Iron Concentration in Teeth of Tetra-odontiform Fishes and its Phylogenetic Significance

Abstract

It is known that iron is deposited in the enameloid of some teleost fishes, although its biological significance has not been clarified. In the present investigation, a quantitative analysis of iron in the enameloid of fishes of a primitive suborder, the Balistoidei, and an advanced suborder, the Tetra-odontoidei, of the Tetra-odontiformes of marine teleosts was performed by means of the electron microprobe. The results indicated that the enameloid of Balistoidei contained from 0.4-13.5% iron at its surface layer, whereas that of Tetra-odontoidei was very low in iron, which could not be discriminated from the background value of the emission intensity. The enameloid of three perciform species belonging to the Acanthuridae-from which the Tetra-odontiformes are considered to have been derived-also contained high iron (2. 7 - 3.9%) throughout its entire layer. The iron concentration in the enameloid seemed to be related to the phylogeny of fishes rather than to their environmental water and feeding habits, and it is believed that the mechanisms of iron concentration into the developing enameloid have been lost during evolution from the Achanthuridae to the Tetra-odontoidei. Since a similar phenomenon has been previously observed with respect to the fluoride concentration in the enameloid of the same fishes (Suga et al., 1981a), it is speculated that the concentrations of iron and fluoride, which have originally no chemical correlation, have some special biological significance, although the timing and distribution pattern of their deposition are completely different.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bauminger, E. ; Ofer, S. ; Gedalia, I. ; Horowitz, G. ; and Mayer, I. (1985): Iron Uptake by Teeth and Bones: A Mossbauer Effect Study, Calcif Tissue Int 37:386-389.

Besic, F.C. ; Bayard, M. ; Wiemann, M.R., Jr. ; and Bur-Rell, K.H. (1975): Composition and Structure of Dental Enamel. Elemental Composition and Crystalline Structure as They Relate to its Solubility, J Am Dent Assoc 91:594-601.

Breder, C.M., Jr. and Clark, E. (1947): A Contribution to the Visceral Anatomy, Development, and Relationships of the Plectognathi, Bull Am Mus Nat Hist 88:287-320.

Büttner, W. (1966): Konzentration und Verteilung von Fluorid in Haifischzahnen , Adv Fluorine Res 4:193-200.

Daculsi, G. and Kerebel, L.M. (1980): Ultrastructural Study and Comparative Analysis of Fluoride Content of Enameloid in Sea-Water and Fresh-Water Sharks, Arch Oral Biol 25:145-151.

Garant, P.R. (1970): Observations on the Ultrastructure of the Ectodermal Component during Odontogenesis in Helostoma temmincki, Anat Rec 166:167-188.

Glas, J.E. (1962): Studies on the Ultrastructure of Dental Enamel. VI. Crystal Chemistry of Shark's Teeth, Odont Revy 13:315-326.

Greenhalgh, R. and Riley, J.P. (1963): Occurrence of Abnormally High Fluoride Concentrations at Depth in the Oceans, Nature 197:371-372.

Hiatt, R.W. and Strasburg, D.W. (1960): Ecological Relationships of the Fish Fauna in Coral Reefs of the Marshall Islands, Ecological Monograph 30:65-127.

10.

LeGeros, R.Z. and Suga, S. (1980): Crystallographic Nature of Fluoride in Enameloids of Fish, Calcif Tissue Int 32:169-174.

11.

LeGeros, R.Z. ; Taheri, M.H. ; Quirolgico, G.B. ; and LeGeros, J.P. (1980): Formation and Stability of Apatite: Effects of Some Cationic Substituents. In: Proc 2nd International Congress on Phosphorus Compounds, Boston, pp. 89-103.

12.

Lowenstam, H.A. (1967): Lepidocrocite, an Apatite Mineral, and Magnetite in Teeth of Chitons (Polyplacophora), Science 156 :1373-1374.

13.

Matsuura, K. (1979): Phylogeny of the Superfamily Balistoidea (Pisces: Tetra-odontiformes), Mem Fac Fish Hokkaido Univ 26 :49-169.

14.

Miles, A.E.W. (1963): Pigmented Enamel, Proc R Soc Med 56 :918-920.

15.

Motta, P.J. (1987): A Quantitative Analysis of Ferric Iron in Butterflyfish Teeth (Chaetodontidae, Perciformes) and the Relationship to Feeding Ecology , Can J Zool 65:106-112.

16.

Ogaard, B. ; Rolla, G. ; Ruben, J. ; Dijkman, T. ; and Arends, J. (1988): Microradiographic Study of Demineralization of Shark Enamel in a Human Caries Model, Scand J Dent Res 96:209-211.

17.

Schmidt, W.J. (1958): Natürliche Farbung von Reptilien- und Fischzahnen durch Eisenoxyd, Zool Anz 161:168-178.

18.

Schmidt, W.J. (1969): Die Schmelznatur der Eisenoxidhaltigen Kappe auf Teleostier-Zähnen, Z Zellforsch Mikrosk Anat 93 :447-450.

19.

Selvig, K.A. and Halse, A. (1975): The Ultrastructural Localization of Iron in Rat Incisor Enamel, Scand J Dent Res 83:88-95.

20.

Shellis, R.P. and Berkovitz, B.K.B. (1976): Observations on the Dental Anatomy of Piranhas (Characidae) with Special Reference to Tooth Structure , J Zool 180:69-84.

21.

Stephenson, D.A. (1969): An Improved Flux-fusion Technique for X-Ray Emission Analysis, Anal Chem 41:966-967.

22.

Suga, S. (1984): The Role of Fluoride and Iron in Mineralization of Fish Enameloid. In: Tooth Enamel , R.W. Fearnhead and S. Suga , Eds., Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers BV, pp. 472-477.

23.

Suga, S. ; Taki, Y. ; and Wada, K. (1983): Fluoride Concentration in the Teeth of Perciform Fishes and its Phylogenetic Significance, Jpn J Ichthyol 30:81-93.

24.

Suga, S. ; Wada, K. ; and Ogawa, M. (1977): Fluoride Concentration in the Enameloid of Fishes , IADR Prog & Abst 56(A): 54, Abst. No. 45.

25.

Suga, S. ; Wada, K. ; and Ogawa, M. (1978a): Possible Relationship between the Fluoride Concentration in the Enameloid and Phylogeny of Fishes, IADR Prog & Abst 57(A): 280, Abst. No. 823.

26.

Suga, S. ; Wada, K. ; and Ogawa, M. (1978b): Mineralization Pattern and Fluoride Distribution of the Developing and Matured Enameloid of the Shark, Jpn J Oral Biol 20:67-81 (in Japanese).

27.

Suga, S. ; Wada, K. ; and Ogawa, M. (1980): Fluoride Concentration in the Enameloid of Fishes . In: The Mechanisms of Bio-mineralization in Animals and Plants , M. Omori and N. Watabe , Eds., Tokyo: Tokai Univ. Press, pp. 229-240.

28.

Suga, S. ; Wada, K. ; and Ogawa, M. (1981a): Fluoride Concentration in Teeth of Tetra-odontiform Fishes and its Phylogenetic Significance, Jpn J Ichthyol 28:304-312.

29.

Suga, S. ; Wada, K. ; and Ogawa, M. (1981b): Fluoride Concentration in the Enameloid of Fish Teeth and its Relationship to the Phylogeny of Fishes. In: Fluoride Metabolism, K. Binder and M. Hohenegger , Eds., Wien : Verlag Wilhelm Maudrich, pp. 79-88.

30.

Torell, P. (1957): Determination of Iron in Dental Enamel, Odont Tidskr 65:20-23.

31.

Trautz, O.R. ; Klein, E. ; and Addelston, H.K. (1952): Variations in the X-Ray Diffractograms of Dental Enamel of Man and Shark, J Dent Res 31:472-473 (Abst.).

32.

Tyler, J.C. (1968): A Monograph on Plectognath Fishes of the Superfamily Triacanthoidea, Monogr Acad Nat Sci Philad 16 :1-364.

33.

Tyler, J.C. (1980): Osteology, Phylogeny, and Higher Classification of the Fishes of the Order Plectognathi (Tetra-odontiformes), U. S. Dept Commerce Nat Ocean Atmos Admin Nat Mar Fish Serv, NOAA Tech Rep. NMFS Circ 434, 422 pp.

34.

Winterbottom, R. (1974): The Familial Phylogeny of the Tetraodontiforms (Acanthopterygii; Pisces) as evidenced by Their Comparative Myology, Smithsonian Contr Zool 155:1-201.