A Statistical Approach to the Ecology of Porphyromonas gingivalis

Abstract

Previous studies have suggested that infections with Porphyromonas gingivalis, associated with periodontal disease, may consist of one clonal type. It has also been shown that each individual patient carries a unique clonal type of P. gingivalis, as assessed by DNA fingerprinting. This issue was further examined by random collection of multiple isolates ofP. gingivalis from multiple sites in several patients, and characterization of these isolates by DNA fingerprinting. Although most patients appeared to be infected exclusively by one clonal type of P. gingivalis, at least one patient was found to harbor two distinct clonal types. This indicates that the simultaneous presence of different clonal types of P. gingivalis can occur. A statistical method was developed for retrospective analysis of these data for estimation of whether the remainder of these patients were actually infected with single or multiple clonal types ofP. gingivalis. With this statistical method, a confidence interval was calculated for estimation of the true proportion of a single observed clonal type in the potential population of P. gingivalis that might be recovered from an infected patient. Statistically, the sampling of small numbers of sites per patient or isolates per site leads to a wide confidence interval for the estimated true proportion of the observed clonal type in the infecting P. gingivalis population. For example, when five sites in an oral cavity yield indistinguishable P. gingivalis isolates, then the true proportion of this clonal type in the total P. gingivalis population in the infected oral cavity is estimated to be in the interval between 55% and 100% (at a 95% confidence level). If the isolates from all sampled sites from a periodontal patient appear to be of the same clonal type, it can be calculated that at least 29 different sites must be sampled for this observed clonal type to represent at least 90% of the P. gingivalis population in this patient (95% confidence level); this was termed the LTP, or lowest true proportion. Such calculations can also be used for estimation of the LTP of a clonal type infecting a single oral site in a periodontal patient. These results confirm the commonly held opinion that studies investigating the ecology of P. gingivalis and other suspected pathogens must be designed on a large scale in order for statistically meaningful results to be obtained.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beyer, W.H. (1988): CRC Handbook of Tables for Probability and Statistics , 2nd ed., Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, Inc., pp. 182-205.

Campos, J. ; Garcia-Tornel, S. ; Musser, J.M. ; Selander, R.K. ; and Smith, A.L. (1987): Molecular Epidemiology of Multiply Resistant Haemophilus influenzae type b in Day Care Centers, J Infect Dis 156:483-489.

Chen, C. -KC.; Sunday, G.J. ; Zambon, J.J. ; and Wilson, M.E. (1990): Restriction Endonuclease Analysis of Eikenella corrodens, J Clin Microbiol 28:1265-1270.

Genco, R. ; Zambon, J.J. ; and Christersson, L.A. (1988): The Origin of Periodontal Infections, Adv Dent Res 2:245-259.

Haapasalo, M. ; Ranta, H. ; Ranta, K. ; and Shah, H. (1986): Black-pigmented Bacteroides spp. in Human Apical Periodontitis, Infectlmmun 53:149-153.

Holt, S.C. ; Ebersole, J. ; Felton, J. ; Brunsvold, M. ; and Kornman, K.S. (1988): Implantation of Bacteroides gingivalis in Nonhuman Primates Initiates Progression of Periodontitis, Science 239:55-57.

Huntsberger, D.V. and Billingsley, P. (1981): Elements of Statistical Inference, 5th ed., Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon, Inc., pp. 189-194.

Isenberg, H.D. (1988): Pathogenicity and Virulence: Another View, Clin Microbiol Rev 1:40-53.

Krichevsky, M.I. and The Workshop Participants ( 1991): Draft Results of a Workshop to Develop Guidelines for Studies Involving Microbial Incidence or Populations in the Oral Cavity, J Dent Res 70:226-232.

10.

Kristiansen, B.-E. ; Sorensen, B. ; Simonson, T. ; Spanne, 0.; Lund, V. ; and Bjorvatn, B. (1984): Isolates of Neisseria meningitidis from Different Sites in the Same Patient: Phenotypic and Genomic Studies, with Special Reference to Adherence, Piliation, and DNA Restriction Endonuclease Pattern, J Infect Dis 150:389-396.

11.

Loos, B.G. ; Bernstein, J.M. ; Dryja, D.M. ; Murphy, T.F. ; and Dickinson, D.P. (1989a): Determination of the Epidemiology and Transmission of Nontypeable Haemophilus influenzae in Children with Otitis Media by Comparison of Total Genomic DNA Restriction Fingerprints, Infect Immun 57:2751-2757.

12.

Loos, B.G. ; Genco, R.J. ; and Dickinson, D.P. (1989b): Epidemiology of Bacteroides gingivalis using DNA Restriction Fragment Pattern Analyses, J Dent Res 68:985, Abst. No. 944.

13.

Loos, B.G. ; Mayrand, D. ; Genco, R.J. ; and Dickinson, D.P. (1990): Genetic Heterogeneity of Porphyromonas (Bacteroides) gingivalis by Genomic DNA Fingerprinting, J Dent Res 69:1488-1493.

14.

Mayrand, D. and Holt, S.C. (1988): Biology of Asaccharolytic Black-pigmented Bacteroides Species, Microbiol Rev 52:134-152.

15.

Selander, R.K. and Musser, J.M. (1990): Population Genetics of Bacterial Pathogenesis . In: The Bacteria: a Treatise on Structure and Function, Vol. XI: Molecular Basis of Bacterial Pathogenesis, B.H. Iglewski and V.L. Clark (Vol. Eds.), J.R. Sokatch and L.N. Ornston , Eds., New York, NY: Academic Press, Inc., pp. 11-36.

16.

Shah, H.N. and Collins, M.D. (1988): Proposal for Reclassification of Bacteroides asaccharolyticus, Bacteroides gingivalis and Bacteroides endodontalis in a New Genus, Porphyromonas, Int J Syst Bacteriol 38:128-131.

17.

Slots, J. and Listgarten, M.A. (1988): Bacteroides gingivalis, Bacteroides intermedius and Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans in Human Periodontal Diseases, J Clin Periodontol 15:85-93.

18.

Snedecor, G.W. and Cochran, W.G. (1967): StatisticalMethods, 6th ed., Ames, IA: The Iowa State University Press, pp. 199-227.

19.

Van Winkelhoff, A.J. ; Van Der Velden, U. ; Clement, M. ; and De Graaff, J. (1988a): Intra-oral Distribution of Black-pigmented Bacteroides Species in Periodontitis Patients, Oral Microbiol Immunol 3:83-85.

20.

Van Winkelhoff,A.J. ; Van Steenbergen, T.J.M. ;and De Graaff, J. (1988b): The Role of Black-pigmented Bacteroides in Human Oral Infections, J Clin Periodontol 15:145-155.