Manufacturers generally quote indentation hardness values when predicting the clinical wear potential of newly introduced ceramic restoratives. The objective of this study was to determine whether in vitro two-body wear correlated well with hardness. A modified polisher was used to abrade enamel cylinders against polished disks of commercially available dental porcelains and glass. Enamel loss after four h was measured with a micrometer. Five ceramic materials were tested, and enamel abrasion rates were correlated with Knoop hardness values. Dicor and Dicor coated with a shading porcelain were found to cause the lowest wear of enamel. These rates were statistically significantly lower than those obtained with Optec, the most abrasive material. These findings may be due to microstructural differences between the materials. Knoop hardness showed poor correlation with the results of the abrasive testing.
Archard, J.F. (1953): Contact and Rubbing of Flat Surfaces, J Appl Physiol24:981-988.
3.
Babichev, M.A. (1962): Investigation of Abrasive Wear of Metals by the Brinnell Method. In: Friction and Wear in Machinery, Vol. 14 , M.M. Kruschov, Ed., ASME Translations, New York: American Society of Mechanical Engineering, pp. 1-29.
4.
Barreiro, M.M.; Riesgo, O.; and Vicente, E.E. (1989): Phase Identification in Dental Porcelains for Ceramo-metallic Restorations, Dent Mater5:51-57.
5.
Buckley, D.H. and Miyoshi, K. (1984): Friction and Wear of Ceramics, Wear100:333-353.
6.
Cho, S.-J., Hockey, B.J.; Lawn, B.R.; and Bennison, S.J. (1989): Grain-size and R-curve Effects in the Abrasive Wear of Alumina, J Am Ceram Soc72:1249-1252.
7.
Christensen, G.J. (1986): The Use of Porcelain-fused-to-metal Restorations in Current Dental Practice: A Survey, J Prosthet Dent56:1-3.
8.
Delong, R. and Douglas, W.H. (1983): Development of an Artificial Oral Environment for the Testing of Dental Restoratives: Biaxial Force and Movement Control , J Dent Res62:32-36.
9.
Delong, R.; Douglas, W.H.; Sakaguchi, R.L.; and Pintado, M.R. (1986): The Wear of Dental Porcelain in an Artificial Mouth, Dent Mater2:214-219.
10.
Delong, R.; Sakaguchi, R.L.; and Douglas, W.H. (1985): The Wear of Dental Amalgam in an Artificial Mouth: A Clinical Correlation, Dent Mater1:238-242.
11.
Delong, R.; Sasik, C.; Pintado, M.R.; and Douglas, W.H. (1989): The Wear of Enamel when Opposed by Ceramic Systems , Dent Mater5:266-271.
12.
Ekfeldt, A. and Øilo, G. (1988): Occlusal Contact Wear of Prosthodontic Materials , Acta Odontol Scand46:159-169.
13.
Evans, A.G. and Marshall, D.B. (1980): Wear Mechanisms in Ceramics. In: Fundamentals of Friction and Wear of Materials, D.A. Rigney, Ed., Metals Park, OH: American Society for Metals, pp. 439-452.
14.
Fischer, T.E.; Anderson, M.P.; and Jahanmir, S. (1989): Influence of Fracture Toughness on the Wear Resistance of Yttria-doped Zirconium Oxide, JAm Ceram Soc72:252-257.
15.
Fischer, T.E. and Tomizawa, H. (1985): Interaction of Microfracture and Tribochemistry in the Friction and Wear of Silicon Nitride, Wear105:29-45.
16.
Grossman, D.G. (1972): Machinable Glass-ceramics Based on Tetrasilicic Mica, JAm Ceram Soc55:446-449.
17.
Katz, S. (1989): High Strength Feldspathic Porcelains Containing Crystalline Leucite, U.S. Patent No. 4,798,536, Jan. 17.
18.
Lambrechts, P.; Braem, M.; and Vanherle, G. (1987): Evaluation of Clinical Performance for Posterior Composite Resin and Dental Adhesives, Oper Dent12:53-78.
19.
Levy, A.V. and Jee, N. (1988): Unlubricated Sliding Wear of Ceramic Materials , Wear121:363-380.
20.
Mahalick, J.A.; Knap, F.J.; and Weiter, E.J. (1971): Occlusal Wear in Prosthodontics, J Am Dent Assoc82:154-159.
21.
Miller, G.R.; Powers, J.M.; and Ludema, K.C. (1975): Frictional Behavior and Surface Failure of Dental Feldspathic Porcelain, Wear31:307-316.
22.
Monasky, G.E. and Taylor, D.F. (1971): Studies on the Wear of Porcelain, Enamel, and Gold, J Prosthet Dent25:299-306.
23.
Øilo, G. (1988): Flexural Strength and Internal Defects in some Dental Porcelains, Acta Odontol Scand46:313-322.
24.
Rice, R.W. (1985): Micromechanics of Microstructural Aspects of Ceramic Wear, Ceram Eng Sci Proc6:940-958.
25.
Rosenstiel, S.F.; Land, M.L.; and Fujimoto, J. (1988): Contemporary Fixed Prosthodontics, St. Louis: The C.V. Mosby Co., p. 301.
26.
Sakaguchi, R.L.; Douglas, W.H.; Delong, R.; and Pintado, M.R. (1986): The Wear of a Posterior Composite in an Artificial Mouth: a Clinical Correlation, Dent Mater2:235-240.
27.
Sen, R.; Dutta, S.; Das, S.K.; and Basu, S.K. (1989): Evaluation of a Glass-ceramic Coating for Machine Tool Slides, Wear130:249-260.
28.
Stachowiak, G.W. and Stachowiak, G.B. (1989): Unlubricated Friction and Wear Behavior of Toughened Zirconia Ceramics, Wear132:151-171.
29.
Stachowiak, G.W.; Stachowiak, G.B.; and Batchelor, A.W. (1989): Metallic Film Transfer during Metal-ceramic Unlubricated Sliding, Wear132:361-381.
30.
Tillitson, E.W.; Craig, R.G.; and Payton, F.A. (1971): Friction and Wear of Restorative Dental Materials , J Dent Res50:149-154.
31.
Weinstein, M.; Katz, S.; and Weinstein, A.B. (1962): Fused Porcelain-to-metal Teeth. U.S. Patent No. 3,052,982, Sept. 11.
32.
Wiley, M.G. (1989): Effects of Porcelain on Occluding Surfaces of Restored Teeth, J Prosthet Dent61:133-137.
33.
Wu, C.C.M. and Rice, R.W. (1985): Porosity Dependence of Wear and Other Mechanical Properties on Fine-grain Al2O3 and B4C, Ceram Eng Sci Proc6:977-994.
34.
Wu, C.C.M.; Rice, R.W.; Johnson, D.; and Platt, B.A. (1985): Grain Size Dependence of Wear in Ceramics, Ceram Eng Sci Proc6:995-1011.
35.
Yust, C.S. and Carignan, F.J. (1985): Observations on the Sliding Wear of Ceramics, ASLE Trans28:245-252.
