Though some estimate that marijuana use has cost U.S. companies billions of dollars in lost productivity, the relationship between use of marijuana and job performance is far from clear. In this paper, I review studies on this topic from four different methodological perspectives and discuss models to account for their apparently contradictory findings. This discussion suggests hypotheses for future research addressing possible reasons for inconsistencies in past findings.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbelE.1970Marijuana and memory. Nature227:1151–1152.
2.
AbelE.1971Marijuana and memory: Acquisition or retrieval?Science173:1038–1040
3.
AgarwalA.SethiB.GuptaS.1975Physical and cognitive effects of chronic bhang (cannabis) intake. Indian Journal of Psychiatry17:1–17.
4.
AldrichM.1977Tantric cannabis use in India. Journal of Psychedelic Drugs9:227–233.
5.
BarnettG.LickV.ThompsonT.1985Behavioral pharmacokinetics of marijuana. Psychopharmacology85:51–56.
6.
BariteE.BeaverW.WhiteR.BlackenP.AdamsP.1972The effects of chronic use of marijuana on sleep and perceptual-motor performance in humans. In LewisM. (ed.) Current Research in Marijuana. New York: Academic Press.
7.
BechP.RafaelsenL.RafaelsonO.1973Cannabis and alcohol: Effects on estimation of time and distance. Psychopharmacologia32:373–381.
8.
BlankD.FentonJ.1989Early employment testing for marijuana: Demographic and employee retention patterns. In GustS.WalshM. (eds.) Drugs in the workplace: Research and evaluation data. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse: 139–150.
9.
BlockR.FarnhamS.BravermanK.NoyesR.GhoneimM.1990Long-term marijuana use and subsequent effects on learning and cognitive functions related to school achievement: A preliminary study. NIDA Research Monograph Series101:96–111.
10.
BlockR.GhoneimM.1993Effects of chronic marijuana use on human cognition. Psychopharmacology110:219–228.
11.
BompeyS.1988Drugs in the workplace: From the batter's box to the boardroom. In BompeyS. (ed.) Alcohol and Drug Abuse in the Workplace: The Complete Resource Guide. Washington, D.C.: Bureau of National Affairs.
12.
BowmanM.PihlR.1973Cannabis: Psychological effects of chronic heavy use. Psychopharmacologia29:159–170.
13.
BriefD.SilvertonL.SaccuzzoD.JanowskyD.1981Impaired speed of visual information processing in marijuana intoxication. American Journal of Psychiatry138:613–617.
14.
BrillN.ChristieR.1974Marijuana use and psychosocial adaptation. Archives of General Psychiatry31:713–719.
15.
BroadK.FeinbergB.1995Perceptions of ganja and cocaine in urban Jamaica. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs27:261–276.
16.
BrookoffD.CookC.WilliamsC.MannC.1994Testing reckless drivers for cocaine and marijuana. New England Journal of Medicine331:518–522.
17.
CarlinA.TrupinE.1977The effect of long-term chronic marijuana use on neuropsycho-logical functioning. International Journal of Addictions12:617–624.
18.
CarterW.1980Cannabis in Costa Rica. Philadelphia: ISHI Press.
19.
CasswellS.MarksD.1973aCannabis and temporal disintegration in experienced and naive subjects. Science179:803–805.
20.
CasswellS.MarksD.1973bCannabis-induced impairment of performance on a divided attention task. Nature241:60–61.
21.
CastilloR.1990Depersonalization and meditation. Psychiatry53:158–168.
22.
ChaitL.1990Subjective and behavioral effects of marijuana the morning after smoking. Psychopharmacology100:328–333.
23.
ChaitL.FischmanM.SchusterC.1985“Hangover” effects the morning after marijuana smoking. Drug and Alcohol Dependence15:229–238.
24.
ClarkL.HughesR.NakashimaE.1970Behavioral effects of marijuana. Archives of General Psychiatry23:193–198.
25.
CohenS.1976The 94-day cannabis study. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences282:211–220.
26.
CrancerA.DilleJ.DelayJ.WallaceJ.HaykinM.1969Comparison of the effects of marihuana and alcohol on simulated driving performance. Science164:851–854.
27.
CrouchD.WebbD.PetersonL.BullerP.RollinsD.1989A critical evaluation of the Utah Power and Light Company's substance abuse management program: Absenteeism, accidents, and costs. In GustS.WalshM. (eds.) Drugs in the workplace: Research and evaluation data. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
28.
CrowS.HartmanS.1992Drugs in the workplace: Overstating the problems and the cures. Journal of Drug Issues22:923–937.
29.
CulverC.KingF.1974Neuropsychological assessment of undergraduate marijuana and LSD users. Archives of General Psychiatry31:707–711.
30.
DarleyC.TinklenbergJ.RothW.VernonS.KopellB.1977Marijuana effects on long-term memory assessment and retrieval. Psychopharmacology52:239–241.
31.
DittrichA.BattigK.von ZepplinI.1973Effects of delta-9-transtetrahydrocannabinol on memory, attention, and subjective state. Psychopharmacologia33:369–376.
32.
DixonJ.1963The depersonalization phenomenon in a sample population of college students. British Journal of Psychiatry109:371–375.
33.
DoblinR.KleimanM.1995The medical use of marijuana: The case for clinical trials. Journal of Addictive Diseases14:5–14.
34.
DonovanJ.1996Problem-Behavior Theory and the explanation of adolescent marijuana use. Journal of Drug Issues26:379–404.
35.
DornbushR.ClareG.ZaksA.CrownP.VolavkaJ.FinkM.1972Twenty-one day administration of marijuana in male volunteers. In LewisM. (ed.), Current Research in Marijuana. New York: Academic Press.
36.
DreherM.1982Working Men and Ganja: Marijuana Use in Rural Jamaica. Philadelphia: ISHI Press.
37.
EntinE.GoldzungP.1973Residual effects of marijuana on learning and memory. Psychological Review23:169–178.
38.
EvansM.MartzR.BrownD.RoddaB.KiplingerG.LembergerL.ForneyR.1973Impairment of performance with low doses of marijuana. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics14:936–940.
39.
GianutsosR.LitwackA.1976Chronic marijuana smokers show reduced coding into long-term storage. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society7:277–279.
40.
GieringerD.1988Marijuana, driving, and accident safety. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs20:93–101.
41.
GrantI.RochfordJ.FlemingT.StunkardA.1973A neuropsychological assessment of the effects of moderate marijuana use. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorders156:278–280.
42.
GrinspoonL.BakalarJ.1993Marijuana: Forbidden Medicine. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
43.
GrinspoonL.BakalarJ.1995Marijuana as medicine: A plea for reconsideration. Journal of the American Medical Association274:1838.
44.
HalikasJ.WellerR.MorseC.HoffmanR.1983Regular marijuana use and its effect on psychosocial variables: A longitudinal study. Comprehensive Psychiatry24:229–235.
45.
HansteenR.MillerR.LoneroL.ReidL.JonesB.1976Effects of cannabis and alcohol on automobile driving and psychomotor tracking. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences282:240–256.
46.
HarrisM.1993Drugs in the workplace: Setting the record straight. Journal of Drug Issues23:727′–732.
47.
HarrisM.HeftL.1992Alcohol and drug use in the workplace: Issues, controversies, and directions for future research. Journal of Management18:239–266.
48.
HarrisonL.1995The validity of self-reported data on drug-use. Journal of Drug Issues25:91–111.
49.
HartmanS.CrowS.1993Drugs in the workplace: Setting Harris straight. Journal of Drug Issues23:733–738.
50.
HendinH.PollingerA.UlmanR.1981The function of marijuana abuse for adolescents. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse8:441–456.
51.
HollisterL.1986Health aspects of cannabis. Pharmacological Reviews38:1–18.
52.
HusainS.KahnI.1985An update on cannabis research. Bulletin of Narcotics37:3–15.
53.
JohnstonL.O'MalleyP.BachmanJ.1994National Survey Results on Drug Use from the Monitoring the Future Study (vol. 1 and 2). Rockville, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse. Publication # 94-3810.
54.
JonesR.BenowitzN.1976The 30-day trip—clinical studies of cannabis tolerance and dependence. In BraudeM.SzaraS. (eds.) The Pharmacology of Marijuana. New York: Raven Press.
55.
JonesR.StoneG.1970Psychological studies of marijuana and alcohol in man. Psychopharmacologia18:108–117.
56.
KaestnerR.1994aNew estimates of the effect of marijuana and cocaine on wages. Industrial and Labor Relations Review47:454–470.
57.
KaestnerR.1994bThe effect of illicit drug use on the labor supply of young adults. Journal of Human Resources24:126–155.
58.
KagelJ.BattalioR.MilesC.1980Marijuana and work performance: Results from an experiment. Journal of Human Resources15:373–395.
59.
KleimanM.1989Marijuana: Cost of Abuse, Costs of Control. New York: Greenwood Press.
60.
KlonoffH.1974Marijuana and driving in real-life situations. Science186:317–324.
61.
KupferD.1973A comment on the “amotivational syndrome” in marijuana smokers. American Journal of Psychiatry130:1319–1322.
62.
KvalsethT.1977Effects of marijuana on human reaction time and motor control. Perceptual and Motor Skills45:935–939.
63.
MacDonaldS.1995The role of drugs in workplace injuries: Is drug testing appropriate?Journal of Drug Issues25:723–734.
64.
MannoJ.KiplingerG.HaineS.BennettI.ForneyR.1970Comparative effects of smoking marijuana or placebo on human motor and mental performance. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics11:808–815.
65.
MannoJ.KiplingerG.ScholzN.ForneyR.HaineS.1971The influence of alcohol and marihuana on motor and mental performance. Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics12:202–212.
66.
MargolisR.PopkinN.1980Marijuana: A review of the medical research with implications for adolescents. Personnel and Guidance Journal59:7–14.
67.
MathewR.WilsonW.HumphreysD.LoweJ.WeithK.1993Marijuana use and cognitive functioning. Biological Psychiatry33:431–441.
68.
McBayA.OwensS.1981Marijuana and driving. In HarrisL. (ed.) Problems of Drug Dependence. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
69.
McDanielM.1988Does pre-employment drug use predict on-the-job suitability?Personnel Psychology41:717–729.
70.
McGlothlinW.WestL.1968The marijuana problem: An overview. American Journal of Psychiatry125:370–378.
71.
MelgesF.TinklenbergJ.HollisterL.GillespieH.1970aMarijuana and temporal disintegration. Science168:1118–1120.
72.
MelgesF.TinklenbergJ.HollisterL.GillespieH.1970bTemporal disintegration and depersonalization during marijuana intoxication. Archives of General Psychiatry23:204–210.
73.
MellingerG.SomersR.DavidsonS.ManheimerD.1976The amotivational syndrome and the college student. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences282:37–55.
74.
MellingerG.1978Drug use, academic performance, and career indecision. In CandelD. (ed.) Longitudinal Research on Drug Use: Empirical Findings and Methodological Issues. Washington, D.C.: Hemisphere Press.
75.
MendelsonJ.BabourT.KuehnleJ.RossiA.BernsteinJ.MelloN.GreenbergI., 1976aThe effects of marijuana use on human operant behavior: Individual data. In BraudeM.SzaraS. (eds.) Pharmacology of Marijuana, New York: Raven Press.
76.
MendelsonJ.BabourT.KuehnleJ.RossiA.BernsteinJ.MelloN.GreenbergI.1976bBehavioral and biological aspects of marijuana use. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences282:186–210.
77.
MendhirattaS.VarmaV.DangR.MalhotraA.DasK.NehraR., 1988Cannabis and cognitive functions: A re-evaluation study. British Journal of Addictions83:749–753.
78.
MendhirattaS.WigN.VarmaS.1978Some psychological correlates of long-term heavy cannabis users. British Journal of Psychiatry132:482–486.
79.
MeyerR.PillardR.ShapiroL.MirinS.1971Administration of marijuana to heavy and casual marijuana users. American Journal of Psychiatry128:198–203.
80.
MillerL.DrewW.KiplingerG.1972Effects of marijuana on recall of narrative material and Stroop Color-Word performance. Nature237:172–173.
81.
MiranneA.1979Marijuana use and achievement orientation of college students. Journal of Health and Social Behavior20:194–199.
82.
MorningstarP.1985Thandai and Chilam: Traditional Hindu beliefs about proper uses of cannabis. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs17:141–165.
83.
MoskowitzH.SheaR.BurnsM.1974Effects of marihuana on the psychological refractory period. Perceptual and Motor Skills38:959–962.
84.
MoskowitzH.ZeidmanK.SharmaS.1976Visual search behavior while viewing driving scenes under the influence of alcohol and marijuana. Human Factors18:417–432.
85.
MurrayJ.1986Marijuana's effects on human cognitive functions, psychomotor functions, and personality. Journal of General Psychology113:13–55.
86.
NahasG.1985Critique of a study on ganja in Jamaica. Bulletin on Narcotics37:15–30.
87.
NormandJ.SalyardsS.MahoneyJ.1990An evaluation of preemployment drug testing. Journal of Applied Psychology75:629–639.
88.
PageJ.1983The amotivational syndrome hypothesis and the Costa Rica study: Relationships between methods and results. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs15:261–267.
89.
PageJ.FletcherW.TrueW.1988Psychosociocultural perspectives on chronic cannabis use: The Costa Rican follow-up. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs20:57–65.
90.
ParkerE.BirnbaumI.WeingartnerH.HartleyJ.StillmanR.WyattR.1980Retrograde enhancement of human memory with alcohol. Psychopharmacology69:219–222.
91.
ParishD.1989Relation of pre-employment drug testing result to employment status: A one-year follow-up. Journal of General Internal Medicine4:44–47.
92.
PopeH.GruberA.Yurgelun-ToddD.1995The residual neuropsychological effects of cannabis: The current status of research. Drug and Alcohol Dependence38:25–34.
93.
RafaelsenO.BechP.ChristiansenH.ChristrupH.NyobeJ.RafaelsenL.1973Cannabis and alcohol: Effects on simulated car driving. Science179:920–923.
94.
ReedH.1974Cognitive effects of marijuana. In MendelsonJ.RossiA.MeyerR. (eds.) The Use of Marijuana: A Physiological and Psychological Inquiry. New York: Plenum Press.
RobbeH.O'HanlonJ.1993Marijuana and Actual Driving Performance. Washington, D.C.: Department of Transportation.
97.
RochfordJ.GrantI.LaVigneG.1977Medical students and drugs: Further neuropsychological and use pattern considerations. International Journal of Addictions12:1057–1065.
98.
RothW.TinklenbergJ.WhitakerC.DarleyC.KoppellB.HollisterL.1973The effect of marijuana on tracking task performance. Psychopharmacologia33:259–265.
99.
RubinV.ComitasL.1975Psychological assessment. In RubinV.ComitasL. (eds.) Ganga in Jamaica: A Medical Anthropological Study of Chronic Cannabis Use. Mouton, France: The Hague.
100.
SatzP.FletcherJ.SutkerL.1976Neuro-psychological, intellectual, and personality correlates of marijuana use in native Costa Ricans. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences282:266–306.
101.
SchwartzR.GruenwaldP.KlitznerM.FedioP.1989Short-term memory impairment in cannabis-dependent adolescents. American Journal of Disadvantaged Children143:1214–1219.
102.
SchwenkC.1982Why sacrifice rigor for relevance? A proposal for combining laboratory and field research in strategic management. Strategic Management Journal3:213–225.
103.
SchwenkC.1985The use of participant recollection in the modeling of organizational decision processes. Academy of Management Review10:496–503.
SethiB.TrivediJ.SinghH.1981Long-term effects of cannabis. Indian Journal of Psychiatry23:224–229.
106.
SolowijN.MichieP.FoxA.1991Effects of long-term cannabis use on selective attention: An event-related potential study. Pharmacology, Biochemistry, and Behavior40:683–688.
107.
StaffordP.1976Psychedelics Encyclopedia. Los Angeles: Tarcher.
108.
StefanisC.BoulougourisJ.LiakosA.1976Clinical and psychophysiological effects of cannabis in long-term users. In BraudeM.SzaraS. (eds.) The Pharmacology of Marijuana. New York: Raven Press.
109.
SussmanS.DentC.StacyA.1996The relationship of pro-drug use myths with self-reported drug use among youth at continuation high schools. Journal of Applied Psychology26:2014–2037.
110.
SussmanS.StacyA.DentC.SimonT.JohnsonC.1996Marijuana use: Current issues and new research directions. Journal of Drug Issues26:695–734.
111.
SwanN.1995Marijuana, other drug use among teens continues to rise. NIDA Notes: National Institute on Drug Abuse 10:8–9.
112.
TriceH.SteeleP.1995Impairment testing: Issues and convergence with employee assistance programs. Journal of Drug Issues25:471–503.
113.
TeheruneK.1994The Incidence and Role of Drugs in Fatally Injured Drivers. Washington, D.C.: Department of Transportation.
114.
UngerleiderJ.AndrysiakT.1985Therapeutic issues of marijuana and THC (Tetrahydrocannabinol). International Journal of Addictions20:691–699.
115.
VachonL.SulkowskiA.RichE.1974Marihuana effects on learning, attention, and time estimation. Psychopharmacologia39:1–11.
116.
VarmaV.MalhotraA.DangR.DasK.NehraR.1988Cannabis and cognitive functions: A prospective study. Drug and Alcohol Dependence21:147–152.
117.
WeckowiczT.CollierG.SprengL.1977Field dependence, cognitive functions, personality traits, and social values in heavy cannabis users and non-user controls. Psychological Reports41:291–302.
118.
WhiteH.1991Marijuana use and delinquency: A test of the “independent cause” hypothesis. Journal of Drug Issues21:231–256.
119.
WigN.VarmaV.1977Patterns of long-term heavy cannabis use in North India and its effects on cognitive functions: A preliminary report. Drug and Alcohol Dependence2:211–219.
120.
WilsonW.EllinwoodE.MathewR.JohnsonK.1994Effects of marijuana on performance of computerized cognitive-neuromotor test battery. Psychiatry Research51:115–125.
121.
WishE.1990Preemployment drug screening. Journal of the American Medical Association264:2676–2677.
ZwerlingC.RyanJ.OravE.1990The efficacy of preemployment drug screening for marijuana and cocaine in predicting employment outcomes. Journal of the American Medical Association264:2639–2643.
