Although numerous studies reveal differences in mental health by the structure of one's family of origin, there remains debate regarding the processes generating these patterns. Using a sample of young adults (19–21 years) in Miami-Dade County in Florida, this study examines the explanatory significance of three presumed correlates of family type: socioeconomic status, family processes, and level of social stress. Consistent with prior research, our results reveal higher levels of depressive symptoms among those from stepfamilies, single parent families, and single parent families with other relatives present, compared with mother-father families. All three presumed correlates make significant independent contributions to the prediction of depressive symptomatology. Substantial mediating effects also are observed for all three explanatory dimensions. Collectively, they completely or largely explain observed family type variations in mental health risk.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdlafEdward M.IvisFrank J.1996.
“Structure and Relations: The Influence of Familial Factors on Adolescent Substance Use and Delinquency.”Journal of Child and Adolescent Substance Abuse5:
119
2.
AktanGeorgia B.CalkinsRichard F.RibislKurt M.AliceKroliczakKasimRafa M.1997.
“Test-Retest Reliability of Psychoactive Substance Abuse and Dependence Diagnoses in Telephone Interviews Using a Modified Diagnostic Interview Schedule-Substance Abuse Module.”American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse23:
22948
3.
AlbrechtStan L.CherylAmeyMillerMichael K.1996.
“Patterns of Substance Abuse among Rural Black Adolescents.”Journal of Drug Issues26:
75181
4.
AmatoPaul R.1991.
“Parental Absence during Childhood and Depression in Later Life.”Sociological Quarterly32:
54356
5.
AmatoPaul R.SobolewskiJuliana M.2001.
“The Effects of Divorce and Marital Discord on Adult Children's Psychological Well-Being.”American Sociological Review66:
900921
6.
AmeyCheryl H.AlbrechtStan L.1998.
“Race and Ethnic Differences in Adolescent Drug Use: The Impact of Family Structure and the Quantity and Quality of Parental Interaction.”Journal of Drug Issues28:
28398
7.
AquilinoWilliam S.SuppleAndrew J.2001.
“Long-Term Effects of Parenting Practices during Adolescence on Well-Being Outcomes in Young Adulthood.”Journal of Family Issues22:
289308
8.
AseltineRobert H.Jr.1996.
“Pathways Linking Parental Divorce with Adolescent Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior37:
13348
9.
BarreraManuelJr.LiSusan A.LaurieChassin1995.
“Effects of Parental Alcoholism and Life Stress on Hispanic and Non-Hispanic Caucasian Adolescents: A Prospective Study.”American Journal of Community Psychology23:
479507
10.
CatalanoRichard F.MorrisonDiane M.WellsElizabeth A.GillmoreMary R.BonitaIritaniHawkinsJ. David1992.
“Ethnic Differences in Family Factors Related to Early Drug Initiation.”Journal of Studies on Alcohol53:
20817
11.
Chase-LansdaleP. LindsayJeanneBrooks-GunnZamskyElise S.1994.
“Young Multi-generational Families in Poverty: Quality of Mothering and Grandmothering.”Child Development65:
37393
12.
CherlinAndrew J.ChaP. Lindsayse-LansdaleChristineMcRae1998.
“Effects of Parental Divorce on Mental Health throughout the Life-Course.”American Sociological Review63:
23949
13.
CongerRand D.ElderGlenn H.Jr.LorenzFrederick O.SimonsRonald L.WhitbeckLes B.1994.
Families in Troubled Times: Adapting to Change in Rural America.New York:
Aldine De Gruyter
14.
FarberStephanie S.FelnerRobert D.JudithPrimavera1985.
“Parental Separation/Divorce and Adolescents: An Examination of Factors Mediating Adaptation.”American Journal of Community Psychology13:
17185
FieldsJason2003.
Children's Living Arrangements and Characteristics: March 2002.
Current Population Reports, P20–547.
Washington, DC:
U.S. Census Bureau
17.
FieldsJasonCasperLynne M.2001.
America's Families and Living Arrangements: March 2000.
Current Population Reports, P20–537.
Washington, DC:
U.S. Census Bureau
18.
FineMark A.PatriciaVoydanoffDonnellyBrenda W.1994.
“Parental Perceptions of Child Well-Being: Relations of Family Structure, Parental Depression, and Marital Satisfaction.”Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology15:
16586
19.
FlewellingRobert L.BaumanKarl E.1990.
“Family Structure as a Predictor of Initial Substance Use and Sexual Intercourse in Early Adolescence.”Journal of Marriage and the Family52:
17181
20.
GarnefskiNadiaDiekstraRene F. W.1997.
“Adolescents from One Parent, Stepparent, and Intact Families: Emotional Problems and Suicide Attempts.”Journal of Adolescence20:
2018
21.
GarrisonCarol Z.JacksonKirby L.FrederickMarstellerRobertMcKeownAddyCheryl L.1990.
“A Longitudinal Study of Depressive Symptomatology in Young Adolescents.”Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry29:
58185
22.
GilAndres G.VegaWilliam A.FrankBiafora1998.
“Temporal Influences of Family Structure and Family Risk Factors on Drug Use Initiation in a Multiethnic Sample of Adolescent Boys.”Journal of Youth and Adolescence27:
37393
23.
GilmanStephen E.IchiroKawachiFitz-mauriceGarrett M.BukaStephen L.2003.
“Family Disruption in Childhood and Risk of Adult Depression.”American Journal of Psychiatry160:
93946
24.
GlickPaul C.1990.
“American Families: As They Are and Were.”Sociology and Social Research74:
13945
25.
GoreSusanAseltineRobert H.Jr.ColtonMary Ellen1992.
“Social Structure, Life Stress, and Depressive Symptoms in a High School-Aged Population.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior33:
97113
26.
HardyGillian E.DavidWoodsWallToby D.2003.
“The Impact of Psychological Distress on Absence from Work.”Journal of Applied Psychology88:
30614
27.
HauserRobert M.SweeneyMegan M.1997.
“Does Poverty in Adolescence Affect the Life Chances of High School Graduates?”
Pp. 54195
in Consequences of Growing Up Poor,
edited by DuncanGreg J.JeanneBrooks-GunnNew York:
Russell Sage Foundation
28.
HollingsheadAugust B.1957.
Two Factor Index of Social Position.New Haven, CT:
Hollingshead
29.
KashaniJavad H.BeckNiels C.HoeperEdwin W.CarolynFallahiCorcoranColleen M.JeanneMcAllisterRosenbergTomas K.ReidJohn C.1987.
“Psychiatric Disorders in a Community Sample of Adolescents.”American Journal of Psychiatry144:
58489
30.
KesslerRonald C.MickelsonKristin D.WilliamsDavid R.1999.
“The Prevalence, Distribution, and Mental Health Correlates of Perceived Discrimination in the United States.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:
20830
31.
KreiderRose M.2003.
Adopted Children and Stepchildren: 2000.
Census 2000 Special Reports, CENSR-6RV.
Washington, DC:
U.S. Census Bureau
32.
KuhDianaRebeccaHardyBryanRodgersWadsworthMichael E. J.2002.
“Lifetime Risk Factors for Women's Psychological Distress in Midlife.”Social Science and Medicine55:
195773
33.
Lyons-RuthKarlenDavidZollDavidConnellGrunebaumHenry U.1986.
“The Depressed Mother and Her One-Year-Old Infant: Environment, Interaction, Attachment, and Infant Development.”
Pp. 6182
in Maternal Depression and Infant Disturbance: New Directions for Child Development Series, no. 34,
edited by TronickEdward Z.TiffanyFieldSan Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass
34.
MasonAlexMichaelWindle2001.
“Family, Religious, School, and Peer Influences on Adolescent Alcohol Use: A Longitudinal Study.”Journal of Studies on Alcohol62:
4453
35.
McKeownRobert E.GarrisonCarol Z.JacksonKirby L.CuffeSteven P.AddyCheryl L.WallerJennifer L.1997.
“Family Structure and Cohesion and Depressive Symptoms in Adolescents.”Journal of Research on Adolescence7:
26781
36.
McLanahanSara S.1997.
“Parent Absence or Poverty: Which Matters More?”
Pp. 3548
in Consequences of Growing Up Poor,
edited by DuncanGreg J.JeanneBrooks-GunnNew York:
Russell Sage Foundation
37.
McLeanDiane E.LinkBruce G.1994.
“Unraveling Complexity: Strategies to Refine Concepts, Measures, and Research Designs in the Study of Life Events and Mental Health.”
Pp. 1542
in Stress and Mental Health: Contemporary Issues and Prospects for the Future,
edited by AvisonWilliam R.GotlibIan H.New York:
Plenum
38.
McLeodJane D.1991.
“Childhood Parental Loss and Adult Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior32:
20530
39.
MidanikLorrainHinesAlice M.GreenfieldThomas K.RogersJohn D.1999.
“Face-to-Face versus Telephone Interviews: Using Cognitive Methods to Assess Alcohol Survey Questions.”Contemporary Drug Problems26:
67393
40.
MurryVelma M.BrownP. AdamaBrodyGene H.CutronaCarolyn E.SimonsRonald L.2001.
“Racial Discrimination as a Moderator of the Links among Stress, Maternal Psychological Functioning, and Family Relationships.”Journal of Marriage and the Family63:
91526
41.
NeedleRichard H.SuSusan S.DohertyWilliam J.1990.
“Divorce, Remarriage, and Adolescent Substance Use: A Prospective Longitudinal Study.”Journal of Marriage and the Family52:
15769
42.
OliverJ. M.BergerLaurie S.1992.
“Depression, Parent-Offspring Relationships, and Cognitive Vulnerability.”Journal of Social Behavior and Personality7:
41529
43.
PattenChristi A.GillinJ. ChristianFarkasArthur J.GilpinElizabeth A.BerryCharles C.PierceJohn P.1997.
“Depressive Symptoms in California Adolescents: Family Structure and Parental Support.”Journal of Adolescent Health20:
27178
44.
PavalkoEliza K.MossakowskiKrysia N.HamiltonVanessa J.2003.
“Does Perceived Discrimination Affect Health? Longitudinal Relationships between Work Discrimination and Women's Physical and Emotional Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior43:
1833
45.
RadloffLenore S.1977.
“The CES-D Scale: A Self-Report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population.”Applied Sociological Measurement1:
385401
46.
RenXinhua S.AmickBenjamin C.WilliamsDavid R.1999.
“Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Health: The Interplay between Discrimination and Socioeconomic Status.”Ethnicity and Disease9:
15165
47.
RohdePaulLewinsohnPeter M.SeeleyJohn R.1997.
“Comparability of Telephone and Face-to-Face Interviews in Assessing Axis I and II Disorders.”American Journal of Psychiatry154:
159398
48.
RossCatherine E.JohnMirowsky1979.
“A Comparison of Life-Event Weighting Schemes: Change, Undesirability, and Effect-Proportional Indices.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior20:
16677
49.
SandlerIrwin N.GuentherRobert T.1985.
“Assessment of Life Stress Events.”
Pp. 555600
in Measurement Strategies in Health Psychology,
edited by PaulKarolyNew York:
Wiley
50.
SeccombeKarenDeloresJamesWaltersKimberly Battle1998.
“‘They Think You Ain’t Much of Nothing': The Social Construction of the Welfare Mother.”Journal of Marriage and the Family60:
84965
51.
ShroutPatrick E.1981.
“Scaling of Stressful Life Events.”
Pp. 2947
in Stressful Life Events and Their Contexts,
edited by DohrenwendBarbara S.DohrenwendBruce P.New York:
Prodist
52.
SidelRuth1998.
Keeping Women and Children Last: America's War on the Poor.New York:
Viking Penguin
53.
Sokol-KatzJan S.UlbrichPatricia M.1992.
“Family Structure and Adolescent Risk-Taking Behavior: A Comparison of Mexican, Cuban, and Puerto Rican Americans.”International Journal of the Addictions27:
11971209
54.
SpruijtEdde GoedeMartijn1997.
“Transitions in Family Structure and Adolescent Well-Being.”Adolescence32:
897911
55.
SteinburgLaurenceMountsNina S.LambornSusie D.DornbuschSanford M.1991.
“Authoritative Parenting and Adolescent Adjustment across Varied Ecological Niches.”Journal of Research on Adolescence1:
1936
56.
StewartWalter F.RicciJudith A.ElsbethCheeHahnSteven R.DavidMorganstein2003.
“Cost of Lost Productive Work among U.S. Workers with Depression.”Journal of the American Medical Association289:
313544
57.
SuhTongwooSchutzChristian G.Chris-EllynJohanson1996.
“Family Structure and Initiating Non-medical Drug Use among Adolescents.”Journal of Child and Adolescent Substance Abuse5:
2136
58.
SwaimRandall C.BatesScott C.ChavezErnest L.1998.
“Structural Equation Socialization Model of Substance Use among Mexican-American and White Non-Hispanic School Dropouts.”Journal of Adolescent Health23:
12838
59.
TaylorJohnTurnerR. Jay2002.
“Perceived Discrimination, Social Stress, and Depression in the Transition to Adulthood: Racial Contrasts.”Social Psychology Quarterly65:
21325
60.
TurnerRebecca A.IrwinCharles E.Jr.MillsteinSusan G.1991.
“Family Structure, Family Processes, and Experimenting with Substances during Adolescence.”Journal of Research on Adolescence1:
93106
61.
TurnerR. JayWilliamAvison2003.
“Status Variations in Stress Exposure among Young Adults: Implications for the Interpretation of Prior Research.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior44:
488505
62.
TurnerR. JayDonaldLloyd1995.
“Lifetime Traumas and Mental Health: The Significance of Cumulative Adversity.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior36:
36076
63.
TurnerR. JayDonaldLloyd1999.
“The Stress Process and the Social Distribution of Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:
374404
64.
TurnerR. JayJohnTaylorGundyKaren Van2004.
“Personal Resources and Depression in the Transition to Adulthood: Ethnic Comparisons.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior45:
3452
65.
TurnerR. JayBlairWheaton1995.
“Checklist Measurements of Stressful Life Events.”
Pp. 4085
in Measuring Stress: A Guide for Health and Social Scientists,
edited by SheldonCohenKesslerRonald C.LynnGordenOxford, United Kingdom:
Oxford University Press
66.
TurnerR. JayBlairWheatonDonaldLloyd1995.
“The Epidemiology of Social Stress.”American Sociological Review60:
10424
67.
VegaWilliam A.GilAndres G.1998.
Drug Use and Ethnicity in Early Adolescence.New York:
Plenum
68.
WheatonBlair1994.
“Sampling the Stress Universe.”
Pp. 77114
in Stress and Mental Health: Contemporary Issues and Prospects for the Future,
edited by AvisonWilliam R.GotlibIan H.New York:
Plenum
69.
WheatonBlair1999.
“The Nature of Stressors.”
Pp. 17697
in A Handbook for the Study of Mental Health: Social Contexts, Theories, and Systems,
edited by HorwitzAllanScheidTeresa L.New York:
Cambridge University Press
70.
WilliamsDavid R.1997.
“Race and Health: Basic Questions, Emerging Directions.”Annals of Epidemiology7:
32233
71.
WilliamsDavid R.SpencerMichael S.JacksonJames S.1999.
“Race, Stress, and Physical Health: The Role of Group Identity.”
Pp. 71100
in Self, Social Identity, and Physical Health: Interdisciplinary Explorations,
edited by ContradaRichard J.AshmoreRichard D.New York:
Oxford University Press
72.
WilliamsDavid R.YanYuJacksonJames S.AndersonNorman B.1997.
“Racial Differences in Physical and Mental Health: Socioeconomic Status, Stress, and Discrimination.”Journal of Health Psychology2:
33551
