Within-subject Coronal Caries Distribution Patterns: An Evaluation of Randomness with Respect to the Midline

Abstract

The distribution of caries among homologous surfaces can exhibit three possible patterns: random, aggregated, or regular. In a random caries pattern, caries lesions are randomly distributed among homologous surfaces. An aggregated caries pattern is distinguished by the aggregation of lesions on one side of the mouth or the other to a greater extent than would be expected by chance alone. For a regular caries pattern, the left-right distribution of lesions is more homogenous than would be expected by chance alone. A test statistic based on the left-right distribution of caries lesions among discordant homologous pairs was developed to investigate which of these three caries patterns is present in a representative sample of the adult United States population. The data originated from the National Survey of Oral Health in the US (Employed Adults), 1985-1986. Of the 15,132 subjects studied, 12,776 subjects had 2 or more decayed or filled teeth. (At least 2 carious or filled teeth are required for detection of patterns.) Approximately 50% of these subjects (n = 6,439) had two or more discordant homologous tooth pairs. With these tooth pairs, the hypothesis of a random caries pattern was rejected in favor of an aggregated caries pattern (p < 0.0001). Similar findings were obtained with discordant homologous surface pairs. This aggregation of caries on one side of the mouth or the other may be due to genetic, infectious, and/or environmental factors.

Keywords

Dental Caries DMF Index Statistics Epidemiology.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adler P. (1964). A fogszú epidemiológiájá (Epidemiology of dental caries). Magya Tud Akad Biol Orv Tud Oszt Közl 15:413-426.

Ahlgren J. (1976). Masticatory movements in man. In: Mastication. Anderson D , Methews B , editors. Bristol: John Wright and Sons, p 119.

Backer-Dirks O. (1965). The distribution of caries resistance in relation to tooth surfaces. In: Caries-resistant teeth. Wolstenholme GEW , O'Connor M , editors. Boston: Little, Brown and Company, pp 66-85.

Barr JH , Diodati RR , Stephens RG (1957). Incidence of caries at different locations on the teeth. J Dent Res 36:536-545.

Bartlett MS (1975). The statistical analysis of spatial pattern. London: Chapman and Hall.

Beyron HL (1954). Occlusal changes in the adult dentition. J Am Dent Assoc 48:674-686.

Boraas JC , Messer LB , Till MJ ( 1988). A genetic contribution to dental caries, occlusion and morphology as demonstrated by twins living apart. J Dent Res 67:1150-1155.

Caufield PW , Cutter GR , Dasanayake AP (1993). Initial acquisition of mutans streptococci by infants: evidence for a discrete window of infectivity. J Dent Res 72:37-45.

Christensen LV , Radue JT (1985). Lateral preference in mastication: relation to pain. J Oral Rehabil 12:461-467.

10.

Eckermann R. (1919). Dental caries in relation to oral osmosis. Lund: Carl Bloms Boktryckeri, pp 13,128.

11.

Gisel EG (1988). Development of oral side preference during chewing and its relation to hand preference in normal 2- to 8-year old children. Am J Occup Ther 42:378-383.

12.

Hector MP , Tripathi P. (1990). The effect of chewing side on parotid amylase secretion in conscious rabbits. Arch Oral Biol 35:71-73.

13.

Hoogmartens MJ , Caubergh MAA (1987a). Chewing side preference during the first chewing cycles as a new type of lateral preference in man. Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol 27:3-6.

14.

Hoogmartens MJ , Caubergh MAA (1987b). Chewing side preference in man correlated with handedness, footedness, eyedness and earedness. Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol 27:293-300.

15.

Hradecky C. , Adler P. (1954a). Uber die Symmetrie der Karies. I. Die Karies der ersten Molaren. Öst Z Stomatol 51:8-16.

16.

Hradecky C. , Adler P. (1954b). Uber die Symmetrie der Karies. II. Die Verteilung des Erstbefalles. Öst Z Stomatol 51:376-380.

17.

Hradecky C. , Adler P. (1954c). Uber die Symmetrie der Karies. III. Die zahlenmassige Seitendifferenz im Kariesbefall. Öst Z Stomatol 51:435-441.

18.

Infante PR , Owen GM ( 1975). Dental caries and levels of treatment for school children by geographical region, socioeconomic status, race, and size of community . J Publ Health Dent 35:19-27.

19.

Lashley KS (1916). Reflex secretions of the human parotid glands . J Exp Psychol 1:461-493.

20.

Losee FL (1947). Dental caries in abutting or bilaterally corresponding tooth surf aces. J Am Dent Assoc 35:323-326.

21.

Moyers RE (1980). Handbook of orthodontics. 3rd ed. Chicago: Yearbook Medical Publishers Inc.

22.

Pond LH , Barghi N. , Barnwell GM (1986). Occlusion and chewing side preference. J Prosthet Dent 55:498-500.

23.

Scott DB (1944). A study of the bilateral incidence of carious lesions. J Dent Res 23:105-110.

24.

Svanberg ML , Loesche WJ (1978). Intraoral spread of Streptococcus mutans in man . Arch Oral Biol 23:557-561.

25.

Tóth K. ( 1970). The epidemiology of dental caries in Hungary . Budapest: Akademiai Kiado, p 154.

26.

US Department of Health and Human Services ( 1990). Oral health of United States adults. The national survey of oral health in US employed adults and seniors: 1985-1986. Public use data file documentation and survey methodology. Part I: Employed adults.

27.

Webster N. (1992). Webster's ninth new collegiate dictionary and Webster's collegiate thesaurus. 1st digital ed. NeXT Computer, Inc. and Merriam-Webster Inc.