Despite a considerable amount of literature on the effects of fluoride in dental plaque, several urgent questions remain unanswered, such as: Does the inhibiting effect of fluoride on dental plaque metabolism contribute to caries prevention? Does adaptation of plaque to fluoride affect its cariogenicity?
Single applications of fluoride directly to dental plaque reduced acid production. Also, fluoride dissolving from topically treated enamel reduced the acid production in covering layers of oral bacteria in vitro. The effects of both treatments were only of short duration and may not be relevant to caries prevention in vivo. In contrast, daily applications of fluoride resulted in a reduction of the acidogenicity of dental plaque even 8–12 h after the treatment. Such a reduction is likely to contribute to caries prevention. But it has to be realized that when plaque reaches saturation with respect to fluoridated calcium (phosphate) precipitates, enamel becomes insoluble and any antimicrobial effect becomes irrelevant. Still lacking are data on the antimicrobial effects of fluoride regimens normally used in home care, in weekly rinsing programs in schools, or treatments applied professionally every six months.
Adaptation of Streptococcus mutans to fluoride has been suggested to reduce the cariogenic potential of the cells. In vitio-induced fluoride-resistant strains were less cariogenic in rats, and the velocity of acid production in vitro was reduced at constant pH > 5.5. Despite the ability of oral bacteria to adapt to fluoride, evidence of adaptation in dental plaque of normal subjects resulting in a reduced cariogenic potential has not yet been demonstrated.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AGUSH.M.; SCHAMSCHULAR.G.; BARMESD.E.; and BRUNZELM. (1976): Associations between the Total Fluoride Content of Dental Plaque and Individual Caries Experience in Australian Children, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol4: 210–214.
2.
ARENDSJ.; CHRISTOFFERSENJ.; CHRISTOFFERSENM.R.; and SCHUTHOFJ. (1983): Influence of Fluoride Concentration on the Progress of Demineralization in Bovine Enamel at pH 4.5, Canes Res17: 455–457.
3.
BIBBYB.G., and FuJ. (1986): Effects of Fluorides on in vitro Acid Production by Dental Plaque, J Dent Res65: 686–688.
4.
BIBBYB.G., and VAN KESTERENM. (1940): The Effect of Fluorine on Mouth Bacteria, J Dent Res19: 391–402.
5.
BILLINGSR.J.; MEYEROWITZC.; FEATHERSTONEJ.D.B.; ESPELANDM.A.; FuJ.; COOPERL.F.; and PROSKINH.M. (1988): Retention of Topical Fluoride in the Mouths of Xerostomic Subjects, Caries Res22: 306–310.
6.
BRINERW.W., and FRANCISM.D. (1962): The Effect of Enamel Fluoride on Acid Production by Lactobacillus casei, Arch Oral Biol7: 541–550.
7.
BROWNL.R.; WHITEJ.O.; HORTONI.M.; DREIZENS.; and STRECKFUSSJ.L. (1983): Effect of Continuous Fluoride Gel Use on Plaque Fluoride Retention and Microbial Activity, J Dent Res62: 746–751.
8.
BROWNL.R.; WHITEJ.O.; HORTONI.M.; PERKINSD.H.; STRECKFUSSJ.L.; and DREIZENS. (1981): Effects of a Single Application of Sodium Fluoride Gel on Dental Plaque Acidogenesis, J Dent Res60: 1396–1402.
BRUUNC., and STOLTZEK. (1976): In vivo Uptake of Fluoride by Surface Enamel of Cleaned and Plaque-covered Teeth, Scand J Dent Res84: 268–275.
11.
CHARLTONG.; BLAINEYB.; and SCHAMSCHULAR.G. (1974): Associations between Dental Plaque and Fluoride in Human Surface Enamel, Arch Oral Biol19: 139–143.
12.
CLARKSONB.; FEJERSKOVO.; SILVERSTONEL.M.; and EKSTRANDJ. (1988): Rational Use of Fluorides in Caries Prevention and Treatment. In: Fluoride in Dentistry, EkstrandJ., FejerskovO., and SilverstoneL.M., Eds., Copenhagen: Munks-gaard, pp. 276–288.
13.
DIJKMANA.G.; DE BOERP.; and ARENDSJ. (1983): In vivo Investigation on the Fluoride Content in and on Human Enamel after Topical Applications, Caries Res17: 392–402.
14.
DIJKMANA.G.; TakJ.; and ARENDSJ. (1982): Fluoride Deposited by Topical Applications in Enamel. KOH Soluble and Acquired Fluoride, Caries Res16: 147–155.
15.
EDGARW.M.; COCKBURNM.A.; and JENKINSG.N. (1981): Uptake of Fluoride and its Inhibitory Effects in Oral Microorganisms in Culture, Arch Oral Biol26: 615–623.
16.
EDGARW.M.; JENKINSG.N.; and TATEVOSSIANA. (1970): The Inhibitory Action of Fluoride on Plaque Bacteria. Further Evidence, Br Dent J124: 129–132.
17.
EISENBERGA.D., and SPITZL.M. (1987): Fluoride Resistance in Oral Streptococci: Acid Production, J Dent Res66:148, Abst. No. 330.
18.
EISENBERGA.D., and SPITZL.M. (1988): Characteristics of Fluoride-resistant Mutans Streptococci, Abstract 71, ORCA.
19.
EISENBERGA.D.; WEGMANM.R.; OLDERSHAWM.D.; and CURZONM.E.J. (1985): Effect of Fluoride, Lithium or Strontium on Acid Production by Pelleted Human Dental Plaque, Caries Res19: 454–457.
20.
GEDDESD.A.M., and McNEES.G. (1982): The Effect of 0.2 per cent (48 mM) NaF Rinses Daily on Human Plaque Acidogenicity in situ (Stephan Curve) and Fluoride Content, Arch Oral Biol27: 765–769.
21.
GREENG.E., and DODDM.C. (1957): Resistance of Oral Lactobacilli to Sodium Fluoride, J Am Dent Assoc54: 654–656.
22.
GRØNP.; YaoK.; and SPINELLIM. (1969): A Study of Inorganic Constituents in Dental Plaque, J Dent Res48: 799–805.
23.
HAMILTONI.R. (1969): Growth Characteristics of Adapted and Ultraviolet-induced Mutants of Streptococcus salivarius Resistant to Sodium Fluoride, Can J Microbiol15: 287–295.
24.
HAMILTONI.R. (1977): Effects of Fluoride on Enzymatic Regulation of Bacterial Carbohydrate Metabolism, Caries Res11 (Suppl. 1):262–291.
25.
HAMILTONI.R., and BOWDENG.H. (1982): Response of Freshly Isolated Strains of Streptococcus mutans and Streptococcus mitior to Change in pH in the Presence and Absence of Fluoride during Growth in Continuous Culture, Infect Immun36: 255–262.
26.
HAMILTONI.R., and BOWDENG.H. (1988): Effect of Fluoride on Oral Microorganisms. In: Fluoride in Dentistry, EkstrandJ., FejerskovO., and SilverstoneL.M., Eds., Copenhagen: Munks-gaard, pp. 77–103.
27.
HAMILTONI.R.; BOYARR.M.; and BOWDENG.H. (1985): Influence of pH and Fluoride on Properties of an Oral Strain of Lactobacillus casei Grown in Continuous Culture, Infect Immun48: 664–670.
28.
HARDWICKJ.L. (1970): Associations between Plaque Fluoride Concentrations and other Parameters. In: Dental Plaque, McHughW.D., Ed., Edinburgh: Livingstone, pp. 171–178.
29.
HARPERD.S., and LOESCHEW.J. (1986): Inhibition of Acid Production from Oral Bacteria by Fluorapatite-derived Fluoride, J Dent Res65: 30–33.
30.
HAYESM.L., and HYATTA.T. (1974): The Decarboxylation of Amino Acids by Bacteria Derived from Human Dental Plaque, Arch Oral Biol19: 361–369.
31.
HELLWIGE.; KLIMEKJ.; SCHMIDTH.F.M.; and EGERERR. (1985): Fluoride Uptake in Plaque-covered Enamel after Treatment with the Fluoride Lacquer Duraphat, J Dent Res64: 1080–1083.
32.
HELLWIGE.; KLIMEKJ.; and WAGNERH. (1987): The Influence of Plaque on Reaction Mechanisms of MFP and NaF in vivo, J Dent Res66: 46–49.
33.
JENKINSG.N., and EDGARW.M. (1969): The Distribution and Metabolic Effects of Human Plaque Fluorine, Arch Oral Biol14: 105–119.
34.
JENKINSG.N., and EDGARW.M. (1977): Distribution and Forms of F in Saliva and Plaque, Caries Res11 (Suppl. 1):226–237.
35.
JENSENM.E. (1985): The Effect of Sodium Fluoride on Human Interproximal Plaque pH Responses to 10% Sucrose, Caries Res19: 157, Abst. No. 14.
36.
JOYSTON-BECHALS.; DUCKWORTHR.; and BRADENM. (1976): The Effect of Artificially Produced Pellicle and Plaque on the Uptake of 18F by Human Enamel in vitro, Arch Oral Biol21: 73–78.
37.
KASHKETS.; RODRIGUEZV.M.; and BUNICKF.J. (1977): Inhibition of Glucose Utilization in Oral Streptococci by Low Concentrations of Fluoride, Caries Res11: 301–307.
38.
KLEINBERGI. (1967): Effect of Urea Concentrations on Human Plaque pH Levels in situ, Arch Oral Biol12: 1475–1484.
39.
KLEINBERGI.; CHATTERJEER.; REDDYJ.; and CRAWD. (1977): Effects of Fluoride on the Metabolism of the Mixed Oral Flora, Caries Res11 (Suppl. 1):292–320.
40.
LOESCHEW.J. (1982): Dental Caries. A Treatable Infection, Springfield, IL: C.C. Thomas, pp. 477–478.
41.
LUOMAH., and LUOMAA.-R. (1982): Differences in pH Fall, Phosphorus Content and Dissolution of Enamel in Layers of the Oral Bacterium Streptococcus mutans Deposited in vitro on Bovine Enamel Granules with and without Fluoride Varnish, Arch Oral Biol27: 1003–1006.
42.
LUOMAH.; LUOMAA.-R.; and SEPPÄL. (1984): Exchange of Fluoride between Bovine Enamel and the Surface-related Cells of the Oral Bacterium Streptococcus mutans, Arch Oral Biol29: 343–348.
43.
MALTZM., and EMILSONCG. (1982): Susceptibility of Oral Bacteria to Various Fluoride Salts, J Dent Res61: 786–790.
44.
MARGOLISH.C.; MORENOE.C.; and MURPHYB.J. (1986): Effects of Low Levels of Fluoride in Solution on Enamel Demineralization in vitro, J Dent Res65: 23–29.
45.
McNEES.G.; GEDDESD.A.M.; MAINC.; and GILLESPIEF.C. (1980): Measurements of the Diffusion Coefficient of NaF in Human Dental Plaque in vitro, Arch Oral Biol25: 819–823.
46.
MELLBERGJ.R.; LAAKSOP.V.; and NICHOLSONC.R. (1966): The Acquisition and Loss of Fluoride by Topically Fluoridated Human Tooth Enamel, Arch Oral Biol11: 1213–1220.
47.
MORENOE.C., and MARGOLISH.C. (1988): Composition of the Human Plaque Fluid, J Dent Res67: 1181–1189.
48.
NEFFD. (1967): Acid Production from Different Carbohydrate Sources in Human Plaque in situ, Caries Res1: 78–87.
49.
ØGAARDB.; GAFFARA.; BAHLM.K.; RØLLAG.; and HELGELANDK. (1985): Fluoride Retention in Clean and Plaque-covered Demineralized Enamel in vivo after Application of Monofluorophosphate, Scand J Dent Res93: 486–493.
50.
RØLLAG., and ØGAARDB. (1986): Studies on the Solubility of Calcium Fluoride in Human Saliva. In: Factors Relating to Demineralisation of the Teeth, LeachS.A., Ed., Oxford: IRL Press Ltd., pp. 45–50.
51.
ROSENS.; FREAJ.I.; and HsuS.M. (1978): Effect of Fluoride-resistant Microorganisms on Dental Caries, J Dent Res57: 180.
52.
RUGG-GUNNA.J.; EDGARW.M.; COCKBURNM.A.; and JENKINSG.N. (1981): Correlations between Fluoride Concentration, Sample Weight and Acid Production in Dental Plaque from Children, Arch Oral Biol26: 61–63.
53.
SEPPÄL. (1983): Effect of Dental Plaque on Fluoride Uptake by Enamel from a Sodium Fluoride Varnish in vivo, Caries Res17: 71–75.
54.
SHIELDSW.F., and MÜHLEMANNH.R. (1975): Simultaneous pH and Fluoride Telemetry from the Oral Cavity, Helv Odontol Acta19: 18–26.
55.
SISSONSC.H., and CUTRESST.W. (1988): pH Changes during Simultaneous Metabolism of Urea and Carbohydrate by Human Salivary Bacteria in vitro, Arch Oral Biol33: 579–587.
56.
TATEVOSSIANA. (1989): Fluoride in Dental Plaque and its Effects, J Dent Res (accepted for publication).
57.
TEN CATEJ.M., and DUIJSTERSP.P.E. (1983): Influence of Fluoride in Solution on Tooth Demineralization. I. Chemical Data, Caries Res17: 193–199.
58.
TINANOFFN.; WeiS.H.Y.; and PARKINSF.M. (1974): Effect of a Pumice Prophylaxis on Fluoride Uptake in Tooth Enamel, J Am Dent Assoc88: 385–389.
59.
VAN DER HOEVENJ.S., and FRANKENH.C.M. (1984): Effect of Fluoride on Growth and Acid Production by Streptococcus mutans in Dental Plaque, Infect Immun45: 356–359.
60.
VAN LOVERENC.; FIELMICHA.M.; and TEN BRINKB. (1987): Comparison of the Effects of Fluoride and the Ionophore Nigericin on Acid Production by Streptococcus mutans and the Resultant in vitro Enamel Demineralization, J Dent Res66: 1658–1662.
61.
VAN LOVERENC.; HUIS IN TVELDJ.H.J.; and TEN CATEJ.M. (1984): Interactions between Bacterial Metabolism and Enamel Demineralisation in an in vitro Caries Model. In: Bacterial Adhesion and Preventive Dentistry, Ten CateJ.M., LeachS.A., and ArendsJ., Eds., Oxford: IRL Press Ltd., pp. 207–220.
62.
VAN LOVERENC.; LAMMENSA.J.; and TEN CATEJ.M. (1989): In vitro-induced Fluoride Resistance of Streptococcus mutans and Dental Caries in Rats, Caries Res23: 358–364.
63.
VAN LOVERENC and TEN CATEJ.M. (1988): Effect of Fluoride on the Fluoride-tolerance and Establishment of Streptococcus mutans in Rats, Abstract 72, ORCA.
64.
VON KLIMEKJ.; HELLWIGE.; and AHRENSG. (1982): Der Einfluss von Plaque und die Aminfluorid in Kunstlichen Mund, Dtsch Zahnärztl Z37: 836–840.
65.
WILLIAMSR.A.D. (1964): The Effect of Sodium Fluoride upon Streptococcus faecalis of the Dental Plaque, Adv Fluorine Res Dent CarPrev3: 267–280.
66.
WOOLLEYL.H., and RICKLESN.H. (1971): Inhibition of Acidogenesis in Human Dental Plaque in situ Following the Use of Topical Sodium Fluoride, Arch Oral Biol16: 1187–1194.
67.
ZWEMERJ.D. (1957): Lactic Acid Formation by Lactobacilli exposed to Fluoridized Enamel, J Dent Res36: 182–191.
