Rebels with our Applause? A Critique of Resistance Theory in Paul Willis's Ethnography of Schooling

Abstract

The importance of conflict, contestation, and pupil resistance in schooling has been stressed in recent accounts of schooling's role in social reproduction. One of the most influential instances of this “resistance theory” of reproduction is Paul Willis's Learning to Labour, an ethnography of schooling. After some critical remarks about use of the term “resistance,” this paper analyzes Willis's ethnographic data and his presentation and interpretation are criticized for unduly romanticizing the “resistant” practices (or “counter-school culture”) of the subjects (“the lads”). Although Willis reveals the sexism, racism, and self-defeating manualism of “the lads,” he implicitly endorses educational and cultural notions which misrepresent the conditions for a progressive working-class education and for breaking the nexus between education and the reproduction of oppressive social structures. An alternative view of “resistance” is offered, in which the evaluation of nonconformist practices becomes a more socially relative and historically contingent issue.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anyon

(1983). Intersections of gender and class: Accommodation and resistance by working class and affluent females to contradictory sex-role ideologies. In Walker

, & Barton

(Eds.), Gender, class and education. Sussex: Falmer.

Arnot

(1981). Class, gender and education. London: Open University Press.

Arnot

, & Whitty

(1982). From reproduction to transformation: Recent radical perspectives on the curriculum from the U.S.A. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 3(1), 93–103.

Brake

(1980). The sociology of youth culture and youth subcultures: Sex and drugs and rock ‘n’ roll. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Braverman

(1974). Labor and monopoly capital: The degradation of work in the twentieth century. New York: Monthly Review Press.

Centre for contemporary cultural studies (1982). The empire strikes back: Race and racism in 70s Britain. London: Hutchinson.

Connell

R. W.

, Ashenden

, Kessler

, & Dowsett

(1982). Making the difference: Schools, families and social division. Sydney: Allen and Unwin.

Davies

(1983). Gender, resistance and power. In Walker

, & Barton

(Eds.), Gender, class and education. Sussex: Falmer.

Denzin

N. K.

(1978). The Research Act: A theoretical introduction to sociological methods (2nd Ed.). Sussex: Falmer.

10.

Giroux

H. A.

(1981). Hegemony resistance and the paradox of educational reform. Interchange, 12(2-3), 3–26.

11.

Giroux

H. A.

(1983a). Theories of reproduction and resistance in the new sociology of education: A critical analysis. Harvard Educational Review, 53(3), 275–294.

12.

Giroux

H. A.

(1983b). Theory and resistance in education: A pedagogy for the opposition. South Hadley, MA: Bergin Press.

13.

Glaser

B. G.

, & Strauss

A. L.

(1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. Chicago: Aldine.

14.

Hall

, & Jefferson

(Eds.) (1976). Resistance through rituals: Youth cultures in postwar Britain. London: Hutchinson.

15.

Hammersley

, & Atkinson

(1983). Ethnography: Principles in practice. London: Tavistock.

16.

Hargreaves

(1982). Resistance and relative autonomy theories: Problems of distortion in recent Marxist analyses of education. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 3(2), 107–126.

17.

Lakatos

(1970). Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes, in Lakatos

, & Musgrave

(Eds.), Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

18.

McRobbie

(1978). Working class girls and the culture of femininity, in Women's Studies Group, Women Take Issue. London: Hutchinson.

19.

McRobbie

, & McCabe

(1981). Feminism for girls: An adventure story. London: Routledge and Reagan Paul.

20.

Popper

K. R.

(1963). Conjectures and refutations. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

21.

Popper

K. R.

(1972). Objective knowledge: An evolutionary approach. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

22.

Walker

J. C.

(1983). Materialism and the growth of knowledge in education. In Some new perspectives in philosophy of education (Occasional Papers, No. 14). Sydney: University of Sydney Department of Education.

23.

Walker

J. C.

(in press-a). Dusting off educational studies: A methodology for implementing certain proposals made by John Wilson. Journal of Philosophy of Education.

24.

Walker

J. C.

(in press-b). Materialist epistemology and sociology of education, British Journal of Sociology of Education.

25.

Walker

J. C.

, & Evers

C. W.

(1982). Epistemology and justifying the curriculum of educational studies. British Journal of Educational Studies, 30(2), 213–229.

26.

Walker

J. C.

, & Evers

C. W.

(in press). Towards a materialist pragmatist philosophy of education. Education Research and Perspectives.

27.

Walker

J. C.

, & Moran

(1983). Theory, practice and discipline: Problems and solutions. Radical Education Dossier, No. 20, pp. 20–23.

28.

Willis

P. E.

(1977). Learning to labour: How working class kids get working class jobs. Farnborough: Saxon House.

29.

Willis

P. E.

(1981). Cultural production is different from cultural reproduction is different from social reproduction is different from reproduction. Interchange, 12(2-3), 48–68.

30.

Willis

P. E.

(1983). Cultural production and theories of reproduction. In Barton

, & Walker

(Eds.), Race, class and education. London: Croom Helm.