How do schemas about self-salience—the importance of the self versus the collective in social relations—affect mental health? We propose that self-salience shapes the likelihood of experiencing internalizing or externalizing problems. Schemas that privilege others over the self increase the risk of internalizing symptoms, including depressive symptoms and anxiety, whereas those that privilege the self over others predispose individuals to externalizing behaviors of antisocial behavior and substance abuse. Furthermore, we propose that these schemas contribute to the gender differences that exist in these problems. We test these predictions with data from adolescents, the stage at which these problems and the gender differences in them arise. Results show that self-salience underlies both internalizing and externalizing problems. In addition, schemas about self-salience help explain the gender differences found in mental health problems.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AneshenselCarol S.RutterCarolyn M.LachenbruchPeter A.1991.
“Social Structure, Stress, and Mental Health: Competing Conceptual and Analytic Models.”American Sociological Review56:
166–78
2.
AvisonWilliam R.McAlpineDonna D.1992.
“Gender Differences in Symptoms and Depression among Adolescents.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior33:
77–96
3.
BakanDavid1966.
The Duality of Human Existence: Isolation and Communion in Western Man.Boston, MA:
Beacon
4.
BaumeisterRoy F.LauraSmartJosephBoden1999.
“Relation of Threatened Egotism to Violence, and Aggression: The Dark Side of High Self-Esteem.”
Pp. 24048
in The Self in Social Psychology,
edited by RoyBaumeisterPhiladelphia, PA:
Psychology Press
5.
BeckAaron T.1967.
Depression: Clinical, Experimental, and Theoretical Aspects.New York:
Harper and Row
6.
BeckAaron T.1999.
Prisoners of Hate: The Cognitive Basis of Anger, Hostility, and Violence.New York:
HarperCollins
7.
BordoSusan1993.
Unbearable Weight.Berkeley:
University of California Press
8.
BrownGeorge W.AndrewsB.BifulcoA.VeielH.1990.
“Self-Esteem and Depression: 1. Measurement Issues and Prediction of Onset.”Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology25:
200–209
9.
ChodorowNancy1978.
The Reproduction of Mothering.Berkeley:
University of California Press
10.
ConnellR. W.1995.
Masculinities.Berkeley:
University of California Press
11.
CooleyCharles H.1902.
Human Nature and the Social Order.New York:
Scribner
12.
DerogatisLeonardPatriciaCleary1977.
“Configuration of the Dimensional Structure of the SCL–90: A Study in Construct Validation.”Journal of Clinical Psychology33:
981–89
13.
DodgeKenneth A.1993.
“Social-Cognitive Mechanisms in the Development of Conduct Disorder and Depression.”Annual Review of Psychology44:
559–84
14.
EatonWilliamCarlesMuntaner1999.
“Socioeconomic Stratification and Mental Disorder.”
Pp. 25983
in The Sociology of Mental Health and Illness,
edited by AllanHorwitzTeresaSheidNew York:
Cambridge University Press
15.
FairbairnRonald1952.
An Object Relations Theory of the Personality.New York:
Basic
16.
FoucaultMichel1980.
The History of Sexuality.New York:
Vintage
17.
GilliganCarol1993.
In a Different Voice.Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press
18.
GreenbergerEllenChuanshengChen1996.
“Perceived Family Relationships and Depressed Mood in Early and Late Adolescence: A Comparison of European and Asian Americans.”Developmental Psychology32:
707–16
19.
GuisingerS.BlattSidney J.1994.
“Individuality and Relatedness: Evolution of a Fundamental Dialectic.”American Psychologist49:
104–11
20.
HaganJohnGillisA. R.JohnSimpson1985.
“The Class Structure of Gender and Delinquency: Toward a Power-Control Theory of Common Delinquent Behavior.”American Journal of Sociology90:
1151–78
21.
HarterSusan1999.
The Construction of the Self.New York:
Guilford
22.
HelgesonVicki S.1994.
“Relation of Agency and Communion to Well-Being: Evidence and Potential Explanations.”Psychological Bulletin116:
412–28
JacksonD. N.1974.
Personality Research Form Manual.Goshen, NY:
Research Psychologists Press
25.
JamesWilliam [1890]
1950.
The Principles of Psychology.Vol 1.
New York:
Dover
26.
JosephsRobert A.HazelRose MarkusTafarodiRomin W.1992.
“Gender and Self-Esteem.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology63:
391–402
27.
KaplanHoward1980.
Deviant Behavior in Defense of Self.New York:
Academic
28.
KaplanHowardMartinSteven S.JohnsonRobert J.1986.
“Self-Rejection and the Explanation of Deviance: Specification of the Structure among Latent Constructs.”American Journal of Sociology92:
384–411
29.
KesslerRonald C.KatherineMcGonagleShanyangZhaoChristopherNelsonMichaelHughesSuzannEshlemanHans-UlrichWittchenKennethKendler1994.
“Lifetime and 12-Month Prevalence of DSM III-R Psychiatric Disorders among Persons Aged 15–54 in the United States: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey.”Archives of General Psychiatry51:
8–19
30.
KohlbergLawrence1983.
Moral Stages: A Current Formulation and a Response to Critics.New York:
Karger
31.
LennonMary ClareSarahRosenfield1995.
“Relative Fairness and the Division of Household Work.”American Journal of Sociology100:
506–31
32.
MarkusHazel1977.
“Self-Schemata and Processing Information about the Self.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology35:
63–78
33.
MarkusHazelKitayamaS.1991.
“Culture and the Self: Implications for Cognition, Emotion, and Motivation.”Psychological Review98:
224–53
34.
MeadGeorge Herbert1934.
Mind, Self, and Society.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
35.
MenaghanElizabeth1999.
“Social Stressors in Childhood and Adolescence.”
Pp. 31527
in The Sociology of Mental Health and Illness,
edited by AllanHorwitzTeresaSheidNew York:
Cambridge University Press
36.
MillerJean Baker1976.
Toward a New Psychology of Women.Boston, MA:
Beacon
37.
MirowskyJohn1985.
“Depression and Marital Power: An Equity Model.”American Journal of Sociology91:
557–92
38.
MirowskyJohnCatherineRoss1996.
“Fundamental Analysis in Research on Well-Being: Distress and the Sense of Control.”Gerontologist36:
584–94
39.
Nolen-HoeksemaSusan1990.
Sex Differences in Depression.Stanford, CA:
Stanford University Press
40.
Nolen-HoeksemaSusanJudithLarsonCarlaGrayson1999.
“Explaining the Gender Difference in Depressive Symptoms.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology77:
1061–72
41.
NorasakkunkitV.KalickM. S.2002.
“Culture, Ethnicity, and Emotional Distress Measures: The Role of Self-Construal and Self-Enhancement.”Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology33:
56–70
42.
OhbuchiKen-IchiTsutomuOhnoHirokoMukai1992.
“Empathy and Aggression: Effects of Self-Disclosure and Fearful Appeal.”The Journal of Social Psychology133:
243–53
43.
OkazakiSumie1997.
“Sources of Ethnic Differences between Asian American and White American College Students on Measures of Depression and Social Anxiety.”Journal of Abnormal Psychology1:
52–60
44.
PandinaRobertErichLabouvieHeleneWhite1984.
“Potential Contributions of the Life Span Developmental Approach to the Study of Adolescent Alcohol and Drug Use: The Rutgers Health and Human Development Project.”Journal of Drug Issues14:
253–68
45.
PearlinLeonard1989.
“The Sociological Study of Stress.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior30:
241–56
46.
PearlinLeonard1999.
“Stress and Mental Health: A Conceptual Overview.”
Pp. 16175
in The Sociology of Mental Health and Illness,
edited by AllanHorwitzTeresaSheidNew York:
Cambridge University Press
47.
PearlinLeonard I.LiebermanMorton A.MenaghanElizabeth G.MullanJoseph T.1981.
“The Stress Process.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior22:
37–56
48.
RosenbergMorris1989.
“Self-Concept Research: A Historical Overview.”Social Forces68:
34–44
49.
RosenfieldSarah1989.
“The Effects of Women's Employment: Personal Control and Sex Differences in Mental Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior30:
77–91
50.
RosenfieldSarah1999a.
“Gender and Mental Health: Do Women Have More Psychopathology, Men More, or Both the Same (and Why)?”
Pp. 34860
in The Sociology of Mental Health and Illness,
edited by AllanHorwitzTeresaSheidNew York:
Cambridge University Press
51.
RosenfieldSarah1999b.
“Splitting the Difference: Gender, Psychopathology, and the Self.”
Pp. 20924
in Handbook of Psychiatric Sociology,
edited by CarolAneshenselJoPhelanNew York:
Plenum
52.
RosenfieldSarahJuliePhillipsHeleneWhite2004.
‘The Impact of Gender and Race on Mental Health.’
Presented at the International Conference on Social Stress Research, May 29–31, Montreal, Canada
53.
RosenfieldSarahJeanVertefuilleDonnaMcAlpine2000.
“Gender Stratification and Mental Health: An Exploration of Dimensions of the Self.”Social Psychology Quarterly63:
208–23
54.
SeligmanMartin E. P.1975.
Helplessness.San Francisco, CA:
Freeman
55.
ShwederRichard1991.
Thinking through Cultures.Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press
56.
SpenceJanetRobertHelmreich1978.
Masculinity and Femininity: Their Psychological Dimension, Correlates, and Antecedents.Austin:
University of Texas Press
57.
StrickerL. J.1974.
“Personality Research Form: Factor Structure and Response Style Involvement.”Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology42:
529–37
58.
SullivanHarry Stack1953.
Interpersonal Theory of Psychiatry.New York:
Norton
59.
ThoitsPeggy A.1999.
“Self, Identity, and Mental Health.”
Pp. 34568
in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health,
edited by CarolAneshenselJoPhelanNew York:
Kluwer
60.
ThoitsPeggy A.VirshupL. K.1993.
“Me's and We's: Forms and Functions of Social Identities.”
Pp. 10633
in Self and Identity: Fundamental Issues,
edited by AshmoreRichard D.LeeJussimNew York:
Oxford University Press
61.
TurnerHeather A.TurnerR. Jay1999.
“Gender, Social Status, and Emotional Reliance.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:
360–73
62.
TurnerR. JayDonaldLloyd1995.
“Lifetime Traumas and Mental Health: The Significance of Cumulative Adversity.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36:
360–76
63.
TurnerR. JayDonaldLloyd1999.
“The Stress Process and the Social Distribution of Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:
374–404
64.
ValianVirginia1999.
Why So Slow.Boston, MA:
MIT Press
65.
WhiteHelene R.LabouvieErich W.1989.
“Toward the Assessment of Adolescent Problem Drinking.”Journal of Studies on Alcohol50:
30–37
66.
WilliamsDavidMichelleHarris-Reid1999.
“Race and Mental Health: Emerging Patterns and Promising Approaches.”.
Pp. 295314
in The Sociology of Mental Health and Illness,
edited by AllanHorwitzTeresaSheidNew York:
Cambridge University Press
67.
WinnicottDonald W.1965.
The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment.New York:
International Universities Press
68.
ZhengY. P.LinK. M.TakeuchiD.KurasakiK. S.WangY. X.CheungF.1997.
“An Epidemiological Study of Neurasthenia in Chinese-Americans in Los Angeles.”Comprehensive Psychiatry38:
249–59
