Correlation of the Hydrolysis of Benzoyl-Arginine Naphthylamide (BANA) by Plaque with Clinical Parameters and Subgingival Levels of Spirochetes in Periodontal Patients

Abstract

Recent studies have shown that the extent of hydrolysis by plaque of the trypsin substrate, N-benzoyl-DL-arginine-2-naphthylamide (BANA), correlates with the numbers and proportions of spirochetes in subgingival plaque samples, and appears to be an indicator of clinical disease. In this study, BANA hydrolysis by subgingival plaque was evaluated in a blind manner for its ability to reflect both clinical parameters and subgingival levels of bacteria and spirochetes. Subgingival plaque samples were collected from periodontally healthy and diseased sites in 23 untreated periodontal patients and in 13 treated and maintained periodontal patients. In untreated patients, BANA hydrolysis was statistically associated with the total number of spirochetes and bacteria in the plaque sample, but in the treated patients BANA hydrolysis was statistically associated only with the spirochetes. Most BANA-positive reactions in both patient groups were from the sites which were clinically diseased and high in spirochetes. The majority of the negative reactions for BANA hydrolysis in both patient groups was among the sites which were periodontally healthy and low in spirochetes. Specificity and sensitivity of the test were above 80% for disease status in untreated patients. The predictive value of a positive and negative test was above 83%. Slightly lower sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values were found in the treated group. The BANA reaction appears to be an accurate and simple indicator of both clinical disease status and plaque levels of spirochetes in individual tooth sites in untreated and treated periodontal patients.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Armin, S. (1964): Microcosms of the Mouth-Role in Periodontal Disease , Tex Dent J 82:4-10.

Bretz, W.A. and Loesche, W.J. (1987): Characteristics of Trypsin-like Reaction in Subgingival Plaque Samples, J Dent Res 66:1668-1672.

Dzink, J.L. ; Tanner, A.C.R. ; Haffajee, A.D. ; and Socransky, S.S. (1985): Gram-negative Species Associated with Active Destructive Periodontal Lesions, J Clin Periodontol 12 :648-659.

Haffajee, A.D. and Socransky, S.S. (1986): Attachment Changes in Destructive Periodontal Disease, J Clin Periodontol 13:461-472.

Keyes, P.H. ; Wright, W.E. ; and Howard, S.A. (1978): The Use of Phase-Contrast Microscopy and Chemotherapy in the Diagnosis and Treatment of Periodontal Lesions. An Initial Report, Quint Int 1:51-68.

Liuenberg, B. and Lindhe, J. (1980): Juvenile Periodontitis. Some Microbiological, Histopathological and Clinical Characteristics , J Clin Periodontol 7:48-61.

Listgarten, M.A. (1980): Periodontal Probing: What Docs it Mean?, J Clin Periodontol 7:165-176.

Listgarten, M.A. and Hellden, L. (1978): Relative Distribution of Bacteria at Clinically Healthy and Periodontally Diseased Sites in Humans, J Clin Periodontol 5:115-132.

Loesche, W.J. (1986): The Identification of Bacteria Associated with Periodontal Disease and Dental Caries by Enzymatic Activity Methods, Oral Microbiol Immunol 1:65-70.

10.

Loesche, W.J. ; Syed, S.A. ; Morrison, E.C. ; Kerry, G.A. ; Higgins, T. ; and Stoll, J. (1984): Metronidazole in Periodontitis. I. Clinical and Bacteriological Results after 15 to 30 Weeks, J Periodontol 55:325-335.

11.

Loesche, W.J. ; Syed, S.A. ; Schmidt, E. ; and Morrison, E.C. (1985): Bacterial Profiles of Subgingival Plaques in Periodontitis , J Periodontol 56:447-456.

12.

Loesche, W.J. ; Syed, S.A. ; and Stoll, J. (1987): Trypsin-like Activity in Subgingival Plaque-A Diagnostic Marker for Spirochetes and Periodontal Disease?, J Periodontol 58:266-273.

13.

Moore, W.E.C. ; Holdeman, L.V. ; Cato, E.P. ; Smibert, R.M. ; Burmeister, J.A. ; Palcanis, K.G. ; and Ranney, R.R. (1985): Comparative Bacteriology of Juvenile Periodontitis , Infect Immun 48:507-519.

14.

Page, R.C. ; Bowden, T. ; Altman, L.C. ; Vandesteen, G.E. ; Ochs, H. ; MacKenzie, P. ; Osterberg, S. ; Engel, L.D. ; and Williams, B.L. (1983): Prepubertal Periodontitis. I. Definition of a Clinical Disease Entity, J Periodontol 54:257-271.

15.

Pickett, C.D. ; Murray, P.A. ; Winkler, J.R. ; Hoover, C.H. ; Smith, R.E. ; and Piethe, A. (1986): Development of a Diagnostic Tool for Monitoring Shifts in Subgingival Flora, J Dent Res 65:265, Abst. No. 325.

16.

Riegelman, R.K. (1985): Studying a Study and Testing a Test, Boston: Little, Brown and Co., pp. 119-130.

17.

Schluger, S. ; Youdelis, R.A. ; and Page, R.C. (1977): Periodontal Disease, Philadelphia : Lea & Febiger, 737 pp.

18.

Simonson, L.G. ; Goodman, C.H. ; Bial, J.J. ; and Morton, H.E. (1988): Quantitative Relationship of Treponema denticola to Severity of Periodontal Disease, Infect Immun 56:726-728.

19.

Slots, J. (1986): Rapid Identification of Important Periodontal Microorganisms by Cultivation, J Oral Microbiol Immunol 1:48-55.

20.

Slots, J. ; Emrich, L.J. ; Genco, R.J. ; and Rosling, B.G. (1985): Relationship Between Some Subgingival Bacteria and Periodontal Pocket Depth and Gain or Loss of Periodontal Attachment After Treatment of Adult Periodontitis, J Clin Periodontol 12:540-552.

21.

Tanner, A.C.R. ; Strzempko, M.N. ; Belsky, C.A. ; and McKinley, G.A. (1985): API ZYM and API An-Ident Reactions of Fastidious Oral Gram-negative Species, J Clin Microbiol 22 :333-335.