Indentation Creep Behavior of a Direct-filling Silver Alternative to Amalgam

Abstract

Amalgam creep has been identified as a key parameter associated with marginal breakdown and corrosion. The aim of this study was to evaluate the time-dependent deformation (creep) of a novel silver filling material as an alternative to amalgam. We made the silver specimens by pressing a precipitated powder at room temperature to a density that can be achieved in clinical hand consolidation. The surface of the silver was either polished or burnished. To examine local contact creep and the effect of surface finishing, we used an indentation creep method in which a Vickers indenter was loaded on the specimen surface at a load of 10 N with dwell times of 5 sec to 6 x 104 sec. We used a bonded-interface technique to examine subsurface creep mechanisms. The flexural strength (mean ± SD; n = 10) was 86 ± 20 MPa for amalgam, 180 ± 21 MPa for polished silver, and 209 ± 19 MPa for burnished silver-values which are significantly different from each other (family confidence coefficient = 0.95; Tukey's multiple-comparison test). Indentation creep manifested as hardness number decreasing with increased dwell time. With dwell time increasing from 5 sec to 6 x 104 sec, the hardness number of amalgam was reduced by approximately 80%; that of the polished silver and the burnished silver was reduced by only 40%. Subsurface creep in amalgam consisted of the shape change of the alloy particles from spherical to elongated shapes, and the separation of matrix grains from each other, possibly due to grain-boundary sliding. Creep of the polished silver occurred by densification reducing porosity and increasing hardness; that of the burnished silver occurred by the displacement of the burnished layer. These results suggest that, due to creep-induced subsurface work-hardening and densification, the consolidated silver exhibits a higher resistance to indentation creep than does amalgam. The hardness number of silver approaches that of amalgam after prolonged indentation loading.

Keywords

amalgam creep mechanism hardening indentation silver subsurface deformation.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Society for Testing and Materials ( 1984). ASTM F417-78 : Standard test method for flexural strength of electrical grade ceramics. Philadelphia, PA: ASTM.

American Society for Testing and Materials ( 1991). ASTM E384: Standard test method for microhardness of materials. Philadelphia, PA: ASTM .

Anusavice KJ (1996). Challenges to the development of esthetic alternatives to dental amalgam in an academic research center. Acad Dent Mater Trans 9:25-50.

Anusavice KJ , Zhang NZ , Moorhead JE (1994). Influence of colorants on crystallization and mechanical properties of lithia-based glass-ceramics. Dent Mater 10:141-146.

Averette DF , Marek M. (1983). The effect of tensile strain on corrosion of dental amalgam. J Dent Res 62:842-845.

Bayne SC , Heymann HO , Swift EJ Jr (1994). Update on dental composite restorations. J Am Dent Assoc 125:1166-1168.

Bowen RL (1962). Dental filling materials comprising vinylsilane treated fused silica and a binder consisting of the reaction product of bis-phenol and glycidyl acrylate. US Patent No. 3,066,112.

Carter GM , Henshall JL , Hooper RM (1988). Indentation creep in single-crystal cubic zirconia at room temperature. J Am Ceram Soc 71:C270.

Dariel MP , Admon U. , Lashmore DS , Ratzker M. , Giuseppetti A. , Eichmiller FC (1995). A silver alternative to dental amalgam. J Mater Res 10:505-511.

10.

Espevik S. (1977). Creep and phase transformation in dental amalgam . J Dent Res 56:36-39.

11.

Fairbanks CJ , Polvani RS , Wiederhorn SM , Hockey BJ , Lawn BR ( 1982). Rate effects in hardness. J Mater Sci Lett 1:391-393.

12.

Ferracane JL (1989). Indentation fracture toughness testing and crack propagation mode in dental composites. Mater Res Soc Symp Proc 110:619-624.

13.

Ferracane JL (1992). Using posterior composites appropriately. J Am Dent Assoc 123:53-58.

14.

Gale EN , Osborne JW , Winchell PG (1982). Fracture at the margins of amalgam as predicted by creep, zinc content, and gamma-2 content. J Dent Res 61:678-680.

15.

Gjerdet NR , Espevik S. (1978). Corrosion and creep of dental amalgam. J Dent Res 57:21-26.

16.

Hassan R. , Caputo AA , Bunshah RF (1981). Fracture toughness of human enamel. J Dent Res 60:820-827.

17.

Hero H. ( 1983). On creep mechanisms in amalgam. J Dent Res 62:44-50.

18.

Hoard RJ , Eichmiller FC (1998). Edge-bevel fracture resistance of direct filling materials. Dent Mater (in review).

19.

Jordan RE , Suzuki M. , Mills AR (1978). Marginal integrity of amalgam alloys in relation to creep: a preliminary report. J Prosthet Dent 40:299-303.

20.

Kollenberg W. (1988). Anisotropy of indentation creep in sapphire at 500 and 750°C. J Mater Sci Lett 7:1076-1077.

21.

Lashmore DS , Dariel MP , Johnson CE , Ratzker M. , Giuseppetti A. , Eichmiller FC , et al. (1994). Acid assisted cold welding and intermetallic formation and dental application thereof. US Patent application 8,317,719.

22.

Leinfelder KF (1994). After amalgam, what? Other materials fall short . J Am Dent Assoc 125:586-589.

23.

Li WB , Henshall JL , Hooper RM , Easterling KE (1991). The mechanisms of indentation creep. Acta Metall Mater 39:3099-3110.

24.

Mahler DB , Adey JD , Marantz RL (1977). Creep versus microstructure of γ2-containing amalgams. J Dent Res 56:1493-1499.

25.

Mahler DB , Adey JD , Marek M. (1982). Creep and corrosion of amalgam. J Dent Res 61:33-35.

26.

Mair LH ( 1994). Subsurface compression fatigue in seven dental composites . Dent Mater 10:111-115.

27.

Marshall GW , Jackson BL , Marshall SJ (1980). Copper-rich and conventional amalgam restorations after clinical use. J Am Dent Assoc 100:43-47.

28.

McCabe JF , Carrick TE (1987). Dynamic creep of dental amalgam as a function of stress and number of applied stress cycles. J Dent Res 66:1346-1349.

29.

Okabe T. , Mitchell RJ , Butts MB , Galloway SS , Twiggs WS (1985). Change in creep rate and microstructure in an aged, low-copper amalgam. J Biomed Mater Res 19:727-746.

30.

Osborne JW , Leinfelder KF , Gale EN , Sluder TB (1980). Two independent evaluations of ten amalgam alloys . J Prosthet Dent 43:622-626.

31.

Oshida Y. , Moore BK (1993). Anodic polarization behavior and microstructure of a gallium-based alloy. Dent Mater 9 :234-241.

32.

Papadogiannis Y. , Boyer DB , Lakes RS (1987). Creep of amalgam at low stresses. J Dent Res 66:1569-1575.

33.

Peterson IM , Pajares A. , Lawn BR , Thompson VP , Rekow ED (1998). Mechanical characterization of dental ceramics: a study using Hertzian contacts. J Dent Res 77:589-602.

34.

Port RM , Marshall GW Jr (1985). Characteristics of amalgam restorations with variable clinical appearance. J Am Dent Assoc 110:491-495.

35.

Van Meerbeek B. , Willems G. , Celis JP , Roos JR , Braem M. , Lambrechts P. , et al. (1993). Assessment by nanoindentation of the hardness and elasticity of the resin-dentin bonding area. J Dent Res 72:1434-1442.

36.

Wassell RW , McCabe JF , Walls AW (1992). Subsurface deformation associated with hardness measurements of composites. Dent Mater 8:218-223.

37.

Watkins JH , Nakajima H. , Hanaoka K. , Zhao L. , Iwamoto T. , Okabe T. (1995). Effect of zinc on strength and fatigue resistance of amalgam. Dent Mater 11:24-33.

38.

White SN (1993). Mechanical fatigue of a feldspathic dental porcelain . Dent Mater 9:260-264.

39.

Williams PT , Cahoon JR (1989). Amalgam margin breakdown caused by creep fatigue rupture. J Dent Res 68:1188-1193.

40.

Wilson AD , McLean JW (1988). Glass-ionomer cement. Chicago : Quintessence.

41.

Xu Hhk , Kelly JR , Jahanmir S. , Thompson VP , Rekow ED (1997). Enamel subsurface damage due to tooth preparation with diamonds. J Dent Res 76:1698-1706.

42.

Xu Hhk , Smith DT , Jahanmir S. , Romberg E. , Kelly JR , Thompson VP , et al. (1998a). Indentation damage and mechanical pro-perties of human enamel and dentin. J Dent Res 77:472-480.

43.

Xu Hhk , Eichmiller FC , Giuseppetti AA , Johnson CE (1998b). Cyclic contact fatigue of a silver alternative to amalgam. Dent Mater (accepted for publication).

44.

Xu Hhk , Giuseppetti AA , Eichmiller FC , Ives LK ( 1998c). Two-body sliding wear of a silver alternative to amalgam . Quintessence Int (accepted for publication).