The Release of Elements of Dental Casting Alloys into Cell-culture Medium

Abstract

Ten dental casting alloys were tested for alloy-element release into cell-culture medium, and this release was related to alloy composition, alloy microstructure, and alloy cytotoxicity (previously determined). Cell-culture medium was analyzed for alloy elements by flame atomic absorption. Concentrations of elements in the medium were normalized by dividing them by their atomic abundance in the alloy, giving element medium-alloy ratios (EMA ratios). Results showed that Au, In, and Pd generally did not dissolve into the medium, but that Ag, Cd, Cu, Ga, Ni, and Zn frequently dissolved. Comparison of EMA ratios for Ag, Cu, and Zn showed that each element retained a behavioral identity in diverse metallurgical environments, but that these environments influenced the release behavior to some degree. Some EMA ratios in multiphase alloys were greater than those in solid solutions, and EMA ratios showed great diversity within all the alloys. Nominal composition seemed to be of little value in the prediction of metal release unless the composition supported multiple-phase formation. In addition, release of alloy elements did not, in itself, completely predict alloy cytotoxicity measured previously. However, cytotoxicity was associated with metal release in each case. The commercial alloys used in this study exhibited more complex and less predictable release behavior than did the simpler ternary alloy systems used by previous investigators. It is believed that the use of commercial preparations is necessary for their in vivo behavior to be modeled.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bergman, M. and Ginstrup, O. (1975): Dissolution Rate of Cadmium from Dental Gold Solder Alloys, Acta Odontol Scand 33:199-210.

Brune, D. (1988): Mechanism and Kinetics of Metal Release from Dental Alloys, Int Endo J 21:135-142.

Bumgardner, J.D. ; Lucas, L.C. ; and Tilden, A.B. (1989): Toxicity of Cu-based Dental Alloys in Cell Culture , J Biomed Mater Res 23:1103-1114.

Covington, J.S. ; McBride, M.A. ; Slagle, W.F. ; and Disney, A.L. (1985): Quantization of Nickel and Beryllium Leakage from Base Metal Casting Alloys, J Prosthet Dent 54:127-136.

Craig, R.G. and Hanks, C.T. (1990): Cytotoxicity of Experimental Casting Alloys Evaluated by Cell Culture Tests, J Dent Res 69:1539-1542.

Goehlich, V. and Marek, M. (1990): Corrosion Behavior of Pd-Cu and Pd-Co Alloys in Synthetic Saliva, Dent Mater 6:103-110.

Johansson, B.I. ; Lemons, J.E. ; and Hao, S.Q. (1989): Corrosion of Dental Copper, Nickel, and Gold Alloys in Artificial Saliva and Saline Solutions, Dent Mater 5:324-328.

Wataha, J.C. ; Craig, R.G. ; and Hanks, C.T. (1989): Analysis of Culture Medium for Elements Dissolved from Casting Alloys, J Dent Res 68:322, Abst. No. 1121.

Wright, D.C. ; Gallant, R.F. ; and Spangberg, L. (1982): Correlation of Corrosion Behavior and Cytotoxicity in Au-Cu-Ag Ternary Alloys, J Biomed Mater Res 16:509-517.