The magnitude of fluctuating odontometric asymmetry is reported for a group of 106 urban South African Blacks by use of re-scaled asymmetry values and Euclidean map analyses. When these results were contrasted with those reported for South African Caucasoids and Paraguayan Lengua Indians, Blacks were found to be significantly more asymmetric. It is suggested that the disproportionately high levels of dental asymmetry may be ascribed to the high disease and malnutrition burden of South African Blacks and to decreased individual buffering ability. The present study failed to support Garn's model of x-chromosomal odontogenetic buffering in females, and also failed to confirm significant arcadal differences in the magnitude of fluctuating odontometric asymmetry.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, M.S. and Niswander, J.D. (1967): Developmental Noise and a Congenital Malformation , Genet Res Camb10:849-853.
2.
Alberch, P. (1982): Developmental Constraints in Evolutionary Processes . In: Evolution and Development, J.T. Bonner, Ed., Berlin: Springer , pp. 313-332.
3.
Bailet, H.L.; Workman, P.L.; Niswander, J.D.; and MacLean, C.J. (1970): Dental Asymmetry as an Indicator of Genetic and Environmental Conditions in Human Populations, Hum Biol42:626-638.
4.
Barden, H. (1980): Fluctuating Asymmetry: A Measure of Developmental Instability in Down Syndrome, Am J Phys Anthrop52 :169-173.
5.
Beyers, M.J.C.; Hammer, M.L.; and Groenewald, G. (1979): Foods Commonly Used by Xhosa-speaking People of Transkei and Ciskei, J Dietetics7:96-100.
6.
Botha, J.L.; Bradshaw, D.; and Gonin, R. (1985): Who Dies of What? In: Proceedings, N.A.M.D.A. Conferences, 1985, A.B. Zwi and L.D. Saunders , Eds., Johannesburg: Hendlers , pp. 41-54.
7.
Brandt, M. and Siegel, M.I. (1978): The Effects of Stress on Cortical Bone Thickness in Rodents, Am J Phys Anthrop49 :31-34.
8.
Cheverud, J.M. (1984): Quantitative Genetics and Developmental Constraints on Evolution by Selection, J Theoret Biol110 :155-171.
9.
De Arias, A.R.; Monsón, M.I.; Saldivar, G.V.; and Nestor, A.T. (1984): A seroepidemiological Survey of Chaga's Disease in Two Paraguayan Villages, Bull Pan Am Health Org18 :164-171.
10.
Di Bennardo, R. and Bailit, H.L. (1978): Stress and Dental Asymmetry in a Population of Japanese Children, Am J Phys Anthrop48:89-94.
11.
Doyle, W.J. and Johnston, 0. ( 1977): On the Meeting of Increased Fluctuating Asymmetry, Am J Phys Anthrop46:127-134.
12.
Garn, S.M.; Cole, P.E.; and Smith, B.H. (1979): The Effect of Sample Size on Crown Size Asymmetry , J Dent Res58:2012.
13.
Garn, S.M.: Lewis, A.B.; and Kerewsky, R.S. (1965): Genetic, Nutritional and Maturational Correlates of Dental Development, J Dent Res44:228-242.
14.
Garn, S.M.; Lewis, A.B.; and Kerewsky, R.S. (1966): The Meaning of Bilateral Asymmetry in the Permanent Dentition, Angle Orthodont36:55-62.
15.
Garn, S.M.; Smith, B.H.; and Moyers, R.E. (1981): Structured Dimensional and Developmental Dental Asymmetry, Proc Finn Dent Soc77:33-36.
16.
Gest, T.R.; Siegel, M.I.; and Anistranski, J. (1983): Increased Fluctuating Asymmetry in the Long Bones of Neonatal Rats Stressed by Cold, Heat and Noise, Am J Phys Anthrop60 :196-199.
17.
Greene, D.L. (1984): Fluctuating Dental Asymmetry and Measurement Error , Am J Phys Anthrop65:283-289.
18.
Harris, E.F. and Nweeia, M. (1980): Dental Asymmetry as a Measure of Environmental Stress in the Ticuna Indians of Colombia, Am J Phys Anthrop53:133-142.
19.
Ho, M.W. and Saunders, P.T. (1979): Beyond Neo-Darwinism: an Epigenetic Approach to Evolution, J Theoret Biol78:573-591.
20.
Irwig, L.M. and Ingle, R. (1984): Childhood Mortality Rates, Infant Feeding and use of Health Services in Rural Transkei, S Afr Med J66:607-613.
21.
Katz, M.T. (1982): Odontogenetic Mechanisms: The Middle Road of Evolution . In: Evolution and Development, J.T. Bonner, Ed., Berlin: Springer , pp. 207-212.
22.
Kieser, J.A. and Groeneveld, H.T. (1986a): The Assessment of Fluctuating Odontometric Asymmetry from Incomplete Fossil Data, Anthrop Anz44:175-182.
23.
Kieser, J.A. and Groeneveld, H.T. (1986b): Fluctuating Odontometric Asymmetry in a South African Caucasoid Population, J Dent Assoc S Afr41:185-189.
24.
Kieser, J.A.; Groeneveld, H.T.; and Preston, C.B. (1986a): Fluctuating Odontometric Asymmetry in the Lengua Indians of Paraguay, Ann Hum Biol13:489-498.
25.
Kieser, J.A.; Groeneveld, H.T. and Preston, C.B. (1986b): Fluctuating Dental Asymmetry as a Measure of Odontogenic Canalization in Man, Am J Phys Anthrop71:437-444.
26.
Kieser, J.A.; Groeneveld, H.T.; and Preston, C.B. (1986c): On the Non-existence of Compensatory Tooth Size Interaction in a Contemporary Human Population, J Dent Rest65:1105-1107.
27.
Kohn, L.A. and Bennett, K.A. (1986): Fluctuating Asymmetry in Fetuses of Diabetic Rhesus Macaques, Am J Phys Anthrop71:477-483.
28.
Kolakowski, D. and Bailit, H.L. (1981): A Differential Environmental Effect on Human Anterior Tooth Size, Am J Phys Anthrop54:377-381.
29.
Manning, E.B.; Mann, J.I.; Sophangisa, E.; and Trus-Well, A.S. (1974): Dietary Patterns of Urbanized Blacks, S Afr Med J48:485-489.
30.
Mayhall, J.T. and Saunders, S.R. (1986): Dimensional and Discrete Dental Trait Asymmetry Relationships, Am J Phys Anthrop69:403-411.
31.
McAuliffe, J.F.; DE Sousa, M.A.; Nations, M.K.; Shields, D.S.; and Guerrant, R.L. (1985): Prospective Studies of the Illness Burden in a Rural Community, Bull Pan Am Health Org9:139-146.
32.
Mizoguchi, Y. (1986): Correlated Asymmetries Detected in the Tooth Crown Diameters of Human Permanent Teeth, Bull Nat Science Mus Tokyo12:25-45.
33.
Mooney, M.P.; Siegel, M.I.; and Gest, T.R. (1985): Prenatal Stress and Increased Fluctuating Asymmetry in the Parietal Bones of Neonatal Rats, Am J Phys Anthrop68:131-134.
34.
Nichol, C.R.; Turner, C.G.; and Dahlberg, A.A. (1984): Variation in the Convexity of the Human Maxillary Incisor Surface, Am J Phys Anthrop63:361-370.
35.
Niswander, J.D. and Ching, C.S. (1965): The Effects of Inbreeding on Tooth Size in Japanese Children, Am J Hum Genet17: 390-398.
36.
Noss, J.F.; Scott, G.R.; Potter, R.H.Y.; and Dahlberg, A.A. (1983): Fluctuating Asymmetry in Molar Dimensions and Discrete Morphological Traits in Pima Indians, Am J Phys Anthrop61:437-445.
37.
Pankakoski, E. (1985): Epigenetic Asymmetry as an Ecological Indicator in Muskrats, J Mamm66:52-57.
38.
Perzigian, A.J. (1977): Fluctuating Dental Asymmetry: Variation Among Skeletal Populations, Am J Phys Anthrop47:81-88.
39.
Potter, R.H. and Nance, W.E. (1976): A Twin Study of Dental DimensionI. Discordance, Asymmetry and Mirror Imagery, Am J Phys Anthrop44:391-395.
40.
Quinn, P.J. (1959): Foods and Feedings Habits of the Pedi, Johannesburg : Witwatersrand University Press.
41.
Sciulli, P.W. (1979): Size and Morphology of the Permanent Dentition of Prehistoric Ohio Valley Amerindians, Am J Phys Anthrop50:615-628.
42.
Sciulli, P.S.; Doyle, W.J.; Kelley, C.; Siegel, P.; and Siegel, M.I. (1979): The Interactions of Stressors in the Induction of Increased Levels of Fluctuating Asymmetry in the Laboratory Rats, Am J Phys Anthrop50:279-284.
43.
Siegel, M.I. and Doyle, W.J. (1975): The Effects of Cold Stress on Fluctuating Asymmetry in the Dentition of the Mouse, J Exp Zool193:385-389.
44.
Siegel, M.I.; Doyle, W.J.; and Kelley, C. (1977): Heat Stress, Fluctuating Asymmetry and Prenatal Selection in the Laboratory Rat, Am J Phys Anthrop46:121-126.
45.
Siegel, M.I. and Smookler, H.H. (1973): Fluctuating Dental Asymmetry and Audiogenic Stress , Growth37:35-39.
46.
Smith, B.H.; Garn, S.M.; and Cole, P.E. (1982): Problems of Sampling and Inference in the Study of Fluctuating Dental Asymmetry, Am J Phys Anthrop58:281-289.
47.
Sofaer, J.A. (1979): Human Tooth Size Asymmetry in Cleft Lip With or Without Cleft Palate, Arch Oral Biol24: 141-146.
48.
Stein, H. (1981): The Sick Black Child, Johannesburg : Witwatersrand University Press.
49.
Steyn, N.P.; Albertse, E.C.; Kotze, T.J.; Van Heerden, L.; and Kotze, J.P. (1986): Analysis of Diets of 12 Year Old Children, S Afr Med J69: 739-742.
50.
Suarez, B.T. (1974): Neanderthal Dental Asymmetry and the Probable Mutation Effect, Am J Phys Anthrop41: 411-416.
51.
Townsend, G.C. (1983): Fluctuating Dental Asymmetry in Down Syndrome , Aust Dent J28: 39-44.
52.
Townsend, G.C. and Garcia-Godoy, F. (1984): Fluctuating Asymmetry in the Deciduous Dentition of Dominican Mulatto Children, Arch Oral Biol29: 483-486.
53.
Unterhalter, B. (1982): Inequalities of Health and Disease; the Case of Mortality Rates for the City of Johannesburg, Int J Health Serv12: 617-636.
54.
Valentine, D.W.; Soule, M.E.; and Smollow, P. (1973): Asymmetry Analysis in Fishes: A Possible Statistical Indicator of Environmental Stress, Fish Bull US71: 357-370.
55.
Van Valen, L. (1962): A Study of Fluctuating Asymmetry, Evolution16: 125-142.
56.
Waddington, C.H. (1942): Canalization of Development and the Inheritance of Acquired Characters, Nature150: 357-565.
57.
Walker, A.R.P. (1966): Nutritional, Biochemical and Other Studies on South African Populations, SA Med J44: 814-852.
58.
Walker, A.R.P. (1982): Breakfast Habits of Adolescents in Four South African Populations, Am J Clin Nutr36: 650-656.
59.
Wyndham, C.H. and Irwig, L.M. (1979): A Comparison of Mortality Rates of Various Population Groups in the Republic of South Africa, SA Med J55: 796-802.
