983.
Missing Pieces.Philadelphia, PA:
Temple University Press
59.
ZolaIrving K.1993.
“Self, Identity, and the Naming Question—Reflections on the Language of Disability.”Social Science and Medicine36:
167–73
