Emotional Responses Evoked by Dental Odors: An Evaluation from Autonomic Parameters

Abstract

Among the factors which could explain avoidance behavior toward dental care, the typical clinging odor of the dental office, due to eugenol, is investigated in this study. The hypothesis is supported by the well-known effects of odorants which may influence cognition, emotion, and behavior. The association between the odor of eugenol and dental fear and anxiety could be explained by the fact that eugenates (eugenol-containing cements) are often used in potentially painful restorative dentistry on vital teeth. The emotional impact of the odors of eugenol and two other dental products (menthol and methyl methacrylate) was evaluated on volunteer subjects through autonomic nervous system (ANS) analysis by recording the variations of six ANS parameters (two electrodermal, two thermovascular, and two cardiorespiratory) induced by the inhalation of the odorants. After the experiment, subjects were asked to fill out an 11-point hedonic scale to rate the pleasantness vs. unpleasantness for each odorant. Results were compared between two groups of subjects divided according to their own dental experience (fearful and non-fearful dental-care subjects). These showed that, in both groups, menthol was rated as pleasant and methyl methacrylate as very unpleasant, whereas eugenol was judged pleasant by non-fearful subjects but unpleasant by fearful subjects. Concerning autonomic analysis, only eugenol induced significantly different patterns of ANS responses between the two groups, with stronger variations for dentally fearful subjects, mainly observed through the electrodermal channel. These results suggest that eugenol can be responsible for different emotional states, depending on the unpleasantness of the subjects' dental experience. This seems to confirm the role of odors as elicitors of emotional memories and to support the possible influence of eugenol odor on the avoidance behavior of some subjects toward dental care.

Keywords

autonomic nervous system dental odor emotion eugenol hedonic tone.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aggelton JP , Mishkin M. (1986). The amygdala sensory gateway to the emotions. In: Emotion: theory, research and experience. Plutchick R , Kellerman H , editors. Vol. 3. Biological foundations of emotion . Orlando: Academic Press, pp. 281-299.

Alaoui-Ismaili O. , Vemet-Maury E. , Dittmar A. , Delhomme G. , Chanel J. (1997a). Odor hedonics: connection with emotional response estimated by autonomic parameters. Chem Senses 22:237-248.

Alaoui-Ismaili O. , Robin O. , Rada H. , Dittmar A. , Vernet-Maury E. (1997b). Basic emotions evoked by odorants: comparison between autonomic responses and self-evaluation. Physiol Behav 62:713-720.

Collet C. , Vernet-Maury E. , Delhomme G. , Dittmar A. (1997). Autonomic nervous system response patterns specificity to basic emotions. J Autonom Nerv Syst 62:45-57.

Dawson ME , Schell AM , Filion DL (1990). The electrodermal system. In: Principles of psychophysiology. Physical, social, and inferential elements . Cacioppo JT , Tassinary LG , editors. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 295-324.

Dittmar A. (1989). Skin thermal conductivity in cutaneous investigation . In: Health and disease. Leveque JL , editor. New York: Marcel Dekker Inc., pp. 323-358.

Dittmar A. , Rada H. , Delhomme G. , Vemet-Maury E. , Collet C. , Roure R. (1995). A multi-sensor system for the non-invasive measurement of the activity of the autonomic nervous system. Sensors and Actuators B26-27:461-464.

Ehrlichman H. , Bastone L. (1992). Olfaction and emotion. In: Science of olfaction. Serby MJ , Chobor KL , editors. New York: Springer, pp. 410-438.

Ekman P. , Levenson RW , Friesen WW (1983). Autonomic nervous system activity distinguishes among emotions. Science 221:1208-1210.

10.

Fowles DC , Christie MJ , Edelberg R. , Grings WW , Lykken DT , Venables PH (1981). Committee report. Publication recommendations for electrodermal measurements. Psychophysiol 18:232-239.

11.

Glevarec F. (1994). Memoire involontaire: un phenomene operationnalisable en interaction avec le traitement de l'information sensorielle et l'émotion . Information sur les Sciences Sociales 33:753-785.

12.

Kirk-Smith MD , Van Toller C. , Dodd GH ( 1983). Unconscious odour conditioning in human subjects. Biol Psychol 17 :221-231.

13.

Kleinhauz M. , Eli I. , Baht R. , Shamay D. (1992). Correlates of success and failure in behavior therapy for dental fear. J Dent Res 71:1832-1835.

14.

Kleinknecht RA , Klepac RK , Alexander LD (1973). Origins and characteristics of fear of dentistry . J Am Dent Assoc 86 :842-848.

15.

Klemm WR , Lutes SD , Hendrix DV , Warrenburg S. (1992). Topographical EEG maps of human responses to odors . Chem Senses 17:347-361.

16.

Levenson RW , Ekman P. , Friesen WV (1990). Voluntary facial action generates emotion specific autonomic nervous system activity. Psychophysiol 27:363-384.

17.

Lorig TS (1989). Human EEG and odor response. Prog Neurobiol 33:387-398.

18.

Ludvigson HW , Rottman TR (1989). Effects of ambient odors of lavender and cloves on cognition, memory, affect and mood. Chem Senses 14:525-536.

19.

Ohman A. , Birbaumer N. (1993). Psychophysiological and cognitive-clinical perspectives on emotion: introduction and overview. In: The organization of emotion: cognitive, clinical, and psychophysiological aspects. Birbaumer N , Ohman A , editors. Toronto: Hogrefe and Huber.

20.

Ohman A. , Soares JJ (1993). On the automaticity of phobic fear: conditioned electrodermal responses to masked fear-relevant stimuli. J Abnorm Psychol 102:121-132.

21.

Ohman A. , Esteves F. , Flykt A. , Soares JJF (1993). Gateways to consciousness: emotion, attention, and electrodermal activity. In: Progress in electrodermal research . Roy JC , Boucsein W , Fowles DC , Gruzelier JH , editors. New York: Plenum Press, pp. 137-157.

22.

Rada H. , Dittmar A. , Delhomme G. , Collet C. , Vemet-Maury E. , Priez A. (1995). Bioelectric and microcirculation cutaneous sensors for the study of vigilance and emotional response during tasks and tests. Biosensors and Bioelectronics 10:7-15.

23.

Richardson JT , Zucco GM (1989). Cognition and olfaction: a review. Psychol Bull 105:352-360.

24.

Rosenberg M. (1994). First international workshop on oral malodor. Conference report. J Dent Res 73:586-589.

25.

Scherer KR , Wallbott HG (1994). Evidence for universality and cultural variation of differential emotion response patterning. J Pers Soc Psychol 66:310-328.

26.

Schiffman SS (1981). Characterization of odor quality utilizing multidimensional scaling techniques. In: Odor quality and chemical structure . Mosdowitz HR , Warren CB , editors. Washington, DC: American Chemical Society, pp. 1-21.

27.

Shoben EJ , Borland L. (1954). An empirical study of the etiology of dental fears . J Clin Psychol 10:171-174.

28.

Traeger KA (1981). Psychologic and physiologic facets of anxiety and pain. In: Pain and anxiety control in dentistry. Shapiro SR , editor. Englewood, NJ: J.K. Burgess Inc.

29.

Van Toller S. (1988). Odours, emotion and psychophysiology. Int J Cosmet Sci 10:171-197.

30.

Vernet-Maury E. , Deschaumes-Molinaro C. , Delhomme G. , Dittmar A. (1991). The relation between bioelectrical and thermovascular skin parameters. ITBM 12:112-120.

31.

Vernet-Maury E. , Alaoui-Ismaili O. , Dittmar A. , Economides S. (1995a). Connexion between olfaction and emotion estimated by autonomic nervous system (abstract). Chem Senses 20:128-129.

32.

Vemet-Maury E. , Robin O. , Dittmar A. (1995b). The ohmic perturbation duration: an original temporal index to quantify electrodermal response. Behav Brain Res 67:103-107.

33.

Vemet-Maury E. , Robin O. , Caterini R. , Delhomme G. , Dittmar A. , Economides S. (1996). Skin potential polarity, predictor index of emotional load. Homeostasis 37:145-154.

34.

Warm JS , Dember WN , Parasuraman R. (1991). Effect of olfactory stimulation on performance and stress in a visual sustained attention task. J Soc Cosmet Chem 42 :119-210.

35.

Wilder J. (1962). Basimetric approach (law of initial value) to biological rhythms. Ann NY Acad Sci 98:1211-1228.