This study investigates the assumption that disabled people want improvements in their functional abilities, or complete cures. Contrary to this assumption, many disabled activists are found to have attitudes in which they refuse treatment that promises a cure. In order to explain this attitude, different sources of disability identity are isolated as potential predictor variables. A multivariate model reveals that self-identity related to a personal affirmation of disability is a significant predictor of refusal of treatment, as is the age of onset of disability. Implications for interactions with medical professionals and utility-based modeling of medical treatment seeking are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbbottJ.DoddM.WebbA. K.1996.
“Health Perceptions and Treatment Adherence in Adults with Cystic Fibrosis.”Thorax51:
123338
2.
BarnarttSharonRichardScotch2001.
Disability Protests: Contentious Politics 1970–1999.Washington, DC:
Gallaudet University Press
3.
BeckerM. H., ed.
1974.
The Health Belief Model and Personal Health Behavior.Thorofare, NJ:
Slack
4.
BrewerMarilynn B.1979.
“In-group Bias in the Minimal Inter-group Relationship: A Cognitive Motivational Analysis.”Psychological Bulletin86:
30724
5.
BrownRupert1995.
Prejudice: Its Social Psychology.Oxford, England:
Blackwell
6.
BudneyAlan J.RadonovichKrestin J.HigginsStephen T.WongConrad J.1998.
“Adults Seeking Treatment for Marijuana Dependence: A Comparison with Cocaine-dependent Treatment Seekers.”Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology6:
41926
7.
BurkePeter J.ReitzesDonald C.1981.
“The Link between Identity and Role Performance.”Social Psychological Quarterly44:
8392
8.
BurkePeter J.ReitzesDonald C.1991.
“An Identity Theory Approach to Commitment.”Social Psychological Quarterly54:
28086
9.
CampbellMargaret L.1996.
“A Life Course Perspective: Aging with Long-term Disability.”Maximizing Human Potential1:
12
10.
ChongDennis1991.
Collective Action and the Civil Rights Movement.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press
11.
CitrinJackBethReingoldGreenDonald P.1990.
“American Identity and the Politics of Ethnic Change.”Journal of Politics52:
112454
12.
ConoverPamela Johnston1984.
“The Influence of Group Identification on Political Perception and Evaluation.”Journal of Politics46:
76085
13.
DeJongGerbenBataviaAndrew I.GrissR.1989.
“America's Neglected Health Minority: Working-age Persons with Disabilities.”The Milbank Quarterly67(Supplement 2):
311–51
14.
FitzgibbonMarianStolleyMelinda R.KirschenbaumDaniel S.1993.
“Obese People Who Seek Treatment Have Different Characteristics Than Those Who Do Not Seek Treatment.”Health Psychology12:
34245
GergenKenneth J.1971.
The Concept of Self.New York:
Holt, Rinehart, and Winston
17.
GillCarol2001.
“Divided Understandings: The Social Experience of Disability.”
Pp. 35172
in The Handbook of Disability Studies,
edited by GaryAlbrechtKatherineSeelmanMichaelBuryThousand Oaks, CA:
Sage
18.
GliedmanJohnWilliamRoth1980.
The Unexpected Minority: Handicapped Children in America.New York:
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
19.
GodardSally L.BloomJoseph D.WilliamsMary H.FaulknerLarry R.1986.
“The Right to Refuse Treatment in Oregon: A Two-year Statewide Experience.”Behavioral Sciences & the Law4:
293304
20.
HahnHarlan1985.
“Toward a Politics of Disability: Definitions, Disciplines, and Policies.”The Social Science Journal22:
87105
21.
HahnHarlan1993a.
“The Political Implications of Disability Definitions and Data.”Journal of Disability Policy Studies4:
4152
22.
HahnHarlan1993b.
“The Potential Impact of Disability Studies on Political Science (As well as Vice-versa).”Policy Studies Journal21:
74051
23.
HahnHarlan1994.
“The Minority Group Model of Disability: Implications for Medical Sociology.”
Pp. 324
in Research in the Sociology of Health Care,
vol. 11,
edited by WeitzR.KronenfeldJ. J.Greenwich, Connecticut:
JAI Press
24.
HahnHarlan2000.
“Accommodations and the ADA: Biased Reasoning or Unreasonable Bias?”Berkeley Journal of Employment and Labor Law21:
16692
25.
HahnHarlanRichardBeaulaurier2001.
“Attitudes toward Disabilities: A Research Note on Activists with Disabilities.”Journal of Disability Policy Studies12:
406
26.
HiggsMelinda L.TraceyWadeMarkCescatoMichelleAtchisonAnthonySlavotinekBruceHiggins1997.
“Differences between Treatment Seekers in an Obese Population: Medical Intervention vs. Dietary Restriction.”Journal of Behavioral Medicine20:
391405
27.
HoggMichael A.TerryDeborah J.WhiteKatherine M.1995.
“A Tale of Two Theories: A Critical Comparison of Identity Theory with Social Identity Theory.”Social Psychology Quarterly58:
25569
28.
HuddyLeonie2001.
“From Social to Political Identity: A Critical Examination of Social Identity Theory.”Political Psychology22:
12756
29.
JankowskiKatherine1997.
Deaf Empowerment: Emergence, Struggle, and Rhetoric.Washington, DC:
Gallaudet University Press
30.
KaskutasLee AnnConstanceWeisnerRaulCaetano1994.
“Predictors of Help Seeking among a Longitudinal Sample of the General Population, 1984–1992.”Journal of Studies on Alcohol58:
15561
31.
KirschtJ. P.1988.
“The Health Belief Model and Predictions of Health Actions.”
Pp. 2741
in Health Behavior: Emerging Research Perspectives,
edited by GochmanDavid S.New York:
Plenum
32.
LaneHarlan1992.
“Cochlear Implants are Wrong for Young Deaf Children.”
Pp. 8992
in Viewpoints on Deafness,
edited by GarretsonMervin D.Silver Spring, MD:
National Association of the Deaf
33.
MajorBrendaSciacchitanoAnne MarieJenniferCrocker1993.
“Ingroup Versus Outgroup Comparisons and Self-esteem.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin19:
71121
34.
MonaL. R.GardosP. S.BrownR. C.1994.
“Sexual Self-views of Women with Disabilities: The Relationship among Age-of-onset, Nature of Disability, and Sexual Self-esteem.”Sexuality and Disability12:
26177
35.
NiparkoJohn K.2000.
“Culture and Cochlear Implants.”
Pp. 37179
in Cochlear Implants: Principles and Practices,
edited by NiparkoJohn K.KirkKaren IlerMellonNancy K.RobbinsAmy McConkeyTucciDebra L.WilsonBlake S.Philadelphia, PA:
Lippincott Williams and Wilkins
36.
ParsonsTalcott1950.
The Social System.New York:
The Free Press
37.
PhinneyJean S.1990.
“Ethnic Identity in Adolescence and Adults: Review of Research.”Psychological Bulletin108:
499514
38.
RichmanJoel1987.
Medicine and Health.New York:
Longman
39.
RobinsonJohn P.ShaverPhillip R.1974.
Measures of Social Psychological Attitudes.Ann Arbor, MI:
Institute for Social Research
40.
RynearsonE. K.1995.
“Bereavement after Homicide: A Comparison of Treatment Seekers and Refusers.”British Journal of Psychiatry166:
50710
41.
ShapiroJoseph. P.1993.
No Pity: People with Disabilities Forging a New Civil Rights Movement.New York:
Times Books
42.
StefanSusan2001.
Unequal Rights: Discrimination against People with Mental Disabilities and the Americans with Disabilities Act.Washington, DC:
American Psychological Association
43.
StrykerSheldon1980.
Symbolic Interactionism: A Social Structural Version.Menlo Park, CA:
Benjamin/Cummings
44.
TajfelHenri1981.
Human Groups and Social Categories.Cambridge, MA:
Cambridge University Press
45.
TorranceG. W.1987.
“Utility Approach to Measuring Health-related Quality of Life.”Journal of Chronic Diseases40:
593600
46.
TwaddleAndrew1979.
Sickness Behavior and Sick Role.Boston, MA:
G. K. Hall
47.
WaitzkinHowardBarbaraWaterman1974.
The Exploitation of Illness in Capitalist Society.Indianapolis, IN:
Bobbs-Merrill
48.
WeinbergNancy1988.
“Another Perspective: Attitudes of People with Disabilities.”
Pp. 14153
in Attitudes Toward Persons with Disabilities,
edited by YukerHarold E.New York:
Springer Publishing
49.
WeinbergNancyJudyWilliams1978.
“How the Physically Disabled Perceive their Disabilities.”Journal of Rehabilitation44(3):
31–33
50.
WestCarolyn M.KantorGlenda KaufmanJasinskiJana L.1998.
“Sociodemographic Predictors and Cultural Barriers to Help-Seeking Behavior by Latina and Anglo American Battered Women.”Violence and Victims13(4):
361–75
51.
WrightsonK. J.WardleK.1997.
“Cultural Variation in Health Locus of Control.”Ethnicity & Health2:
1320
