The Relationship Between Plaque pH,Plaque Acid Anion Profiles,and Oral Carbohydrate Retention After Ingestion of Several 'Reference Foods' by Human Subjects

Abstract

The primary aim of this study was to rank several reference foods (apple drink, caramel, chocolate, cookie, skimmed milk powder, snack cracker, and wheat flake) according to their plaque pH response as monitored in a panel of 12 volunteers by the plaque-sampling method for comparison with data previously reported with other methods used to assess cariogenicity potential. Secondary experiments (using subsets of the panel of subjects) were undertaken in an attempt to elucidate some of the reasons for the observed plaque pH changes. Oral carbohydrate retention was measured at a single time period after food use as total anthrone-positive carbohydrate material, and as specific acidogenic sugars by gas-liquid chromatography after gel-exclusion chromatography. The concentrations of acid anions in the plaque fluid after food consumption were measured by isotachophoresis eight min after food use. According to the plaque pH response, apple-flavored fruit drink and chocolate were the most acidogenic foods and skimmed milk powder the least acidogenic. There were significant correlations (p < 0.05) between the plaque pH data and lactate-plus-acetate concentrations in plaque fluid, but the correlations between the pH data and any of the carbohydrate retention parameters were not significant.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ada Health Foundation (1986): Proceedings, Scientific Consensus Conference on Methods for the Assessment of the Cariogenic Potential of Foods, J Dent Res 65:1475-1543.

Bibby, B.G. ; Mundorff, S.A. ; and Huang, C.T. (1983): Enamel Demineralization Tests with some Standard Foods and Candies, J Dent Res 62:885-888.

Clamp, J.R. ; Bhatti, T. ; and Chambers, R.E. (1971): The Determination of Carbohydrate in Biological Materials by Gas-Liquid Chromatography. In: Methods of Biochemical Analysis, Vol. 19, D. Glick , Ed., New York: Interscience Publisher, pp. 229-334.

Dawes, C. (1983): A Mathematical Model of Salivary Clearance of Sugar from the Oral Cavity, Caries Res 17:321-334.

Distler, W. and Kroncke, A. (1983): The Acid Pattern in Human Dental Plaque, J Dent Res 62:87-91.

Dodds, M.W.J. and Edgar, W.M. (1986): Effects of Dietary Sucrose Levels on pH Fall and Acid Anion Profile in Human Dental Plaque after a Starch Mouthrinse, Arch Oral Biol 31:509-512.

Edgar, W.M. (1981): Methodological Considerations Affecting the Determination of pH in Tooth Surface Plaque. In: Surface and Colloid Phenomena in the Oral Cavity: Methodological Aspects, R.M. Frank and S.A. Leach , Eds., Oxford; IRL Press Ltd., pp. 131-142.

Edgar, W.M. (1982): Duration of Response and Stimulus Sequence in the Interpretation of Plaque pH Data, J Dent Res 61:1126-1129.

Edgar, W.M. (1983): Distribution of Acetic Acid in Enamel During Demineralisation in a Hydroxyethyl Cellulose/Lactic Acid System. In: Demineralisation and Remineralisation of the Teeth, S.A. Leach and W.M. Edgar , Eds., Oxford ; IRL Press Ltd., pp. 145-152.

10.

Edgar, W.M. ; Bibby, B.G. ; Mundorff, S. ; and Rowley, J. (1975): Acid Production in Plaques after Eating Snacks: Modifying Factors in Foods, J Am Dent Assoc 90:418-25.

11.

Edgar, W.M. and Wright, W.G. (1982): Effect of Sucrose or Sugar Substitutes on Acid Levels in Plaque Fluid Measured by Isotachophoresis, IADR Progr & Abst 61:265, Abst. No. 782.

12.

Featherstone, J.D.B. ; Duncan, J.F. ; and Cutress, T.W. (1979): A Mechanism for Dental Caries based on Chemical Processes and Diffusion Phenomena During in vitro Caries Simulation on Human Tooth Enamel, Arch Oral Biol 24:101-112.

13.

Featherstone, J.D.B. and Rodgers, B.E. (1981): Effect of Acetic, Lactic and Other Organic Acids on the Formation of Artificial Carious Lesions, Caries Res 15:377-385.

14.

Firestone, A.R. (1982): Human Interdental Plaque-pH Data and Rat Caries Tests: Results with the Same Substances, J Dent Res 61:1130-1136.

15.

Geddes, D.A.M. (1972): The Production of L(+) and D(-) Lactic Acid and Volatile Acids by Human Dental Plaque and the Effect of Plaque Buffering and Acidic Strength on pH, Arch Oral Biol 17:537-545.

16.

Geddes, D.A.M. (1975): Acids Produced by Human Dental Plaque Metabolism in situ, Caries Res 9:98-109.

17.

Geddes, D.A.M. (1984): Current View of Plaque Acidogenicity. In: Cariology Today , B. Guggenheim , Ed., Basel: Karger , pp. 199-204.

18.

Geddes, D.A.M. ; Weetman, D.A. ; and Featherstone, J.D.B. (1984): Preferential Loss of Acetic Acid from Plaque Fermentation in the Presence of Enamel, Caries Res 18:430-433.

19.

Gilmour, M.N. and Poole, A.E. (1967): The Fermentative Capabilities of Dental Plaque , Caries Res 1:247-260.

20.

Gustafsson, B.E. ; Quensel, C.E. ; Lanke, S.L. ; Lundqvist, C. ; Grahnen, H. ; Bonow, B.E. ; and Krasse, B. (1954): The Vipeholm Dental Caries Study, Acta Odontol Scand 11:232-364.

21.

Imfeld, T.N. (1983): Identification of Low Caries Risk Dietary Components , Basel: Karger, p. 102.

22.

Jenkins, G.N. (1983): Review of Food Cariogenicity Testing. In: Diet and Dental Caries: Changing Perspectives, J. Storey , Ed., Melbourne: University of Melboume, pp. 47-55.

23.

Jensen, M.E. and Schachtele, C.F. (1983): The Acidogenic Potential of Reference Foods and Snacks at Interproximal Sites in the Human Dentition , J Dent Res 62:889-892.

24.

Kleinberg, I. ; Jenkins, G.N. ; Chatterjee, R. ; and Wijeyeweera, L. (1982): The Antimony pH Electrode and its Role in the Assessment and Interpretation of Dental Plaque pH, J Dent Res 61:1139-1147.

25.

Leveille, G.A. (1981): Michigan State University Reference Foods. In: Foods, Nutrition and Dental Health, Vol. 3, J.J. Hefferren , W.A. Ayer , and H.M. Koehler , Eds., Park Forest South, IL: Pathotox, pp. 33-43.

26.

Margolis, H.C. ; Moreno, E.C. ; and Murphy, B.J. (1985): Importance of High pKa Acids in Cariogenic Potential of Plaque, J Dent Res 64:786-792.

27.

Moore, B.W. ; Carter, W.J. ; Dunn, J.K. ; and Fosdick, L.S. (1956): The Formation of Lactic Acid in Dental Plaques , J Dent Res 35:778-785.

28.

Mormann, J.E. and Mühlemann, H.R. (1981): Oral Starch Degradation and its Influence on Acid Production in Human Dental Plaque, Caries Res 15 :166-175.

29.

Navia, J.M. and Lopez, H. (1983): Rat Caries Assay of Reference Foods and Sugar-containing Snacks, J Dent Res 62:893-898.

30.

Rugg-Gunn, A.J. ; Edgar, W.M. ; Geddes, D.A.M. ; and Jenkins, G.N. (1975): The Effect of Different Meal Patterns Upon Plaque pH in Human Subjects, Br Dent J 139:351-356.

31.

Rugg-Gunn, A.J. ; Edgar, W.M. ; and Jenkins, G.N. (1978): The Effect of Eating Some British Snacks upon the pH of Human Dental Plaque, Br Dent J 145:95-100.

32.

Schachtele, C.F. and Jensen, M.E. (1982): Comparison of Methods for Monitoring Changes in the pH of Human Dental Plaque, J Dent Res 61:1117-1125.

33.

Snedecor, G.W. and Cochran, W.G. (1967): Statistical Methods, 6th ed., Iowa: Iowa State University Press.

34.

Vratsanos, S.M. and Mandel, LD (1982): Comparative Plaque Acidogenesis of Caries-resistant vs. Caries-susceptible Adults, J Dent Res 61:465-468.

35.

White, C.A. and Kennedy, J.F. (1981): Manual and Automated Spectrophotometric Techniques for the Detection and Assay of Carbohydrates and Related Molecules. In: Techniques in the Life Sciences: Biochemistry, Vol. B3, Techniques in Carbohydrate Metabolism, H.L. Kornberg , J.C. Metcalfe , D.H. Northcote , C.I. Pogson , and K.F. Tipton , Eds., Ireland: Elsevier North-Holland Scientific Publishers Ltd., B312, pp. 1-65.