The Effect of Varying Diagnostic Thresholds upon Clinical Caries Data for a Low Prevalence Group

Abstract

This study investigated the impact of employing differing diagnostic thresholds on clinical caries data in studies of groups with low caries prevalence. Data from clinical examinations of 287 Hong Kong dental students were analyzed by means of the CARIES microcomputer software package. This software allows for re-calculation of raw data according to three different diagnostic thresholds (D3, D2, and D1). When "enamel" and "initial" lesions (as defined by WHO criteria) were included in the calculation of DMFT, its value increased from 3.0 (D3) to 5.9 (D1), while the percentage of individuals considered "caries-free" decreased from 28.2% to 7.0%. Little change was found in the magnitude of the intra-examiner reproducibility, when calculated at each threshold, for a random 10% of the subjects. It was unfortunately not possible to calculate inter-examiner reproducibility in this study. The use of criteria which might be misinterpreted as being similar, but which use differing effective diagnostic thresholds, can dramatically influence the reported level of dental caries. In view of these findings, it may be necessary for the question of diagnostic thresholds to be re-examined and to receive greater emphasis in future studies.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allan, C.D. ; Ashley, F.P. ; and Naylor, M.N. ( 1983): Caries Experience in 11-year-old Schoolgirls between 1962 and 1981, Br Dent J 154:167-170.

Backer-Dirks, O. (1964): At What Stage Should a Carious Lesion be Recorded? . In: Advances in Fluorine Research and Dental Caries Prevention, Vol. 2, J.L. Hardwick , J.P. Dustin , and H.R. Held , Eds., Oxford: Pergamon Press, pp. 21-23.

Cohen, J. (1960): Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales, Educ Psychol Measurement 20:37-46.

Dice, L.R. (1945): Measures of the Amount of Ecologic Association between Species, Ecology 26:297-302.

Downer, M.C. and Teagle, F.A. (1979): SPEED-System for Planning and Epidemiological Evaluation of Dental Services.

Espelid, I. and Tveit, A.B. (1986): Diagnostic Quality and Observer Variation in Radiographic Diagnoses of Approximal Caries, Acta Odontol Scand 44:39-46.

Federation Dentaire Internationale (1982): Global Goals for Oral Health by the Year 2000, Int Dent J 32:74-77.

Glass, R.L. (1982): Conference on Declining Prevalence of Dental Caries , J Dent Res 61 (Spec Iss): 1304.

Glass, R.L. ; Peterson, J.K. ; and Bixler, D. (1983): The Effects of Changing Caries Prevalence and Diagnostic Criteria on Clinical Trials, Caries Res 17:145-151.

10.

Gordon, M. and Newbrun, E. (1986): Comparison of Trends in the Prevalence of Caries and Restorations in Young Adult Populations of Several Countries, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 14:104-109.

11.

Groeneveld, A. (1985): Longitudinal Study of Prevalence of Enamel Lesions in a Fluoridated and Non-fluoridated Area, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 13:159-163.

12.

Haugejorden, O. and Slack, G.L. (1975): A Study of Intra-Examiner Error Associated with Recording of Radiographic Caries at Different Diagnostic Levels, Acta Odontol Scand 33:169-181.

13.

Horowitz, H.S. (1972): Clinical Trials of Preventives for Dental Caries , J Public Health Dent 32:229-233.

14.

Klein, H. ; Palmer, C.E. ; and Knutson, J.W. (1938): Studies on Dental Caries. I. Dental Status and Dental Needs of Elementary Schoolchildren, Public Health Rep 53:751-756.

15.

Landis, J.R. and Koch, G.G. (1977): The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data, Biometrics 33:159-174.

16.

Marthaler, T.M. (1963): Experimental Design in Epidemiologic Research , J Dent Res 42:192-201.

17.

Nuttall, N.M. and Paul, W.McK. (1985): The Analysis of Inter-Dentist Agreement in Caries Prevalence Studies, Community Dent Health 2:123-128.

18.

Palmer, J.D. ; Anderson, R.J. ; and Downer, M.C. (1984): Guidelines for Prevalence Studies of Dental Caries , Community Dent Health 1:55-66.

19.

Pitts, N.B. (1983): Dental Caries Status of a Group of Hong Kong University Students, J HK Soc Community Med 13:27-31.

20.

Renson, C.E. : Crielaers, J.P.A. ; Ibikunle, S.A.J. ; Pinto, V.G. ; Ross, C.B. ; Sardo Infirri, J. ; Takazoe, I. ; and Tala, H. ( 1985): Changing Patterns of Oral Health and Implications for Oral Health Manpower, Int Dent J 35:235-251.

21.

Rugg-Gunn, A.J. ; Downer, M.C. ; and Ashley, F.P. (1976): Reliability of Caries Data in Three Clinical Trials , Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 4:15-18.

22.

Shaw, L. and Murray, J.J. (1975): Inter-Examiner and Intra-Examiner Reproducibility in Clinical and Radiographic Diagnosis, Int Dent J 25:280-287.

23.

Todd, J.E. and Dodd, P. (1985): Children's Dental Health in the United Kingdom 1983. London: HMSO.

24.

Todd, J.E. ; Walker, A.M. ; and Dodd, P. (1982): Adult Dental Health, Vol. 2, United Kingdom 1978 . London: HMSO.

25.

World Health Organization (1977): Oral Health Surveys, Basic Methods (2nd ed.). Geneva: WHO.

26.

World Health Organization (1979): A Guide to Oral Health Epidemiological Investigations. Geneva: WHO.