The relationship of a positive urine test at arrest to recidivism has been a subject of great debate. Some have suggested that a self-report based measure of intensity of drug use would be a better predictor of recidivism than urinalysis results. We use self-report and urinalysis-based measures of drug use among arrestees in Washington, D.C., to examine the relationship between drug use at arrest and recidivism. We conclude that self-report measures of intensity of drug use are not significantly related to rearrest. A positive urine test result for cocaine is the only measure of drug use that is significantly related to rearrest. Implications for pretrial testing programs are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BishopY.M.FienbergS.E.HollandP.W.1975Discrete Multivariate Analysis: Theory and Practice. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
2.
CarverJ.A.1986Drugs and Crime: Controlling Use and Reducing Risk Through Testing. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
3.
DeJongC.1997Survival analysis and specific deterrence: Integrating theoretical and empirical models of recidivism. Criminology35(4):561–575.
4.
EliasonS.R.1992Maximum Likelihood Estimation: Logic and Practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
5.
GoldkampJ.S.GottfredsonM.R.WeilandD.1990Pretrial drug testing and defendant risk. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology81:585–652.
6.
GolubA.L.JohnsonB.D.1997Crack's decline: Some surprises across U.S. cities. National Institute of Justice Research in Brief.
7.
GossopM.GriffithsP.PowisP.StrangJ.1994Cocaine: Patterns of use, route of administration and severity of dependence. British Journal of Psychiatry164:660–664.
8.
HosmerD.W.LemeshowS.1989Applied Logistic Regression. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
9.
MieczkowskiT.1990The accuracy of self-reported drug use: An evaluation and analysis of new data. In Drugs, Crime and the Criminal Justice System, ed. WeisheitR., 275–302. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson.
10.
RhodesW.HyattR.ScheimanP.1996Predicting pretrial misconduct with drug tests of arrestees: Evidence from eight settings. Journal of Quantitative Criminology12: 315–48.
11.
RosenfeldR.DeckerS.1993Discrepant values, correlated measures: Cross-city and longitudinal comparisons of self-reports and urine tests of cocaine use among arrestees. Journal of Criminal Justice21: 223–230.
12.
SmithD.A.PolsenbergC.1992Specifying the relationship between arrestee drug test result and recidivism. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology83:364–77.
13.
WishE.D.CuadradoM.MaguraS.1986Drug abuse as a predictor of pretrial failure-to-appear in arrestees in Manhattan. Unpublished report, Narcotic and Drug Research, Inc.
14.
WishE.D.HoffmanJ.A.NemesS.1997The validity of self-reports of drug use at treatment admission and at follow-up: Comparisons with urinalysis and hair assay. In The Validity of Self-Reported Drug Use: Improving the Accuracy of Survey Estimates, ed. HarrisonL.HughesA., 200–226. Washington, DC: National Institutes of Health.
