This study describes the use of total genomic DNA fingerprinting with the use of restriction endonucleases to characterize clinical isolates of Porphyromonas gingivalis (Bacteroides gingivalis) obtained from patients with periodontitis or with root-canal infections. The majority of independent isolates had a unique DNA fingerprint, indicating extensive genetic heterogeneity within this species. Twenty-nine distinct DNA fingerprints were found among the 33 isolates investigated. This is in contrast to biotyping and serotyping, where only one type and three types, respectively, have been reported. The observed heterogeneity indicates that DNA fingerprinting is a sensitive measure of genetic dissimilarity between P. gingivalis isolates and is able to characterize individual isolates. These results have ecological implications, indicating that there is considerable natural diversity in the global population of P. gingivalis, and that there are likely to be relatively large numbers of genetically distinct clonal lines. Furthermore, DNA fingerprinting is a sensitive and powerful tool for longitudinal and cross-sectional epidemiological studies. This technique provides far greater discrimination between isolates than either biotyping or serotyping, and will be most helpful in, for example, the analysis of distribution of clonal lines within one periodontal patient, or the analysis of the transmission to and turnover of strain populations within a patient population, since the probability of two strains with the same DNA fingerprint being found by chance is small.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allan, I.; Loeb, M.R.; and Moxon, E.R. (1987): Limited Genetic Diversity of Haemophilus influenzae (type b), Microb Pathog2:139-145.
2.
Barua, P.K.; Dyer, D.W.; and Neiders, M.E. (1989): Response of Bacteroides gingivalis to Iron Limitation , J Dent Res68:358, Abst. No. 1415.
3.
Caufield, P.W. and Walker, T.M. (1989): Genetic Diversity within Streptococcus mutans Evident from Chromosomal DNA Restriction Fragment Polymorphisms, J Clin Microbiol27 :274-278.
4.
Christersson, L.A.; Zambon, J.J.; Dunford, R.G.; Grossi, S.G.; and Genco, R.J. (1989): Specific Subgingival Bacteria and Diagnosis of Gingivitis and Periodontitis, J Dent Res68:1633-1639.
5.
Coykendall, A.L.; Kaczmarek, F.S.; and Slots, J. (1980): Genetic Heterogeneity in Bacteroides asaccharolyticus (Holdeman and Moore 1970) (Finegold and Bames 1977) (Approved list, 1980) and Proposal of Bacteroides gingivalis sp. nov. and Bacteroides macacae (Slots and Genco) comb. nov., Int J Syst Bacteriol30 :559-564.
6.
Denning, D.W.; Baker, C.J.; Troup, N.J.; and Tompkins, L.S. (1989): Restriction Endonuclease Analysis of Human and Bovine Group B Streptococci for Epidemiological Study, J Clin Microbiol27:1352-1356.
7.
Dickinson, D.P.; Rivoli, P.S.; Brewster, J.M.; and Genco, R.J. (1987): Plasmids in Black-pigmented Members of the Genus Bacteroides, J Dent Res66:223, Abst. No. 933.
8.
Dickinson, D.P.; Loos, B.G.; Dryja, D.M.; and Bernstein, J.M. (1988): Restriction Fragment Mapping of Branhamella catarrhalis: A New Tool to Study the Epidemiology of this Middle Ear Pathogen, J Infect Dis158:205-208.
9.
Dzink, J.L.; Socransky, S.S.; and Haffajee, A.D. (1988): The Predominant Cultivable Microbiota of Active and Inactive Lesions of Destructive Periodontal Diseases, J Clin Periodontol15:316-323.
10.
Ebersole, J.L.; Taubman, M.A.; Smith, D.J.; and Frey, D.E. (1986): Human Immune Responses to Oral Microorganisms: Patterns of Systemic Antibody Levels to Bacteroides Species, Infect Immun51:507-513.
11.
Fisher, J.G.; Zambon, J.J.; and Genco, R.J. (1987): Identification of Serogroup-specific Antigens among Bacteroides gingivalis Components, J Dent Res66:222, Abst. No. 927.
12.
Fisher, J.G. and Zambon, J.J. (1989): The Effect of Hemin Concentration on the Outer Membrane of Bacteroides gingivalis, J Dent Res68:358, Abst. No. 1414.
13.
Goodson, J.M.; Tanner, A.C.R.; Haffajee, A.D.; Sor-Berger, G.C.; and Socransky, S.S. (1982): Patterns of Progression and Regression of Advanced Destructive Periodontal Disease, J Clin Periodontol9:427-481.
14.
Grenier, D. and Mayrand, D. (1987): Selected Characteristics of Pathogenic and Nonpathogenic Strains of Bacteroides gingivalis, J Clin Microbiol25:738-740.
15.
Grothues, D.; Koopmann, U.; Von Der Hardt, H.; and Tummler, B. (1988): Genome Fingerprinting of Pseudomonas aeruginosa Indicates Colonization of Cystic Fibrosis Siblings with Closely Related Strains , J Clin Microbiol26:1973-1977.
16.
Haapasalo, M.; Ranta, H.; Ranta, K.; and Shah, H. (1986): Black-pigmented Bacteroides spp. in Human Apical Periodontitis, Infect Immun53:149-153.
17.
Haffajee, A.D.; Socransky, S.S.; and Goodson, J.M. (1983): Comparison of Different Data Analyses for Detecting Changes in Attachment Levels, J Clin Periodontol10:513-521.
18.
Kulkarni, G.V.; Chan, K.H.; and Sandham, H.J. (1989): An Investigation into the Use of Restriction Endonuclease Analysis for the Study of Transmission of Mutans Streptococci, J Dent Res68:1155-1161.
19.
Laliberte, M. and Mayrand, D. (1983): Characterization of Black-pigmented Bacteroides Strains Isolated from Animals, JAppl Microbiol55:247-252.
20.
Langenberg, W.; Rauws, E.A.J.; Widjojokusumo, A.; Tytgat, G.N.J.; and Zanen, H.C. (1986): Identification of Campylobacter pyloridis Isolates by Restriction Endonuclease DNA Analysis, J Clin Microbiol24:414-417.
21.
Laughon, B.E.; Syed, S.A.; and Loesche, W.J. (1982): API ZYM System for Identification of Bacteroides spp., Capnocytophaga spp., and Spirochetes of Oral Origin, J Clin Microbiol15:97-102.
22.
Loesche, W.J.; Syed, S.A.; Schmidt, E.; and Morrison, E.C. (1985): Bacterial Profiles of Subgingival Plaques in Periodontitis , J Periodontol56:447-456.
Loos, B.G.; Bernstein, J.M.; Dryja, D.M.; Murphy, T.F.; and Dickinson, D.P. (1989b): Determination of the Epidemiology and Transmission of Nontypeable Haemophilus influenzae in Children with Otitis Media by Comparison of Total Genomic DNA Restriction Fingerprints, Infect Immun57:2751-2757.
25.
Loos, B.G.; Genco, R.J.; and Dickinson, D.P. (1989c): Epidemiology of Bacteroides gingivalis using DNA Restriction Fragment Pattern Analyses, J Dent Res68:985, Abst. No. 944.
26.
Maniatis, T.; Fritsch, E.F.; and Sambrook, J. (1982): Molecular Cloning: a Laboratory Manual, Cold Spring Harbor, NY: Cold Harbor Spring Laboratory .
27.
Mayrand, D. and Holt, S.C. (1988): Biology of Asaccharolytic Black-pigmented Bacteroides Species, Microbiol Rev52:134-152.
28.
Moore, W.E.C.; Ranney, R.R.; and Holdeman, L.V. (1982): Subgingival Microflora in Periodontal Disease: cultural studies. In: Host-parasite Interactions in Periodontal Disease, R.J. Genco and S. Mergenhagen, Eds., Washington, DC: American Society for Microbiology, pp. 13-26.
29.
Mouton, C.; Hammond, P.G.; Slots, J.; and Genco, R.J. (1981): Serum Antibodies to Oral Bacteroides asaccharolyticus (Bacteroidesgingivalis): Relationship to Age and Periodontal Disease, Infect Immun31:182-192.
30.
Musser, J.M.; Granoff, D.M.; Pattison, P.E.; and Selander, R.K. (1985): A Population Genetic Framework for the Study of Invasive Diseases Caused by Serotype b Strains of Haemophilus influenzae, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA82:5078-5082.
31.
Ochman, H. and Selander, R.K. (1984): Evidence for Clonal Population Structure in Escherichia coli, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA81:198-201.
32.
Ørskov, F. and Ørskov, I. (1983): Summary of a Workshop on the Clone Concept in the Epidemiology, Taxonomy, and Evolution of the Enterobacteriaceae and Other Bacteria, J Infect Dis148 :346-357.
33.
Parent, R.; Mouton, C.; Lamonde, L.; and Bouchard, D. (1986): Human and Animal Serotypes of Bacteroides gingivalis Defined by Crossed Immunoelectrophoresis, Infect Immun51 :909-918.
34.
Sako, K.; Takazoe, I.; and Okuda, K. (1988): Isolation and Characterization of Plasmid DNA from Bacteroides Strains Isolated from the Human Oral Cavity, Oral Microbiol Immunol3:72-76.
35.
Scherer, S. and Stevens, D.A. (1987): Application of DNA Typing Methods to Epidemiology and Taxonomy of Candida Species, J Clin Microbiol25:675-679.
36.
Selander, R.K.; Caugant, D.A.; Ochman, H.; Musser, J.M.; Gilmour, M.N.; and Whittam, T.S. (1986): Methods of Multilocus Enzyme Electrophoresis for Bacterial Population Genetics and Systematics, Appl Environ Microbiol51:873-884.
37.
Selander, R.K.; Musser, J.M.; Caugant, D.M.; Gilmour, M.N.; and Whittam, T.S. (1987): Population Genetics of Pathogenic Bacteria. Mini-review , Microb Pathog3:1-7.
38.
Shah, H.N. and Collins, M.D. (1988): Proposal for Reclassification of Bacteroides asaccharolyticus, Bacteroides gingivalis and Bacteroides endodontalis in a New Genus, Porphyromonas, Int J Syst Bacteriol38:128-131.
39.
Slots, J. and Gibbons, R.J. (1978): Attachment of Bacteroides melaninogenicus Subsp. asaccharolyticus to Oral Surfaces and its Possible Role in Colonization of the Mouth and of Periodontal Pockets, Infect Immun19:254-264.
40.
Slots, J. (1981): Enzymatic Characterization of Some Oral and Nonoral Gram-negative Bacteria with the API ZYM System, J Clin Microbiol14:288-294.
41.
Slots, J. and Reynolds, H.S. (1982): Long-wave UV Light Fluorescence for Identification of Black-pigmented Bacteroides spp., J Clin Microbiol16:1148-1151.
42.
Slots, J.; Bragd, L.; Wikstrom, M.; and Dahlen, G. (1986): The Occurrence of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, Bacteroides gingivalis and Bacteroides intermedius in Destructive Periodontal Disease in Adults, J Clin Periodontol13:570-577.
43.
Slots, J. and Listgarten, M.A. (1988): Bacteroides gingivalis, Bacteroides intermedius and Actinobacillus acinomycetemcomitans in Human Periodontal Diseases, J Clin Periodontol15 :85-93.
44.
Syed, S.A. (1980): Characteristics of Bacteroides asaccharolyticus from Dental Plaque of Beagle Dogs, J Clin Microbiol11 :522-526.
45.
Tanner, A.C.R.; Socransky, S.S.; and Goodson, J.M. (1984): Microbiota of Periodontal Pockets Losing Crestal Alveolar Bone, J Periodont Res19:279-291.
46.
Tew, J.G.; Marshall, D.R.; Moore, W.E.C.; Best, A.M.; Palcanis, K.G.; and Ranney, R.R. (1985): Serum Antibody Reactive with Predominant Organisms in the Subgingival Flora of Young Adults with Generalized Severe Periodontitis , Infect Immun48:303-311.
47.
Van Winkelhoff, A.J.; Carlee, A.W.; and De Graaff, J. (1985): Bacteroides endodontalis and Other Black-pigmented Bacteroides Species in Odontogenic Abscesses, Infect Immun49 :494-497.
48.
Van Winkelhoff, A.J.; Van Steenbergen, T.J.M.; and De Graaff, J. (1988): The Role of Black-pigmented Bacteroides in Human Oral Infections, J Clin Periodontol15:145-155.
49.
Wachsmuth, K. (1986): Molecular Epidemiology of Bacterial Infections : Examples of Methodology and of Investigations of Outbreaks, Rev Infect Dis8:682-692.
50.
White, D. and Mayrand, D. (1981): Association of Oral Bacteroides with Gingivitis and Adult Periodontitis, J Periodont Res16:259-265.
51.
Wilson, K. (1987): Preparation of Genomic DNA from Bacteria. In: Current Protocols in Molecular Biology, F.M. Ausubel, R. Brent, R.E. Kingston, D.D. Moore , J.G. Seidman, J. A. Smith, and K. Struhl, Eds., New York, NY: Greene Publishing Associates and Wiley-Interscience, John Wiley & Sons, pp. 2.4.1-2.4.5.
52.
Wren, B.W. and Tabaqchali, S. (1987): Restriction Endonuclease DNA Analysis of Clostridium difficile, J Clin Microbiol25:2402-2404.
53.
Zambon, J.J.; Reynolds, H.S.; and Slots, J. (1981): Black-pigmented Bacteroides sp. in the Human Oral Cavity, Infect Immun32:198-203.
54.
Zambon, J.J.; Sunday, G.J.; and Smutko, J.S. (1990): Molecular Genetic Analysis of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans Ecology, J Periodontol61:75-80.
