Influence of Tempering Method on Residual Stress in Dental Porcelain

Abstract

The porcelain component of a porcelain-fused-to-metal restoration is strengthened by residual (tempering) stresses which are induced by cooling procedures followed in dental laboratories. The thermophysical properties of materials and cooling rate are the main factors which determine the residual stress. In this paper, the temperatures in the midplane of body-porcelain disks were measured from a heat-soak temperature (1000°C) to room temperature during two different cooling procedures: slow cooling in air and forced-air cooling. Experimental results approximated exponential cooling wherein the cooling rates could be represented by a linear equation of temperature. Residual stresses, as affected by the tempering method and thickness of a porcelain disk, were calculated by computer simulation for regions away from the edges. The following temperature-dependent factors were incorporated into the simulation: elastic modulus, viscosity, and coefficient of thermal expansion. The cooling rate dependencies of the glass transition temperature and the temperature distribution during cooling were also included. The cooling rates used in this simulation were derived from the tempering data. The agreement between development of transient and residual stresses—calculated by computer simulation for various cooling methods, and the tendency toward failures of porcelain disks subjected to the tempering processes-was examined. Simulated residual stresses were also in good agreement with those measured by the indentation fracture method of Marshall and Lawn (1977) and Anusavice et al. (1989).