Recent clinical and laboratory evidence has suggested that systemic fluoride plays a more minor role in caries inhibition than was previously believed. This paper reviews clinical data on water fluoridation, the topical administration of fluorides, and fluoride supplements in the light of more recent understanding of the disease dental caries. Due to reduced functional usage, erupting teeth tend to accumulate plaque which has cariogenic potential. For this reason, the period from tooth emergence to the establishment of interproximal contact and full occlusion is the most critical for caries initiation. Analyses of clinical data indicate that maximum protection against caries is obtained when teeth erupt into an environment with low concentrations of ionic fluoride. The similarity in caries reductions obtained in water fluoridation studies and long-term studies with topically administered fluoride regimens, including fluoride-containing dentifrices, indicates that the pre-eruptive effect of fluoride is of borderline significance relative to the more significant post-eruptive effect. Water fluoridation and topical fluoride programs are thus important measures for the control of caries at the community level. For the individual, topical application of fluoride is seen as an integral part of caries treatment aimed at arresting progressive caries. Fluoride application is thus considered a supportive therapy, in conjunction with cariogenic plaque control. Daily use of fluoridated dentifrices from tooth eruption is more efficacious than daily use of fluoride supplements from birth.
ARMSTRONGW.D., and BREKHUSP. (1938): Possible Relationship Between the Fluoride Content of Enamel and Resistance to Dental Caries, J Dent Res17: 393–399.
3.
ARNOLDF.A.; DEANH.T.; and KNUTSONJ.W. (1953): Effect of Fluoridated Public Water Supplies on Dental Caries Prevalence. Results of the Seventh Year of Study at Grand Rapids and Muskegon, Mich., Publ Health Rep68: 141–148.
4.
ARNOLDF.A.; LIKINSR.C.; RUSSELLA.L.; and SCOTTD.B. (1962): Fifteen Years of the Grand Rapids Fluoridation Study, J Am Dent Assoc65: 780–785.
5.
ÅRTUNJ., and THYLSTRUPA. (1986): Clinical and Scanning Electron Microscopic Study of Surface Changes of Incipient Enamel Lesions after Debonding, Scand J Dent Res94: 193–201.
6.
ÅRTUNJ., and THYLSTRUPA. (1989): A Three-Year Clinical and SEM Study of Surface Changes of Carious Enamel Lesions after Inactivation, Am J Ortho Dentofac Orthop95: 327–333.
7.
BACKER DIRKSO. (1965): The Distribution of Caries in Relation to Tooth Surfaces. In: Caries Resistant Teeth, Wolsten-holmeG.E.W., and O'ConnorM., Eds., London: J. & A. Churchill, pp. 66–85.
BIRKELANDJ.M.; BROCHL.; and JORKJENDL. (1977): Benefits and Prognoses Following 10 Years of a Fluoride Mouthrinsing Program, Scand J Dent Res85: 31–37.
BISCHOFFJ.I.; VAN DER MERWEE.H.M.; RETIEFD.H.; BARBAKOWF.H.; and CLEATON-JONESP.E. (1976): Relationship Between Fluoride Concentrations in Enamel, DMFT Index, and Degree of Fluorosis in a Community Residing in an Area with a High Level of Fluoride, J Dent Res55: 37–42
17.
BLACKG.V. (1908): A Work on Operative Dentistry, Vol. 1, The Pathology of the Hard Tissues of the Teeth, Chicago: Med-ico-Dental Publishing Company.
18.
BLACKG.V., and McKAYF.S. (1916): Mottled Teeth: An Endemic Developmental Imperfection of the Enamel of the Teeth, Heretofore Unknown in the Literature of Dentistry, Dent Cosmos58: 129–156.
19.
BRATTHALLD. (1986): Current Status of Caries Activity Tests. In: Textbook of Cariology, ThylstrupA., and FejerskovO., Eds., Copenhagen: Munksgaard, pp. 249–265.
20.
BROWNW.E., and KÖNIGK.G., Eds. (1977): Cariostatic Mechanisms of Fluoride, Caries Res11 (Suppl 1).
21.
BRUNELLEJ.A., and CARLOSJ.P. (1982): Changes in the Prevalence of Dental Caries in U.S. Schoolchildren, 1961-1980, J Dent Res61 (Spec Iss): 1346–1351.
22.
BRUUNC., and GIVSKOVH. (1979): Fluoride Concentrations in Saliva in Relation to Chewing of Various Supplementary Fluoride Preparations, Scand J Dent Res87: 1–6.
23.
BRUUNC.; GIVSKOVH.; and THYLSTRUPA. (1984): Whole Saliva Fluoride After Toothbrushing with NaF and MFP Dentifrices with Different F Concentrations, Caries Res18: 282–288.
24.
BRUUNC.; LAMBROUD.; LARSENM.J.; FEJERSKOVO.; and THYLSTRUPA. (1982): Fluoride in Mixed Human Saliva After Different Topical Fluoride Treatments and Possible Relation to Caries Inhibition, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol10: 124–129.
25.
BRUUNC.; POULSENS.; ØSTERGAARDV.; and HØJBJERGR. (1983): Preeruptive Acquisition of Fluoride by Surface Enamel of Permanent Teeth after Daily Use of F Supplements, Caries Res17: 89–91.
26.
BRUUNC.; QVISTV.; and THYLSTRUPA. (1987): Effect of Flavour and Detergent on Fluoride Availability in Whole Saliva after Use of NaF and MFP Dentifrices, Caries Res21: 427–434.
27.
BRUUNC., and THYLSTRUPA. (1984): Fluoride in Whole Saliva and Dental Caries Experience in Areas with High and Low Concentrations of Fluoride in the Drinking Water, Caries Res18: 450–456.
28.
BRUUNC., and THYLSTRUPA. (1988): Dentifrice Usage Among Danish Children, J Dent Res67: 1114–1117.
29.
CARLOSJ.P., and GITTELSOHNA.M. (1965): Longitudinal Studies of the Natural History of Caries. II. A Life-table Study of Caries Incidence in Permanent Teeth, Arch Oral Biol10: 739–751.
30.
CARVALHOJ.C.; EKSTRANDK.R.; and THYLSTRUPA. (1989): Dental Plaque and Caries on Occlusal Surfaces of First Permanent Molars in Relation to Stage of Eruption, J Dent Res68: 773–779.
31.
DayC.D.M., and SEDWICKH.J. (1935): Studies on the Incidence of Dental Caries, Dent Cosmos77: 442–452.
32.
DEANH.T.; ARNOLDF.A.; and ELVOVEE. (1942): Domestic Water and Dental Caries, Publ Health Rep57: 1155–1179.
33.
DEANH.T., and ELVOVEE. (1936): Some Epidemiological Aspects of Chronic Endemic Dental Fluorosis, Am J Public Health26: 567–575.
34.
DEPAOLAP.F.; BRUDEVOLDF.; AASENDENR.; MORENOE.C.; ENGLANDERH.; BAKHOSY.; BOOKSTEINF.; and WARRAMJ. (1975): A Pilot Study of the Relationship Between Caries Experience and Surface Enamel Fluoride in Man, Arch Oral Biol20: 859–864.
35.
DOWNERM.C.; HOLLOWAYP.J.; and DAVIEST.G.H. (1976): Clinical Testing of a Topical Fluoride Caries Prevention Programme, Br Dent J141: 242–247.
36.
DRIESSENSF.C.M. (1982): Mineral Aspects of Dentistry, Mono-gr Oral Sci, Vol. 10, Basel: S. Karger.
37.
DRISCOLLW.S. (1974): The Use of Fluoride Tablets for the Prevention of Dental Caries. In: International Workshop on Fluorides and Dental Caries Reduction, ForresterD.J., and SchulzE.M., Eds., Baltimore: University of Maryland, School of Dentistry, pp. 25–111.
38.
DRISCOLLW.S. (1981): A Review of the Clinical Research on the Use of Prenatal Fluoride Administration for Prevention of Dental Caries, J Dent Child48: 109–117.
39.
DRISCOLLW.S.; SWANGOP.A.; HOROWITZA.M.; and KINGMANA. (1982): Caries-preventive Effect of Daily and Weekly Fluoride Mouthrinsing in a Fluoridated Community: Findings After 30 Months, J Am Dent Assoc105: 1010–1013.
40.
DUNNINGJ.M. (1970): Principles of Dental Public Health, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
41.
EDGARW.M. (1978): In vivo Experimental Human Caries. In: Methods of Caries Prediction, BibbyB.G., and ShernR.J., Eds., Washington, D.C.: IRL Press, pp. 245–252.
ERICSSONY. (1980): Fluorides: State of the Art, J Dent Res59 (Spec Iss, Part II): 2131–2136.
44.
EVANSC.A. (1978): Postnatal Development of the Human Face and Dentition. In: Textbook of Oral Biology, ShawJ.H., SweeneyE.A., CappuccinoC.C., and MellerS.M., Eds., Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders Co., pp. 109–142.
45.
FANNINGE.A.; CELLIERK.M.; LEADBEATERM.M.; and SOMERVILLECM. (1975): South Australian Kindergarten Children. Fluoride Tablet Supplements and Dental Caries, Aust Dent J20: 7–9.
46.
GEDDESD.A.M.; COOKEJ.H.; EDGARW.M.; and JENKINSG.N. (1978): The Effect of Frequent Sucrose Mouthrinsing on the Induction in vivo of Caries-like Changes in Human Dental Enamel, Arch Oral Biol23: 663–665.
47.
HALSE., and SIMONSENT.L. (1972): Histopathology of Experimental in vivo Caries Around Silver Amalgam Fillings, Caries Res6: 16–33.
48.
HAMBERGL. (1971): Controlled Trial of Fluoride in Vitamin Drops for Prevention of Caries in Children, Lancet1: 441–442.
49.
HENNOND.K.; STOOKEYG.K.; and MUHLERJ.C. (1970): The Clinical Anticariogenic Effectiveness of Supplementary Fluoride-Vitamin Preparations. Results at the End of Five and a Half Years, J Pharm Ther Dent1: 1–6.
50.
HENNOND.K.; STOOKEYG.K.; and MUHLERJ.C. (1972): Prophylaxis of Dental Caries: Relative Effectiveness of Chewable Fluoride Preparations with and without Added Vitamins, J Pediat80: 1018–1021.
51.
HODGEH.C.; HOLLOWAYP.J.; DAVIEST.G.H.; and WORTHINGTONH.V. (1980): Caries Prevention by Dentifrices Containing a Combination of Sodium Monofluorophosphate and Sodium Fluoride, Br Dent J149: 201–204.
52.
HOLMENL. (1987): A Scanning Electron Microscope Study of Approximal Premolar Surfaces from Fifteen-year-old Children Living in a Fluoridated Community, Scanning Electron Microsc1: 2019–2024.
53.
HOLMENL.; MEJÁREJ.; MALMGRENB.; and THYLSTRUPA. (1988): The Effect of Regular Professional Plaque Removal on Dental Caries in vivo. A Polarized Light and Scanning Electron Microscope Study, Caries Res22: 250–256.
54.
HOLMENL., and THYLSTRUPA. (1984): Variations in ‘Normal’ Enamel Surfaces as Visualized in the SEM. In: Tooth Morphogenesis and Differentiation II, BelcourtA.B., and RuchJ.-V., Eds., Strasbourg: INSERM, Vol. 125, pp. 283–294.
55.
HOLMENL., and THYLSTRUPA. (1986): Natural Caries Development and Its Arrestment. In: Factors Relating to Demineralisation and Remineralisation of the Teeth, LeachS.A., Ed., Oxford: IRL Press Ltd, pp. 139–152.
56.
HOLMENL.; THYLSTRUPA.; and ÅRTUNJ. (1987a): Clinical and Histological Features Observed during Arrestment of Active Enamel Carious Lesions in vivo, Caries Res21: 546–554.
57.
HOLMENL.; THYLSTRUPA.; and ÅRTUNJ. (1987b): Surface Changes During the Arrest of Active Enamel Carious Lesions in vivo. A Scanning Electron Microscope Study, Acta Odontol Scand45: 383–390.
58.
HOLMENL.; THYLSTRUPA.; ØGAARDB.; and KRAGHF. (1985a): A Polarized Light Microscopic Study of Progressive Stages of Enamel Caries in vivo, Caries Res19: 348–354.
59.
HOLMENL.; THYLSTRUPA.; ØGAARDB.; and KRAGHF. (1985b): A Scanning Electron Microscopic Study of Progressive Stages of Enamel Caries in vivo, Caries Res19: 355–367.
60.
HOPET. (1979): Results of 10 Years of Supervised Fluoride Tooth-brushing in Rygge, Norway, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol7: 330–334.
61.
HOWATA.P.; HOLLOWAYP.J.; and DAVIEST.G.H. (1978): Caries Prevention by Daily Supervised Use of MFP Gel Dentifrice. Report of a 3-Year Clinical Trial, Br Dent J145: 233–235.
62.
KEENEH.J.; GROSSMANF.D.; PEDERSONE.D.; MELLBERGJ.R.; and NICHOLSONC.R. (1975): Caries Experience and Fluoride Concentration of Surface Enamel in Dental Fluorosis Patients, Caries Res9: 247–250.
63.
KLEINH. (1945): Dental Caries Experience in Relocated Children Exposed to Water Containing Fluorine. I. Incidence of New Caries after 2 Years of Exposure among Previously Caries-free Permanent Teeth, Publ Health Rep60: 1462–1467.
64.
KLEINH. (1946): Dental Caries (DMF). Experience in Relocated Children Exposed to Water Containing Fluorine II, J Am Dent Assoc33: 1136–1141.
65.
KNUTSONJ.W., and ARMSTRONGW.D. (1943): Effect of Topically Applied Sodium Fluoride on Dental Caries Experience, Publ Health Rep58: 1701–1715.
LARSENM.J., and THORSENA. (1974): Fluoride and Enamel Solubility, Scand J Dent Res82: 455–461.
68.
LUDWIGT.G. (1965): The Hastings Fluoridation Project V. Dental Effects between 1954 and 1964, N Z Dent J61: 175–179.
69.
MARGOLISF.J.; MACAULEYJ.; and FRESHMANE. (1967): The Effects of Measured Doses of Fluoride, Am J Dis Child113: 670–672.
70.
MARGOLISH.C.; MORENOE.C.; and MURPHYB.J. (1986): Effect of Low Levels of Fluoride in Solution on Enamel Demineralization, J Dent Res65: 23–29.
71.
MARSHP.D., and MARTINM.V. (1984): Oral Microbiology, Sunbury on Thames: Nelson.
72.
MARTHALERT.M. (1971): Confidence Limits of Results of Clinical Caries Tests with Fluoride Administration, Caries Res5: 343–372.
73.
MARTHALERT.M. (1979): Fluoride Supplements for Systemic Effects in Caries Prevention. In: Continuing Evaluation of the Use of Fluorides, JohansenE., TavesD.R., and OlsenT.O., Eds., AAAS Selected Symposium 11, Colorado: Westview Press, pp. 33–59.
74.
MARTHALERT. (1988): Clinical Effects of Various Fluoride Methods and Programs. In: Fluoride in Dentistry, EkstrandJ., FejerskovO., and SilverstoneL.M., Eds., Copenhagen: Munks-gaard, pp. 252–275.
75.
McCANNH.G. (1968): Inorganic Components of Saliva Secretions. In: Art and Science of Dental Caries Research, HarrisR.S., Ed., New York: Academic Press, pp. 55–73.
76.
McCLUREF.J. (1948): Fluorine in Dentin and Enamel of Sound and Carious Teeth, J Dent Res27: 287–298.
77.
McCLUREF.J. (1950): Fluorine, Ash, Calcium and Phosphorus in Human Teeth, J Dent Res29: 315–319.
78.
McCLUREF.J., and LIKINSR.C. (1951): Fluorine in Human Teeth Studied in Relation to Fluorine in the Drinking Water, J Dent Res30: 172–176.
79.
MELLBERGJ.R. (1977): Enamel Fluoride and its Anticaries Effects, J Prev Dent4: 8–20.
80.
MELLBERGJ.R., and SINGERL. (1977): Assimilation of Fluoride by Enamel Throughout the Life of the Tooth. Discussion, Caries Res11 (Suppl 1):101–115.
81.
MILLERW.D. (1890): The Micro-Organisms of the Human Mouth. Unaltered reprint, Basel: Karger (1973).
82.
MØLLERI.J. (1965): Dental Fluorose og caries. En undersøgelse over litteraturen samt nogle epidemiologiske undersøgelser af danske børn. Thesis, Copenhagen: Rhodos.
83.
NANCOLLASG.H. (1983): Kinetics of Demineralisation and Remineralisation. In: Demineralisation and Remineralisation of the Teeth, LeachS.A., and EdgarW.M., Eds., London: IRL Press Ltd., pp. 113–128.
84.
NAYLORM.N., and MURRAYJ.J. (1983): Fluorides and Dental Caries. In: The Prevention of Dental Disease, MurrayJ.J., Ed., Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 83–158.
85.
NEWBRUNE., and BRUDEVOLDF. (1960): Studies on the Physical Properties of Fluorosed Enamel. I. Microradiographic Studies, Arch Oral Biol2: 15–20.
NYGAARD ÖSTBYB.; MÖRCHT.; and HALSE. (1957): A Method for Caries Production in Selected Tooth Surfaces in vivo-Employed in a Preliminary Study of the Caries-Inhibiting Effect of Topically Applied Agents, Acta Odontol Scand15: 357–363.
88.
ØGAARDB.; RÖLLAG.; and HELGELANDK. (1983): Alkali Soluble and Alkali Insoluble Fluoride Retention in Demineralized Enamel in vivo, Scand J Dent Res91: 200–204.
89.
PETTERSONE.O. (1979): Attitudes Concerning Water Fluoridation among Graduating Swedish Dentists, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol1: 69–14.
90.
POULSENS., and LARSENM.J. (1975): Dental Caries in Relation to Fluoride Content of Enamel in the Primary Dentition, Caries Res9: 59–65.
91.
RETIEFD.H.; HARRISB.E.; and BRADLEYE.L. (1987): Relationship Between Enamel Fluoride Concentration and Dental Caries Experience, Caries Res21: 68–78.
92.
RICHARDSA.; LARSENM.J.; FEJERSKOVO.; and THYL-STRUPA. (1977): Fluoride Content of Buccal Surface Enamel and its Relation to Dental Caries in Children, Arch Oral Biol22: 425–428.
93.
RUGG-GUNNA.J.; HOLLOWAYP.J.; and DAVIEST.G.H. (1973): Caries Prevention by Daily Fluoride Mouthrinsing, Br Dent J135: 353–366.
94.
RUSSELLA.L., and WHITEC.L. (1961): Dental Caries in Maryland Children After 7 Years of Fluoridation, Publ Health Rep76: 1087–1093.
95.
SHERNR.J.; DRISCOLLW.S.; and KORTSD.C. (1977): Enamel Biopsy Results of Children Receiving Fluoride Tablets, J Am Dent Assoc95: 310–314.
96.
TEN CATEJ.M., and DUIJSTERSP.P.E. (1983): Influence of Fluoride in Solution on Tooth Demineralization II. Microradiographic Data, Caries Res17: 513–519.
97.
THYLSTRUPA. (1981): Is There a Biological Rationale for Prenatal Fluoride Administration?, J Dent Child48: 103–108.
98.
THYLSTRUPA.; BILLEJ.; and BRUUNC. (1982): Caries Prevalence in Danish Children Living in Areas with Low and Optimal Levels of Natural Water Fluoride, Caries Res16: 413–420.
99.
THYLSTRUPA.; CHIRONGAL.; DE CARVALHOJ.; and EKSTRANDK.R. (1989): The Occurrence of Dental Calculus in Occlusal Fissures as an Indication of Caries Activity. In: Dental Calculus, ten CateJ.M., Ed., London: IRL Press, pp. 211–222.
100.
THYLSTRUPA.; FEATHERSTONEJ.D.B.; and FREDEBOL. (1983): Surface Morphology and Dynamics of Early Enamel Caries Development. In: Demineralisation and Remineralisation of the Teeth, LeachS.A., and EdgarW.M., Eds., London: IRL Press, pp. 165–184.
101.
THYLSTRUPA., and FEJERSKOVO. (1978): Clinical Appearance of Dental Fluorosis in Permanent Teeth in Relation to Histological Changes, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol6: 315–328.
102.
THYLSTRUPA.; FEJERSKOVO.; BRUUNC.; and KANNJ. (1979): Enamel Changes and Dental Caries in 7-Year-Old Children Given Fluoride Tablets from Shortly after Birth, Caries Res13: 265–276.
103.
THYLSTRUPA., and FREDEBOL. (1982): A Method for Studying Surface Coatings and the Underlying Enamel Features in the Scanning Electron Microscope. In: Surface and Colloid Phenomena in the Oral Cavity: Methodological Aspects, FrankR.M., and LeachS.A., Eds., London: IRL Press, pp. 169–184.
104.
TIJMSTRAT.; BRINKMAN-ENGELSM.; and GROENEVELDA. (1978): Effects of Socioeconomic Factors on the Observed Caries Reduction after Fluoride Tablet and Fluoride Toothpaste Consumption, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol6: 227–230.
105.
TORELLP., and RIBELIUSU. (1973): Kariesbenägenheten hos 13-âringer i Göteborg och Uppsala, Tandläkartidningen65: 1298–1304.
106.
YON DER FEHRF.R. (1965): Maturation and Remineralisation of Enamel, Adv Fluorine Res3: 83–95.
107.
VON DER FEHRF.R.; LÖEH.; and THEILADEE. (1970): Experimental Caries in Man, Caries Res4: 131–148.
108.
WEATHERELLJ.A.; DEUTSCHD.; ROBINSONC.; and HALLSWORTHA.S. (1977): Assimilation of Fluoride by Enamel Throughout the Life of the Tooth, Caries Res11 (Suppl 1):85–101.
109.
WEATHERELLJ.A.; STRONGM.; ROBINSONC.; and RALPHJ.P. (1986): Fluoride Distribution in the Mouth After Fluoride Rinsing, Caries Res20: 111–119.
110.
WIDENHEIMJ. (1985): On Fluoride Tablets, Thesis, Malmø: In-fotryck ab.
111.
WILLIAMSJ.L. (1923): Mottled Enamel and Other Studies of Normal and Pathological Conditions of this Tissue, J Dent Res5: 117–195.
112.
ZEROD.T.; FuJ.; ESPELANDM.A.; and FEATHERSTONEJ.D.B. (1988): Comparison of Fluoride Concentrations in Unstimulated Whole Saliva Following Use of a Fluoride Dentifrice and a Fluoride Rinse, J Dent Res67: 1257–1262.
