Dental Caries and Fluoride Exposure in Western Australia

Abstract

Most water supplies in Western Australia (WA) have been fluoridated since about 1968, but one region has persistently resisted. Supplement use has been encouraged there, and fluoride toothpaste is widely used. Caries prevalence and caries experience in children in Perth (F- 0.8 mg/L) have declined steadily since fluoridation, but in the Bunbury region (F- <0.2 mg/L), caries measures remain higher than in Perth. The purpose of this study was to correlate the magnitude and timing of fluoride exposure with caries experience. Altogether, 592 randomly selected children born in 1978 (mean age, 11.8 years) in Perth and the Bunbury region provided residence and fluoride exposure information for the periods from birth to four and from four to 12 years of age. Caries experience was recorded clinically in accordance with DMFT and WHO criteria. Sixty-one percent had been continuous residents of fluoridated areas from birth to four years, and 51% between the ages of four and 12 years. Fluoride supplement use was low. By the age of 1.5 years, 42% had used toothpaste. The prevalence of caries was 0.38 in Perth and 0.61 in the Bunbury region, and mean DMFT scores were 0.89 (SD, 1.39) and 1.57 (SD, 1.60), respectively. Bivariate analysis revealed all fluoride exposure to be associated with reduced caries experience, but there were large correlations between some variables. When unconditional logistic regression analysis was used, the most important (p < 0.05) odds ratios associated with no caries experience were for residence in a fluoridated area from four to 12 years of age and early use of toothpaste. Residence in a fluoridated area from birth to four years of age and use of supplements at any age did not reduce caries risk significantly (p>0.05) at 12 years of age. Increased total fluoride exposure (up to optimal exposure) was associated with decreased mean DMF scores. These data suggest that water fluoridation had an important anti-caries effect; the post-eruptive effect was more important than the pre-eruptive effect.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aasenden, R. and Peebles, T.C. (1974): Effects of Fluoride Supplementation from Birth on Human Deciduous and Permanent Teeth, Arch Oral Biol 19:321-326.

Anderson, R.J. (1989): The Changes in Dental Caries Experience of 12-year-old Schoolchildren in Two Somerset Schools. A Review after an Interval of 25 Years , Br Dent J 167:312-314.

Attwood, D. and Blinkhorn, A.S. (1989): Reassessment of the Effect of Fluoridation on Cost of Dental Treatment among Scottish Schoolchildren, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 17:79-82.

Barnhart, W.E. ; Hiller, L.K. ; Leonard, G.J. ; and Mi-Chaels, S.E. (1974): Dentifrice Usage and Ingestion among Four Age Groups, J Dent Res 53:1317-1322.

Beltran, E.D. and Burt, B.A. (1988): The Pre- and Posteruptive Effects of Fluoride in the Caries Decline, J Public Health Dent 48:233-240.

Brown, L.P. ; Mulqueen, T.F. ; and Storey, E. (1990): The Effect of Fluoride Consumption and Social Class on Dental Caries in 8-year-old Children, Aust Dent J 35:61-68.

Brunelle, J.A. and Carlos, J.P. (1990): Recent Trends in Dental Caries in U.S. Children and the Effect of Water Fluoridation, J Dent Res 69 (Spec Iss):723-727.

Carr, L.M. (1982): Dental Health of Children in Australia, 1977-1980 , Aust Dent J 27:169-175.

Carr, L.M. (1983): Dental Health of Children in Australia 1977-1982 , Aust Dent J 28:269-276.

10.

Carr, L.M. (1988): Dental Health of Children in Australia, 1977-1985 , Aust Dent J 33:205-211.

11.

Clovis, J. ; Hargreaves, J.A. ; and Thompson, G.W. (1988): Caries Prevalence and Length of Residency in Fluoridated and Non-fluoridated Communities, Caries Res 22:311-315.

12.

Commonwealth Department Of Health (1987): Dental Health of Children in Australia 1977-86. Canberra : Australian Government Publishing Service, Cat. no. 87 00519.

13.

Ericsson, Y. and Forsman, B. (1969): Fluoride Retained from Mouthrinses and Dentifrices in Preschoolchildren, Caries Res 3 :290-299.

14.

Fejerskov, 0.; Thylstrup, A. ; and Larsen, M.J. (1981): Rational Use of Fluoride in Caries Prevention, Acta Odontol Scand 39:241-249.

15.

Grembowski, D. (1988): Measuring Length of Exposure to Fluoridated Water , Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 16:131-134.

16.

Groeneveld, A. and Backer-Dirks, O. (1988): Fluoridation of Drinking Water, Past, Present and Future. In: Fluoride in Dentistry . J. Ekstrand , O. Fejerskov , and L.M. Silverstone , Eds., Copenhagen: Munksgaard, pp. 229-251.

17.

Groeneveld, A. ; Van Eck, A.A.M.J. ; and Backer Dirks, O. (1990): Fluoride in Caries Prevention: Is the Effect Pre- or Post-eruptive?, J Dent Res 69 (Spec Iss):751-755.

18.

Grondahl, H.-G. (1979): Some Factors Influencing Observer Performance in Radiographic Caries Diagnosis, Swed Dent J 3 :157-172.

19.

Hargreaves, J.A. ; Ingram, G.S. ; and Wagg, B.J. (1972): A Gravimetric Study of the Ingestion of Toothpaste by Children, Caries Res 6:236-243.

20.

Holm, A.-K. and Andersson, R. (1982): Enamel Mineralisation Disturbances in 12-year-old Children with Known Early Exposure to Fluorides, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 10:335-359.

21.

Kalsbeek, H. and Verrips, G.H.W. (1990): Dental Caries Prevalence and the Use of Fluorides in Different European Countries, J Dent Res 69 (Spec Iss):728-732.

22.

Kleinbaum, D.G. ; Kupper, L.L. ; and Morgenstern, H. (1982): Epidemiologic Research, New York: Van Nostrand Rein-hold Company, pp. 419-438.

23.

Larsen, M.J. ; Fejerskov, 0.; Bojen, 0.; Senderowitz , F. ; Lambrou, D. ; Manji, F. ; and Hobdell, M.H. (1989): Fluctuation of Fluoride Concentrations in Drinking Waters: an International Collaborative Study, Int Dent J 39:140-146.

24.

Larsen, M.J. ; Richards, A. ; and Fejerskov, O. (1985): Development of Dental Fluorosis According to Age at Start of Fluoride Administration, Caries Res 19:519-527.

25.

Lo, E.C. M.; Evans, R.W. ; and Lind, O.P. (1990): Dental Caries Status and Treatment Needs of the Permanent Dentition of 6-12-year-olds in Hong Kong, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 18 :9-11.

26.

Marthaler, T. (1988): Clinical Cariostatic Effects of Various Fluoride Methods and Programs. In: Fluoride in Dentistry, J. Ekstrand , O. Fejerskov , and L.M. Silverstone , Eds., Copenhagen: Munksgaard, pp. 252-275.

27.

McClure, F.J. and Likins, R.C. (1951): Fluorine in Human Teeth Studied in Relation to Fluorine in the Drinking Water, J Dent Res 30:172-176.

28.

Medcalf, G.W. (1970): Report on Caries Experience and Treatment Needs in Western Australian Children Aged 6-14 Years, Aust Dent J 15:50-54.

29.

Medcalf, G.W. (1978): Ten Years of Fluoridation in Perth, Western Australia , Aust Dent J 23:474-476.

30.

Medcalf, G.W. and O'Grady, M.J. (1983): The Dental Health of Children Eight and Fifteen Years of Age Living in Bunbury, Western Australia, Aust Dent J 28:162-165.

31.

Mileman, P.A. and Espelid, I. (1988): Decisions on Restorative Treatment and Recall Intervals Based on Bitewing Radiographs. A Comparison between National Surveys of Dutch and Norwegian Practitioners, Community Dent Health 5:273-284.

32.

National Research Council Food And Nutrition Board (1974): Recommended Dietary Allowances, 8th ed., Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences, pp. 98-99.

33.

Osuji, 0.0.; Leake, J.L. ; Chipman, M.L. ; Nikiforuk, G. ; Locker, D. ; and Levine, N. (1988): Risk Factors for Dental Fluorosis in a Fluoridated Community, J Dent Res 67:1488-1492.

34.

Pendrys, D.G. and Katz, R.V. (1989): Risk of Enamel Fluorosis Associated with Fluoride Supplementation, Infant Formula, and Fluoride Dentifrice Use, Am J Epidemiol 130:1199-1208.

35.

Riordan, P.J. and Banks, J.A. (1991): Dental Fluorosis and Fluoride Exposure in Western Australia, J Dent Res 70 :1022-1028.

36.

Rothman, K.J. (1986): Modern Epidemiology, Boston : Little, Brown and Company, pp. 289-304.

37.

Rugg-Gunn, A.J. and Holloway, P.J. (1974): Methods of Measuring the Reliability of Caries Prevalence and Incremental Data, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2:287-294.

38.

Stockwell, A.J. ; Medcalf, G.W. ; Rutledge, G.J. ; Holman, C.D.J. ; and Roberts, M. (1990): Dental Caries Experience in Schoolchildren in Fluoridated and Non-fluoridated Communities in Western Australia, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 18:184-189.

39.

Susser, M. (1987): Falsification, Verification, and Causal Inference in Epidemiology: Reconsiderations in the Light of Sir Karl Popper's Philosophy . In: Epidemiology, Health and Society. Selected Papers, M. Susser , Ed., New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 82-93.

40.

Szpunar, S.M. and Burt, B.A. (1988): Dental Caries, Fluorosis, and Fluoride Exposure in Michigan Schoolchildren, J Dent Res 67:802-806.

41.

Thylstrup, A. (1990): Clinical Evidence of the Role of Pre-eruptive Fluoride in Caries Prevention, J Dent Res 69 (Spec Iss) :742-750.

42.

Thylstrup, A. ; Fejerskov, 0.; Bruun, C. ; and Kann, J. (1979): Enamel Changes and Dental Caries in 7-year Old Children Given Fluoride Tablets from Shortly after Birth, Caries Res 13 :265-276.

43.

U.S. Department Of Health And Human Services ( 1989): Oral Health of United States Children. The National Survey of Dental Caries in U.S. Schoolchildren: 1986-87. National and Regional Findings . Bethesda, MD: National Institutes of Health Publication No. 89-2247, pp. 13 and 215.

44.

Woltgens, J.H.M. ; Etty, E.J. ; Nieuwland, W.M.D. ; and Lyaruu, D.M. (1989): Use of Fluoride by Young Children and Prevalence of Mottled Enamel, Adv Dent Res 3:177-182.

45.

World Health Organization (1987): Oral Health Surveys. Basic Methods, 3rd ed., Geneva: World Health Organization, pp. 35-37.