The Effect of Study Design on in situ Treatment of Carious Enamel Lesions

Abstract

The aim of this exploratory study was to investigate the influence of several factors on changes in the mineral content of carious enamel lesions treated in situ. The study involved 36 adult volunteers who used either a non-fluoride toothpaste or one of two fluoride toothpastes (1000 or 1500 ppm F). Human enamel specimens were prepared and attached to partial dentures as described previously (Schäfer, 1989) and treated in situ for between three and six weeks. The mineral content of lesions was determined by microradiography and computerized densitometry.

The factors investigated in this study included study length, frequency of treatment, trial design, patient compliance, patient diet, and previous caries experience of the patient. The effects observed were small, relative to that of the treatment, and not statistically significant (p > 0.05). However, the trends in the data were all as would be intuitively predicted. Study duration correlated positively with observed lesion mineral content. Lesions worn by panelists using a fluoride toothpaste for six weeks contained greater levels of mineral with respect to placebo than did those in panelists on a three-week study. The residual variations in the three phases of the study were found to be similar, suggesting that there is no advantage in these studies having a cross-over design. Brushing frequency also correlated positively with observed lesion mineral content, with panelists brushing three times per day with a fluoridated dentifrice having lesions with greater levels of mineral, with respect to placebo, than those brushing twice per day. Overall, no clear relationship between reported diet and changes in lesion mineral levels was apparent. However, increased frequency of sugar intake was associated with lower levels of mineral in lesions. No correlation was seen in this study between lifelong caries experience of panelists (DMFT) and observed mineral changes during the test period.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ANGMAR

; CARLSTRÖM

; and GLAS

J.-E.

(1963): Studies on the Ultrastructure of Dental Enamel. IV. The Mineralization of Normal Human Enamel, J Ultrastruct Res 8: 12–23.

BURCHELL

C.K.

; STEPHEN

K.W.

; CREANOR

S.L.

; and RUSSELL

J.I.

(1987): 2-year Effect of Stated Brushing Frequency on Plaque, Gingivitis and Caries Increments in Teenagers, Caries Res 21: 185, Abst. No. 74.

BURT

B.A.

; EKLUND

S.A.

; MORGAN

K.J.

; LARKIN

F.E.

; GUIRE

K.E.

; BROWN

L.O.

; and WEINTRAUB

J.A.

(1988): The Effects of Sugar Intake and Frequency of Ingestion on Dental Caries Increment in a Three-year Longitudinal Study, J Dent Res 67: 1422–1429.

DE BRUYN

; VAN RIJN

L.J.

; PURDELL-LEWIS

D.J.

; and ARENDS

(1988): Influence of Various Fluoride Varnishes on Mineral Loss Under Plaque, Caries Res 22: 76–83.

DE KLOET

H.J.

; EXTERKATE

R.A.M.

; REMPT

H.E.

; and TEN CATE

J.M.

(1986): In vivo Bovine Enamel Remineralization and Fluoride Uptake from Two Dentifrices Containing Different Fluoride Concentrations, J Dent Res 65: 1410–1414.

DIJKMAN

A.G.

; SCHUTHOF

; and ARENDS

(1986): In vivo Remineralization of Plaque-induced Initial Enamel Lesions—A Microradiographic Investigation, Caries Res 20: 202–208.

FEATHERSTONE

J.D.B.

; CUTRESS

T.W.

; RODGERS

B.E.

; and DENNISON

P.J.

(1982): Remineralization of Artificial Caries-like Lesions in vivo by a Self-administered Mouthrinse or Paste, Caries Res 16: 235–242.

GELHARD

T.B.F.M.

, and ARENDS

(1984): Microradiography of in vivo Remineralized Lesions in Human Enamel. II, J Biol Buccale 12: 59–65.

GOORHUIS

, and PURDELL-LEWIS

D.J.

(1986): 0.25% and 0.4% Amine Fluoride Gel for Weekly Topical Application. An in vivo Study on Human Dental Enamel, Caries Res 20: 458–464.

10.

KLEEMOLA-KUJALA

, and RÄSÄNEN

(1982): Relationship of Oral Hygiene and Sugar Consumption to Risk of Caries in Children, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 10: 224–233.

11.

MELLBERG

J.R.

; CASTROVINCE

L.A.

; and ROTSIDES

I.D.

(1986): In vivo Remineralization by a Monofluorophosphate Dentifrice as Determined with a Thin-section Sandwich Method, J Dent Res 65: 1078–1083.

12.

MELLBERG

J.R.

; CHOMICKI

W.G.

; MALLON

D.E.

; and CASTROVINCE

L.A.

(1985): Remineralization in vivo of Artificial Caries Lesions by a Monofluorophosphate Dentifrice, Caries Res 19: 126–135.

13.

SCHÄFER

(1989): Evaluation of the Anticaries Benefit of Fluoride Toothpastes Using an Enamel Insert Model, Caries Res 23: 81–86.

14.

TEN CATE

J.M.

, and REMPT

H.E.

(1986): Comparison of the in vivo Effect of a 0 and 1,500 ppm F MFP Toothpaste on Fluoride Uptake, Acid Resistance and Lesion Remineralization, Caries Res 20: 193–201.