Radiometric Classification of Alveolar Bone Health

Abstract

A radiograph-based classifier for discrimination between normal and diseased alveolar bone was developed. The alveolar bone health of dry mandibles was rated, by consensus of two trained observers, as normal or diseased. Bitewing radiographs of mandibular quadrants were digitized and regions of interest (ROIs) of the alveolar bone between the first and second permanent molars outlined. Gray-scale histograms for the ROIs were computed, and a classifier based on these histograms was developed. Two observers (independently) used only the classifier to rate the bone as being normal or diseased. These ratings were compared with the original ratings of trained observers who viewed and scored the actual alveolar bone. The sensitivity (the ability to detect diseased alveolar bone), specificity (the ability to detect normal alveolar bone), and accuracy were 0.90 or greater, indicating good agreement with subjective visual assessments of dry mandibles. These results suggest that this procedure may be applicable for evaluations of bone health in humans.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bragger U. , Pasquali L. , Weber H. , Kornman KS (1989). Computer-assisted densitometric image analysis (CADIA) for the assessment of alveolar bone density changes in furcations . J Clin Periodontol 16:46-52.

Grondahl K. , Gröndahl H-G. , Webber RL (1983). Digital subtraction radiography for diagnosis of periodontal bone lesions with simulated highspeed systems. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 55:313-318.

Grondahl K. , Grondahl H-G. , Wennstrom J. , Heijl L. (1987). Examiner agreement in estimating changes in periodontal bone from conventional and subtraction radiographs. J Clin Periodontol 14:74-79.

Hausmann E. , Allen K. , Christersson L. , Genco RJ (1989a). Effect of x-ray beam vertical angulation on radiographic alveolar crest level measurement. J Periodont Res 24:8-19.

Hausmann E. , Allen K. , Dunford R. , Christersson L. (1989b). A reliable computerized method to determine the level of the radiographic alveolar crest. J Periodont Res 24:368-369.

Hausmann E. , Christersson L. , Dunford R. , Wikesjo U. , Phyo J. , Genco RJ (1985). Usefulness of subtraction radiography in the evaluation of periodontal therapy. J Periodontol 56(Spec Iss):4-7.

Hausmann E. , Dunford R. , Wikesjo U. , Christersson L. , McHenry K. (1986). Progression of untreated periodontitis as assessed by subtraction radiography. J Periodont Res 21:716-721.

Hausmann E. , Ortman LF , McHenry K. , Fallon J. (1982). Relationship between alveolar bone measured by 125I absorptiometry with analysis of standardized radiographs: 1. Magiscan . J Periodontol 53:307-310.

Hildebolt CF , Vannier MW (1988). Automated classification of periodontal disease using bitewing radiographs. J Periodontol 59:87-94.

10.

Hildebolt CF , Vannier MW , Shrout MK , Pilgram TK , Province M. , Vahey EP , et al. (1990). Periodontal disease morbidity quantification. II. Validation of alveolar bone loss measurements and vertical defect diagnosis from digital bite-wing images. J Periodontol 61:623-632.

11.

Okano T. , Mera T. , Ohki M. , Ishikawa I. , Yamada N. (1990). Digital subtraction of radiograph in evaluating alveolar bone changes after initial periodontal therapy. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 69:258-262.

12.

Ortman LF , Dunford R. , McHenry K. , Hausmann E. (1985). Subtraction radiography and computer assisted densitometric analyses of standardized radiographs. J Periodont Res 20:644-651.

13.

Rethman M. , Ruttimann U. , O'Neal R. , Webber R. , Davis A. , Greenstein G. , Woodyard S. (1985). Diagnosis of bone lesions by subtraction radiography . J Periodontol 56:324-329.

14.

Ruttimann UE , van der Stelt PF , Webber RL (1986). Use of image similarity for the selection of synthesis of projections for subtraction radiography. SPIE 626:301-307.

15.

Ruttimann UE , Webber RL , Groenhuis Raj , Troullos E. , Rethman MT (1985). Automated estimation of lesion size. SPIE 535:325-330.

16.

Shrout MK , Hildebolt CF , Vannier MW (1991). The effect of alignment errors on bitewing-based bone loss measurements. J Clin Periodontol 18:708-712.

17.

Steffensen B. , Pasquali LA , Yuan C. , Wood RC , Schoolfield JD , Kornman KS (1989). Correction of density changes caused by methodological errors in CADIA. J Periodont Res 24:402-408.

18.

Van der Stelt PF , Van der Linden Lwj , Geraets Wgm , Alons CL (1985a). Digitized image processing and pattern recognition in the diagnosis of periodontal bone defects. J Clin Periodontol 12:815-821.

19.

Van der Stelt PF , Van der Linden Lwj , Geraets Wgm , Alons CL (1985b). Digitized pattern recognition in dental radiographs with emphasis on the interdental bone. J Clin Periodontol 12:822-827.

20.

Webber RL , Ruttimann UE , Heaven TJ (1990). Calibration errors in digital subtraction radiography . J Periodont Res 25:268-275.