This paper examines how multiple roles affect the mental health of the elderly in Japan and the United States, two countries with vastly different cultures. Hypotheses were drawn based on the cultural differences in role experiences, and these hypotheses are tested by analyzing nationally representative samples of the elderly in these countries. The results show that Americans are more likely to be involved in roles related to family, work, and community, while the Japanese are more likely to be involved in only those roles related to family and work. Multiple roles are also found to be less beneficial for the mental health of Japanese elderly compared to American counterparts. National differences in the effects of individual roles and role configurations on mental health are also documented. Overall, the results show the importance of broad cultural contexts for understanding the relationship between roles and mental health.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdelmannPamela K.1994.
“Multiple Roles and Psychological Well-Being in a National Sample of Older Adults.”Journal of Gerontology4
(6):
S277–S285
2.
AneshenselCarol S.PearlinLeonard I.1987.
“Structural Contexts of Sex Differences.”
Pp. 7595
in Gender and Stress,
edited by BarnettRosalind C.LoisBeinerBaruchGrace K.New York:
The Free Press
3.
BarnettRosalind ChaitHydeJanet Shibley2001.
“Women, Men, Work, and Family.”American Psychologist56:
781–96
4.
Bolla-WilsonKarenBleeckerMargit L.1989.
“Absence of Depression in Elderly Adults.”Journal of Gerontology44(2):
53–55
5.
BollenKenneth A.BarbaraEntwisleAldersonArthur S.1993.
“Macrocomparative Research Methods.”Annual Review of Sociology19:
321–25
6.
BurtonRussell P. D.1998.
“Global Integrative Meaning as a Mediating Factor in the Relationship between Social Roles and Psychological Distress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior39:
201–15
7.
ColeRobert E.1979.
Work, Mobility, and Participation.Berkeley:
University of California Press
8.
DohiItsukoToshimuneHirosawaKunioTanaka1990.
“Tayo na Yakuwari Juji ni Kansuru Kenkyu.”Shakai Shinrigaku Kenkyu5:
137–45
9.
DurkheimEmile
[1897]
1951.
Suicide: A Study in Sociology.
Translated by SpauldingJohn A.SimpsonGeorge.New York:
The Free Press
10.
ElderJoseph W.1976.
“Comparative Cross-National Methodology.”Annual Review of Sociology3:
209–30
11.
FukutakeTadashi1967.
Japanese Rural Society.Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press
12.
GallinRita S.1985.
“Women and Work in Rural Taiwan: Building a Contextual Model Linking Employment and Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior30:
374–85
13.
GoodeWilliam J.1960.
“A Theory of Role Strain.”American Sociological Review25:
483–96
14.
HardyMelissa A.1993.
Regression with Dummy Variables.Newbury Park, CA:
Sage
15.
HashimotoAkiko1996.
The Gift of Generations: Japanese and American Perspectives on Aging and the Social Contract.New York:
Cambridge University Press
16.
HaugMarieHirokoAkiyamaGeorgeanaTrybanKyoichiSonodaMayWykle1991.
“Self Care: Japan and the U.S. Compared.”Social Science and Medicine33(9):
1011–22
17.
HoganDennis P.EggebeenDavid J.CloggClifford C.1993.
“The Structure of Intergenerational Exchanges in American Families.”American Journal of Sociology98:
1428–58
18.
HongJinkukSeltzerMarsha Mailick1995.
“The Psychological Consequences of Multiple Roles: The Nonnormative Case.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36:
386–98
19.
HouseJames S.1986. Americans'Changing Lives: WAVE I, 1986.
Ann Arbor, MI:
Survey Research Center
[producer]. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research [distributor]
IwasakiNobuhikoManabuAjisakaTadakazuUedaMasaakiTakagiMoriakiHiroharaNaokiYoshihara1989.
Chonaikai no Kenkyu.Tokyo, Japan:
Ochanomizu Shobo
22.
JacksonPamela Braboy1997.
“Role Occupancy and Minority Mental Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior38:
237–55
23.
JacksonPamela Braboy2004.
“Role Sequencing: Does Order Matter for Mental Health?”Journal of Health and Social Behavior45:
132–54
24.
Japan Management and Coordination Agency, Koreishakai Taisakushitsu.1997.
Rojin no Seikatsu to Ishiki: Dai 4 kai Kokusai Hikaku Chosa Kekka Hokokusho.Tokyo, Japan:
Chuohoki Shuppan
25.
Japan Statistics Bureau, Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications.2003.
Survey on Time Use and Leisure Activities.Tokyo, Japan:
Japan Statistical Association
26.
KanekoIkuyo1992.
Borantia — Mouhitotu no Joho Shakai.Tokyo, Japan:
Iwanami
27.
KikuzawaSaeko2001.
“Danjo ni Miru Eijingu, Yakuwari Ruiseki, Distress.”Shakaigaku Hyoron52:
2–15
28.
KimuraTakeshiMasatoOka2001.
“Japan's Current Policy Focus on Longer Employment for Older People.”
Pp. 34859
in Restructuring Work and the Life Course,
edited by MarshallVictor W.HeinzWalter R.HelgaKrugerAnilVermaToronto, Canada:
University of Toronto Press
29.
KrauseNealJerseyLiang1992.
“Cross-Cultural Variations in Depressive Symptoms in Later Life.”International Psychogeriatrics4
(Supplement 2):
185–202
30.
LaiGina1995.
“Work and Family Roles and Psychological Well-Being in China.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36:
11–37
31.
LiangJerseyJoanBennettNancyWhitelawDaisakuMaeda1991.
“The Structure of Self-Reported Physical Health among the Aged in the United States and Japan.”Medical Care29(12):
1161–79
32.
LiangJerseyDaisakuMaeda1987.
National Survey of Japanese Elderly, 1987
[MRDF].
Tokyo:
Japan Metropolitan Institute of Gerontology
[producer]. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research [distributor]
33.
LinNanGinaLai1995.
“Urban Stress in China.”Social Science and Medicine41(8):
1131–45
34.
MarkusStephen R.1977.
“Multiple Roles and Role Strain: Some Notes on Human Energy, Time and Commitment.”American Sociological Review42:
921–36
35.
MarmotM. G.SmithD. G.1989.
“Why Are the Japanese Living Longer?”British Medical Journal299:
1547–51
36.
MarsellaAnthony J.1987.
“The Measurement of Depressive Experience and Disorder across Cultures.”
Pp. 37697
in The Measurement of Depression,
edited by MarsellaAnthony J.HirschfeldRobert M. A.KatzMartin M.New York:
Guildford Press
37.
MatsushimaShizuo1983.
Koreika Shakai no Rodo-sha.Tokyo, Japan:
University of Tokyo Press
38.
MenaghanElizabeth G.1989.
“Role Changes and Psychological Well-Being: Variations in Effects by Gender and Role Repertoire.”Social Forces67:
693–714
39.
MertonRobert K.1957.
Social Theory and Social Structure.Glencoe, IL:
The Free Press
40.
MikamiFumiko1996.
“Chiiki Fukushi ni okeru Infomaru Sapoto Nettowaku no Ichizuke.”Shakaihosho Kenkyu31(4):
368–79
41.
MillerAlan S.1992.
“Conventional Religious Behavior in Modern Japan: A Service Industry Perspective.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion31:
207–14
42.
MoenPhyllisDonnaDempster-McClainWilliamsRobin M.Jr1992.
“Successful Aging: A Life-Course Perspective on Women's Multiple Roles and Health.”American Journal of Sociology97:
1612–38
NishiokaHachiro2000.
“Parent-Adult Child Relationships in Japan.”Review of Population and Social Policy9:
221–38
45.
NoguchiYukioWiseDavid A.1995.
Koreika no Nichibei Hikaku.Tokyo, Japan:
Nihon Keizai Shinbunsha
46.
OgawaNaohiroRetherfordRobert D.1997.
“Shifting Costs of Caring for the Elderly Back to Families in Japan: Will it Work?”Population and Development Review23(1):
59–94
47.
PavalkoElizaShariWoodbury2000.
“Social Roles as Process: Caregiving Careers and Women's Health.”Journal of Health and Social Benavior41:
91–105
48.
RadloffLenore Sawyer1977.
“The CES-D Scale: A Self-Reported Depression Scale for Research in the General Population.”Applied Psychological Measurement1(3):
385–401
49.
RaymoJames M.JerseyLianHidehiroSugisawaErikaKobayashiYokoSugihara2004.
“Work at Older Ages in Japan: Variation by Gender and Employment Status.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences59B
(3):
S154–S163
50.
ReitzesDonald C.MutranElizabeth J.1994.
“Multiple Roles and Identities: Factors Influencing Self-Esteem among Middle-Aged Working Men and Women.”Social Psychology Quarterly57(4):
313–25
51.
RosowIrving1985.
“Status and Role Change through the Life Cycle.”
Pp. 6293
in Handbook of Aging and the Social Sciences,
2nd ed.,
edited by BinstockRobert H.EthelShanasNew York:
Van Nostrand Reinhold Company
52.
SchultzJames H.AllanBorowskiCrownWilliam H.1991.
Economics of Population Aging: The ‘Graying’ of Australia, Japan, and the United States.New York:
Auburn House
53.
ShirahaseSawako2000.
“Kateinai Shien to Shakaihosho.”Shakaihosho Kenkyu36(1):
122–33
54.
SieberSam D.1974.
“Toward a Theory of Role Accumulation.”American Sociological Review39:
567–78
55.
TaeuberIrene B.1958.
The Population of Japan.Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press
56.
ThoitsPeggy A.1987.
“Negotiating Roles.”
Pp. 1122
in Spouse, Parent, Worker: On Gender, and Multiple Roles,
edited by CrosbyFaye J.New Haven, CT:
Yale University Press
57.
ThoitsPeggy A.1992.
“Identity Structures and Psychological Well-Being: Gender and Marital Status Comparisons.”Social Psychology Quarterly55(3):
236–56
58.
ThoitsPeggy A.2003.
“Personal Agency in the Accumulation of Multiple Role-Identities.”
Pp. 17994
in Advances in Identity Theory and Research,
edited by BurkePeter J.OwensTimothy J.RichardSerpeThoitsPeggy A.New York:
Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers
59.
WilkinsonR. G.1992.
“Income Distribution and Life Expectancy.”British Medical Journal304:
165–68
60.
ZaneNolan W. S.TakeuchiDavid T.YoungKathleen N. J., eds.
1994.
Confronting Critical Health Issues of Asian and Pacific Islander Americans.Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage
