In order to understand the nature and intensity of the debate over the reform of “drug” legislation, it is necessary to appreciate the aesthetic forces which influence attitudes to this question, and the symbolic meaning which is attached to the imagery of drugs. The “war on drugs” is a war about emotional imagery and contested symbols, and in particular about the idea of the boundary—a matter crucial to the metaphysics and social organization of Western society. At the same time, it will be argued, it is the failure to recognize that we are dealing with the symbolic realm which bedevils both drug users and legislative policy. The reification of symbols causes and perpetuates the very problems that are intended to be solved. In their fetishization of the objects of drug use, the law and the addict are far more alike than one might think.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AgarM.1973Ripping and running: A formal ethnography of urban heroin addicts. New York:Seminar Press.
2.
BairdR.RosenbaumS.1989Pornography: Private right or public menace?Buffalo:Prometheus Books.
3.
BalkinJ. M.1990Tradition, betrayal, and the politics of deconstruction. Cardozo Law Review11:1613–1630.
4.
BattjesR. J.PickensR. W.1988Needle sharing among intravenous drug abusers: National and international perspectives. Rockville, Md.:U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
5.
BeckerE.1973The denial of death. New York:Free Press.
6.
BerridgeV.1978War conditions and narcotics control: The passing of the Defense of the Realm Act Regulation 40B. Journal of Social Policy7:285.
7.
BerridgeV.EdwardsG.1981Opium and the people. London:St Martin's Press.
8.
BoydN.1984The origin of Canadian narcotics legislation. Dalhousie Law Journal8:102.
9.
CorbinA.1986The foul and the fragrant: Odor and the French social imagination. Cambridge, Mass.:Harvard University Press.
10.
Davenport-HinesR.1990Sex, death and punishment. London:Collins.
11.
Des JarlaisD.FriedmanS.StrugD, 1986AIDS and needle-sharing within the IV-drug use subculture. In The social dimensions of AIDS, eds. FeldmanD.JohnsonT., New York:Praeger.
12.
DouglasM.1966Purity and danger. London:Routledge and Kegan Paul.
13.
DworkinA.1987Intercourse. New York:Free Press.
14.
FeldmanH.BiernackiP.1988The ethnography of needle sharing among intravenous drug users and implications for public policies and intervention strategies. In Needle sharing among intravenous drug abusers: National and international perspectives, eds. BattjesR.J.PickensR.W., Rockville, Md.:U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
15.
FoucaultM.1986The use of pleasure, The history of sexualityvol. 2, trans. HurleyR., New York: Vintage Books.
16.
FurstP. T.1976Hallucinogens and culture. San Fransisco:Chandler & Sharp.
17.
GeyS.1990This is not a flag: The aesthetics of desecration. Wisconsin Law Review1990:1549.
18.
GiffenP. J.EndicottS.LambertS.1991Panic and indifference: The politics of Canada's drug laws, a study in the sociology of law. Ottawa:Canadian Centre on Substance Abuse.
19.
GracykT.1987Pornography as representation: Aesthetic representations. Journal of Aesthetics and Education21:103.
20.
GreenM.1979A history of Canadian narcotics control: The formative years. University of Toronto Faculty Law Review37:42.
21.
HelmerJ.1975Drugs and minority oppression. New York:Seabury Press.
22.
HimmelsteinJ.1978Drug politics theory. Journal of Drug Issues8:37.
23.
HowardJ.BorgesP.1972Needle sharing in the Haight: Some social and psychological functions. In It's so good don't even try it once, eds. SmithD.E.GayG., Englewood Cliffs, N.J.:Prentice-Hall.
24.
HowesD.1989Odor in the court. border/lines winter28–90.
25.
HowesD.1991The varieties of sensory experience: A sourcebook in the anthropology of the senses. Toronto:Toronto University Press.
26.
KaplanJ.1983The hardest drug—Heroin and social policy. Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
27.
KingR.1978The drug problem and the idioms of war. Journal of Drug Issues8:221–231.
28.
KlinanbergE.LewisD.1994Rethinking drug discourse. Paper presented to 5th International Harm Reduction Conference. March 7. Toronto.
29.
LyotardJ.-F.1993Libidinal economy, trans. HaIainTmilton Grant. Bloomington:Indiana University Press.
30.
MacIntyreA.1988Whose justice? Which rationality. Notre Dame, Ind.:University of Notre Dame Press.
31.
MandersonD.1988The first loss of freedom: Early opium laws in Australia. Australian Drug and Alcohol Review7:439.
32.
MandersonD.1992Trends and influences in the history of Australian drug legislation. Journal of Drug Issues22:507.
33.
MandersonD.1993From Mr Sin to Mr Big: A history of Australian drug laws. Melbourne:Oxford University Press.
34.
MandersonD.1995Disease, defilement, depravity—Towards an aesthetic analysis of health. In Minorities, Migrants, and Medicine, eds. MarksL.WarboysM., London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
35.
MillerJ.1993The passion of Michel Foucault. New York:Simon and Schuster.
36.
MillerJ.H.1990Versions of Pygmalion. Cambridge, Mass.:Harvard University Press.
37.
MurphyS. B.1987Intravenous drug use and AIDS: Notes on the social economy of needle sharing. Contemporary Drug Problems14:373.
38.
MustoD.1973The American disease. New Haven:Yale University Press.
39.
NietzscheF.1967The birth of tragedy/the case of Wagner, trans. KaufmannW., New York:Vintage Books.
40.
NietzscheF.1989On the genealogy of morals and ecce homo, trans. KaufmannW., New York:Vintage Books.
41.
PageJ. B.SmithP. C.1990Venous envy: The importance of having functional veins. Journal of Drug Issues20:291.
42.
PascalC.1988Intravenous drug abuse and AIDS transmission: Federal and state laws regulating needle availability. In Needle sharing among intravenous drug abusers: National and international perspectives, eds. BattjesR.J.PickensR.W., Rockville, Md.:U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
43.
PeeleS.1985The meaning of addiction. Lexington, Mass.:Lexington Books.
44.
PrebleE.CaseyJ.1969Taking care of business—The heroin user's life on the streets. International Journal of the Addictions4:1.
45.
SamekR.1981The meta-phenomenon. New York:The Philosophical Library.
46.
ScarryE.1985The body in pain: The making and unmaking of the world. New York:Oxford University Press.
47.
SolomonR.MadisonT.1976The evolution of non-medical opiate use in Canada—Part 1 1870–1929.
48.
-77 Drug Forum5(3):237–265.
49.
SteinerG.1992After Babel: Aspects of language and translation. Oxford:Oxford University Press.
50.
TaylorA.1993Women drug users: An ethnography of a female injecting community. Oxford:Oxford University Press.
51.
WaldorfD.MurphyS.LaudersonD.ReinarmanC.MarottaT.1990Needle sharing among male prostitutes. Journal of Drug Issues20:309.
