Efficacy of Panoramic Radiography in Dental Diagnosis and Treatment Planning

Abstract

We compared treatment decisions based on a clinical examination alone with decisions based on an examination plus a panoramic radiograph to determine whether the panoramic radiograph increased the diagnostic yield and consequently affected treatment. Provisional treatment plans, based on a screening clinical examination alone (n = 33), or on a screening clinical examination plus panoramic radiograph (n = 43), were compared with final treatment plans based on a complete diagnostic assessment (including all necessary radiographs). For this analysis, the final treatment plan was considered correct and used as the gold standard. The two groups used in the comparison were equivalent in age, gender, and final treatment plan needs. The availability of a panoramic radiograph did not improve the accuracy with which provisional treatment plans predicted the number of teeth requiring composites, amalgams, crowns, or extraction, nor did it improve the accuracy of the assessment of the periodontal status (Wilcoxon rank sum, alpha = 0.05). The proportion of patients who had an intra-oral full-mouth series as part of the complete diagnostic work-up was essentially the same for both groups (58% and 60%, respectively); the availability of the panoramic film did not reduce the need for full-mouth series radiographs for the development of the final treatment plans.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adriaens, P.A. ; Deboever, J. ; and Vande Velde, F. (1982): Comparison of Intra-Oral Long-Cone Paralleling Radiographic Surveys and Orthopantomograms with Special Reference to Bone Height, J Oral Rehabil 9:355-365.

Ahlquist, M. ; Halling, A. ; and Hollender, L. (1986): Rotational Panoramic Radiography in Epidemiological Studies of Dental Health, Swed Dent J 10:79-84.

Council On Dental Materials, Instruments, And Equipment (1984): Recommendations in Radiographic Practices, 1984, J Am Dent Assoc 109:764-765.

Davies, E.E. ; Meister, F. ; and Lommel, T.J. (1977): Panoramic Versus Periapical Surveys-A Comparison of Findings on Freshman Dental Students, Dent Radiol Photogr 50:41-47.

Douglass, C.W. ; Valachovic, R.W. ; Wijesnha, A. ; Chauncey, H.H. ; Kapur, K.K. ; and McNeil, B.J. (1986): Clinical Efficacy of Dental Radiographs in the Detection of Dental Caries and Periodontal Diseases, Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 62:330-339.

Hurlburt, C.E. and Wuehrmann, A.H. (1976): Comparison of Interproximal Carious Lesion Detection in Panoramic and Standard Intraoral Radiography, J Am Dent Assoc 93:1154-1158.

Kantor, M.L. and Slome, B.A. (1987): The Effect of Eliminating Administrative Radiographs on Patient Exposure and Accuracy of Provisional Treatment Plans, J Dent Educ 51:701-704.

Muhammed, A.H. and Manson-Hing, L.R. (1982): A Comparison of Panoramic and Intraoral Radiographic Surveys in Evaluating a Dental Clinic Population , Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 54:108-117.

Ohba, T. and Katayama, H. (1972): Comparison of Orthopantomography with Conventional Periapical Dental Radiography, Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 34:524-530.

10.

Stephens, R.G. ; Kogon, S.L. ; Reid, J.A. ; and Ruprecht, A. (1977): A Comparison of Panorex and Intraoral Surveys for Routine Dental Radiography, J Can Dent Assoc 43:281-286.

11.

Valachovic, R.W. ; Douglass, C.W. ; Reiskin, A.B. ; Chauncey, H.H. ; and McNeil, B.J. (1986): The Use of Panoramic Radiography in the Evaluation of Asymptomatic Adult Dental Patients, Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 61:289-296.

12.

Weems, R.A. ; Manson-Hing, L.R. ; Jamison, H.C. ; and Greer, D.F. (1985): Diagnostic Yield and Selection Criteria in Complete Intraoral Radiography, J Am Dent Assoc 110:333-338.

13.

White, S.C. ; Forsythe, A.B. ; and Joseph, L.P. (1984): Patient-Selection Criteria for Panoramic Radiography , Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 57:681-690.