Self-reports continue to be the most widely used method of data gathering in adolescent substance misuse surveys. This paper addresses the issue of validity and reliability of the data gathered using this method. The sources of error are discussed and the process of validating responses are illustrated using data obtained through our survey. Some suggestions are made to improve the validity of responses both in the planning and in the execution phases of surveys.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AblesonH.FishburneP.CisinI.1977The National Survey on Drug Abuse: 1977. Washington, D.C.: NIDA.
2.
AbramsL.GarfieldE.SwisherJ.1973Accountability in Drug Education. Washington, D.C.: The Drug Abuse Council.
3.
AlwinD.1977Making errors in surveys: An overview. Sociological Methods and Research, 6:131–150.
4.
BachmanJ.O'MalleyP.JohnstonL.1979Developing composite measures of drug use: Comparisons among lifetime, Annual and Monthly prevalence reports for thirteen classes of drugs: Monitoring the Future, Ann Arbor, Michigan: Institute for Social Research.
5.
BachmanJ.O'MalleyP.JohnstonL.1980Correlates of drug use. Part I: Selected Measures of Background, recent experiences, and lifestyle orientations. Monitoring the Future paper 8. Ann Arbor, Michigan: Institute for Social Research.
6.
BallJ.1967The reliability and validity of interview data obtained from 59 narcotic drug addicts. The American Journal of Sociology, 76:650–654.
7.
BarneaZ.RahavG.TeichmanM.1987The reliability and consistency of self-reports on substance use in a longitudinal study, British Journal of Addiction, 82:891–898.
8.
BerkowitzA.1974Draft final report on cost-effectiveness of urine testingWashington, D.C.: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
9.
BonitoA.NurcoD.ShafferJ.1976The veridicality of addicts' self-reports in social research, International Journal of the Addictions, 11:719–724.
10.
BradburnN.1979Improving Interview Methods and Questionnaire Design. Washington, D.C.: Jossey-Bass.
11.
CannellC.FowlerF.1963Comparison of Self-enumerative procedure and a personal interview. A validity test, Public Opinion Questions, 27:250–264.
12.
EdwardsA.1957The Social Desirability Variable in Personality Assessment and Research, New York: Dryden.
13.
FarringtonD.1980Truancy, delinquency, the home and the school. In HersovL.BergI. (eds.), Out of School: 49–64. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
14.
GfroererJ.1985Influence of privacy on self-reported drug use by youth. In RouseB.KozelN.RichardsL. (eds.), Self-report Methods of Estimating Drug use, NIDA Research Monograph Series No. 57, Washington, D.C.: DHHS.
15.
GoodstadtCookM. G.GrusonV.1978The validity of reported drug use: The randomized response technique. International Journal of the Addictions, 13:359–367.
16.
HabermanP.JosephsonE.ZanesA.ElinsonJ.1972High school drug behavior: A methodological report on pilot studies. In EinsteinS.AllenS. (eds.), Proceedings of the First International Conference on Student Drug Surveys, New York, Baywood.
17.
HarrellA.1985Validation of Self-Report: The research record. In RouseB.KozelN.RichardsL. (eds.) Self-report Methods of Estimating Drug Use, NIDA Research Monograph Series No. 57, Washington, D.C.: DHHS.
18.
HawkerA.1978Adolescents and Alcohol, London: Edsall.
19.
HochhauserM.1979Bias in drug use survey research, International Journal of the Addictions, 14:675–687.
20.
HolmbergM.1985Longitudinal Studies of drug abuse in a fifteen-year-old population: 3. Hidden Drug abuse. Acta Psychiatrica Scandanavica, 71:197–200.
JessorR.JessorS.1977Problem behavior and Psychosocial Development: A Longitudinal Study of Youth. New York: Academic Press.
23.
JohnstonL.1980General Population Surveys of Drug Abuse: A Review and Guide for Planners. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO.
24.
JohnstonL.1985Techniques for Reducing Measurement Error in Surveys of Drug Use. In RobinsL. (ed.), Studying Drug Abuse, New Jersey: Rutgers University Press.
25.
JohnstonL.BachmanJ.O'MalleyP.1982Student Drug use, Attitudes and Beliefs: National Trends1975–1982, Washington, D.C.: NIDA.
26.
JohnstonL.O'MalleyP.1985Issues of validity and population coverage in students surveys of drug use. In RouseB.KozelN.RichardsL. (eds.) Self-report Methods of Estimating Drug Use, NIDA Research Monograph Series No. 57, Washington, D.C.: DHHS.
27.
JosephsonE.RosenM.1978Panel loss in a high school drug study. In KandelD. (ed.) Longitudinal Research on Drug Use: Empirical Findings and Methodological Issues, Washington, D.C.: Hemisphere.
28.
JourardS.1971Self-disclosure: An Experimental Analysis of the Transparent Self, New York: Wiley.
29.
KandelD.1973Adolescent marihuana use: Role of Parents and Peers. Science, 181:1067–1070.
30.
KandelD.1974Inter- and Intra-generational influences on adolescent marihuana use, Journal of Social Issues, 30:107–135.
31.
KandelD.1975Reaching the hard-to-reach: Illicit drug use among high school absentees, Addictive Disease, 1:465–480.
32.
KingG.1970Anonymous vs. Identifiable questionnaires in drug usage surveys, American Psychologist, 25:982–985.
33.
KishL.1965Survey Sampling, New York: Wiley.
34.
MalcolmS.ShephardR.1984Difficult temperament and drug use: Analysis from the New York Longitudinal Study, Journal of Drug Education, 14:1–7.
35.
NurcoD.1985A Discussion of Validity In RouseB.KozelN.RichardsL. (eds.), Self-report methods of estimating drug use, NID A Research Monograph Series No. 57, Washington, D.C.: DHHS.
36.
Office of Population Censuses and Surveys1985Smoking among Secondary School Children, London: HMSO.
37.
Office of Population Censuses and Surveys1986Adolescent Drinking, London: HMSO.
38.
ParryH.CrossleyH.1950Validity of response in survey questions, Public Opinion Questions, 14:61–80.
39.
PetzelT.JohnsonJ.McKillipJ.1973Response bias in drug surveys, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 40:437–439.
40.
PhillipsD.ClanceyK.1970Response bias in field studies of mental illness, American Sociology Review, 35:503–515.
41.
PlantM.PeckD.SamuelE.1985Alcohol, Drugs and School Leavers, London: Tavistock.
42.
RadosevichM.Lanza-KaduceL.AkersR.KrohnA.1979The sociology of adolescent drug and drinking behavior: A review of the state of the field: Part I, Development and Behavior, 1:15–35.
43.
RobinsL.1974The Vietnam Drug User Returns, Special Action Monograph for Drug Abuse Prevention, Series A, No. 2. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
44.
SingleE.KandelD.JohnsonB.1975The reliability and validity of drug use response in a large-scale longitudinal survey, Journal of Drug Issues, 5:426–443.
45.
SwadiH.1987Methodological Problems in Adolescent Substance Abuse Research, paper presented at the November meeting of the Child Psychiatry Research Society, London.
46.
SwadiH.1988Substance use among 3,333 London Adolescents. British Journal of Addiction.
47.
WhiteheadP.SmartR.1972Validity and reliability of self-reported drug use. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Corrections, 14:1–8.
48.
ZeitlinH.SwadiH.1987Teachers, Pupils and Adolescent Substance Abuse: A Pilot Study. Pastoral Care in Education, 5:192–200.
49.
ZuckermanB.HingsonR.MorelockS.1985A pilot study assessing maternal marijuana use by urine assay during pregnancy. In RouseB.KozelN.RichardsL. (eds.), Self-report Methods of Estimating Drug Use, NIDA Research Monograph No. 57, Washington, D.C.: DHHS.
