A Histological Comparison in the Dog of Porous-coated vs. Threaded Dental Implants

Abstract

The histological findings of an 18-month trial, in the dog, of a partially porous-coated endosseous dental implant made of Ti-6Al-4V, with a truncated conical shape, are described and compared with those for a cylindrical, threaded, endosseous implant made of commercially pure Ti. Six beagle dogs each received two porous-coated implants on one side of the mandible and two threaded implants on the contralateral side. Each set of two implants supported a two-unit fixed bridge for an 18-month functional period.

Methylmethacrylate sections of both the buccolingual and mesiodistal aspects of each implant were examined qualitatively and by computer-assisted morphometry. The morphometric measurements were used for determination of the length of implant surface in direct contact with bone on each aspect of each implant. The data were expressed both as an absolute length and as a fraction of the maximum length available for contact (contact length fraction or CLF). On the buccal and lingual aspects of the implants, both the absolute lengths and CLF were significantly smaller for the porous-coated design. For the mesial and distal aspects, the absolute lengths and CLF were less for the porous-coated design, but the differences were not significant. However, when the absolute contact length was related to the corresponding vertical bone height, significant differences were observed, the absolute contact length being greater for any given bone height for the porous-coated design. Taken together, the data suggest that shorter implants may be used with the porous-coated design.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bobyn, J.D. ; Szivek, J.A. ; Binnington, A. ; and Pilliar, R.M. (1987): The Effect of Proximally and Fully Porous-coated Hip Stem Design on Bone Modelling, J Orthop Res 5:393-408.

Branemark, P.-I. ; Hansson, B.O. ; and Adell, R. (1977): Osseointegrated Implants in the Treatment of the Edentulous Jaw. Experience from a 10 Year Period, Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg (Suppl.) 16:1-132.

Buch, J.K. ; Cruse, J.G. ; and Bechtol, C.O. (1974): Biomechanical and Biomaterials Considerations of Natural Teeth, Tooth Replacement and Skeletal Fixation, Biomat Med Dev Artif Organs 2:171-186.

Carter, D.R. (1984): Mechanical Loading Histories and Cortical Bone Remodelling, Calcif Tissue Int 36:519-524.

Churches, A.E. ; Howlett, C.R. ; and Waldron, K.J. (1979): The Response of Living Bone to Controlled Time-varying Loading. Methods and Preliminary Results, J Biomech 12:34-45.

Cook, S.D. ; Klawitter, J.J. ; and Weinstein, A.M. (1981): The Influence of Implant Elastic Modulus on the Stress Distribution Around LTI Carbon and Aluminum Oxide Dental Implants, J Biomed Mater Res 15:879-887.

Deporter, D.A. ; Friedland, B. ; Watson, P.A. ; Pilliar, R.M. ; Howley, T.P. ; Abdulla, D. ; Melcher, A.H. ; and Smith, D.C. (1986a): A Clinical and Radiographic Assessment of a Porous-Surfaced, Titanium Alloy Dental Implant System in Dogs, J Dent Res 65:1071-1077.

Deporter, D.A. ; Watson, P.A. ; Pilliar, R.M.P. ; Melcher, A.H. ; Winslow, J. ; Howley, T.P. ; Hansel, P. ; Maniatopoulos, C. ; Rodriguez, A. ; Abdulla, D. ; Pari-Sien, K. ; and Smith, D.C. (1986b): A Histological Assessment of the Initial Healing Response Adjacent to Porous-Surfaced, Titanium Alloy Dental Implants in Dogs , J Dent Res 65:1064-1070.

Deporter, D.A. ; Watson, P.A. ; Pilliar, R.M. ; Howley, T.P. ; and Winslow, J. (1988): A Histological Evaluation of a Functional Endosseous, Porous-Surfaced, Titanium Alloy Dental Implant System in the Dog, J Dent Res 67:1190-1195.

10.

Hayes, W.C. and Snyder, B. (1981): Toward a Quantitative Formulation of Wolff's Law in Trabecular Bone. In: Mechanical Properties of Bone, S.C. Cowin , Ed., New York: American Society of Mechanical Engineering, pp. 43-68.

11.

Lanyon, L.E. (1987): Functional Strain in Bone Tissue as an Objective and Controlling Stimulus for Adaptive Bone Remodelling, J Biomech 20:1083-1093.

12.

Maniatopoulos, C. ; Pilliar, R.M. ; and Smith, D.C. (1986): Threaded versus Porous-Surfaced Designs for Implant Stabilization in Bone-Endodontic Implant Model, J Biomed Mater Res 20:1309-1333.

13.

Pilliar, R.M. ; Cameron, H.U. ; Binnington, A.G. ; Szivek, J. ; and MacNab,I. (1979): Bone Ingrowth and Stress Shielding with a Porous Surface-Coated Fracture Fixation Plate, J Biomed Mater Res 13:799-810.

14.

Pilliar, R.M. (1986): Implant Stabilization by Tissue Ingrowth. In: Tissue Integration in Oral and Maxillo-Facial Reconstruction, D. Van Steenberghe , Ed., Amsterdam: Excerpta Medica, pp. 60-76.

15.

Pilliar, R.M. (1987): Porous-surfaced Metallic Implants for Orthopedic Applications, J Biomed Mater Res 21:1-33.

16.

Woo, S.L. ; Akeson, W.H. ; Coutts, R.D. ; Rutherford, L. ; Doty, D. ; Jemmott, G.F. ; and Amiel, D. (1976): A Comparison of Cortical Bone Atrophy Secondary to Fixation with Plates with Large Differences in Bending Stiffness, J Bone Joint Surg 58A:190-195.