The Effect of Sugar Cane Chewing on the Development of Dental Caries

Abstract

In Tanzania, the effect of sugar cane chewing on the development of caries was investigated. Two groups were selected; those who had easy access to sugar cane (sugar cane cutters) and those who did not (sisal plant workers). These groups had a similar socio-economic background, had similar levels of fluoride in drinking water, consumed similar amounts of refined sugar per day, but had a significant difference in number of pieces of sugar cane chewed per day. The caries prevalence in both groups was low compared with that in adult populations in Western countries. Sugar cane cutters had significantly higher mean DMT/S scores than sisal plant workers. Analysis of Variance revealed a weakly significant effect of sugar cane chewing on the caries scores (p = 0.02 for DMT and p = 0.05 for DMS). Results of the study suggest that sugar cane chewing in large quantities over a long period has a caries-promoting effect in populations with a low caries prevalence, and further, that sugar sales figures reported for such populations are of questionable reliability.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Dawes, C. (1983): A Mathematical Model of Salivary Clearance of Sugar from the Oral Cavity, Caries Res 17:321-334.

Dreizen, S. and Spies, T.D. (1952): The Incidence of Dental Caries in Habitual Sugar Cane Chewers, J Am Dent Assoc 45:193-200.

Fejerskov, O. ; Thylstrup, A. ; Mosha, H. ; Langebaek, H. ; and Gadegaard, E. (1984): Dental Health Survey among Workers of Tanganyika Planting Company. In: Changing and Developing Dental Health Service in Tanzania 1980-2000, R.J. Muya et al., Ministry of Health, Danida: pp. 112-116.

Gadegaard, E. and Fejerskov, O. (1983): Epidemiologic Data on Caries and Periodontal Diseases in Tanzania. Data from National Dental Health Surveys 1982-1983 and a Survey in 1977. Aarhus, Royal Dental College .

Harris, S. and Cleaton-Jones, P. (1978): Oral Health in a Group of Sugar Cane Chewers, J Dent Assoc S Afr 33:255-258.

Hefti, A. and Schmid, R. (1979): Effect on Caries Incidence in Rats of Increasing Dietary Sucrose Levels, Caries Res 13:298-300.

Jenkins, G.N. ; Forster, M.G. ; and Speirs, R.L. (1959): The Influence of the Refinement of Carbohydrates on Their Cariogenicity, Br Dent J 106 :362-374.

Kilombero Sugar Company (1986): Monthly Sugar Distribution Report, Kilombero: KSC.

Newbrun, E. (1978): Cariology, Baltimore: The Williams & Wilkins Company.

10.

Osborn, T.W.B. ; Noriskin, J.N. ; and Staz, J. (1937): A Comparison of Crude and Refined Sugar and Cereals in their Ability to Produce in vitro Decalcification of Teeth, J Dent Res 16 :165-171.

11.

Osborn, T.W.B. and Noriskin, J.N. (1937): The Relation Between Diet and Caries in the South African Bantu, J Dent Res 16:431-441.

12.

Rugarabamu, P. ; Frencken, J.E. ; Amuli, J.A.D. ; and Lihepa, A. (1989): Caries Experience amongst 12- and 15-year old Tanzanian Children Residing on a Sugar Estate, Community Dental Health (accepted).

13.

Sugar Development Cooperative (1982): Annual Distribution Figures, Dar es Salaam: SUDECO.

14.

Takeuchi, M. (1974): On the Epidemiological Principles in Dental Caries Attack, Bull Tokyo Dent Coll 3:96-111.

15.

Von Künzel, W. ; Borroto, R.C. ; Lanier, S. ; and Soto, F. (1973): Auswirkungen Habituellen Zuckerrohrkauens auf Kariesbefall und Parodontalzustand Kubanischer Zuckerrohrarbeiter, Deut Sromatol 23 :554-561.

16.

World Health Organization (1977): Oral Health Surveys, Basic Methods, 2nd ed., Geneva: WHO.