This study was designed to evaluate the use of salivary cotinine, salivary thiocyanate, and expired-air carbon monoxide as biochemical validation measures for assessing the smoking status of adults. The participants were 20 known non-smokers plus 216 admitted smokers and 102 proclaimed quitters participating in a clinical trial of approaches to facilitate smoking cessation. Conventional analytical procedures were utilized. By use of data from known non-smokers and admitted smokers, the sensitivity and specificity of the validation measures were as follows: salivary cotinine, 99% and 100%; expired-air carbon monoxide, 96% and 100%; and salivary thiocyanate, 67% and 95%, respectively. The salivary cotinine and expired-air carbon monoxide tests confirmed smoking cessation for 55% and 74%, respectively, of the proclaimed quitters. The length of time since quitting was significantly related to the results observed with the latter measures. Consideration of these observations along with various practical factors suggests that expired-air carbon monoxide assays may be the validation measure of choice for most clinical trials.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allen, P.; Lundl, B.; and Westling, H. (1976): Carbon Monoxide Levels and Reported Cessation of Smoking, Psychopharmacol49: 263-269.
2.
Benowitz, N.L. (1983): The Use of Biologic Fluid Samples in Assessing Tobacco Smoke Consumption. In: "Measurement in the Analysis and Treatment of Smoking Behavior", NIDA Research Monograph, No. 48, J. Grabowski and C. Bell , Eds., Rockville, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse, pp. 6-26.
3.
Benowitz, N.L.; Kuyt, F.; and Jacob, P. (1982): Circadian Blood Nicotine Concentrations during Cigarette Smoking, Clin Pharmacol Ther32: 758-764.
4.
Benowitz, N.L.; Kuyt, F.; Jacob, P.; Jones, R.T.; and Osman, A.L. (1983): Cotinine Disposition and Effects, Clin Pharmacol Ther34: 604-611.
5.
Bliss, R.E. and O'Connell, K.A. (1984): Problems with Thiocyanate as an Index of Smoking Status: A Critical Review with Suggestions for Improving the Usefulness of Biochemical Measures in Smoking Cessation Research, Health Psych3: 563-581.
6.
Borgers, D. and Junge, B. (1979): Thiocyanate as an Indicator of Tobacco Smoking , Prev Med8: 351-357.
7.
Butts, W.C.; Kuehneman, M.; and Widdowson, G.M. (1974): Automated Method for Determining Serum Thiocyanate to Distinguish Smokers from Non-smokers, Clin Chem20: 1344-1348.
8.
Castleden, C.M. and Cole, P.V. (1974): Variations in Carboxyhemoglobin Levels in Smokers , Br Med J4: 736-738.
9.
Cohen, J.D. and Bartsch, G.E. (1980): A Comparison Between Carboxyhemoglobin and Serum Thiocyanate Determinations as Indicators of Cigarette Smoking, Am J Public Health70: 284-286.
10.
Cohen, S.J.; Christen, A.G.; Katz, B.P.; Drook, C.A.; Davis, B.J.; Smith, D.M.; and Stookey, G.K. (1987): Counseling Medical and Dental Patients about Cigarette Smoking: The Impact of Nicotine Gum and Chart Reminders, Am J Public Health77:313-316.
11.
Densen, P.M.; Davidow, B.; Bass, H.E.; and Jones, E.W. (1967): A Chemical Test for Smoking Exposure, Arch Environ Health14: 865-874.
12.
Evans, R.I.; Hansen, W.B.; and Mittelmark, M.B. (1977): Increasing the Validity of Self-reports of Smoking Behavior in Children, J Appl Psych62: 521-523.
13.
Feyerabend, C.; Higenbottam, T.: and Russell, M.A.H. (1982): Nicotine Concentrations in Urine and Saliva of Smokers and Non-smokers, Br Med J284:1002-1004.
14.
Fortmann, S.P.; Rogers, T.; Vranizan, K.; Haskell, W.L.; Solomon. D.S.; and Farquhar, J.W. (1984): Indirect Measures of Cigarette Use: Expired-air Carbon Monoxide versus Plasma Thiocyanate, Prev Med13:127-135.
15.
Gillies, P.A.; Wilcox, B.; Coates, C.; Kristmundsdot-Tir, F.; and Reid, D.J. (1982): Use of Objective Measurement in the Validation of Self-reported Smoking in Children aged 10 and 11 Years: Saliva Thiocyanate , J Epidemiol Community Health36: 205-208.
16.
Greenberg, R.A.; Haley, N.J.; Etzel, R.A.; and Loda, F.A. (1984): Measuring the Exposure of Infants to Tobacco Smoke, Nicotine and Cotinine in Urine and Saliva, N Eng J Med310: 1075-1078.
17.
Hengen, N. and Hengen, M. (1978): Gas-Liquid Chromatographic Determination of Nicotine and Cotinine in Plasma, Clin Chem24: 50-53.
18.
Jarvis, M.J.; Russell, M.A.H.; Feyerabend, C.; Eiser, J.R.; Morgan, M.; Gammage, P.; and Gray, E. (1985): Passive Exposure to Tobacco Smoke: Saliva Cotinine Concentrations in a Representative Population Sample of Non-smoking Schoolchildren , Br Med J291: 927-929.
19.
Jarvis, M.J.; Tunstall-Pedoe, H.; Feyerabend, C.; Vesey, C.; and Saloogee, Y. (1984): Biochemical Markers of Smoke Absorption and Self-reported Exposure to Passive Smoking, J Epidemiol Community Health38: 335-339.
20.
Junge, B. (1985): Changes in Serum Thiocyanate Concentration on Stopping Smoking, Br Med J291: 22.
21.
Luepker, R.V.; Pechacek, T.F.; Murray, D.M.; Ander-Son, J.C.; Hund, F.; and Jacobs, D.R. (1981): Saliva Thiocyanate : A Chemical Indicator of Cigarette Smoking in Adolescents, Am J Public Health71: 1320-1324.
22.
Matsukura, S.; Taminato, T.; Kitano, N.; Seino, Y.; Hamada, H.; Uchihashi, M.; Nakajima, H.; and Hirata, Y. (1984): Effects of Environmental Smoke on Urinary Cotinine Excretion in Nonsmokers, Evidence for Passive Smoking, N Eng J Med311: 828-832.
23.
Petitti, D.B.; Friedman, G.D.; and Kahn, W. (1981): Accuracy of Information on Smoking Habits Provided on Self-administered Research Questionnaires, Am J Public Health71: 308-311.
24.
Pettigrew, A.R. and Fell, G.S. (1972): Simplified Colorimetric Determination of Thiocyanate in Biological Fluids, and its Application to Investigation of the Toxic Amblyopias , Clin Chem18: 996-1000.
25.
Pojer, R.; Whitfield, J.B.; Poulos, V.; Eckhard, I.; Richmond, R.; and Hensley, W. (1984): Carboxyhemoglobin, Cotinine, and Thiocyanate Assay Compared for Distinguishing Smokers from Non-smokers, Clin Chem30: 1377-1380.
26.
Prue, D.M.; Martin, J.E.; and Hume, A.S. (1980): A Critical Evaluation of Thiocyanate as a Biochemical Index of Smoking Exposure, Behav Ther11: 368-379.
27.
Sillett, R.W.; Wilson, M.B.; Malcolm, R.E.; and Ball, K.P. (1978): Deception Among Smokers, Br Med J2: 1185-1186.
28.
Snedecor, G.W. and Cochran, W.G. (1967): Statistical Methods, 6th ed., Ames, Iowa: The Iowa State University Press, pp. 246-248.
29.
Swan, G.E.; Parker, S.D.; Chesney, M.A.; and Rosen-Man, R.H. (1985): Reducing the Confounding Effects of Environment and Diet on Saliva Thiocyanate Values in Ex-smokers, Addict Behav10: 187-190.
30.
Vesey, C.J.; Saloojee, Y.; Cole, P.V.; and Russell, M.A.H. (1982): Blood Carboxyhemoglobin, Plasma Thiocyanate and Cigarette Consumption: Implications for Epidemiological Studies in Smokers , Br Med J284: 1516-1518.
31.
Vogt, T.M.; Selvin, S.; Widdowson, G.; and Hulley, S.B. (1977): Expired Air Carbon Monoxide and Serum Thiocyanate as Objective Measures of Cigarette Exposure, Am J Public Health67: 545-549.
32.
Wald, N.; Howard, S.; Smith, P.G.; and Bailey, A. (1975): Use of Carboxyhaemoglobin Levels to Predict the Development of Diseases Associated with Cigarette Smoking, Thorax30: 133-140.
33.
Warner, E. (1978): Possible Increases in the Under-reporting of Cigarette Consumption, J Am Stat Assoc73: 314-318.
34.
Williams, C.L.; Eng, A.; Botvin, G.J.; Hill, P.; and Wynder, E.L. (1979): Validation of Students' Self-reported Cigarette Smoking Status with Plasma Cotinine Levels, Am J Public Health69: 1272-1274.
