Effects of Two Fluoride Gels on Fluoride Uptake and Phosphorus Loss During Artificial Caries Formation

Abstract

Blocks of human enamel were cycled through a demineralization - F-treatment-remineralization procedure and then analyzed for fluoride and the presence of caries-like lesions. Treatments with a sodium fluoride gel (5000 ppm F) increased the enamel fluoride concentration to 6500 ppm F, whereas a stannous fluoride gel (1000 ppm F) increased enamel fluoride to about 1200 ppm F. Although a control treatment (water) allowed caries-like lesions to form, as observed by microradiography, no lesions were found in either of the fluoride-treated groups.

When the experiment was repeated with radioactive teeth, mineral loss, as determined by release of ³²P, was again greatest in the water-treated control group, but some loss was observed in the fluoride treatment groups. The least loss was found in the sodium fluoride group.

It was concluded that the fluoride treatments not only increased enamel resistance but also enhanced remineralization so that calcium phosphate was replaced during the subsequent remineralization phase. Because of the probability that stannous ions were deposited during the stannous fluoride treatments, some of the apparent calcium phosphate re-deposition in this group was probably stannous compounds.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Englander, H.R. ; Keyes, P.H. ; Gestwicki, M. ; and Sultz, H.A. (1967): Clinical Anticaries Effect of Repeated Topical Sodium Fluoride Applications by Mouthpieces, J Am Dent Assoc 75:638-644.

Englander, H.R. ; Carlos, J.P. ; Senning, R.S. ; and Mellberg, J.R. (1969): Residual Anticaries Effect of Repeated Topical Sodium Fluoride Applications by Mouthpieces, J Am Dent Assoc 78:783-787.

Englander, H.R. ; Sherrill, L.T. ; Miller, B.G. ; Carlos, J.P. ; Mellberg, J.R. ; and Senning, R.S. (1971): Incremental Rates of Dental Caries After Repeated Topical Sodium Fluoride Applications in Children with Life-long Consumption of Fluoridated Water, J Am Dent Assoc 82:354-358.

Ericsson, Y. (1961): The Compatibility of Fluoride and Common Dentifrice Components. In: Proceedings, Caries Symposium Zürich , H. R. Mühlemann and K. G. Konig, Eds., Bern: Hans Huber Publishers, pp. 79-91.

Glass, R.L. (1967): Radiographic Evidence of Tin Uptake by Human Tooth Structure, Arch Oral Biol 12:401-406.

Hals, E. and Selvig, K.A. (1977): Correlated Electron Probe Micro-analysis and Microradiography of Carious and Normal Cementum, Caries Res 11:62-75.

Hefferren, J.J. (1976): A Laboratory Method for Assessment of Dentifrice Abrasivity, J Dent Res 55:563-573.

Lobene, R.R. ; Zular-Nain, B.J. ; and Hein, J.W. (1966): Masking of Enamel Caries by Topically Applied Stannous Fluoride: A Source of Error in Clinical Diagnosis, J Oral Ther 3:35-43.

Mallon, D.E. and Mellberg, J.R. (1984): Inhibition of Caries Lesion Formation in vitro by an MFP Dentifrice and APF Solution, Pediat Dent 6:230-234.

10.

Mallon, D.E. and Mellberg, J.R. (1985): Analysis of Hard Tissue by Computerized Microdensitometry , J Dent Res 64:112-116.

11.

Mellberg, J.R. and Ripa, L.W. (1983): Fluoride in Preventive Dentistry, Theory and Clinical Applications. Chicago: Quintessence Publishing Co., Inc., pp. 226-228.

12.

Nicholson, C.R. ; Taylor, G.R. ; and Mellberg, J.R. (1974): An Automated Device for Removing Enamel Layers by Dissolution, Caries Res 8:293-299.