The purpose of this study was to compare the relative cytotoxicity of amalgams and to determine whether their toxicity depends upon composition and aging time, by means of a rapid and sensitive in vitro cell culture test. Zinc-containing amalgams showed higher cytotoxicity than did any other amalgams. High-copper amalgams had the same cytotoxicity as did the low-copper amalgam. The addition of selenium did not reduce the cytotoxicity of amalgam. Moreover, excessive additions of selenium increased the cytotoxicity of amalgam compared with that of a similar selenium-free material. The cytotoxicity of amalgam was decreased with aging time, possibly due to the combined effects of surface oxidation and further amalgamation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American Dental Association (1974): Guide to Dental Materials and Devices, 7th ed., Chicago, American Dental Association , pp. 170-173.
2.
Brune, D. (1981): Corrosion of Amalgams, Scand J Dent Res89 :506-514.
3.
Brune, D. and Evje, D.M. (1984): Initial Corrosion of Amalgams in vitro, Scand J Dent Res92:165-171.
4.
Dahl, B.L. and øRstavik, J. (1976): Cytotoxicity of Temporary Crown and Bridge Materials, J Oral Rehabil3:341-347.
5.
deFreitas, J.F. (1979): A Survey of the Elemental Composition of Alloy for Dental Amalgam, Aust Dent J24:17-25.
6.
Ferracane, J.L.; Mafiana, P.; Cooper, C.; and Okabe, T. (1987): Time-dependent Dissolution of Amalgams into Saline Solution, J Dent Res66:1331-1335.
7.
Ferracane, J.L.; Mafiana, P.; Spears, R.; and Okabe, T. (1986): Rate of Liquid Mercury Consumption in Freshly Made Amalgams, J Dent Res66:192, Abst. No. 206.
8.
Gjerdet, N.R. and Berge, M. (1983): Liberation of Copper, Zinc, and Cadmium from Different Amalgams, Acta Odontol Scand41:217-220.
9.
Guess, W.L.; Rosenbluth, S.A.; Schmidt, B.; and Autian, J. (1965): Agar Diffusion Method for Toxicity Screening of Plastics on Cultured Cell Monolayers, J Pharm Sci54 :1545-1547.
10.
Hanawa, T.; Takahashi, H.; Ota, M.; Pinizzotto, R.F.; Ferracane, J.L.; and Okabe, T. (1987): Surface Characterization of Amalgams Using X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, J Dent Res66:1470-1478.
11.
Helgeland, K. and Leirskar, J. (1972): A Further Testing of the Effect of Dental Materials on Growth and Adhesion of Animal Cells in vitro, Scand J Dent Res80:206-212.
12.
Kaga, M.; Seale, N.S.; Hanawa, T.; Ferracane, J.L.; and Okabe, T. (1988): Cytotoxicity of Amalgams, Alloys and Their Elements and Phases, J Dent Res67:262, Abst. No. 1195.
13.
Kawahara, H.; Nakamura, M.; Yamagami, A.; and Nakanishi, T. (1975): Cellular Responses to Dental Amalgam in vitro , J Dent Res54:394-401.
14.
Kawahara, H.; Tomii, S.; Kushuoka, S.; Shiota, M.; Imai, T.; Masukawa, M.; Inada, H.; Yamamoto, H.; and Takeda, M. (1959): Cellular Response to Ag-Sn Amalgam, Jpn J Conserv Dent2:328-334.
15.
Kawahara, H.; Yamagami, A.; and Nakamura, M. (1968): Biological Testing of Dental Materials by Means of Tissue Culture, Int Dent J18:443-467.
16.
Kumei, Y. (1983): Effects of Addition of Selenium on Biological Properties of Dental Amalgam, J Stomatol Soc Jpn50:64-82.
17.
Kumei, Y. and Sato, A. (1982): Evaluation of a New Selenium-containing Amalgam on Mice, Toxicol Appl Pharmacol65 :177-179.
18.
Lappalainen, R. and Yli-Urpo, A. (1987): Release of Elements from Some Gold Alloys and Amalgams in Corrosion, Scand J Dent Res95:364-368.
19.
Leirskar, J. (1974): On the Mechanism of Cytotoxicity of Silver and Copper Amalgams in a Cell Culture System, Scand J Dent Res82:74-81.
20.
Leirskar, J. and Helgeland, K. (1972): A Methodologic Study of the Effect of Dental Materials on Growth and Adhesion of Animal Cells in vitro, Scand J Dent Res80:120-133.
21.
Leirskar, J. and Helgeland, K. (1981): Mechanism of Toxicity of Dental Materials, Int Endo J14:42-48.
22.
Marmary, Y.; Brunette, D.M.; and Heersche, J.N.M. (1976): Differences in vitro Between Cells Derived from Periodontal Ligament and Skin of Macaca irus, Arch Oral Biol21 :709-716.
23.
Meryon, S.D. (1984): The Effect of Zinc on the Biocompatibility of Dental Amalgams in vitro, Biomater5:293-297.
24.
Meryon, S.D.; Stephens, P.G.; and Browne, R.M. (1982): A Modification of the Millipore Method for Screening Restorative Materials, Int Endo J15:197-202.
25.
Nakamura, M. and Kawahara, H. (1979): Cellular Responses to the Dispersion Amalgams in vitro, J Dent Res58:1780-1790.
26.
Parizek, J. and Ostadalova, I. (1967): The Protective Effect of Small Amounts of Selenite in Sublimate Intoxication, Experientia23:142-143.
27.
Potter, S.D. and Matrone, G. (1977): A Tissue Culture Model for Mercury-Selenium Interactions , Toxicol Appl Pharmacol40:201-215.
28.
Spangberg, L. (1973): Kinetic and Quantitative Evaluation of Material Cytotoxicity in vitro, Oral Surg35:389-401.
29.
Terhune, W.F.; Sydiskis, R.J.; and Davidson, W.M. (1983): In vitro Cytotoxicity of Orthodontic Bonding Materials , Am J Orthod83:501-506.
30.
Tomii, S.; Isogai, M.; Kato, K.; Tanetani, K.; Mizuno, Y.; and Kawahara, H. (1962): Cellular Response of Pulp Cells to Ag-Sn Amalgam , J Jpn Soc Dent Appar Mater3 :136-141.
31.
Tronstad, L and Wennberg, A. (1980): In vitro Assessment of the Toxicity of Filling Materials, Int Endo J13:131-138.
32.
Tsutsumi, M. (1971): Studies on the Cytotoxic Action of Dental Amalgam upon L. Strain Cells in vitro, J Osaka Odontol Soc34:765-775.
33.
Tyas, M.J. (1977): A Method for the in vitro Toxicity Testing of Dental Restorative Materials, J Dent Res56:1285-1290.
34.
Wennberg, A.; Hasselgren, G.; and Tronstad, L. (1979): A Method for Toxicity Screening of Biomaterials Using Cells Cultured on Millipore Filters, J Biomed Mater Res13:109-120.
35.
Yoshida, R. and Ide, M. (1976): On Dispersed-Strengthened Amalgams, J Dent Eng37:30-35.
