The Association Between Water-borne Fluoride and Bone Mineral Density in Older Adults

Abstract

While the benefit of fluoridation in the prevention of dental caries has been overwhelmingly substantiated, the effect of fluoride on bone mineral density is less clear. This cross-sectional study was designed to compare the bone mineral densities of older adults exposed to various levels of fluoride from community water systems. Participants were recruited from 3 rural communities with naturally occurring fluoride in their water systems at 0.03, 0.7, and 2.5 mg/L. All adults, age 60 and over, were eligible if they were ambulatory and had a long-term history (≥ 20 yrs) of ingesting city water. Bone mineral density (BMD) was measured by means of dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry at 3 anatomical sites: lumbar spine, proximal femur, and forearm. A total of 353 white non-Hispanic women and 317 white non-Hispanic men took part in the study. When the data were stratified by city of residence and gender, men and women living in the community with high levels of fluoride in their community water system had significantly higher lumbar spine BMD than their counterparts from the communities with low and moderate fluoride levels. The women in the high-fluoride community had significantly higher proximal femur BMD, but there were no statistically significant differences among men in either proximal femur or forearm BMD. Long-term exposure (≥ 20 yrs) to higher levels of fluoride appears to have a positive impact on lumbar spine and proximal femur BMD. Based on the results of this study, exposure to fluoride at levels considered "optimal" for the prevention of dental caries (from 0.7 to 1.2 mg/L) appears to have no significant impact on bone mineral density. The relationship between higher levels of fluoride exposure and bone mineral density requires further investigation.

Keywords

fluorides fluoridation bone density osteoporosis,environmental health

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ansell BM , Lawrence JS (1966). Fluoridation and the rheumatic diseases. A comparison of rheumatism in Watford and Leigh. Ann Rheum Dis 25:67-75.

Arnala I. , Alhava EM , Kivivuori R. , Kauranen P. (1986). Hip fracture incidence not affected by fluoridation. Osteofluorosis studied in Finland. Acta Orthop Scand 57:344-348.

Avorn J. , Niessen LC (1986). Relationship between long bone fractures and water fluoridation. Gerodontics 2:175-179.

Barnhart WE , Hiller LK , Leonard GJ , Michaels SE (1974). Dentifrice usage and ingestion among four age groups. J Dent Res 53:1317-1322.

Bauer DC , Browner WS , Cauley JA , Orwoll ES , Scott JC , Black DM , et al. (1993). Factors associated with appendicular bone mass in older women. Ann Intern Med 118:657-665.

Bernstein DS , Sadowsky N. , Hegsted DM , Guri D. , Stare FJ (1966). Prevalence of osteoporosis in high- and low-fluoride areas in North Dakota. J Am Med Assoc 198:499-504.

Caffeine: grounds for concern? [no author] (1994). UC Berkeley Wellness Lett March:4-5.

Cauley JA , Murphy PA , Riley TJ , Buhari AM (1995). Effects of fluoridated drinking water on bone mass and fractures: the study of osteoporotic fractures. J Bone Miner Res 10 :1076-1086.

Cooper C. , Wickham C. , Lacey RF , Barker DJ (1990). Water fluoride concentration and fracture of the proximal femur. J Epidemiol Community Hlth 44:17-19.

10.

Dabeka RW , McKenzie AD (1995). Survey of lead, cadmium, fluoride, nickel, and cobalt in food composites and estimation of dietary intakes of these elements by Canadians in 1986-1988. J AOAC Int 78:897-909.

11.

Danielson C. , Lyon JL , Egger M. , Goodenough GK (1992). Hip fractures and fluoridation in Utah's elderly population. J Am Med Assoc 268:746-748.

12.

Einhorn TA (1992). Bone strength: the bottom line (editorial). Calcif Tissue Int 51:333-339.

13.

Environmental Protection Agency (1986). National primary and secondary drinking water regulations: fluoride: final rule. Fed Register 51:11396-11342.

14.

Faulkner KG , McClung MR (1995). Quality control of DXA instruments in multicenter trials. Osteoporosis Int 5:218-227.

15.

Felson DT , Zhang Y. , Hannan MT , Kannel WB , Kiel DP ( 1995). Alcohol intake and bone mineral density in elderly men and women. The Framingham Study. Am J Epidemiol 142:485-492.

16.

Glynn NW , Meilahn EN , Charron M. , Anderson SJ , Kuller LH , Cauley JA (1995). Determinants of bone mineral density in older men. J Bone Miner Res 10:1769-1777.

17.

Gruber HE , Baylink DJ (1991). The effects of fluoride on bone. Clin Orthop Rel Res 267:264-277.

18.

Hhhq-Dietsys Analysis Software, Version 3.0 (computer program) (1993). Washington, DC; National Cancer Institute .

19.

Hollenbach KA , Barrett-Conner E. , Edelstein SL , Holbrook T. (1993). Cigarette smoking and bone mineral density in older men and women. Am J Public Hlth 83:1265-1270.

20.

Jacobsen SJ , Goldberg J. , Miles TP , Brody JA , Stiers W. , Rimm AA ( 1990). Regional variation in the incidence of hip fracture: US white women aged 65 years and older. J Am Med Assoc 264:500-502.

21.

Jacobsen SJ , Goldberg J. , Cooper C. , Lockwood SA (1992). The association between water fluoridation and hip fracture among white women and men aged 65 years and older. A national ecologic study. Ann Epidemiol 2:617-626.

22.

Jacobsen SJ , O'Fallon WM , Melton LJ 3rd (1993). Hip fracture incidence before and after the fluoridation of the public water supply, Rochester, Minnesota. Am J Public Hlth 83:743-745.

23.

Kelsey JL , Thompson WD , Evans AS (1986). Methods in observational epidemiology. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 293-297.

24.

Kleerekoper M. , Balena R. (1991). Fluorides and osteoporosis. Ann Rev Nutr 11:309-324.

25.

Kroger H. , Alhava E. , Honkanen R. , Tuppurainen M. , Saarikoski S. (1994). The effect of fluoridated drinking water on axial bone mineral density-a population-based study. Bone Miner 27:33-41.

26.

Lahti SM , Uusitalo U. , Feskens E. , Haw U. , Tuomilehto J. , Luoma H. (1995). Fluoride and sugar intake among adults and youth in Mauritius: preliminary results. Adv Dent Res 9 :21-25.

27.

Leone NC , Stevenson CA , Hilbish TF , Sosman MC (1955). A Roentgenologic study of a human population exposed to high-fluoride domestic water. A 10-year study. Am J Roentg Radium Ther Nucl Med 74:874-885.

28.

Madans J. , Kleinman JC , Cornoni-Huntley J. (1983). The relationship between hip fracture and water fluoridation: an analysis of national data. Am J Public Hlth 73:296-298.

29.

Orwoll ES , Bauer DC , Vogt TM , Fox KM (1996). Axial bone mass in older women. Ann Intern Med 124:187-196.

30.

Phipps KR , Burt BA ( 1990). Water-borne fluoride and cortical bone mass: a comparison of two communities. J Dent Res 69:1256-1260.

31.

Rencken ML , Murano R. , Drinkwater BL , Chesnut CH 3rd (1991). In vitro comparability of dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) bone densitometers. Calcif Tissue Int 48:245-248.

32.

Riggs BL , Hodgson SF , O'Fallon WM , Chao EY , Wahner HW , Muhs JM , et al. (1990). Effect of fluoride treatment on the fracture rate in postmenopausal women with osteoporosis. N Engl J Med 322:802-809.

33.

Schlenker RA , VonSeggen WW (1976). The distribution of cortical and trabecular bone mass along the lengths of the radius and ulna and the implications for in vivo bone mass measurements. Calcif Tissue Res 20:41-52.

34.

Simonen O. , Laitinen O. (1985). Does fluoridation of drinking water prevent bone fragility and osteoporosis? Lancet 2(8452):432-434.

35.

Sowers MR , Wallace RB , Lemke JH (1986). The relationship of bone mass and fracture history to fluoride and calcium intake: a study of three communities. Am J Clin Nutr 44:889-898.

36.

Sowers MF , Clark MK , Jannausch ML , Wallace RB (1991). A prospective study of bone mineral content and fracture in communities with differential fluoride exposure. Am J Epidemiol 133:649-660.

37.

Whitford GM (1996). The metabolism and toxicity of fluoride. 2nd rev. ed. Basel, Switzerland: Karger.