This article utilizes the agency-structure debate as a framework for constructing a health lifestyle theory. No such theory currently exists, yet the need for one is underscored by the fact that many daily lifestyle practices involve considerations of health outcomes. An individualist paradigm has influenced concepts of health lifestyles in several disciplines, but this approach neglects the structural dimensions of such lifestyles and has limited applicability to the empirical world. The direction of this article is to present a theory of health lifestyles that includes considerations of both agency and structure, with an emphasis upon restoring structure to its appropriate position. The article begins by defining agency and structure, followed by presentation of a health lifestyle model and the theoretical and empirical studies that support it.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbelThomasEstherWalterSteffenNiemannRolfWeitkunat1999.
“The Berne-Munich Lifestyle Panel.”Sozial- und Präventivmedizin44:
91106
2.
AdlerNancy E.ThomasBoyceChesneyMargaret A.SheldonCohenSusanFolkmanKahnRobert L.SymeS. Leonard1994.
“Socioeconomic Status and Health: The Challenge of the Gradient.”American Psychologist10:
1524
3.
AdonisAndrewStephenPollard1997.
A Class Act: The Myth of Britain's Classless Society.London:
Penguin
4.
AinsworthBarbara E.2000.
“Issues in the Assessment of Physical Activity in Women.”Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport71:
3750
5.
AnnandaleEllen1998.
The Sociology of Health and Medicine: A Critical Introduction.Cambridge, United Kingdom:
Polity Press
6.
ArcherMargaret S.1995.
Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach.Cambridge, United Kingdom:
Cambridge University Press
7.
ArcherMargaret S.1998.
“Realism and Morphogensis.”
Pp. 35681
in Critical Realism,
edited by MargaretArcherRoyBhaskarAndrewCollierTonyLawsonAlanNorrieLondon:
Routledge
8.
ArcherMargaret S.2003.
Structure, Agency and the Internal Conversation.Cambridge, United Kingdom:
Cambridge University Press
9.
AspinallPeter J.2001.
“Operationalising the Collection of Ethnicity Data in Studies of the Sociology of Health and Illness.”Sociology of Health and Illness23:
82982
10.
BackettKathryn C.CharlieDavison1995.
“Lifecourse and Lifestyle: The Social and Cultural Location of Health Behaviours.”Social Science and Medicine40:
62938
11.
BaumanZygmunt1992.
Intimations of Post-modernity.London:
Routledge
12.
BaumanZygmunt1999.
In Search of Politics.Stanford, CA:
Stanford University Press
13.
BaumanZygmunt2000.
Liquid Modernity.Cambridge, United Kingdom:
Polity Press
14.
BeckUlrich1992.
Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity.
Translated by RitterMark.
London:
Sage
15.
BhaskarRoy1998.
The Possibility of Naturalism.3d ed.London:
Routledge
16.
BlaxterMildred1990.
Health and Lifestyles.London:
Routledge
17.
BohmanJames1999.
“Practical Reason and Cultural Constraint: Agency in Bourdieu's Theory of Practice.”
Pp. 12952
in Bourdieu: A Critical Reader,
edited by RichardShustermanOxford, United Kingdom:
Blackwell
18.
BourdieuPierre1977.
Outline of a Theory of Practice.
Translated by NiceRichard.
Cambridge, United Kingdom:
Cambridge University Press
19.
BourdieuPierre1984.
Distinction.
Translated by NiceRichard.
Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press
20.
BourdieuPierre1990.
The Logic of Practice.
Translated by NiceRichard.
Stanford, CA:
Stanford University Press
21.
BourdieuPierre1996.
The Rules of Art.
Translated by EmanuelSusan.
Cambridge, United Kingdom:
Cambridge University Press
22.
BourdieuPierreWacquantLoïc J. D.1992.
An Introduction to Reflexive Sociology.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
23.
BrownTamara L.ParksGregory S.ZimmermanRick S.PhillipsClarenda M.2001.
“The Role of Religion in Predicting Adolescent Alcohol Use and Problem Drinking.”Journal of Studies on Alcohol65:
696706
24.
BrowningChristopherCagneyKathleen A.2002.
“Neighborhood Structural Disadvantage, Collective Efficacy, and Self-Rated Physical Health in an Urban Setting.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior43:
38399
25.
CalnanMichael1987.
Health and Illness.London:
Tavistock
26.
ClarkeAdele E.ShimJanet K.LauraMamoJenniferRuth FosketFishmanJennifer R.2003.
“Biomedicalization: Technoscientific Trans formations of Health, Illness, and U.S. Biomedicine.”American Sociological Review68:
16194
27.
CockerhamWilliam C.1997.
“The Social Determinants of the Decline of Life Expectancy in Russia and Eastern Europe: A Lifestyle Explanation.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior38:
13148
28.
CockerhamWilliam C. 1999.
Health and Social Change in Russia and Eastern Europe.London:
Routledge
29.
CockerhamWilliam C.2000a.
“The Sociology of Health Behavior and Health Lifestyles.”
Pp. 15972
in Handbook of Medical Sociology,
5th ed.,
edited by ChloeBirdPeterConradFremontAllen M.Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall
30.
CockerhamWilliam C.2000b.
“Health Lifestyles in Russia.”Social Science and Medicine51:
131324
31.
CockerhamWilliam C.ThomasAbelLüschenGünther1993.
“Max Weber, Formal Rationality, and Health Lifestyles.”The Sociological Quarterly34:
41335
CockerhamWilliam C.SneadM. ChristineDeWaalDerek F.2002.
“Health Lifestyles in Russia and the Socialist Heritage.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior43:
4255
34.
CrawfordRobert1984.
“A Cultural Account of Health: Control, Release, and the Social Body.”
Pp. 60103
in Issues in the Political Economy of Health Care,
edited by JohnMcKinleyNew York:
Tavistock
35.
CromptonRosemary1998.
Class and Stratification.2d ed.Oxford, United Kingdom:
Polity Press
36.
DahrendorfRalf1979.
Life Chances.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
37.
DemersAndréeJocelynBissonJézabellePalluy1999.
“Wives' Convergence with Their Husbands' Alcohol Use: Social Conditions as Mediators.”Journal of Studies of Alcohol60:
36877
38.
DemersAndréeSylviaKairouzAdlafEdward M.LouisGlickmanBrendaNewton-TaylorAlainMarchand2002.
“Multilevel Analysis of Situational Drinking among Canadian Undergraduates.”Social Science and Medicine55:
41524
39.
DentonMargaretVivienneWalters1999.
“Gender Differences in Structural and Behavioral Determinants of Health: An Analysis of the Social Production of Health.”Social Science and Medicine48:
122135
40.
d'HoutaudA.FieldMark G.1984.
“The Image of Health: Variations in Perception by Social Class in a French Population.”Sociology of Health and Illness6:
3059
41.
DunnAndrea L.MarcusBess H.KampertJames B.GarciaMelissa E.KohlHarold W.IIIBlairSteven N.1999.
“Comparison of Lifestyle and Structural Interventions to Increase Physical Activity and Cardiorespiratory Fitness.”Journal of the American Medical Association281:
32734
42.
DurkheimEmile
[1895]
1950.
The Rules of Sociological Method.New York:
Free Press
43.
EmirbayerMustafaAnnMische1998.
“What Is Agency?”American Journal of Sociology103:
9621023
44.
EricksonRobert E.GoldthorpeJohn H.1992.
The Constant Flux: A Study of Class Mobility in Industrial Society.Oxford, United Kingdom:
Clarendon Press
45.
FordEarl S.MerrittRobert K.HeathGregory W.PowellKenneth E.WashburnRichard A.AndreaKriskaGwendolynHalle1991.
“Physical Activity Behaviors in Lower and Higher Socioeconomic Status Populations.”American Journal of Epidemiology133:
124656
46.
FrohlichKatherine L.EllenCorinLouisePotvin2001.
“A Theoretical Proposal for the Relationship between Context and Disease.”Sociology of Health and Illness23:
77697
47.
GeorgeValerie A.PauletteJohnson2001.
“Weight Loss Behaviors and Smoking in College Students of Diverse Ethnicity.”American Journal of Health Behavior25:
11524
48.
GiddensAnthony1984.
The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration.Berkeley:
University of California Press
49.
GiddensAnthony1991.
Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age.Stanford, CA:
Stanford University Press
50.
GochmanDavid S.1997.
“Health Behavior Research, Cognate Disciplines, Future Identity, and an Organizing Matrix: An Integration of Perspectives.”
Pp. 395425
in Handbook of Health Behavior,
vol. 4,
edited by GochmanDavid.
New York:
Plenum
51.
GreenacreMichaelJörgBlasius, eds.
1993.
Correspondence Analysis in the Social Sciences.London:
Academic Press
52.
GrzywaczJoseph G.MarksNadine F.2001.
“Social Inequalities and Exercise during Adulthood: Toward an Ecological Perspective.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior42:
20220
53.
HardeyMichael1999.
“Doctor in the House: The Internet as a Source of Lay Knowledge and the Challenge to Expertise.”Sociology of Health and Illness21:
82035
54.
HusserlEdmund
[1952]
1989.
Ideas Pertaining to a Pure Phenomenology and to a Phenomenological Philosophy.
Translated by RojecwiczR.SchuwerA..
London:
Kluwer Academic
55.
JanečkováHana2001.
“Transformation of the Health Care System in the Czech Republic—A Sociological Perspective.”
Pp. 34764
in The Blackwell Companion to Medical Sociology,
edited by WilliamCockerhamOxford, United Kingdom:
Blackwell
56.
JarvisMartin J.JaneWardle1999.
“Social Patterning of Individual Health Behaviours: The Case of Cigarette Smoking.”
Pp. 24056
in Social Determinants of Health,
edited by MarmotMichaelWilkinsonRichard G.Oxford, United Kingdom:
Oxford University Press
57.
JohnsonRobert A.HoffmannJohn P.2000.
“Adolescent Cigarette Smoking in the U.S. Racial/Ethnic Subgroups: Findings from the National Education Longitudinal Study.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior41:
392407
58.
KalbergStephen1994.
Max Weber's Comparative-Historical Sociology.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
59.
KarlsenSaffronNazrooJames Y.2002.
“Agency and Structure: The Impact of Ethnic Identity and Racism on the Health of Ethnic Minority People.”Sociology of Health and Illness24:
120
60.
KlatskyArthur L.1999.
“Moderate Drinking and Reduced Risk of Heart Disease.”Alcohol Research and Health23:
1523
61.
LaaksonenMikkoPrättäläRitvaEeroLahelma2002.
“Sociodemographic Determinants of Multiple Unhealthy Behaviours.”Scandinavian Journal of Public Health30:
17
62.
LindquistChristineCockerhamWilliam C.Sean-ShongHwang1999.
“Drinking Patterns in the American Deep South.”Journal of Studies on Alcohol60:
66366
63.
LinkBruceJoPhelan2000.
“Evaluating the Fundamental Cause Explanation for Social Disparities in Health.”
Pp. 3347
in Handbook of Medical Sociology,
5th ed.,
edited by BirdChloe E.PeterConradFremontAllen M.Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall
64.
LomasJonathan1998.
“Social Capital and Health: Implications for Public Health and Epidemiology.”Social Science and Medicine47:
118188
MarxKarl1960.
Politische Schriften [Political Writings].
Edited by LieberH.Stuttgart, Germany:
Enke
67.
MeadGeorge Herbert1934.
Mind, Self and Society.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
68.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.2003.
Education, Social Status, and Health.New York:
Aldine de Gruyter
69.
OstrowskaNina2001.
“In and Out of Communism: The Macrosocial Context of Health in Poland.”
Pp. 33446
in The Blackwell Companion to Medical Sociology,
edited by WilliamCockerhamOxford, United Kingdom:
Blackwell
70.
PescosolidoBernice A.JaneMcLeodMargaritaAlegría2000.
“Confronting the Second Social Contract: The Place of Medical Sociology in Research and Policy for the Twenty-First Century.”
Pp. 41126
in Handbook of Medical Sociology,
5th ed.,
edited by ChloeBirdPeterConradFremontAllen M.Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall
71.
PescosolidoBernice A.RubinBeth A.2000.
“The Web of Group Affiliations Revisited: Social Life, Postmodernism, and Sociology.”American Sociological Review65:
5276
72.
ReidIvan1998.
Class in Britain.Cambridge, United Kingdom:
Polity Press
73.
RobertStephanie A.HouseJames S.2000.
“Socioeconomic Inequalities in Health: An Enduring Sociological Problem.”
Pp. 7997
in Handbook of Medical Sociology,
5th ed.,
edited by BirdChloe E.PeterConradFremontAllen M.Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall
74.
RoosEvaEeroLahelmaMikkoVirtanenPrättäläRitvaPirjoPietinen1998.
“Gender, Socioeconomic Status and Family Status as Determinants of Food Behaviour.”Social Science and Medicine46:
151929
75.
RossCatherine E.BirdChloe E.1994.
“Sex Stratification and Health Lifestyle: Consequences for Men's and Women's Perceived Health.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior35:
16178
76.
ScottJohn1996.
Stratification and Power: Structures of Class, Status, and Command.Cambridge, United Kingdom:
Polity Press
77.
SewellWilliam H.1992.
“A Theory of Structure: Duality, Agency, and Transformation.”American Journal of Sociology98:
129
78.
ShifflettPeggy A.1987.
“Future Time Perspective, Past Experiences, and Negotiation of Food Use Patterns among the Aged.”Gerontologist27:
61115
79.
ShifflettPeggy A.McIntoshWilliam A.1986–87.
“Food Habits and Future Time: An Exploratory Study of Age-Appropriate Food Habits among the Elderly.”International Journal of Aging and Human Development24:
117
80.
SibeonRoger2004.
Rethinking Social Theory.London:
Sage
81.
SmajeChris2000.
“Race, Ethnicity, and Health.”
Pp. 11428
in Handbook of Medical Sociology,
5th ed.,
edited by ChloeBirdPeterConradFremontAllen M.Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall
82.
SneadM. ChristineCockerhamWilliam C.2002.
“Health Lifestyles and Social Class in the Deep South.”Research in the Sociology of Health Care20:
10722
83.
SwartzDavid1997.
Culture and Power: The Sociology of Pierre Bourdieu.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
84.
SweatMichael D.DenisonJulie A.1995.
“Reducing HIV Incidence in Developing Countries with Structural and Environmental Interventions.”AIDS9:
S251–S257
85.
TurnerBryan S.1992.
Regulating Bodies: Essays in Medical Sociology.London:
Routledge
86.
TurnerBryan S.WainwrightSteven P.2003.
“Corps de Ballet: The Case of the Injured Dancer.”Sociology of Health and Illness25:
26988
87.
VeblenThorstein [1899] 1994.
Theory of the Leisure Class.New York:
Dover
88.
VickersRoss R.ConwayTerry L.HervigLinda K.1990.
“Demonstration of Replicable Dimensions of Health Behaviors.”Preventive Medicine19:
377401
89.
WarrenMary GuptillRoseWeitzStephenKulis1998.
“Physician Satisfaction in a Changing Health Care Environment: The Impact of Challenges to Professional Autonomy, Authority, and Dominance.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior39:
35667
90.
WeberMax1946.
From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. Translated and
edited by HansGerthMillsC. WrightNew York:
Oxford University Press
91.
WeberMax1949.
The Methodology of the Social Sciences.
Edited by ShilsEdwardFinchH.New York:
Free Press
92.
WeberMax1958.
The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism.
Translated by ParsonsTalcott.
New York:
Scribners
93.
WeberMax.
[1922]
1978.
Economy and Society.2 vols.
Translated and
edited by RothGuentherClausWittichBerkeley:
University of California Press
94.
WickramaK. A. S.CongerRand D.WallaceLora EbertElderGlen H.Jr.1999.
“The Intergenerational Transmission of Health-Risk Behaviors: Adolescent Lifestyles and Gender Moderating Effects.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:
258272
95.
WilliamsGareth H.2003.
“The Determinants of Health: Structure, Context, and Agency.”Sociology of Health and Illness25:
13154
96.
WilliamsSimon J.1995.
“Theorising Class, Health and Lifestyles: Can Bourdieu Help Us?”Sociology of Health and Illness17:
577604
97.
ZerubavelEviatar1997.
Social Mindscapes.Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press
