Potential Retinal Hazards of Visible-light Photopolymerization Units

Abstract

We evaluated the potential for retinal damage, both thermal and photochemical, from commercially available visible-light photopolymerization units. The spectral radiance profiles of 11 visible-light photopolymerization units were measured by means of a spectroradiometer and the results weighted according to the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) Blue Light Hazard Function and Thermal Hazard Function. The values were then integrated by means of the proposed ACGIH hazard formulae, so that we could determine the maximum permissible exposure (t_MAX) duration for each light. This calculation assumed a worst-case condition of direct vision of the light source from a distance of 25 cm. The results indicate that there is no thermal hazard to the retina. The t_MAX duration values for the photochemical (blue light) hazard to the retina ranged from 2.4 minutes per day (for the most hazardous unit) to 16.0 minutes per day (for the least hazardous). None of these hazard times is short enough to be of concern unless the individual operator elects to focus on the light source or the reflected output from these visible-light photopolymerization units for an extended period of time.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (1985): Threshold Limit Values for Chemical Substances and Physical Agents in the Workroom Environment and Biological Exposure Indices with Intended Changes for 1985-1986, Cincinnati, OH.

American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (1986): Notice of Intended Changes for 1986-87, Occup Saf & Health Rptr, Current Report; May 29, 1986: 1335.

Benedetto, M.D. and Antonson, D.E. (1984): Ophthalmic Concerns When Using Visible Light Curing Units, J Dent Res (Sp Iss) 63:199, Abstr. No. 260.

Council on Dental Materials, Instruments and Equipment (1985): Visible Light Cured Composites and Activating Units, J Am Dent Assoc 110:100-103.

Council on Dental Materials, Instruments and Equipment (1986): The Effects of Blue Light on the Retina and the Use of Protective Filtering Glasses, J Am Dent Assoc 112:533-535.

Ellingson, O.L. ; Landry, R.J. ; and Bostrom, R.G. (1986): An Evaluation of Optical Radiation Emissions From Dental Visible Photopolymerization Devices, J Am Dent Assoc 112:67-70.

Griess, G.A. and Blankenstein, M.F. (1981): Additivity and Repair of Actinic Retinal Lesions, Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 20 :803-807.

Ham, W.T., Jr. (1983): Ocular Hazards of Light Sources: Review of Current Knowledge, J Occup Med 25:101-103.

Ham, W.T., Jr. and Mueller, H.A. (1976): Retinal Sensitivity to Damage From Short Wavelength Light, Nature 260:153-155.

10.

Ham, W.T., Jr. ; Mueller, H.A. ; Ruffolo, J.J., Jr. ; and Clarke, A.M. (1979): Sensitivity of the Retina to Radiation Damage as a Function of Wavelength, Photochem Photobiol 29 :735-743.

11.

Ham, W.T., Jr. ; Mueller, H.A. ; Ruffolo, J.J., Jr. ; Guerry, D. III ; and Guerry, R.K. (1982): Action Spectrum for Retinal Injury from Near-ultraviolet Radiation in the Aphakic Monkey, Am J Ophthalmol 93:299-306.

12.

Ham, W.T., Jr. ; Ruffolo, J.J., Jr. ; Mueller, H.A. ; and Guerry, D. III (1980): The Nature of Retinal Radiation Damage : Dependence of Wavelength, Power Level and Exposure Time, Vision Res 20:1105-1111.

13.

Irvine, A.R. ; Wood, I. ; and Morris, B.W. (1984): Retinal Damage From the Illumination of the Operating Microscope, Arch Ophthalmol 102:1358-1365.

14.

Lawwill, T. ; Crockett, S. ; and Currier, G. (1977): Retinal Damage Secondary to Chronic Light Exposure: Thresholds and Mechanisms, Doc Ophthalmol 44:379-402.

15.

Pollack, B.F. and Lewis, A.L. (1981): Visible Light Resin-curing Generators: A Comparison , Gen Dent 29:488-493.

16.

Sliney, D.H. (1983): Standards for Use of Visible and Nonvisible Radiation on the Eye, Am J Optom Physiol Opt 60:278-286.

17.

Sliney, D.H. and Wolborsht, M.L. (1980): Safety Standards and Measurement Techniques for High Intensity Light Sources, Vision Res 20:1133-1141.