A Genetic Contribution to Dental Caries,Occlusion,and Morphology as Demonstrated by Twins Reared Apart

Abstract

The heritability of dental characteristics has been systematically studied in animals, human populations, families, and twins, but not in twins reared apart. Under the assumption that environmental factors are no different for monozygotic twins reared apart than for dizygotic twins reared apart, the present study measured the genetic variance of several dental characteristics in twins reared apart. Ninety-seven subjects (44 twin pairs, three triplet sets) of mean age 40.6 years (S. D. 11. 7) were examined over a six year period by means of clinical and radiographic examinations, study models, and dental history questionnaires. Characteristics assessed retrospectively were: dentate status, treatment status, treatment/caries status, tooth size, malalignment, occlusion, and morphology. Data were analyzed by two-way ANOVA, intraclass correlations, heritability estimates, and concordance. There was statistically significant resemblance within monozygotic but not dizygotic pairs in the number of teeth present (p<0.001), percentage of teeth and surfaces restored (p<0.001), percentage of teeth and surfaces restored or carious (p< 0. 001), tooth size (p < 0. 001), and malalignment (p <0. 009). Intercanine and intermolar arch width showed significant resemblance within both monozygotic (p<0.001) and dizygotic (p <0. 01, p<0.05) pairs, whereas overjet and overbite showed no significant resemblance within pairs. Morphological features (Carabelli's trait and mandibular first premolar groove configuration) were more highly concordant in monozygous than in dizygous twins. This study provides new evidence for a marked genetic component to dentate status and dental caries experience and confirms previous reports of acknowledged inherited contributions to tooth size, malalignment, occlusion, and morphology.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ash, M.M. (1982): Wheeler's Dental Anatomy, Physiology, and Occlusion , 6th ed., Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders.

Biggerstaff, R.H. (1973): Heritability of the Carabelli Cusp in Twins, J Dent Res 52:40-44.

Bouchard, T.J. (1984): Twins Reared Together and Apart: What They Tell Us About Human Diversity. In: Individuality and Determinism : Chemical and Biological Bases, S.W. Fox , Ed., New York: Plenum Publishing , pp. 147-178.

Bouchard, T.J. ; Lykken, D.T. ; Segal, N.L. ; and Wilcox, K.J. (1986): Development in Twins Reared Apart: A Test of the Chronogenetic Hypothesis. In: Human Growth: A Multidisciplinary Review, A. Demirjian , Ed., London: Taylor & Francis, Ltd., pp. 299-310.

Corruccini, R.S. and Potter, R.H. (1980): Genetic Analysis of Occlusal Variation in Twins , Am J Orthod 78: 140-154.

Falconer, D.S. (1981): Introduction to Quantitative Genetics, 2nd ed., London: Longman .

Farber, S.L. (1981): Identical Twins Reared Apart: A Reanalysis, New York: Basic Books, Inc.

Finn, S.B. and Caldwell, R.C. (1963): Dental Caries in Twins. LA Comparison of the Caries Experience of Monozygotic Twins, Dizygotic Twins and Unrelated Children, Arch Oral Biol 8: 571-585.

Finn, S.B. (1971): Anomalies of Tooth Numbers Including Peg-shaping , Birth Defects 7: 185-193.

10.

Forrai, G. and Bankovi, G. (1984): On the Food Favoritism of Twins, Acta Physiol Hung 64: 25-32.

11.

Galton, F. (1875): The History of Twins as a Criterion of the Relative Powers of Nature and Nurture, Fraser's Magazine 12: 566-576.

12.

Garn, S.M. ; Cole, P.E. ; and Bailey, S.M. (1979): Living Together as a Factor in Family-line Resemblances , Hum Biol 51: 565-587.

13.

Gedda, L. and Brenci, G. (1966): Chronological Aspects of Gene Action: A Twin Study , Acta Genet Med Gemellol 15: 327-332.

14.

Goodman, H.O. ; Luke, J.E. ; Rosen, S. ; and Hackel, E. (1959): Heritability in Dental Caries, Certain Oral Microflora and Salivary Components, Am J Hum Genet 11:263-273.

15.

Goose, D.H. and Lee, G.T. (1971): The Mode of Inheritance of Carabelli's Trait, Hum Biol 43:64-69.

16.

Harris, E.F. and Smith, R.J. (1980): A Study of Occlusion and Arch Widths in Families , Am J Orthod 78:155-163.

17.

Horowitz, S.L. ; Osborne, R.H. ; and DeGeorge, F.V. (1958): Caries Experience in Twins, Science 128:300-301.

18.

Hunt, H.R. ; Hoppert, C.A. ; and Erwin, W.G. (1944): Inheritance of Susceptibility to Caries in Albino Rats (Mus norvegicus), J Dent Res 23: 385-401.

19.

Juel-Nielsen, N. (1980): Individual and Environment, New York: International Universities Press, Inc.

20.

Klein, H. and Palmer, C.E. (1940): Dental Caries in Brothers and Sisters of Immune and Susceptible Children, Milbank Mem Fund Q 18:67-82.

21.

Klein, H. (1946): The Family and Dental Disease. IV. Dental Disease (DMF) Experiences in Parents and Offspring, J Am Dent Assoc 33:735-743.

22.

Kolmakow, S. and Puranen, M. (1985): Determining the Caries At-Risk Child: Part III. The Relationship Between Morphology of Maxillary Dentition and Occurrences of Focal Demineralization Lesions and Caries, J Pedod 9: 312-321.

23.

Konig, K.G. (1963): Dental Morphology in Relation to Caries Resistance with Special Reference to Fissures as Susceptible Areas, J Dent Res 42:461-475.

24.

Kraus, B.S. and Furr, M.L. (1953): Lower First Premolars. Part I. A Definition and Classification of Discrete Morphologic Traits, J Dent Res 32: 554-564.

25.

Lee, G.T. and Goose, D.H. (1982): Heritability of Dental Occlusal Variables in a Family Study in Liverpool, U.K., Arch Oral Biol 27: 987-989.

26.

Lundstrom, A. (1964): Size of Teeth and Jaws in Twins, J Dent Res 64:1389-1391.

27.

Lundstrom, A. (1984): Nature versus Nurture in Dento-facial Variation , Eur J Orthod 6:77-91.

28.

Lykken, D.T. (1978): The Diagnosis of Zygosity in Twins, Behav Genet 8:437-473.

29.

McGue, M. and Bouchard, T.J. (1984): Adjustment of Twin Data for the Effects of Age and Sex, Behav Genet 14:325-343.

30.

Mandel, I.D. (1974): Relation of Saliva and Plaque to Caries, J Dent Res 53: 246-266.

31.

Markovic, M. (1982): Hypodontia in Twins, Swed Dent J 15: 153-162.

32.

Nakata, M. (1985): Twin Studies in Craniofacial Genetics: A Review , Acta Genet Med Gemellol 34:1-14.

33.

Newman, H.H. ; Freeman, F.N. ; and Holzinger, K.J. (1937): Twins: A Study of Heredity and Environment. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

34.

Osborne, R.H. ; Horowitz, S.L. ; and DeGeorge, F.V. (1958): Genetic Variation in Tooth Dimensions: A Twin Study of the Permanent Anterior Teeth, Am J Hum Genet 10: 350-356.

35.

Pindborg, J.J. (1970): Abnormalities of Tooth Morphology. In: Pathology of Dental Hard Tissues, Philadelphia : W.B. Saunders Co., pp. 15-74.

36.

Potter, R.H. ; Yu, P.L. ; and Christian, P.C. (1979): Association of Twin Zygosity with the Mean and Variance of Tooth Size, Acta Genet Med Gemellol 28:211-223.

37.

Potter, R.H. ; Corruccini, R.S. ; and Green, L.J. (1981): Variance of Occlusion Traits in Twins, J Craniofac Genet Dev Biol 1:217-227.

38.

Price, B. (1950): Primary Biases in Twin Studies, Am J Hum Genet 2:293-343.

39.

Reiser, H. and Vogel, F. (1958): Uber die Erblichkeit der Zahnsteinbildung beim Menschen, Dtsch Zahnärztl Z 13:1355-1358. In: Genetics and Periodontal Disease, R.J. Gorlin, R.E. Stallard, and B.L. Shapiro, J Periodontol 38:5-10.

40.

Riquelme, A. and Green, L.J. (1970): Palatal Width, Height and Length in Human Twins , Angle Orthod 40:71-79.

41.

Rosen, S. ; Hunt, H.R. ; and Hoppert, C.A. (1961): The Importance of the Genotype on Susceptibility to Dental Caries in the Rat, J Dent Res 40:352-354.

42.

Rubin, M.M. ; Nevins, A. ; Berg, M. ; and Borden, B. (1981): A Comparison of Identical Twins in Relation to Three Dental Anomalies: Multiple Supernumerary Teeth, Juvenile Periodontosis, and Zero Caries Incidence, Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 52: 391-394.

43.

Sharma, K. ; Corruccini, R.S. ; and Henderson, A.M. (1985): Genetic Variance in Dental Dimensions of Punjabi Twins, J Dent Res 64:1389-1391.

44.

Shields, J. (1962): Monozygotic Twins: Brought up Apart and Brought up Together, London: Oxford University Press.

45.

Singh, I.J. and Savara, B.S. (1964): A Method for Making Tooth and Dental Arch Measurements , J Am Dent Assoc 69:719-721.

46.

VanKirk, L.E. and Pennell, E.H. (1959): Assessment of Malocclusion in Population Groups , Am J Orthod 45:752-758.

47.

Wood, B.F. and Green, L.J. (1969): Second Premolar Morphologic Trait Similarities in Twins, J Dent Res 48:74-78.