A Modified DDE Index for Use in Epidemiological Studies of Enamel Defects

Abstract

The aim of this study was to investigate possible modifications to the DDE Index to make it simpler to use and to make the data collected more meaningful and amenable to analyses and interpretation. After the use of the DDE Index in a National Study in Ireland, initial alterations to the Index were tested on a group of children with enamel defects, in Ireland and New Zealand. The DDE Index was then modified to allow for the measurement of demarcated, diffuse, and hypo-plastic defects and their severity. With the Modified Index, the prevalence of defects both on index teeth and all permanent tooth surfaces of 8-and 15-year-old children in fluoridated Cork City and non-fluoridated areas of Cork County and Manchester, U.K., was measured. The prevalence of enamel defects on one or more index teeth of children in the three areas ranged from 30 to 42% in 8-year-olds and from 31 to 38% in 15-year-olds. The percentage of children affected as seen by full-mouth examination was somewhat higher, ranging from 38 to 51 % for 8 year-olds and 58 to 63% for 15-year-olds. The percentage of index teeth affected (7 to 14%) was generally higher than for all teeth (5 to 9%). Demarcated opacities were the most common defect seen. Diffuse opacities were found to be the discriminating factor between the fluoridated and non-fluoridated areas. In all areas, the vast majority of diffuse opacities extended over less than 1/3 of the surface area of the teeth affected. As a result of this study, proposals for a single scoring DDE Index for use in general purpose and screening surveys are made. The modifications to the DDE Index allow for efficient recording of the prevalence and severity of enamel defects.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Al-Alousi, W. ; Jackson, D. ; Crompton, G. ; and Jenkins, O.C. (1975): Enamel Mottling in a Fluoride and Non-Fluoride Community, Parts I and II, Br Dent J 138:9-15, 56-60.

Clarkson, J. (1987): An Epidemiological Study of Dental Enamel Defects in Fluoridated and Non-Fluoridated Areas of Ireland. PhD Thesis, University College, Cork.

Clarkson, J. and O'Mullane, D.M. (1986): Enamel Fluorosis/Defects in 8-and 15-year-old Children in Fluoridated and Non-fluoridated Areas in Ireland, Caries Res 20:154, Abst. No. 19.

Clarkson, J. ; O'Mullane, D.M. ; and O'Hickey, S. (1988): The Prevalence of Enamel Defects using a Modified DDE Index, J Dent Res 67:229, Abst. No. 935.

Cutress, T.W. ; Suckling, G.W. ; Pearce, E.I.F. ; and Ball, B.E. (1985): Defects of Tooth Enamel in Children in Fluoridated and Non-fluoridated Water Areas of Auckland, NZ Dent J 81:12-19.

Dean, H.T. (1934): Classification of Mottled Enamel Diagnosis, J Am Dent Assoc 21:1421-1426.

Dean, H.T. ; Arnold, F.A. ; and Elvove, E. (1942): Domestic Water and Dental Caries. Additional Studies of the Relation of Fluoride Domestic Waters to Dental Caries Experience in 4,425 White Children Aged 12-14 Years in 13 Cities in Four States, Public Health Rep 57:1155-1179.

De Liefde, N. and Herbison, G.P. (1985): Prevalence of Developmental Defects of Enamel and Dental Caries in New Zealand Children Receiving Different Fluoride Supplementation , Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 13:164-167.

Driscoll, W.S. ; Horowitz, H. ; Meyers, R. ; Heifetz, S. ; Kingman, A. ; and Zimmerman, E. (1986): Prevalence of Dental Caries and Dental Fluorosis in Areas with Negligible, Optimal and Above Optimal Fluoride Concentrations in Drinking Water, J Am Dent Assoc 113:29-33.

10.

Dummer, P.M. ; Kingdon, A. ; and Kingdon, R. (1986): Prevalence of Enamel Developmental Defects in a Group of 11- and 12-year-old Children in South Wales, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 14:119-122.

11.

Fdi Commission On Oral Health, Research & Epidemiology (1982): An Epidemiological Index of Developmental Defects of Dental Enamel (D.D.E. Index), Int Dent J 32:159-167.

12.

Goward, P.E. (1976): Enamel Mottling in a Non-fluoride Community in England, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 4:111-114.

13.

Horowitz, H. (1986): Indices for Measuring Dental Fluorosis, J Public Health Dent 46:179-183.

14.

Horowitz, H. ; Driscoll, W.S. ; Meyers, R. ; Heifetz, S. ; and Kingman, A. (1984): A New Method of Assessing the Prevalence of Fluorosis-The Tooth Surface Index of Fluorosis, J Am Dent Assoc 109:37-41.

15.

Iizuka, Y. and Yasaki, T. (1976): Differential Diagnosis Between Dental Fluorosis and Non-fluoride Mottling, Bull Kanagawa Dent Coll 4:55-56.

16.

Jackson, D. (1961): A Clinical Study of Non-Endemic "Mottling of Enamel ", Arch Oral Biol 5:212-223.

17.

Jackson, D. (1966): Errors in Clinical Trials. In: Advances in Fluorine Research and Dental Caries Prevention, Vol. 3, P.M.C. James , K.G. Konig , and H. Held , Eds., Oxford: Pergamon Press, pp. 23-32.

18.

Jackson, D. ; James, P.M.C. ; and Wolfe, W.B. (1975): Fluoridation in Anglesey, A Clinical Study, Br Dent J 138:165-171.

19.

King, N.M. and Brook, A. (1984): Enamel Defects Among Young Adults in Hong Kong; Use of F.D.I. Index, NZ Dent J 80:47-49.

20.

King, N.M. and Wei, S.H. (1986): Developmental Defects of Enamel; A Study of 12-year-olds in Hong Kong, J Am Dent Assoc 112:835-839.

21.

Moller, I.J. (1982): Fluorides and Dental Fluorosis, Int Dent J 32:134-147.

22.

Murray, J.J. and Shaw, L. (1979): Classification and Prevalence of Enamel Opacities in the Human Deciduous and Permanent Dentitions, Arch Oral Biol 24:7-12.

23.

O'Mullane, D. ; Clarkson, J. ; Holland, T. ; O'Hickey, S. ; and Whel-Ton, H. (1986): Children's Dental Health in Ireland, 1984, Government Publications Office, Dublin 2.

24.

Rugg-Gunn, A.J. ; Holloway, P.J. ; and Davies, T.G.H. (1975): Partial Recording in Caries Incremental Studies in English Schoolchildren, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 3:11-19.

25.

Russell, A.L. (1961): The Differential Diagnosis of Fluoride and Non-fluoride Enamel Opacities, Public Health Rep 21:143-146.

26.

Shaw, L. and Murray, J.J. (1975): Inter-examiner and Intra-examiner Reproducibility in Clinical and Radiographic Diagnosis, Int Dent J 25:280-288.

27.

Suckling, G.W. ; Brown, R.H. ; and Herbison, G.P. (1985): The Prevalence of Defects of Enamel in Nine-year-old Children in New Zealand in a Health and Development Study, Community Dent Hlth 2:303-313.

28.

Suckling, G.W. and Pearce, E.I.F. (1984): Developmental Defects of Enamel in a Group of New Zealand Children, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 12 :177-184.

29.

Suckling, G.W. ; Pearce, E.I.F. ; and Cutress, T.W. (1976): Developmental Defects of Enamel in New Zealand School Children, NZ Dent J 72 :201-210.

30.

Thylstrup, A. and Fejerskov, O. (1978): Clinical Appearance and Surface Distribution of Dental Fluorosis in Permanent Teeth in Relation to Histological Changes, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 6:315-328.

31.

Young, M.A. (1973): An Epidemiological Study of Enamel Opacities. PhD Thesis, University of London.

32.

Zimmerman, E.R. (1954): Fluoride and Non-fluoride Enamel Opacities, Public Health Rep 69:1115-1120.