Dental fluorosis in children is reported from many locations, and its prevalence may be increasing. This study aimed to measure fluorosis in 12-year-olds in fluoridated and non-fluoridated areas of Western Australia and to relate this to exposure. School dental clinics in Perth (F- 0.8 mg/L) and the Bunbury area (F- <0.2 mg/L) were the sampling units. Parents provided data on residence in fluoridated areas and on use of supplements and toothpaste. Exposure to water and supplemental fluoride between birth and four years was calculated. Clinical examinations (upper left central incisor) based on the TF classification of fluorosis (which requires teeth to be dried) were conducted for 338 children in Perth and 321 in the Bunbury region. Re-examinations (n = 50) gave a weighted kappa of 0.78. Contingency analysis estimated bivariate relationships, and multiple logistic regression estimated odds ratios (OR) for risk factors. Fluorosis prevalence in the Perth region was 0.40, and in the Bunbury region 0.33 (χ2 = 3.69, df = 1, p = 0.055). Prevalence was 0.44 in children with fluoride exposure equivalent to optimal water fluoridation and 0.20 among those with the lowest exposure (χ 2 = 35.99, df = 1, p = 0.0001). Increasing exposure was associated with higher fluorosis prevalence and higher TF scores, but overall, 27.3% of participants had TF score 1 (barely discernible), and only 9.4% had TF score ≥2. The odds of fluorosis were greatest for use of fluoride supplements in accordance with recommendations (OR = 4.63, 95% CI 1.97, 10.90) and extended residence in an area with fluoridated water (OR = 4.06, 95% CI 2.55, 6.44). All toothpaste-related variables had ORs > 1, but none was statistically significant, suggesting recall error. The findings suggest that supplement use by some children in 1978-82 provided too much fluoride, and that a small number of persons have undesirable fluorosis.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aasenden, R. and Peebles, T.C. (1974): Effects of Fluoride Supplementation from Birth on Human Deciduous and Permanent Teeth, Arch Oral Biol19:321-326.
2.
Bagramian, R.A.; Narendran, S.; and Ward, M. (1989): Relationship of Dental Caries and Fluorosis to Fluoride Supplement History in a Non-fluoridated Sample of Schoolchildren , Adv Dent Res3:161-167.
3.
Barnhart, W.E.; Hiller, L.K.; Leonard, G.J.; and Mi-Chaels, S.E. (1974): Dentifrice Usage and Ingestion among Four Age Groups, J Dent Res53:1317-1322.
4.
Beltran, E.D. and Szpunar, S.M. (1988): Fluoride in Toothpastes for Children: Suggestions for Change, Pediatr Dent10 :185-190.
5.
Breslow, N.E. and Day, N.E. (1980): Statistical Methods in Cancer Research. Volume 1 - The Analysis of Case-control Studies, Lyon: International Agency for Research on Cancer. IARC Scientific Publications No. 32, pp. 235-236.
6.
Brown, L.P.; Mulqueen, T.F.; and Storey, E. (1990): The Effect of Fluoride Consumption and Social Class on Dental Caries in 8-year-old Children, Aust Dent J35:61-68.
7.
Castles, I. (1990): Year Book Australia 1990, Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics, pp. 142-143.
8.
Chau, S.S.Y. and King, N.M. (1989): An in vitro Investigation of Developmental Defects of Enamel under Wet and Dry Conditions, NZ Dent J85:78-82.
9.
Cicchetti, D.V. (1976): Assessing Inter-rater Reliability for Rating Scales: Resolving Some Basic Issues, Br J Psychiat129 :452-456.
10.
Commonwealth Department Of Health (1987): Dental Health of Children in Australia 1977-86, Canberra : Australian Government Publishing Service , Cat. no. 87 0051 9.
11.
Cutress, T.W. (1989): Symposium and Workshop on Developmental Defects of Enamel, February 23-25, 1988, Rotorua, New Zealand, Adv Dent Res3:95-103.
12.
Cutress, T.W.; Suckling, G.W.; Pearce, E.I.F.; and Ball, M.E. (1985): Defects of Tooth Enamel in Fluoridated and Nonfluoridated Water Areas of the Auckland Region, NZ Dent J81 :12-19.
13.
De Liefde, B. and Herbison, G.P. (1985): Prevalence of Developmental Defects of Enamel and Dental Caries in New Zealand Children Receiving Differing Fluoride Supplementation , Community Dent Oral Epidemiol13:164-167.
14.
Driscoll, W.S.; Heifetz, S.B.; Horowitz, H.S.; King-Man, A.; Meyers, R.J.; and Zimmerman, E.R. (1983): Prevalence of Dental Caries and Dental Fluorosis in Areas with Optimal and Above-optimal Water Fluoride Concentrations, JAm Dent Assoc107:42-47.
15.
Driscoll, W.S.; Heifetz, S.B.; Horowitz, H.S.; Kingman, A.; Meyers, R.J.; and Zimmerman, E.R. (1986): Prevalence of Dental Caries and Dental Fluorosis in Areas with Negligible, Optimal, and Above-optimal Fluoride Concentrations in Drinking Water, J Am Dent Assoc113:29-33.
16.
Drummond, B.K.; Curzon, M.E.J.; and Strong, M. (1990): Estimation of Fluoride Absorption from Swallowed Fluoride Toothpastes, Caries Res24:211-215.
17.
Ekstrand, J.; Koch, G.; and Petersson, L.G. (1983): Plasma Fluoride Concentrations in Pre-school Children after Ingestion of Fluoride Tablets and Toothpaste, Caries Res17:379-384.
18.
Ericsson, Y. and Forsman, B. (1969): Fluoride Retained from Mouthrinses and Dentifrices in Preschoolchildren, Caries Res3 :290-299.
19.
Evans, R.W. (1989): Changes in Dental Fluorosis Following an Adjustment to the Fluoride Concentration of Hong Kong's Water Supplies, Adv Dent Res3:154-160.
20.
Fejerskov, 0.; Bælum, V.; Manji, F.; and M0Ller, I.J., Eds. (1988): Dental Fluorosis-a Handbook for Health Workers, Copenhagen : Munksgaard, pp. 17-32 and 44-45.
21.
Fejerskov, O.; Manji, F.; and Bælum, V. (1990): The Nature and Mechanisms of Dental Fluorosis in Man, J Dent Res69 (Spec Iss):692-700.
22.
Grembowski, D. (1988): Measuring Length of Exposure to Fluoridated Water , Community Dent Oral Epidemiol16:131-134.
23.
Grobler, S.R.; Van Wyk, C.W.; and Kotze, D. (1986): Relationship between Enamel Fluoride Levels, Degree of Fluorosis and Caries Experience in Communities with a Nearly Optimal and a High Fluoride Level in the Drinking Water, Caries Res20 :284-288.
24.
Hargreaves, J.A.; Ingram, G.S.; and Wagg, B.J. (1972): A Gravimetric Study of the Ingestion of Toothpaste by Children, Caries Res6:236-243.
25.
Heifetz, S.B.; Driscoll, W.S.; Horowitz, H.S.; and King-Man, A. (1988): Prevalence of Dental Caries and Dental Fluorosis in Areas with Optimal and Above-optimal Water-fluoride Concentrations: A 5-year Follow-up Survey, J Am Dent Assoc116:490-495.
26.
Holm, A.-K. and Andersson, R. (1982): Enamel Mineralisation Disturbances in 12-year-old Children with Known Early Exposure to Fluorides, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol10:335-359.
27.
Horowitz, H.S.; Heifetz, S.B.; Driscoll, W.S.; King-Man, A.; and Meyers, R.J. (1984): A New Method for Assessing the Prevalence of Dental Fluorosis-the Tooth Surface Index of Fluorosis, J Am Dent Assoc109:37-41.
28.
Kleinbaum, D.G.; Kupper, L.L.; and Morgenstern, H. (1982): Epidemiologic Research, New York: Van Nostrand-Reinhold Company, pp. 419-438.
29.
Kumar, J.V.; Green, E.L.; Wallace, W.; and Carnahan, T. (1989): Trends in Dental Fluorosis and Dental Caries Prevalences in Newburgh and Kingston, NY, Am J Public Health79 :565-569.
30.
Kuthy, R.A.; Naleway, C.; and Durkee, J. (1985): Factors Associated with Maintenance of Proper Water Fluoride Levels, J Am Dent Assoc110:511-513.
31.
Landis, J.R. and Koch, G.G. (1977): The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data, Biometrics33:159-174.
32.
Larsen, M.J.; Fejerskov, 0.; Bojen, 0.; Senderowitz , F.; Lambrou, D.; Manji, F.; and Hobdell, M.H. (1989): Fluctuation of Fluoride Concentrations in Drinking Waters: an International Collaborative Study, Int Dent J39:140-146.
33.
Larsen, M.J.; Kirkegaard, E.; and Poulsen, S. (1987): Patterns of Dental Fluorosis in a European Country in Relation to the Fluoride Concentration of Drinking Water, J Dent Res66 :10-12.
34.
Larsen, M.J.; Richards, A.; and Fejerskov, O. (1985): Development of Dental Fluorosis According to Age at Start of Fluoride Administration, Caries Res19:519-527.
35.
Leverett, D.H. (1982): Fluorides and the Changing Prevalence of Dental Caries, Science217:26-30.
36.
Leverett, D.H. (1986): Prevalence of Dental Fluorosis in Fluoridated and Nonfluoridated Communities-a Preliminary Investigation, J Public Health Dent46:184-187.
37.
Levine, R.S.; Beal, J.F.; and Fleming, C.M. (1989): A Photographically Recorded Assessment of Enamel Hypoplasia in Fluoridated and Non-fluoridated Areas of England, Br Dent J166:249-252.
38.
Manji, F.; Bælum, V.; and Fejerskov, O. (1986): Fluoride, Altitude and Dental Fluorosis, Caries Res20:473-480.
39.
Medcalf, G.W. and O'Grady, M.J. (1983): The Dental Health of Children Eight and Fifteen Years of Age Living in Bunbury, Western Australia, Aust Dent J28:162-165.
40.
Ministry Of Education (1990): Education Statistics Bulletin Number 12, 1990, Perth: Ministry of Education, Western Australia, pp. 16 and 112-116.
41.
O'Mullane, D.M. (1990): The Future of Water Fluoridation, J Dent Res69 (Spec Iss):756-759.
42.
Osuji, 0.0.; Leake, J.L.; Chipman, M.L.; Nikiforuk, G.; Locker, D.; and Levine, N. (1988): Risk Factors for Dental Fluorosis in a Fluoridated Community, J Dent Res67:1488-1492.
43.
Osuji, O.O. and Nikiforuk, G. (1988): Fluoride Supplement-induced Dental Fluorosis: Case Reports, Pediatric Dent10 :48-52.
44.
Pendrys, D.G. and Katz, R.V. (1989): Risk of Enamel Fluorosis Associated with Fluoride Supplementation, Infant Formula, and Fluoride Dentifrice Use, Am J Epidemiol130:1199-1208.
45.
Pink, B.N. (1989): Western Australian Year Book No. 26-1989, Perth: Australian Bureau of Statistics, pp. 128-130.
46.
Richards, A.; Fejerskov, O.; and Bælum, V. (1989): Enamel Fluoride in Relation to Severity of Human Dental Fluorosis, Adv Dent Res3:147-153.
47.
Riordan, P.J. (1989): Guidelines for the Use of Dietary Fluoride Supplements in Australia, Aust Dent J34:359-362.
48.
Ross, K.N.; Farish, S.; and Plunkett, M. (1988): Indicators of Socioeconomic Disadvantage for Australian Schools, Geelong (Vic.): Deakin Institute for Studies in Education, Deakin University, pp. 13-22.
49.
Rothman, K.J. (1986): Modern Epidemiology, Boston : Little, Brown and Company, pp. 289-304.
50.
Stockwell, A.J.; Medcalf, G.W.; Rutledge, G.J.; Holman, C.D.J.; and Roberts, M. (1990): Dental Caries Experience in Schoolchildren in Fluoridated and Non-fluoridated Communities in Western Australia, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol18:184-189.
51.
Suckling, G.W. (1989): Developmental Defects of Enamel-Historical and Present-day Perspectives of their Pathogenesis, Adv Dent Res3:87-94.
52.
Szpunar, S.M. and Burt, B.A. (1987): Trends in the Prevalence of Dental Fluorosis in the United States, J Public Health Dent47:71-79.
53.
Szpunar, S.M. and Burt, B.A. (1988): Dental Caries, Fluorosis and Fluoride Exposure in Michigan Schoolchildren, J Dent Res67:802-806.
54.
Thylstrup, A. (1990): Clinical Evidence of the Role of Pre-eruptive Fluoride in Caries Prevention, J Dent Res69 (Spec Iss) :742-750.
55.
Thylstrup, A. and Fejerskov, O. (1978): Clinical Appearance of Dental Fluorosis in Permanent Teeth in Relation to Histological Changes, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol6:315-328.
56.
Wenzel, A. and Thylstrup, A. (1982): Dental Fluorosis and Localized Enamel Opacities in Fluoride and Nonfluoride Danish Communities, Caries Res16:340-348.
57.
Whitford, G.M.; Allmann, D.W.; and Shahed, A.R. (1987): Topical Fluorides: Effects on Physiologic and Biochemical Processes, J Dent Res66:1072-1078.
58.
Whitford, G.M. (1989): IV. Factors that Modify the Metabolism or Effects of Fluoride. In: The Metabolism and Toxicity of Fluoride, Basel: Karger, Monographs in Oral Science, Vol. 13, pp. 81-87.
59.
Woltgens, J.H.M.; Etty, E.J.; Nieuwland, W.M.D.; and Lyaruu, D.M. (1989): Use of Fluoride by Young Children and Prevalence of Mottled Enamel, Adv Dent Res3:177-182.
