The Effects of 1% Pyrophosphate and 0.02% Sodium Fluoride on Artificial Caries Lesions in vivo

Abstract

We evaluated the potential of a pyrophosphate-fluoride solution to affect the remineralizing-demineralizing equilibrium, i.e., caries-inhibitingl-promoting effects on enamel in vivo. Fifteen subjects carried dentin blocks and enamel thin sections with artificial caries lesions in removable partial dentures for periods of two weeks, during which time they rinsed twice daily in a double-blind, randomized cross-over design with solutions containing (a) 90 ppm F, (b) 90 ppm F and 1% pyrophosphate, or (c) no active agents (placebo). A severe cariogenic challenge provided to the lesions by plaque under a stainless steel mesh cover resulted in the placebo-treated lesions losing 70.2% ± 72.1% mineral. The pyrophosphate rinse with fluoride held the mineral loss to only 28.1 ± 52.8%, while the fluoride rinse without pyrophosphate held the loss to 24.2 ± 50.1%. The differences between the fluoride and placebo results were significant (p < 0.01), but the difference between the two fluoride groups was not.

A large amount of fluoride was deposited in the dentin lesions. In the surface layer, the concentration was increased from 1000 ppm F to more than 2300 ppm F by both fluoride treatments. The concentration of fluoride in both groups of fluoride-treated lesions further increased to more than 3500 ppm F in the approximate center of the lesion before declining in deeper layers toward the level found in the placebo-treated group. The findings from both mineral change and fluoride uptake phases of this study show that in the presence of 90 ppm F, 1% pyrophosphate did not promote demineralization of artificial caries lesions.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arends, J. and Christoffersen, J. (1986): The Nature of Early Caries Lesions in Enamel, J Dent Res 65:2-11.

Dawes, C. and Dibdin, G.H. (1986): A Theoretical Analysis of the Effects of Plaque Thickness and Initial Salivary Sucrose Concentration on Diffusion of Sucrose into Dental Plaque and its Conversion to Acid During Salivary Clearance, J Dent Res 65:89-94.

Dijkman, A.G. ; Schuthof, J. ; and Arends, J. (1986): In vivo Remineralization of Plaque-induced Initial Enamel Lesions: A Microradiographic Investigation, Caries Res 20:202-208.

Essig, M.E. ; Bodden, W.R. ; Housch, T. ; and Koulou-Rides, T. (1987): Effect of Plaque Thickness on Enamel Softening and pH Depression, J Dent Res 66:108, Abst. No. 16.

Finn, S.B. ; Moller, P. ; Jamison, H. ; Regattieri, L. ; and Manson-Hing, L. (1975): The Clinical Cariostatic Effectiveness of Two Concentrations of Acidulated Phosphate-Fluoride Mouthwash, J Am Dent Assoc 90:398-402.

Fleisch, H. and Russell, R.G.G. (1972): A Review of the Physiological and Pharmacological Effects of Pyrophosphate and Diphosphonates on Bones and Teeth, J Dent Res 51:324-332.

Fleisch, H. ; Russell, R. ; and Straumann, F. (1966): Effect of Pyrophosphate on Hydroxyapatite and its Implications in Calcium Homeostasis, Nature 212:901-903.

Gaffar, A. ; Polefka, T. ; Afflitto, J. ; Esposito, A. ; and Smith, S. (1987): In vitro Evaluations of Pyrophosphate/Copolymer/NaF as an Anticalculus Agent, Compend Cont Ed Dent Suppl 8:S242-S250.

Jenkins, G.N. (1978): The Physiology and Biochemistry of the Mouth, 4th ed., Oxford: Alden Press, p. 59.

10.

Kinoshita, S. and Muhlemann, H.R. (1966): Effect of Sodium Ortho- and Pyrophosphate on Supragingival Calculus, Helv Odont Acta 10:46-48.

11.

Mallon, D.E. and Mellberg, J.R. (1985): Analysis of Dental Hard Tissue by Computerized Microdensitomety, J Dent Res 64:112-116.

12.

Mellberg, J.R. (1986): Demineralization and Remineralization of Root Surface Caries, Gerodontology 5:25-31.

13.

Mellberg, J.R. (1988a): Remineralization. A Status Report for the American Journal of Dentistry. Part I, Am J Dent 1:39-43.

14.

Mellberg, J.R. (1988b): Remineralization. A Status Report for the American Journal of Dentistry. Part II, Am J Dent 1:85-89.

15.

Mellberg, J.R. ; Castrovince, L. ; and Rotsides, I. (1986): In vivo Remineralization by a Monofluorophosphate Dentifrice as Determined with a Thin-section Sandwich Method, J Dent Res 65:1078-1083.

16.

Mellberg, J.R. ; Castrovince, L.A. ; Rotsides, I.D. ; Hayes, J.C. ; and Deutchman, M. (1987): Changes in the Mineral Content of Artificial Carious Lesions Brushed in vivo with Anticalculus Dentifrices, Compend Cont Ed Dent Suppl 8 :S267-S271.

17.

Mellberg, J.R. ; Charig, A. ; Deutchman, M. ; O'Brien, W. ; and Lass, A. (1986): Effects of Two Fluoride Gels on Fluoride Uptake and Phosphorus Loss During Artificial Caries Formation, J Dent Res 65:1084-1086.

18.

Mellberg, J.R. and Chomicki, W.G. (1982): Effect of Soluble Calcium on Fluoride Uptake by Enamel from Sodium Monofluorophosphate, J Dent Res 61:1394-1396.

19.

Mellberg, J.R. and Chomicki, W.G. (1985): The Effect of Soluble Calcium on Fluoride Uptake by Artificial Caries Lesions in vivo, Caries Res 19:122-125.

20.

Mellberg, J.R. and Petrou, I.D. (1988): Effect of Plaque Thickness on Artificial Caries Lesions in vivo, J Dent Res 67:146, Abst. No. 264.

21.

Mitropoulos, C.M. ; Holloway, P.J. ; Davies, T.G.H. ; and Worthington, H.V. (1984): Relative Efficacy of Dentifrices Containing 250 or 1000 ppm F on Preventing Dental Caries-Report of a 32-month Clinical Trial, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1:193-200.

22.

Nicholson, C.R. ; Taylor, G.R. ; and Mellberg, J.R. (1974): An Automated Device for Removing Enamel Layers by Dissolution, Caries Res 8:293-299.

23.

Øgaard, B. ; Arends, J. ; Schuthof, J. ; Rølla, G. ; Ek-Strand, J. ; and Oliveby, A. (1986): Action of Fluoride on Initiation of Early Enamel Caries in vivo. A Micro-radiographical Investigation, Caries Res 20:270-277.

24.

Reed, M.W. (1973): Clinical Evaluation of Three Concentrations of Sodium Fluoride in Dentifrices, J Am Dent Assoc 87:1401-1403.

25.

Robertson, W.G. (1973): Factors Affecting the Precipitation of Calcium Phosphate in vitro, Calcif Tissue Res 11:311-322.

26.

Sanchez, M. and Mellberg, J.R. (1988): Fluoride Uptake by Artificial Caries Lesions in Root Surface Dentin from Sodium Monofluorophosphate Dentifrices, Caries Res 22:150-152.

27.

Strang, R. ; Damato, F.A. ; Creanor, S.L. ; and Stephen, K.W. (1987): The Effect of Baseline Lesion Mineral Loss on in situ Remineralization, J Dent Res 66:1644-1646.

28.

Ten Cate, J.M. (1986): Demineralization Models: Mechanistic Aspects of the Caries Process with Special Emphasis on the Possible Role of Foods, J Dent Res 65:1511-1515.

29.

Ten Cate, J.M. and Duijsters, P.P.E. (1982): Alternating Demineralization and Remineralization of Artificial Enamel Lesions, Caries Res 16:201-210.