Effect of Acid Type on Kinetics and Mechanism of Dental Enamel Demineralization

Abstract

The influence of acid type (pKa effects) of weak organic acid buffers on dissolution kinetics of dental enamel was critically examined for rigorous testing of the behavioral validity of the physical model of Patel et al. (1987). Quantitative evaluation of this model indicated that monitoring initial dissolution rates was a viable approach to critical testing of the model. Initial dissolution rates were determined in 0.1 mol/L acetate (pKa = 4.77), benzoate (pKa = 4.20), and salicylate (pKa = 2.98) buffers (pH = 4.50, μ = 0.50), with ground bovine enamel blocks of known surface area mounted in a rotating disk apparatus. The Levich theory was used to study dependence of dissolution rates on stirring rates in these buffers. The experimental data were analyzed by the physical model which includes pKa effects, complexation of the buffer anion with the other ions, surface kinetics, simultaneous diffusion and equilibrium of all species in enamel pores, diffusion layer thickness, and bulk solution composition. The K_IAp [a¹⁰ _Ca2 + a⁶ _PO34-a² _OH-] governing the dissolution reaction and the surface

resistance factor were deduced from the model. Dissolution kinetics was also followed in these buffers in the presence of calcium or phosphate common ions. In effect, by conducting both the stirring rate studies and common ion experiments, we derived the driving force function independently by these two techniques. The results obtained in this study were consistent with the model, indicating that pKa effects on the dissolution of dental enamel can be accountedfor quantitatively by the model, and it was found that weak acids do not influence either the apparent solubility or the surface reaction process of bovine dental enamel.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bergstrom, D.H. (1985): Inter-crystalline Solution Ion Activity Product Basis of Subsurface Dissolution in a Hydroxyapatite System. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah , p. 78.

Fox, J.L. ; Higuchi, W.I. ; Fawzi, M.B. ; and Wu, M.S. (1978): A New Two-site Model for Hydroxyapatite Dissolution in Acidic Media, J Colloid Interface Sci 67:312-330.

Gee, A. ; Domingues, L. ; and Deitz, V. (1954): Determination of Inorganic Constituents in Sugar , Anal Chem 26:1487-1492.

Gray, J.A. (1962): Kinetics of the Dissolution of Human Dental Enamel in Acid, J Dent Res 41:633-645.

Higuchi, W.I. ; Gray, J.A. ; Hefferren, J.J. ; and Patel, P.R. (1965a): Mechanism of Enamel Dissolution in Acid Buffers , J Dent Res 44:330-341.

Higuchi, W.I. ; Mir, N.A. ; Patel, P.R. ; Becker, J.W. ; and Hefferren, J.J. (1969): Quantitation of Enamel Demineralization Mechanisms , J Dent Res 48:396-409.

Higuchi, W.I. ; Patel, P.R. ; and Hefferren, J.J. (1965b): Quantitation of Enamel Demineralization Mechanism: II, J Pharm Sci 54:587-590.

Kielland, J. (1937): Individual Activity Coefficient of Ions in Aqueous Solutions, J Am Chem Soc 59:1675-1678.

Levich, V.G. (1962): Physical Hydrodynamics. New York: Prentice-Hall, Inc., p. 71.

10.

Ludwig, A. ; Dave, S.C. ; Higuchi, W.I. ; Fox, J.L. ; and Kad-Tare, A. (1983): Dissolution Rates of Apatite Powders in Acidic Fluoride Solutions and the Relationship to Hydroxyapatite Disk and Bovine Enamel Behavior, Int J Pharm 16:1-10.

11.

Nancollas, G.H. (1974): Physico-chemistry of Enamel Demineralization and Remineralization, J Dent Res 53:297-302.

12.

Patel, M.V. ; Fox, J.L. ; and Higuchi, W.I. (1987): Physical Model for Non-steady State Dissolution of Dental Enamel J Dent Res (in press).

13.

Robinson, R.A. and Stokes, R.H. (1959): Electrolyte Solutions. London : Academic Press, p. 482.

14.

Sillen, L.G. and Martell, A.E. (1964): Stability Constants of Metal-ion Complexes. London: The Chemical Society, Burlington House, Special Publication No. 17.

15.

Spooner, P.J. ; Kanaya, Y. ; Fox, J.L. ; and Higuchi, W.I. (1983): Novel Topical Fluoride Delivery System for Remineralization of Dental Enamel; Optimization Studies, Int J Pharmacol 15:177-184.

16.

Wu, M.S. ; Higuchi, W.I. ; Fox, J.L. ; and Friedman, M. (1976): Kinetics and Mechanism of Hydroxyapatite Crystal Dissolution in Weak Acid Buffers Using the Rotating Disk Method, J Dent Res 55:496-505.

17.

Yonese, M. ; Fox, J.L. ; Nambu, N. ; Hefferren, J.J. ; and Higuchi, W.I. (1981a): Fluoride Remineralization of Demineralized Bovine Tooth Enamel and Hydroxyapatite Pellets, J Pharm Sci 70:904-907.

18.

Yonese, M. ; Iyer, B.V. ; Fox, J.L. ; Hefferren, J.J. ; and Higuchi, W.I. (1981b): Novel Topical Fluoride Delivery System I, J Pharm Sci 70:907-910.