A 1989 newspaper story describing twenty-nine cocaine-related deaths in British Columbia is used to illustrate the lands of unwarranted inferences that are propagated by the news media during the current War on Drugs. The newspaper story conveys the impression that most of the deaths involved well-integrated, moderate drug users, that all twenty-nine deaths were caused by cocaine, and that these deaths provided evidence of an epidemic of dangerous cocaine use sweeping the province. However, the coroner's files on which the story was based, and related research, provide strong evidence that all three frightening inferences are wrong. A more careful analysis of these deaths as a consequence of chronic deterioration in a fringe population can contribute to the development of realistic drug policy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlexanderB.K.1990Peaceful Measures: Canada's Way Out of the War on Drugs. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
2.
AlexanderB.K.MacInnesT.M.BeyersteinB.L.1988Methadone and Addict Mortality. British Columbia Medical Journal30:160–163.
3.
AmbreJ.RuoT.I.NelsonJ.BelknapS.1988Urinary Excretion of Cocaine, Benzoylecgonine and Ecgonine Methyl Ester in Humans. Journal of Analytical Toxicology12:301–306.
4.
BarnettG.HawksR.ResnickR.1981Cocaine Pharmacokinetics in Humans. Journal of Ethnopharmacology3:353–366.
5.
BasaltR.C.1983Stability of Cocaine in Biological Fluids. Journal of Chromatography268:502–505.
6.
BatesC.K.1988Medical Risks of Cocaine Use. Western Journal of Medicine148:440–444.
7.
CaveW.1989Personal Communication. August 17.
8.
CohenP.D.A. In press Cocaine Use in Amsterdam in Nondeviant Subcultures. Amsterdam: University of Amsterdam.
9.
ComstockE.G.1977Treatment for survival prior to death and interpretation of postmortem toxicologic findings. In Guide to the investigation and reporting of drug abuse deaths, GottschalkL.A.McGuireS.L.DinovoE.C.BirchH.HeiserJ.F. (ed.). Rockville, Maryland: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
10.
Coordinated Law Enforcement Unit1987Cocaine: Demand Reduction Strategies. Final Report. Victoria, B.C.: Ministry of the Attorney General.
11.
DevenviP.McDonoughM.A.1988Cocaine Abuse and Endocarditis. Annals of Internal Medicine109:82.
12.
EricksonP.G.AdlafE.M.MurrayG.F.SmartR.G.1987The Steel Drug: Cocaine in Perspective. Lexington, Massachusetts: D.C. Heath.
13.
EricksonP.G.AlexanderB.K.1989Cocaine and Addictive Liability. Social Pharmacology3:249–270.
14.
FeehanH.F.Mancusi-UngaroA.1976The Use of Cocaine as a Topical Anesthetic in Nasal Surgery: A Survey Report. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery57:62–65.
15.
FinkleB.S.McCloskeyK.L.1978The Forensic Toxicology of Cocaine (1971–1976). Journal of Forensic Sciences23:173–189.
16.
FischmanM.W.SchusterC.R.1980Experimental investigations of the actions of cocaine in humans. In Cocaine 1980, JeriF.R. (ed.). Lima, Peru: Pacific Press.
17.
GarberM.W.FlahertyD.1987Cocaine and sudden death. American Family Physician36:227–230.
18.
GolbeL.I.MerkinM.D.1986Cerebral infarction in a user of free-base cocaine (crack). Neurology36:1602–1604.
19.
GordenB.R.1987Topical cocaine nasal anesthesia. Archives of Otolaryngology — Head and Neck Surgery113:211.
20.
GottschalkL.A.McGuireS.L.HeiserJ.F.DinovoE.C.BirchH.1979Drug Abuse Deaths in Nine Cities: A Survey Report. NIDA Research Monographs 29. Rockville, Maryland: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
21.
HaddadL.M.1983Cocaine. In Clinical Management of Poisoning and Drug Overdose, HaddadL.M.WinchesterJ.F. (eds.). Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders.
22.
HainesJ.D.SexterS.1987Acute myocardial infarction associated with cocaine abuse. Southern Medical Journal80:1326–1327.
23.
HallerP.R.1988Infections in Intravenous Drug Abusers. Postgraduate Medicine83:95–114.
24.
HelpernM.1977Certification of death from narcotism and other psychoactive drugs of abuse. In Guide to the investigation and reporting of drug-abuse deaths, GottschalkL.A.McGuireS.L.DinovoE.C.BirchH.HeiserJ.F. (eds.). Rockville, Maryland: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
25.
IngoldF.R.1986Study of Deaths Related to Drug Abuse in France and Europe. Bulletin on Narcotics38:81–89.
26.
JatlowP.1987Drug of Abuse Profile: Cocaine. Clinical Chemistry33:66B–72B.
27.
JatlowP.1988Cocaine: Analysis, Pharmacokinetics, and Metabolic Disposition. Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine61:105–113.
28.
JavaidJ.I.FischmanM.W.SchusterC.R.DekirmenjianH.DavisJ.M.1978Cocaine Plasma Concentration: Relation to Physiological and Subjective Effects in Humans. Science202:227–228.
29.
KayeB.R.FainstatM.1987Cerebral basculitis associated with cocaine abuse. Journal of the American Medical Association258:2104–2106.
30.
KostenT.R.KleberH.D.1988Rapid Death During Cocaine Abuse: A Variant of the Neuroleptic Malignant Syndrome?American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse14:335–346.
31.
LeonJ.S.1978Methodology and Law: Problems Associated with coroner's Data on Alcohol and Drug Related Deaths. Legal Medical Quarterly2:29–32.
32.
LiuY.BuddR.D.GriesemerE.C.1982Study of the Stability of Cocaine and Benzoylecgonine, its Major Metabolite, in Blood Samples. Journal of Chromatography248:318–320.
33.
LowensteinD.H.MassaS.M.RowbothamM.C.CollinsS.D.McKinneyH.E.SimonR.P.1987Acute neurological and psychiatric complications associated with cocaine abuse. American Journal of Medicine83:841–846.
MittlemanR.E.WetliC.V.1987Cocaine and Sudden “Natural” Death. Journal of Forensic Sciences32:11–19.
36.
ModyC.K.MillerH.B.McIntyreS.K.CobbS.K.GoldbergM.A.1988Neurological complications of cocaine use. Neurology38:1189–1193.
37.
MooreG.F.EmanuelJ.M.OgrenT.P.YonkersA.J.1986Cocaine: Current Clinical Use and Potential Abuse. Nebraska Medical Journal71:317–321.
38.
MugfordS.CohenP.1989Drug Use, Social Relations, and Commodity Consumption: A Study of Recreational Cocaine Users in Sydney, Canberra and Melbourne. A Report to the Research into Drug Abuse Advisory Committee, National Campaign Against Drug Abuse. Department of Sociology, Australian National University.
39.
NoguchiT.T.1977Postmortem examination. In Guide to the investigation and reporting of drug-abuse deaths, GottschalkL.A.McGuireS.L.DinovoE.C.BirchH.HeiserJ.F. (eds.). Rockville, Maryland: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
40.
PalyD.JatlowP.Van DykeC.JeriF.R.ByckR.1978Plasma cocaine concentrations During Cocaine Paste Smoking. Life Sciences30:731–738.
41.
SmartR.G.AnglinL.1987Do We Know the Lethal Dose of Cocaine?Journal of Forensic Sciences32:303–312.
42.
SternbergR.G.WinnifordM.D.HillisL.D.DowlingG.P.BujuL.M.1989Simultaneous acute thrombosis of two major coronary arteries following intravenous cocaine use. Archives of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine113:521–524.
43.
TuchmanA.J.DarasM.ZalzalP.MangiardiJ.1987Intracranial hemorrhage after cocaine abuse. Journal of the American Medical Association257:1175.
44.
Van DykeC.JatlowP.UngererJ.BarashP.G.ByckR.1978Oral Cocaine: Plasma Concentrations and Central Effects. Science200:211–213.
45.
WeissR.D.GawinF.H.1988Protracted elimination of cocaine metabolites in long-term high-dose cocaine abusers. American Journal of Medicine85:879–880.
46.
WetliC.V.FishbainD.A.1985Cocaine-induced Psychosis and Sudden Death in Recreational Cocaine Users. Journal of Forensic Sciences30:873–380.
47.
WinekC.L.1985Drug and Chemical Blood-Level Data 1985. Pittsburgh: Fisher Scientific.
48.
WojackJ.D.FlammE.S.1987Intracranial hemorrhage and cocaine use. Stroke18:712–715.
